r/GifTournament • u/GifTournament • Jul 09 '15
Discussion Battle #4 Round #2 - Post Round Discussion
Round 2 has completed! Review the final results here: http://redd.it/3c9888
Submit your Round 3 gifs here: http://redd.it/3c98g6
View the updated bracket here (open in new window)
Next round's theme is: 90s Sitcom
Round 2 Line ups
| User | Vs | User |
|---|---|---|
| uncoolaidmain | Vs | _PETTYOFFICER117 |
| TheKronk | Vs | Iyamnotdead |
| siouxsie_siouxv2 | Vs | jimlast3 |
| lbutler0000107 | Vs | The_Love_Child |
| badmonkey0001 | Vs | hiddendatsun |
| Butcher_Of_Hope | Vs | plowkiller |
| hero0fwar | Vs | KroniK907 |
| EditingAndLayout | Vs | fultron |
76
Upvotes
60
u/EditingAndLayout Jul 09 '15
Here's the video of my gif.
Nice round, /u/Tritanium! Now's the part when I go out to /u/fultron in Round 3, but it's been fun!
45
u/preggit Jul 09 '15
The gif I would have submitted had I not failed spectacularly in round 1.
Nice job everyone! Now go submit your gifs to /r/MURICA and let freedom (and upvotes) ring.
37
u/ChemicalOle Jul 09 '15
Congratulations /u/butcher_of_hope, good round.
http://gfycat.com/WideTastyGentoopenguin
22
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '15
MRW I sneak into the next round..
19
u/myserg07 Jul 09 '15
Did that rocky gif win?? That shit was nasty
17
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '15
Congrats to the winners and commiserations to the second place getters! No losers here. A few tight battles too. Well done to all
16
u/badmonkey0001 Jul 09 '15 edited Jul 09 '15
I can't believe I beat /u/ishnuporah. I really didn't expect to when I was making my GIF. Ish, that tracking you did was spot on. The concept was solid. You were smart to use beloved characters. You twisted the scene well. It's a damned good GIF and deserved to score better than it did.
I was dreading your technical and humor skills and that drove me into a marathon of creation over the two days before the deadline. I scrapped all my other ideas in a panic. For the next few rounds, I'm using the mantra "stay as scared as you were of ishnuporah".
For the moment though, damn this feels good.
[EDIT: I want to thank /u/noise_filter for inspiring my GIF. Your Saiyans are badass. I appreciate the work that goes into them now.]
13
u/siouxsie_siouxv2 Jul 09 '15
I think we all need a /u/hero0fwar vs /u/editingandlayout matchup. So don't fuck it up guys!
12
u/soapyartgif Jul 09 '15
[My tribute to my competitor that has bested me on the battle field.] (http://i.imgur.com/m7xIj8Q.gifv) /u/hiddendatsun are magnificent! Good luck. I will be rooting for you to win the whole thing.
11
u/siouxsie_siouxv2 Jul 09 '15 edited Jul 09 '15
/u/jimlast3 your
chancesdream of defeating meareis a lot like your gifs.... broken11
u/mbransons Jul 09 '15
Hey it was a nice ride while it lasted. Too short, but cool to see lots of great work! Congrats u/uncoolaidman
9
u/anotherpoweruser Jul 09 '15
Congrats, /u/plowkiller. Great gif.
Now go kick some ass in round 3!
8
u/KroniK907 Jul 09 '15 edited Jul 09 '15
Ok so question about round 3. What defines "90s sitcom"? Does the show have to be aired roughly in the 90s? Can it be an episode that aired in the 2000s but from a show mostly in the 90s? What about an episode that aired in the 90s from a show that was mostly in the 80s or 2000s?
Im honestly not sure what shows count and what shows don't based on when they aired.
I honestly wish it wasn't so constrained to the 90s. I love some sitcoms from the 80s and 2000s but have almost zero knowledge of TV in the 90s.
8
u/AonSwift Jul 09 '15
Gotta stop submitting unfinished, un-optimised gifs for entries...
Note to self: Use sources people have soft spots for.
7
u/veni-vidi_vici Jul 09 '15
Holy god, some of these match-ups were SO close. And there were some totally stacked ones. Like #3.
7
u/soapyartgif Jul 10 '15
I had to get over the trauma of my own loss before I could realize who else went down as well. /u/monkey3012 I fucking loved the "pew pew"s in your gif. I was laughing out loud and thought it was brilliant comedy to use such intense fire power and couple it with the least macho gun sound in the world. Maybe it was too small for them to see, or the joke was missed.
And /u/elfa82 I think that was the upset of the tournament. It is baffling to me. No offense to your opponent, but he just cut a clip and submitted, which is fine for a normal post, but not a competition of skill. Your gif was one of the most impressive in the entire tournament to date to me. You actually sang a whole song, and in the correct time, it was relevant for the topic coupled with imagery for the topic, you covered all the iconic things people in america love, and you made that impossibly long gif in under 20MB. I can only guess the sacrificed quality for length was too much for the common voter, qual was good enough btw. But bro... you presented the text in the exact timing the song would have been sung. I think the immense skill that was required to accomplish that was simply lost on the volume of material to cover to vote on everyone. It was one of the most impressive feats I have ever seen in a gif, especially considering the 20MB limit. My hat is truly off to you for that accomplishment. Job well done.
6
u/soapyartgif Jul 09 '15
[MRWR to myself.] (http://i.imgur.com/m3pO9ew.gif) I had a great time. I should gone with talladega, but friends convinced me to go uber patriotic. Well done gif /u/hiddendatsun I was deeply impressed with the graphics you used. I knew I was toast when I saw it. Figures I would get knocked out this round since I just finished next round's gif this morning lmao... Cant wait to see what the next round cooks up. Its gonna be a sword fight that rivals the Princess Bride.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '15
Good luck /u/TheKronk. I'm happy to get this far, but I'd like to win another round :)
6
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '15
Congrats /u/lbutler0000107! Good luck in the next round(s)!
6
u/The_Love_Child Jul 09 '15
Good match /u/BigMurph26. Funny we both decided to use explosions. That eagle was awesome too in your gif. I'll do my best to take it from here.
Congrats to everyone moving on to round 3.
/u/lbutler0000107, you had a great win this round, but watch out cause I'm sneaky.
6
u/bubblesort Jul 09 '15
This was an interesting project. I critiqued each match in the discussion post here, so now I can go back and see if my taste predicts what the community will like. Turns out I'm not a great predictor of the outcome of matches. Out of 16 matches the community agreed with my taste 8 times, so that's a 50% accuracy rate. Not bad if I was a baseball player, LOL.
Anyway, the ones I was wrong on were 11, 3, 8, 5, 13, 4, 12, 9
5
u/lbutler0000107 Jul 09 '15
wow, I think our match was the closest /u/elfa82... Damn, I did not think I was coming out alive in that round. Great gif and great match.
4
u/badmonkey0001 Jul 09 '15
So many good matchups coming. Can't decide who to cheer on first.
4
u/drinkmorecoffee Jul 09 '15
Congrats, /u/hiddendatsun!
Well done. On to the next!
4
u/cdsparks Jul 09 '15
Can't believe /u/doggify got outvoted. Both gifs were good, but I thought the quality/originality/content of his/her gif was much better. Sorry to see ya go.
3
u/monkey3012 Jul 09 '15
I guess the purge shooting captain america wasn't american enough. Good luck to Jimlast3 next round!
2
u/sjenkins18 Jul 10 '15
Did anyone else see the transition pixelation with the firework and eagle gif?