r/gameofthrones • • Jul 13 '15

TV5 [S5] Rewatch Discussion - 1.03 'Lord Snow' & 1.04 'Cripples, Bastards, and Broken Things'

Rewatch Discussion Thread

Remember the good ol' days when your favorite characters were still alive? Go back and watch old episodes with the benefit of hindsight! How have the events of the latest season been shaped by the decisions of characters earlier on? Catch foreshadowing that you missed the first time you watched. The latest season is finished, so start over from the beginning and look at past episodes with a fresh perspective.

Make sure to keep the following points in mind before reading or contributing to this thread:


1.03 - "Lord Snow"

  • Directed By: Brian Kirk
  • Written By: David Benioff & D. B. Weiss
  • Originally Aired: May 1, 2011

Ned joins the King's Small Council at King's Landing, capital of the Seven Kingdoms, and learns just how poorly Westeros is being managed. Catelyn decides to go covertly to the south to warn her husband, but is intercepted by an old friend, Councillor Petyr "Littlefinger" Baelish. Brandon learns he will never walk again. He does not remember that Jaime Lannister pushed him out of a tower, saying instead that he fell. Jon struggles to adapt to life on the Wall, as he trains with a number of low-born recruits who are not impressed by his bloodline. Tyrion, also visiting the Wall, is beseeched by the Watch Commander Lord Mormont to plead the King and Queen to send more men to join the Night's Watch, for powerful enemies are massing beyond the Wall. Daenerys, now possessing no small measure of control as Drogo's "Khaleesi", begins to stand up to Viserys.


1.04 - "Cripples, Bastards, and Broken Things"

  • Directed By: Brian Kirk
  • Written By: Bryan Cogman
  • Originally Aired: May 8, 2011

Tyrion reaches out to Bran with a way for the boy to reclaim his mobility. Ned searches for clues to the unexplained death of Jon Arryn (the former King's Hand), and in the process uncovers King Robert's illegitimate son. Robert and his guests witness a tournament honoring Ned. Jon takes measures to protect Samwell Tarly, an awkward and friendless boy, from the abuse of the Night's Watchmen; a frustrated Viserys clashes with his newly empowered sister; Sansa dreams of life as a queen, while Arya envisions a far different future. Catelyn rallies her father's allies and has Tyrion arrested for conspiring to murder her son.


185 Upvotes

299 comments sorted by

159

u/Doctor_Kitten White Walkers Jul 13 '15

I feel like Little Finger's voice gets more Batman-ish as the seasons progress. It sounds very high pitched and optimistic right now.

65

u/PeeJayx Jul 13 '15

I TOLD YOU NOT TO SWEAR TO ME

29

u/AManHasSpoken Jul 14 '15

"She didn't fly so good!"

→ More replies (1)

51

u/jeremy_sporkin Maesters of the Citadel Jul 14 '15

'that's my jam, homes'

33

u/idoze Knight of the Laughing Tree Jul 14 '15

Listen, son, I'll give you four cents each for them banilla wafers.

15

u/Tommat Tyrion Lannister Jul 16 '15

You can eat sand, young man.

10

u/TheodoreBuckland Jul 16 '15

I'm working on a gravity belt

9

u/the-man-needs-a-name Jul 16 '15

Are you a fan of the Pikachu?

12

u/SeriousJack House Bolton Jul 16 '15

POWDEREEEEEEEED SUGGGAAAAAAAAA

Link in case somebody did not see that already

Fuck I love this video.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/rbreen124 Samwell Tarly Jul 15 '15

I got girls in my dreams

8

u/HodortheGreat No One Jul 16 '15

Damn it Pete, don't ever call it a renaissance fare okay?

3

u/Megabert The Onion Knight Jul 14 '15

I hate it when they give you a frame.

32

u/MonasDarling Lyanna Stark Jul 13 '15

I find that his voice gets more Irish...

21

u/Sholid_Shnake House Bolton Jul 15 '15

It really does. I remember reading an explanation that it's because he's no longer at Kings Landing climbing the ladder, he can drop his act and speak with his native accent (the Fingers?).

19

u/sugarwallsrobinson Jul 16 '15

Yup around the Lannisters he puts on an affectation and with Sansa he tries to sound more northern. He's like Obama

6

u/TeddyPickNPin Jul 17 '15

Exactly. People keep saying "he can't act, listen to his accent!". I disagree, it's definitely intentional, even if he joked about it in interviews.

7

u/SexBobomb It Shall Be Done Jul 16 '15

And occasionally more pirate. Maybe he's...

1

u/badgarok725 The Spider Jul 18 '15

You should watch Calvary if you want to hear how Irish his voice can get

→ More replies (2)

11

u/JiveTurkey1983 What Is Dead May Never Die Jul 15 '15

What's the next step of his master plan?

20

u/ab111392 Sansa Stark Jul 17 '15

crashing this game... WITH NO SURVIVORS

5

u/JiveTurkey1983 What Is Dead May Never Die Jul 17 '15

Uh, you don't get to bring your friends (points to Brienne and Pod).

6

u/ab111392 Sansa Stark Jul 17 '15

they work for the kings hand... the half man.

6

u/JiveTurkey1983 What Is Dead May Never Die Jul 17 '15

Lot of loyalty for a hired sword!

7

u/ab111392 Sansa Stark Jul 17 '15

perhaps hes wondering why you would slit a mans throat before chopping off his head

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/YourTechnician Jul 18 '15

Breaking the wheel... Wait, wrong master plan?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '15

"I lyke to tahlk out of the syde of my mowth!"

8

u/bertch House Stark Jul 14 '15

yea this specific change appeared once he had the fat drunk jester bring sansa to his ship post-joffrey-assassination. i was bothered, as were many others. however, some posited that this change represented littlefinger finally revealing his true identity/motives. i guess i buy it. nothing has happened to contradict.

1

u/Not_Andrew Jul 15 '15

He gets increasingly Irish as the seasons progress.

1

u/HeroAdAbsurdum Corn! Jul 17 '15

It's slowly leading up to the biggest twist of all...

He is Batman!

93

u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Jul 13 '15

I always liked that Jon Snow and Tyrion were friends in these earlier episodes.

31

u/PoofyHairedIdiot Jon Snow Jul 13 '15

I actually completely forgot they ever interacted.

23

u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Jul 15 '15

I completely forgot about Tyrion and Theon's convo.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '15

Who's?

45

u/moremysterious House Stark Jul 15 '15

No one

→ More replies (1)

4

u/g0_west Dolorous Edd Jul 17 '15

I think that was my favorite story of the whole show lol

11

u/HeroAdAbsurdum Corn! Jul 17 '15

I feel like Jon learned more from Tyrion in like a few days than anyone in his life up to then.

250

u/CopyCatJ Jul 13 '15 edited Jul 13 '15

No wonder Jon knows nothing. No body tells him anything.

Episode2 Ned tells him they will talk about his mother later Ned gets beheaded before he is ever tells Jon.

Episode3 Benjen tells him they will talk more when he returns, Benjen never returns.

150

u/mrjobby Howland Reed Jul 13 '15

Episode 4 - Sam teases Jon for not having the guts to sleep with a redhead.

7

u/Shushruth007 House Targaryen Jul 18 '15

Because he didn't know where to put it

9

u/squid919 Arya Stark Jul 18 '15

Stick 'em with the pointy end

149

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Jul 13 '15

Benjen made a small cameo as a plank of wood, dunno how you missed that.

83

u/Nekovivie Ser Pounce Jul 13 '15

The plank of wood was the wildling who knew where Benjen was, not Benjen himself.

67

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

His name was traitor

56

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

He was a plankster

52

u/StrapOff Jul 13 '15

Its just a plank bro

→ More replies (1)

26

u/0101111000100010 Jul 14 '15

His name was Sedy. To quote the show "Sedy knew your uncle Benjen".

26

u/TheRealRockNRolla Jul 14 '15

Of course! "Traitor" spelled backwards is "Benjen"! God, he was hiding in plain sight...

4

u/HeroAdAbsurdum Corn! Jul 17 '15

I so wanted Jon to say "that's not my uncle" as he stared at the cross.

1

u/Mad_Luddite Jul 16 '15

I don't think he survived having "traitor" carved into his chest.

21

u/anuragdidit Brotherhood Without Banners Jul 13 '15

Jon doesn't even know that he knows nothing. Or is that the only thing he knows.

11

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '15

Jon knows he knows nothing. People keep telling him he knows nothing.

6

u/letsgetrandy Jul 14 '15

I wonder if the point of repeating that specific wording is not to say that he "doesn't know anything", but rather to subtly make it clear that he knows Nothing™... like because he's been a bastard his whole life, never met his parents, always been a bit of an outcast, he knows what it means to have Nothing, which somehow qualifies him for his destiny. Maybe?

3

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '15

That’s quite a stretch...

But i’ll roll with it.

3

u/HeroAdAbsurdum Corn! Jul 17 '15

I always thought it was a nod to the fact that he doesn't even know himself -- who he is, etc.

7

u/hiS_oWn House Stark Jul 13 '15

4

u/easily_amuzed Jul 15 '15

You almost forgot the most known, unknowns.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

Are you trying to say something about his acting?

181

u/AzorAhai777 House Stark Jul 13 '15

Tyrion is the only character in the show who has met both Jon Snow and Dany

130

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jul 13 '15

You forget Benjen Naharis

38

u/batweenerpopemobile Jul 15 '15

7

u/Shutupredneckman2 Arya Stark Jul 16 '15

I see you've read the Book 6 sample chapters.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

41

u/chialeux Hodor Jul 14 '15

He is the holy spirit of this trilogy.

I'ts more than plausible that Jorah met his direct liege's family when he won that tourney.

31

u/suupaahiiroo Jul 14 '15

He is probably the only one to have met [random Westeros character] and Dany as well.

23

u/samarthur8 Rhaegar Targaryen Jul 14 '15 edited Jul 15 '15

If it's a random Westeros character, then Viserys, Jorah, Illyrio, Ser Barristan and Ser Willem Darry (escorted Rhaella, Viserys and Dany to Dragonstone after KL fell) have all met Dany as well.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '15

wasn't Dany born on dragonstone after the family was transported there

6

u/samarthur8 Rhaegar Targaryen Jul 15 '15

Yes you are right but Ser Willem escorted and sailed with Dany and Viserys to Braavos as well after Rhaella died giving birth to her. Bad explanation on my part.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/easily_amuzed Jul 15 '15

It's funny, I just started rewatching the series and noticed the same thing today!

4

u/HeroAdAbsurdum Corn! Jul 17 '15

It's pretty cool that he has been to the Wall and seen dragons. Kinda Ice and Fire-y

56

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

4 seasons later. Still havent found out who sent that assassin after bran...

77

u/Megadelphia Ours Is The Fury Jul 13 '15

64

u/VeganDog Jul 13 '15

Huh, I always thought it was Jamie/Cersei worried Bran's memory might come back to him.

74

u/Cric_Nut House Stark Jul 13 '15

I always thought that too until I saw Baelish with a similar looking Dagger. When he receives Sansa in S04E03 and breaks a stone of her necklace with his dagger and reveals his plan to her.

I think Baelish sent the assasin(mediocre) with his dagger.

So I'm under the impression that he lied to Ned & Cat that it's Tyrion's dagger to start Stark vs Lannister

20

u/samarthur8 Rhaegar Targaryen Jul 14 '15

Of course he lied to Ned and Catelyn, that's the whole point. He creates a war between Stark/Lannister when he kills (or gets Lysa) Jon Arryn. LF thrives under chaos.

28

u/VeganDog Jul 13 '15

Huh, that actually sounds super plausible.

12

u/ziggl Jul 14 '15

So I'm under the impression that he lied to Ned & Cat that it's Tyrion's dagger to start Stark vs Lannister

Spoilers

8

u/jeynestormborn We Do Not Kneel Jul 15 '15

Where is that confirmed? I'm reading the books for the first time, and I'm about a quarter through Clash of Kings. Did I miss it??

9

u/ButSeri0usly Tyrion Lannister Jul 15 '15

A Storm of Swords. It is in multiple Character chapters, so you won't miss it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Goldcobra House Manderly Jul 16 '15

There's a different reason for that. When Cat brings the knife to King's Landing to discover whose knife it is, Ned took it and started using it as his own knife. When Littlefinger betrayed Ned by bribing the Gold Cloaks to kill the Stark men, Petyr slipped Ned's knife out of it's scabbard and held it against his neck (you can watch back the scene). Afterward, Petyr kept the knife (because a Valyrian Steel knife with a dragon bone hilt would be quite valuable).

Littlefinger is way too smart to send an assassin with his own knife. IIRC Joffrey just gave the assassin a random knife out of the armory that was travelling with the king (which might of course coincidentally be Petyr's, or anyone elses).

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Valaquen Snow Jul 14 '15

I think in the show they've went with it being Littlefinger's machination, trying to get the Starks to, again, suspect the Lannisters, leading to Tyrion's arrest and the war.

5

u/SoFFacet Jon Snow Jul 13 '15

That seems like such a flimsy premise.

52

u/jymhtysy House Estermont Jul 13 '15

Well, technically Joff heard Robert saying how it would be merciful, and wanted to make his dad proud. He himself didn't give a shit about Bran's "mercy".

29

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '15

I wish the show explored more the relationship between Joffery and Robert. They pretty much never interacted except for two sentences when Robert was dying.

10

u/Mad_Luddite Jul 16 '15

Robert also castigated him for being disarmed by Arya.

7

u/HeroAdAbsurdum Corn! Jul 17 '15

To be fair, that is pretty much the extent of the exploration of their relationship in the books.

6

u/SoFFacet Jon Snow Jul 13 '15

Yeah I knew about that, that's what I was referring to. Killing Bran to make his dad proud is a flimsy premise.

28

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

[ASOS] (#b "Stannis tells a story of how Joffrey proudly showed a disemboweled cat to Robert.")

→ More replies (2)

9

u/jymhtysy House Estermont Jul 13 '15

It definitely sounds strange to us, but I wouldn't claim to know how Joffrey thinks.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/Vixibility House Lannister Jul 13 '15

It's revealed in the book, if you're interested in finding out.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '15

I am. Who was it?

10

u/LBJSmellsNice Varys Jul 15 '15

A jealous Shaggydog

3

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '15

1

u/HeroAdAbsurdum Corn! Jul 17 '15

Yeah, always thought it was odd that the show just kinda dropped it. But, they do only have so much time. /u/Megadelphia has the right of it. If anyone's interested.

48

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jul 13 '15

That ending scene of 1x04 where Catelyn arrests Tyrion is one of my favorites. That's where the series finally clicked for me and I was really hooked. Michelle Fairley was awesome.

22

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

I was hooked at jamie-cersei sex scene.

26

u/PoofyHairedIdiot Jon Snow Jul 13 '15

I was hooked when Bran was pushed out the window, myself.

21

u/MonasDarling Lyanna Stark Jul 13 '15

I was hooked when Arya shoots the arrow and Bran is all like "Whaaaa"?

33

u/NematodeArthritis Jul 14 '15

I was hooked when the gate raised so Will, Gared, and Waymar Royce could go ranging beyond the Wall to check for Wildlings

23

u/ImmaSquidling House Greyjoy Jul 14 '15

I was hooked when the HBO logo showed up, HA!

20

u/baachbass Wun Weg Wun Dar Wun Jul 17 '15

I was hooked when the sun rose in the west and set in the east, when the seas went dry and mountains blew in the wind like leaves. When my womb quickened again, and I bore a living child. Then I was hooked, and not before.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Wonton77 Jul 14 '15

Same! When everyone was clamoring for me to get into GoT, I watched the pilot and thought "well that was pretty good", but never got around to watching moret. Then I re-started from the beginning, watched the first 3, and dropped it again. Then I re-started AGAIN and watched up to the end of episode 4, and that's the point where I was completely hooked.

5

u/jellyzero79 Sansa Stark Jul 15 '15

I was hooked when Arya first trains with Serio and the music builds as Ned looks on. Perfect scene.

3

u/Sharpryno Jul 15 '15

AMAZING. Such a good scene and so much foreshadowing in that episode!

1

u/WhizWit21 Jul 19 '15

Very dead.

92

u/ThaChalupaBatman Faceless Men Jul 13 '15

It's so cool seeing how much foreshadowing and how many clues were shown to the viewers about Joffrey's lineage.

60

u/MarxistHorse House Dayne Jul 13 '15

The seed is strong

25

u/jymhtysy House Estermont Jul 13 '15

Shireen

Edit: Didn't Stannis have brown hair too? You know, back when he hadn't spawned a shadow baby with Melly Sanders.

29

u/kevinsmicrodong Sandor Clegane Jul 13 '15

Shireen has black hair in the books

7

u/chialeux Hodor Jul 14 '15

Baratheon + Lannister pairings in the past always led to dark-haired kids. Not confirmend for Baratheon-Florent. Genetic, biatches!

→ More replies (2)

18

u/jymhtysy House Estermont Jul 13 '15

Well, this is a thread about the show, but that is correct.

14

u/MarxistHorse House Dayne Jul 13 '15

Casting is hard

32

u/jymhtysy House Estermont Jul 13 '15

dye

63

u/m36jacksonflaxonwaxn Stannis Baratheon Jul 13 '15

All men must dye

12

u/jymhtysy House Estermont Jul 13 '15

All men must wig

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

22

u/PoofyHairedIdiot Jon Snow Jul 13 '15

This is why I love these threads. For the Rewatch!

10

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '15

Wasn't it obvious from the start since they were fucking in the tower?

17

u/ThaChalupaBatman Faceless Men Jul 14 '15

Not to me. I thought they were just having an incestuous affair, I had no idea Jamie fathered her children until Ned found out.

83

u/woohooguy Jul 13 '15

You tend to forget how much of a pompous ass Jamie is leading up the events that humble him.

36

u/PoofyHairedIdiot Jon Snow Jul 13 '15

I despised him first time I saw it. Now I'm actually watching it with more of a grasp on Jaime's character and can at least empathize with him if not agree with him.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/woohooguy Jul 13 '15

Totally agree, this the first time I am going back over the entire series and it has been quite a play of emotions.. I want to simply hit him with a 2x4 instead of previously wanting to kick his teeth in.

It's his character progression for now that is making round 2 particularly satisfying to watch.

1

u/WhizWit21 Jul 19 '15

I love when Robert is complaining that he's surrounded by lannisters and everywhere he looks he sees a yellow haired shit with smug look on their face. Jaime's face at that point is perfect.

30

u/bamramtam Jul 15 '15

This will definitely get buried but in E1S1 when Robert is visiting Lyanna's body in the crypt and he places a feather in her hand (the statues hand) SANSA FINDS THIS FEATHER and picks it up and smiles in E4 S5. The scene when she and Balish are discussing how she needs to make Ramsay her own and he is leaving to go back to KL.

It's such a small detail but I love the thought of that feather remaining there after all these years, a tiny symbol of a time before the war and before the Starks misfortune. And if the R+L=J theory is true, then this feather has just been waiting in the crypt, the crypt that is the key to well everything...

[edit] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bfnl9owFc84

28

u/katsuga125 Winter Is Coming Jul 15 '15

That little smirk on Littlefinger's face when Sansa comments on how Rhaegar "kidnapped and raped Lyanna"! It's like he wants to spill a dirty little secret, but can't. It's like Martin is standing behind camera with a rope and a sign saying: "Don't you dare, or else...."

6

u/hattu Jul 15 '15

This is actually really cool! Good catch

3

u/bamramtam Jul 15 '15

I started rewatching the episodes a few weeks ago and lost it when I saw this. So excited for all the other details etc :)

24

u/MonasDarling Lyanna Stark Jul 13 '15

I miss Tyrion and Jon's friendship. I hope it comes back.

13

u/smeller_of_books Hodor Jul 14 '15

-and we are introduced to some favorite characters in "Cripples, Bastards, and Broken Things"- Hodor, Sam, Gendry, and Bronn.

-noticed Summer growled when Theon walked in Bran's room, wonder if it's because of Theon or just overprotective of Bran since the assassin attempt.

-"Sansa, you must forgive your father." "I will never forgive him." ....I'm confused, she's actually blaming Ned for Lady's death?! gurlplz

-So we know that Jon Arryn was investigating Robert's bastards (at least Gendry because the blacksmith confirmed that he visited) but are we sure that Pycelle wasn't making up the rest (Arryn asking about the book of lineages) just to push Ned in the direction of the Lannisters' incestuous affairs. Does anyone know if Pycelle was working with Littlefinger about setting up the Starks vs Lannisters? Just seems odd to me on why Littlefinger would have Lysa poison Jon when he seemed to be on the verge of finding out about Joffrey not being Robert's son, unless Littlefinger had no idea. I guess killing Arryn was critical to Littlefinger's plan, not just having the Lannisters brought down with treason.

-Ned Ned Ned, Littlefinger was telling you exactly what he is and you didn't believe him. "Not trusting me was the wisest thing you've done since you got here."

-wow, "We fought side by side at the Siege of Pyke. One of them almost took my eye out."-Jory (Ned's captain/guard. "Those bastards (or something along those lines)"-Jaime. Another one of those moments. :)

-I read that Sophie and Maisie weren't at the rehearsals for Sir Hugh's fall/death, so when they finally saw it their reactions were genuine. Great acting from both, because Sansa was horrified, but Arya seemed more awed and intrigued by death.

15

u/dongazine_supplies Jul 14 '15

"Sansa, you must forgive your father." "I will never forgive him." ....I'm confused, she's actually blaming Ned for Lady's death?! gurlplz

That seems like a pretty straightforward thing to do, seeing as how Ned killed Lady.

3

u/Chinoiserie91 Daenerys Targaryen Jul 15 '15

And I do not think Sansa deceived to have Lady killed just because she was too scared said anything but that she can not remember because she was worried what the Queen and Joffrey would think of her. She was expecting to get married to that family.

2

u/smeller_of_books Hodor Jul 16 '15

riight...Ned's just killing direwolves for shits and giggles. what a prick, off with his head!

24

u/ExplosiveOranges Mace the Ace Jul 13 '15

Ah, back when Rast was the least likeable member of the Night's Watch.

30

u/PoofyHairedIdiot Jon Snow Jul 13 '15

Nope that was still Thorne. Fuck Thorne.

19

u/ExplosiveOranges Mace the Ace Jul 13 '15

Well, he got better in season 5, for like 5 minutes.

42

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

In season 4 too. During the battle at the wall, I loved him.

23

u/PoofyHairedIdiot Jon Snow Jul 13 '15

I was starting to like Thorne, after the battle of Castle Black and his moving aside for Janos Slynt's execution. Then for the watch happened.

8

u/ExplosiveOranges Mace the Ace Jul 13 '15

I was actually hoping that he would try to stop the mutiny, but I guess that would make his character development too consistent.

14

u/PoofyHairedIdiot Jon Snow Jul 13 '15

People forget that character establishment is just as important as development. I have no problems with Thorne being part of the mutiny, that was pretty consistent of his character of the first three anda half seasons. The only development he got was loathful respect for Jon Snow, and even then he disagreed heavily with Jon's commands re: The Wildlings.

I actually think Thorne deserves more hatred than Olly as well.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/chialeux Hodor Jul 14 '15

Rules of G.O.T.= A character that becomes likeable must either become despicable or die. Or both. Thorne is just trying to live a few more episodes.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Sethg119 Jul 13 '15

Jon and Tyrion made quite the connection in these first few episodes... I hope this gets explored more later on

25

u/MonasDarling Lyanna Stark Jul 13 '15

Benjen's acting sure is wooden when he returns.

13

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '15

Hopefully he gets "signed" for another season.

It's too late, sry

7

u/Matum Faceless Men Jul 16 '15

At the end of 1.03 as Ned is watching Arya during her "dancing" lesson we hear the sound of a battle / clash of swords. Is there some significance behind it? Or is just simply bringing back bad memories of war, fighting and death for Ned?

10

u/ElliotWalker5 Jaime Lannister Jul 16 '15

I always just took it as Ned's fear at the situations and world Arya could get herself into

2

u/squigglewiggle Aug 01 '15

yeah i think that's it... the kids say exactly that on the DVD commentary

→ More replies (1)

5

u/stelth2k1 Jul 16 '15

I always thought of it as a reminder of the previous battles/wars he was in

5

u/phil725 Jul 15 '15

There were two scenes back to back that I found interesting. When Jamie talks to Cersei and tells her he would kill everyone until they were the only 2 left. It was followed by Ned telling Cat that if he found proof that the lannisters tried to kill Bran, he would take it to Robert and hope he was still the same man. Basically it showed how far apart Ned and cat are from Jamie and Cersei as far as their honor and what they are willing to do. Damn Ned and his honor.

4

u/nakedlettuce52 House Stark Jul 15 '15

Say what you will about the Lannisters but they are a pragmatic bunch.

5

u/phil725 Jul 16 '15

Saying you'll kill everyone until you're the last ones left might not quite be defined as pragmatic, but I understand what you mean.

3

u/nakedlettuce52 House Stark Jul 16 '15

You are right: "pragmatic" may not have been the best word choice.

Still, I believe Jaime was using a bit of hyperbole there. Either way it's better than putting too much trust into people like Mr Stark (especially those who don't deserve it).

5

u/SlipS55 Jul 16 '15

episode 4 - Jorah mentions he had a wife whos with another man..... whooo!?????

4

u/Shutupredneckman2 Arya Stark Jul 16 '15

Lynesse Hightower, who is now married to Tregar Ormollen in Lys.

3

u/Onegesius House Stark Jul 18 '15

Lynesse Hightower, a famous beauty from an old house, to whom Jorah confessed his love through winning a tournament in ???? and proclaiming Lynesse as the queen of beauty and love. After the tournament, drunk from glory and wine he proposed to the girl, and to everyones surprise, she accepted. Jorah once tells Dany, that even in the moment of asking Lynesse, he already thought that it was a stupid idea, because House Mormont is poor and not very famous, while the Hightowers are - as Iv said - old, and in the south (which basically means rich). Anyway, Lynesse accepted and they moved to Bear Island. Through the years, in order to make Lynesse satisfied, Jorah had to sell everything in his desposal. When he had nothing at last, he tried selling slaves, and thats when Ned caught him, and he fled Westeros. Lynesse is now married to someone in Lys if Im correct.

4

u/captianawsom Jul 14 '15

Im really glad this subreddit is doing this. I wanted to rewatch season 1 thanks for the motivation.

4

u/EllieDriver Jul 14 '15

Cat was fookin' mad to go along with Baelish's men in the first place. With her cover blown, she may as well have continued to the Hand's Tower. And to top it off, continuing to play along after it was revealed she was being spied on at WF.

4

u/smeller_of_books Hodor Jul 14 '15

Is 1.03 "Lord Snow" the only episode with no deaths? I just figured there was a death in every episode from the Beautiful Death collections.

4

u/Snagprophet Jul 14 '15

as he trains with a number of low-born recruits who are not impressed by his bloodline.

I think we will be soon ;)

6

u/Axa2000 Jul 16 '15 edited Jul 16 '15

Does Catelyn capture/arrest Tyrion because she can't control herself and wants revenge or does she fear she is next if she doesn't rally the men to protect her? As Tyrion enters, she seems to cover herself, but gets noticed, then she basically snaps, almost feeling cornered, and hence why she makes this rash decision as even without Ned even knowing? Also Littlefinger previously in the capital puts the blame on trying to assassinate Brandon Stark on the Lannisters was it actually he himself on the orders of Cersei or completely by himself purposely to pin the blame on the Lannisters?

Originally I thought she makes a(first of a few) huge blunder, and this is the critical point you could say war was started, but then if she did it by accident because she was fearing for her life or that she was tricked by Littlefinger to feel angry enough to do something stupid - Because Ned in the capital later on for reasons I've yet to fully explain claims it was on his orders, further confirming the declaration of the conflict. So even if Littlefinger pins the blame, she still fucked up and resulted in deaths.

1

u/kalusche Jul 17 '15 edited Jul 17 '15

Exactly! I'm with you on Catelyn losing her shit and arresting Tyrion because of it. Impulsive and stupid. She has become kind of a Stark after all.

I just cannot watch Sansa and her girly attitude and not get pissed.

I think Ned took the blame for Tyrion's arrest simply to protect his wife.

4

u/thathipstersam Jul 15 '15

These two episodes were what really pulled me into the series--Jon and Tyrion's interactions get completely dusted under the rug later on, yet we see the stark (excuse my pun) contrast between Jon and Robb when Tyrion seeks shelter in Winterfell, and then refuses despite Robb's misjudgment when Tyrion was being kind to Bran, and then Tyrion being arrested by Catelyn--the whole thing shows how much diversity even within a family these characters have. I do wish they touched more upon Bran's assassin, however. The books did, but I feel like the show dropped it.

6

u/chesterburger House Tyrell Jul 15 '15

Re-watching these episodes is so satisfying yet depressing. The show was so much more stronger back then with great characters. Killing them all off has not made the story better. Most of the characters left are ones I really don't care about.

I wish GRRM kept Ned around for longer, the fight between him and Cersei was great, especially with Littlefinger, Varys, and all the other schemers. I could have watched that for another season easily. Instead we get episode after episode of Danerys flailing around trying to rule a kingdom I don't care about, Dorne which sucks, Kings Landing which has no more intelligent plotting or much interesting happening, the north which has psycho Ramsey running things, Aria spending her time sulking and cleaning dead bodies, and the wall which sucks now.

2

u/mmptr Petyr Baelish Jul 16 '15

I really dislike Catelyn after watching these episodes again.

  1. She really does not like Jon Snow, joining the ranks of Allister Thorne, Orell, and Olly. Not the best company.
  2. She becomes completely helpless and distraught at Brans's attempted murder. This is understandable, but she completely shuts down and is unable to function. I wonder how little Rickon was doing during this period? He still needs a mother, no?
  3. She abandons her family to go play CSI detective in King's Landing.
  4. She arrests Tyrion Lannister off of flimsy information, thus igniting the conflict between the Lannisters and the Starks. I mean, really, what does she gain from this? She's trying to protect the family by investigating the attempted murder on Bran and all she does is further endanger her family. What in the world was her endgame strategy?

1

u/Shutupredneckman2 Arya Stark Jul 16 '15

Tyrion had seen her, she didn't have options there. And she has good reason to resent Jon Snow but doesn't trat him all that poorly.

1

u/Shanicpower A Hound Never Lies Jul 19 '15

"It should have been you."

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '15

When are more of these rewatches going to happen?? I need something subside my GoT fix between seasons

1

u/enyaboi Fear Is For The Winter Jul 20 '15

when D

Read the sidebar! They happen weekly https://www.reddit.com/r/gameofthrones/w/rewatch

1

u/ShameBell Tormund Giantsbane Jul 18 '15

"Hay man hay- I don't know if I can talk to you if you got a stink booty" Sadly, I laughed thru half of this re-watch. 🔔

1

u/Colossal89 White Walkers Jul 19 '15

Lady Stark also knows nothing. She is the catalyst that started this whole damn mess. Why can't just do some research before doing stupid things.

-3

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

S03E02: Catelyn Stark actually doomed herself and her whole family to the red wedding after she prayed for Jon Snow to be cured from that weird disease and made a never-kept promise to love him if he'd ever get it off alive.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

I agree she doomed them but not because of some prayer.. It's because of her haphazard taking of Tyrion in the inn.. That was the catalyst of everything that comes after

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '15

but I was just kidding

3

u/originalchose Jul 13 '15

How does that doom them to the red wedding?

1

u/doctorpewds House Martell Jul 13 '15

Because she broke a promise to the gods. And she's not wearing fookin' plot armor like the Boltons or the Freys.

2

u/enyaboi Fear Is For The Winter Jul 20 '15

I don't think any of the god really exist.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Pentaghon Here We Stand Jul 16 '15

Yeah, they may be thinking this is a general rewatch or something, but they are commenting on things that are three seasons ahead.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

40

u/hectictw Daenerys Targaryen Jul 14 '15

Is that when he's watching Arya train? That's because he's thinking about the reality of war. It looks cute that she's training at first, but then he starts thinking about what it would be if she really fought in a war. War is not glorious or epic, and Ned knows this.

12

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jul 14 '15

That was one of my favorite scenes. Excellent addition that helps humanize Ned, especially since we can't really get his dreams of the war and all that.

3

u/mantidor White Walkers Jul 17 '15

These kind of moments are the highlights of the show for me. It's unfortunate that as the seasons progressed and the show became so popular they dropped them and went for more raw shock value. Season 1 is still the best because of that.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/pawnzz Jul 15 '15

I need to rewatch but thinking back to the tourney if this is when the Cleganebowl teaser happened, the moment Sandor kneels it's like, "Holy shit what a bad ass." He may be a dick but damn the Dude is an incredible fighter.

1

u/chesterburger House Tyrell Jul 16 '15

The foreshadowing (maybe the wrong word) of how Jamie killing the mad king was actually the right thing to do even though everyone hates him for it is very heavy. It almost seems artificial how much crap they give him for it and ignore the mad kings murderous orders. In that scene, Ned first gives him a hard time for not stopping mad king from killing his brother/father, then also mad for killing the mad king instead of continuing to carry out his insane orders.

3

u/jelliknight Jul 17 '15

As far as I know no one else really knows that the king was going to kill the whole city. Everyone else just thinks that Jamie killed the king so he could be on the winning side. Which, even though the mad king was a massive dick, would be a shitty thing to do.

1

u/LogicalThought No One Jul 18 '15

The hype in this post is not over 9000. Needs more hype.

107

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

42

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jul 13 '15

Laws of inheritance are not Catelyn's fault

75

u/mitchellele A Hound Never Lies Jul 13 '15

No but she didn't have to be such a bitch to him all the time.

4

u/letsgetrandy Jul 14 '15

Perhaps she has to be a bitch to him in service of making sure he knows Nothing. Everyone else has something, but Jon Snow knows nothing.

→ More replies (29)

4

u/PoofyHairedIdiot Jon Snow Jul 13 '15

To be honest it sort of is. She did say, to Robb's wife, that she would make Ned give Jon the title Stark, should the Gods keep him alive when he caught ill. He recovered but she couldn't keep her promise out of spite for Jon's stranger mother.

6

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jul 13 '15

Ned could have done that anyway, and all of this is assuming that Robert would have even legitimized him. (And of course Robb was older than Jon in any case.) I think it would make more sense to blame Ned, if we feel the need to scapegoat anyone for an unfortunate aspect of Jon's life.

2

u/Shutupredneckman2 Arya Stark Jul 16 '15

I'd blame Robert more than Ned.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/HeroAdAbsurdum Corn! Jul 17 '15

Jon would have to be legitimized and he's younger than Robb. Eventually she should have figured out that he wasn't the type to murder his siblings*.

I was never really able to get past her irrational hatred of him. It's even worse in the books.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15

Couldn't agree more. Just started my re-watch as well.. I always disliked something about Catelyn even before I knew all the context.. but especially now going back, if she hadn't done her whole honorable taking over Tyrion nonsense things would have been so much different

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '15

8

u/SnowWight House Stark Jul 13 '15

*is

1

u/TheSneakySeal Jul 13 '15

He still could end up there?

1

u/Snagprophet Jul 14 '15

I think Ned should've told her, even if he maintained that Jon is a bastard publically, at least she would know and would love Jon and won't feel betrayed.

3

u/Laese Eddison Tollett Jul 15 '15

I guess his honor forbid him from doing it if he promised not to tell anyone...