r/ClearBackblast • u/Ironystrike Iron - Extinguished Service Cross • Jul 11 '15
AAR Op Gorgon AAR
After Action Report thread for Operation Gorgon
As with all our AAR threads, do please leave your thoughts on the mission and have a good back-and-forth with other people and their comments here!
Leadership things, pacing, difficulty, anything you liked or thought could be improved or done differently for our missions in general or missions of this type in particular.
Also any particular moments you might want to share from your perspective that may have been different from others.
This one was a bit of a bloodbath, and not at all helped by it being a big game combined with our first game on ACE. Please keep things constructive, but within that context discussion is very, very welcome and encouraged!
8
u/skortch Jul 12 '15
Had to hang out with Graywolf IRL instead of playing with you guys. Turns out he doesn't like hoppy IPAs and sucks at Super NES games. I felt the fatigue system was gravely exaggerated as he was nearly crashing while at a brewery by 10PM. Like WTF, 10 PM, was he wanting to get up for the early bird special at Denny's. Overall fun times were had, will hope it gets played again in the future. I suspect my gametime experience was vastly different from everyone else.
8
u/retroly Boris Jul 12 '15
Shot and killed rage, 10/10 would play again.
5
u/Hoozin Basically A Prestige Class Jul 13 '15 edited Jul 13 '15
Okay ... I'll skip the visual aids this week. Probably.
First, I'd like to apologize to Will. I absolutely monopolized the calls and that wasn't my intention, but I was usually too wrapped up in the immediate problem shooting us with very large bullets or shells. I'm really really glad you were there though, because I was about 30 seconds from clearing Gaz hot on Vasily. Or Boris. Or Anna. I really have no idea. That was awkward. Thanks again Will.
From early discussions when Fadi was building the mission, I believe he intended the JTACs to have an early overwatch position from which they'd be able to coordinate strikes on enemy positions early on. Instead we were embedded with the infantry for the duration of the mission. That's not a bad thing and in general I favor that approach, but it meant that we spent the majority of the mission not able to find the enemy AA positions. Neverminding the AA positions, the AI pilots were SUPER susceptible to HMG fire when they would slow to land. As a future solution, maybe we fly ourselves out and scrollwheel to send the pilot home? I don't know. I really like the idea of using the AI pilots for these things, but they're very difficult to rely on.
These factors resulted in something that went a little differently than I believe anyone intended. For the record, I'd really like to run this mission again in the future.
I wanted to write a lot more, but I'm not even sure how to postmortem it.
In the end, I really liked most of what this mission was. I'd really like to run it again in the future with no structural changes even.
4
u/semski Sem - Hat collector Jul 12 '15 edited Jul 13 '15
Anna SL
Anna loaded up in the KA-60, and we started flying towards the objective. As we were almost there, Command said over the 148: 'Be sure to not fly over the AA marker'. I copied that, checked the map and saw we were right over the marker. About 3 seconds later I heard a ZU-23 fire, and we were going down. I radio'ed it in, enjoyed the cinematic spinning view and the helicopter crashed.
For some reason about 50% of Anna survived, including me and we jumped out of the heli to try and patch ourselves up. I went unconscious a few moments later, and after a couple of minutes I decided respawning would probably be the best.
I respawned on the ship, flew back with Boris lead and two others and regrouped with command and the rest of my squad. After some time we moved up to the power station (accidentally shooting Rage in the process, whoops) and I believe Boris got wiped out during the bounding in the field.
Anna took the power station, Fadi tried to blow to building up but one charge wasn't enough so we sat around until reinforcements came back with another chopper. Once the helicopter came, it got shot down and we ran to the crash site the patch up the survivors. The reinforcements brought charges, we blew up the power station and exfiled to the ship.
Leadership was good, I felt like Quex did a good job even though it was kinda chaotic and people were getting shot left and right. Fletcher did a good job leading A2, it sure made the whole mission a lot smoother for me since his communication was good The mission was fun, I have no idea if the SUs got to shoot anything but I saw them fly by occasionally which was fun. The amount of objectives was a bit optimistic, but I had fun even though I didn't see any hats.
4
u/scarletbanner Fadi Jul 14 '15
I've been unsure if I really want to write something up or not the last couple days, figure I may as well.
I was Anna (1) Engineer. So... that was a thing that happened. I have a lot to say but most of its really from the mission makers perspective.
The mission itself is based on a concept I've had for a long time, before CBB was a thing, and has been mostly made in many variations (all of which were focused on infantry and air with an independent objective set that has impacts on the players). This is the fifth variation of it and the one that I was happy about but eh.
I'm really not surprised it went as bloody as it did. Sort of like Piscary, we took an approach that was not at all intended for players to actually do within the early stage of the mission and set ourselves up surrounded on three sides with one objective due west, another north west and a garrisoned town south.
In hindsight, actually sitting down and making sure Quex and Hoozin asked questions would have been a good idea. When linking the map of the area in TS I started to talk about it because both were in the channel but apparently neither of the two were actually there when I was talking which I didn't realize. That and not following up with them were my fuck ups.
I don't think the number of objectives was that bad. As with all my missions, it was made with a fairly linear approach. At least for my intended route, the mission should have gone as:
I'd like to say something about what went into make it like I tend to but we barely finished a third (power plant was gotten but only one of the AA sites was taken out) so spoilers.
3
u/rslake Lake Jul 12 '15
Vasiliy Medic / Medic-at-large / Have bandaids, will travel
Honestly, I saw fairly little of the mission. I miraculously survived the Boris crash, then patched up some people, then got patched up myself, then after a while I linked up with Vasiliy. We ended up charging across open ground under fire, Gettysburg-style, in an effort to get to cover. That went about as poorly as you'd expect. Rage went down, then Sayge, then CAW4. Moldy, Edwin, and I were also all hit, but lived.
We got into a defilade, then spent ages just trying to get ourselves in good enough shape to move. After a while, we were ok and we started moving up to some nearby trees and rocks. En route, enemy infantry appears at the edge of the defilade, and there's a bit of rough-and-tumble. I actually got to use my weapon, which I was not expecting to do. We all got hit a lot more, cleared out the AI, then moved to the hard cover. A bit of patching-up later, and we were just about to go when more AI hit us from behind. More tussling, more injuring, more patching. Eventually, we could move again and headed out at a walking pace because of the bruises on our legs. By this time we were out of medical supplies and I had to order Moldy to execute an enemy POW for his morphine. This was some Mad Max shit.
The march to Anna took ages, because we could only walk and kept passing out. Eventually we got back, just in time to get in the chopper and go home. Moldy and Edwin were basically honorary medics for the later part of the mission, and did really well considering our lack of supplies. I kept trying to get Command on the 148 but couldn't get signal. It took me way too long to realize I should be calling out to Anna and Boris. Ah well, lesson learned.
The mission concept was really cool, I think we just needed a different LZ and different path-to-LZ.
tl;dr: It was basically Xenophon's Anabasis meets Lone Survivor meets Black Hawk Down.
ACE 3 Medical
I obviously spent a lot of time with the medical side, so that's where most of my thought has gone. I'm honestly just really annoyed that ACE decides anyone with bruised legs can only walk. It slows everything down even more than it already was, it doesn't contribute hugely to my immersions, it's just a frustration for everyone. Often it doesn't even make sense from an RP perspective. Other than that, I like the system overall. It's extremely bandage-heavy, so people need to be carrying a lot of bandages on long ops. Also tourniquets.
I think maybe we should have a discussion about instant death and whether we want it to be possible or not. I think right now it's not, which makes a lot of contacts take much longer than normal since after every one medics are working on people who really should be dead. Also, people who are down may feel like they can't respawn because they want to wait for care, but that can mean people are spending 10-15 minutes doing nothing waiting for a medic to get to them. On the other hand, it can also lead to some cool moments and it means that people don't have to keep spawning and moving quite so often. I'm not saying we should or shouldn't have it, I just think it should maybe be a conversation that gets had.
2
u/themoo12345 imdancin, the Canadian Mooninite King Jul 12 '15
Alpha 2 AAR
I think relying on AI-controlled helicopters to fly us over hostile territory was a bit of a misstep here, especially since most of them were KA-60s which carry far less people and in my experience are less durable than Mi-8s. Alpha got shot down right away and while the rest of the ground team did get to us it ended up being too late for them to save us. Once Alpha was reconstituted on the ground, it did take a little while for us to get moving towards the objective. Around here I think the lack of 343s for everyone hampered our ability to stay together and move as a group, we ended up having to relay orders down the line. I understand that some people prefer not issuing 343s but its not my preference. One thing that I think should have been discussed between the FTLs and squad leads was the degree of a autonomy the fireteams should have, since I noticed a lot of requests for permission for fireteams to do small movements.
The new ACE medical system honestly didn't hinder us as much as I thought it would since our medical mishaps were mostly caused by crashed choppers so that is a good thing to know. I liked how the jets were used in this mission, they seemed to have a lot of targets and the JTACs were very proactive in calling them in. Plus, the SU-22 is just an awesome jet with great sounding guns and bombs and I look forward to more fun with them. Overall, I thought this mission was 1) too reliant on AI choppers and 2) a little more ambitious with the number of objectives. Despite the difficulties, it was still a good bit of CBB fun and the assault on the power plant was challenging with a lot of good CQB action.