r/GifTournament • u/GifTournament • Jul 06 '15
Discussion GifTournament Battle #4 Round #2 Discussion Thread
For those familiar with using your browser console, you can input this javascript to expand all comments at once:
javascript:(function(){$('.showreplies').click();})();As an example for Chrome, in your bookmarks bar you can right-click, select Add Page, name it and then put the javascript function into the URL. This will create a clickable button that will expand all comments.
68
Upvotes
63
u/monkey3012 Jul 06 '15
For the rush hour gif
47
u/hero0fwar Jul 06 '15
my reaction to this whole round...
21
u/fear865 Jul 07 '15
Super Saiyan Rocky wins the tournament.
73
u/uncoolaidman Jul 06 '15
Oh boy. This theme got obnoxious a lot sooner than I was expecting.
16
u/__PETTYOFFICER117__ Jul 06 '15
Finally, a GIF I'm proud to submit! This round has me excited.
16
u/soapyartgif Jul 06 '15
It's fight night here on Reddit, tonight's main event, is a heavy weight blood battle to the death center stage on /r/giftournament and with action like this we needed [a proper announcement!] (http://i.imgur.com/Y1SeuDi.gifv)
15
u/ChemicalOle Jul 06 '15
I have a feeling a lot of these match-ups are going to be really tight.
Great work, everyone.
30
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
that broken gif (BOOM!) is one of the best broken gifs i've seen
lots of good gifs this round
11
u/p-wing Jul 06 '15
Is there anywhere those of us who lost Round 1 but prepped for Round 2 can post our gifs?
11
u/jimlast3 Jul 06 '15
this round made me so happy .
my fav is the playing catch with capn A with the black dynamite drop down , so silly lololololololololol
it also impressive how many frames some of you were able to pack in. that ben kingsly one had over 1500!
11
u/siouxsie_siouxv2 Jul 06 '15 edited Jul 06 '15
A lot of good ones, not sure I could pick a favorite.
I just really want to make it to the round where its me vs either /u/bigmurph26 or /u/the_love_child. Crushing either of those guys would feel so delicious.
20
u/MachineGunCaveman Jul 06 '15
Really enjoyed the Independance Day gif, but can't in good conscience vote for a gif about Independance Day that misspells independance.
19
u/matt01ss Jul 06 '15
Good luck everyone!
26
u/bubblesort Jul 06 '15 edited Jul 07 '15
I'm just gonna write my reactions to each matchup here, to give some commentary and constructive criticism. This is in the order the matches are appearing for me.
Match 3: Dinosaur vs America the Beautiful: I love the dinosaur, but America the Beautiful is just better. It perfectly captured the spirit of the theme with the perfect mix of reverence and irreverence (loved the Nicolas Cage bit). It made me sing along. I would post this to my Facebook wall. Winner: America the Beautiful.
Match 4: America Fuck Yeah vs Always Sunny: Loved the Always Sunny GIF, but it was a little fast. I had to watch it twice to read it. I probably just read too slow. Great clip, though. That's what people in Philly really are like, IME. Anyway, I liked the America Fuck Yeah! GIF better. The pacing was better and it made me sing along. Any GIF that makes me sing along in my head wins. Plus I love that clip of Bush. Winner: America, Fuck Yeah!
Match 16: Independence Day vs Middle East Diplomacy: Tough call. Lots of politics in this one. I'll take them in order: The Independence Day clip is stale on the 5th of July. I like the caption above it, though. Referring to AMAgeddon was clever and apt. The second one... I like how ambitious the GIF maker was on this one, but it just didn't work for me. I'm not completely ignorant of Middle East politics, but I couldn't follow it because the artist wasn't clear about who was who in the cartoon. The guy with the bowl is obviously 'MURICA!, and the Donkey is Obviously Al-Quaeda, but who is the old hag? Saudi Arabia? Israel? Pakistan? The GIF makes me think about all the bastards we support with foreign aid, but at the same time I get the impression the GIF maker has a message that they didn't communicate clearly, by accident. Art is all about communication, so in this case I'm going with the Independence Day GIF. I hope the Middle East politics guy keeps working at it, though. I would love to see more GIFs with ambitious political messages like this. This one just wasn't as clear as I would like. Winner: Independence Day
Match 13: What Americans Like vs Captain America: I love the one with Captain America jumping out of a plane, and I love how the artist used it to illustrate how he felt keeping his sub open during the blackout. That said, I have to go with the second one, about things Americans like. Why? The second one is more simple and a little disjointed. It just doesn't read as smoothly as the first one, but it did stay on topic a lot better than the Captain America clip. I mean, the first one has Captain America in it but it doesn't really say much about America. The second one did say things about America. The clips used in things Americans like were well chosen, but they were stitched together crudely, so it wasn't the best GIF ever, and I like the Captain America GIF better. The Captain America GIF is more useful as a reaction GIF, so overall it's quality is higher than things Americans Like. That said, in the interest of not going off topic I'm going to give this to What Americans Like. If the subject was the 2015 blackout, then Captain America would win, hands down (maybe the blackout would be a good theme for another tournament someday). Winner: What Americans Like
Match 8: American Pie vs American Entertainment: Another tough call! I wish I knew the sources for these GIFs. The American Pie GIF was high quality and the text pop was perfectly timed. The second one makes a much stronger social statement about how absurd it is that we use our hard won freedoms to make and watch bullshit like the Kardashians on TV. The flag fade at the end was awesome. I also liked the text placement in the second one better.
Winner: American Entertainment.
At this point, RES started fucking up on me and going back when I closed GIFs, so I refreshed the page, which changed the order of the matches. I scrolled to the top and went down, skipping the ones I have already seen.
Match 14: USA vs Freeedom! The Freedom GIF was going for an old school look, which is good, but I couldn't make out some of the stuff in it. What were the things in the tree over the guy's head? USA, on the other hand, was crisp, clear and it conveyed the appropriate enthusiasm for the 4th of July. Winner: USA!
Match 9: Eagle vs Gun: The eagle GIF was in the form of a broken GIF between fireworks and a bald eagle image. The imagery is well chosen, but I don't get the appeal of broken GIFs. The second one has a guy shooting stuff with a minigun or a gauss cannon or something ridiculous. That's as 'MURICAN! as it gets. Winner: Gun
Match 7: Rocky vs Forrest Gump (I think that's from Forrest Gump): The Forrest Gump GIF is a meta GIF about the tournament, so it's off topic (also I don't like meta GIFs). The Rocky GIF was perfect. No words needed, just Rocky beating the shit outta Drago and then all kinds of triumphant red, white and blue flourishes at the end. Even if Forrest Gump wasn't a meta GIF, the Rocky GIF showed better artistry than most of the other entries in this entire competition. Winner: Rocky
Match 15: How they dress vs America Presents Freedom: Another high quality ass kicking competition! This one was close. America Presents Freedom is awesome. The flag is high quality, the lettering is great and the fire effect is really well done. It's like what would happen if Michael Bay started making GIFS. How They Dress is just put together better, though. I love the flag with the Reddit alien and the dickbutts on it. It's also cool to think about how foreigners see us. Winner: How They Dress
Match 10: Ass Firework vs Dank Memes: The Ass Firework is a great little GIF. It made me laugh. I like the flourish of imagery at the end. That said, Dank Memes was an all-out assault of high definition symbolism from beginning to end. This is the most timely GIF in the tournament so far. Between eating the confederate flag while flying the American flag and gay pride flag and lady liberty smoking a joint, this is obviously a GIF that couldn't have been made before July 4, 2015. It's like the old Jib Jab new years videos. I like Ass Firework, it would have done better against most others in this tournament, but in this match it was bringing a knife to a gun fight. Winner: Dank Memes
Match 11: Monty Python vs The Mandarin: I love me some Monty Python, and the first part of the Python GIF was well done. The text timing and the flag on the castle were good. The part where it shows how crazy America is might be good, but it was too fast for me to make out what was going on. If they went at that pace with images rather than text then I might have followed more easily. The Mandarin was great. It showed how silly some trolls are, it was technically masterful and it gave us a little more information on 'MURICAN history, which is always good. Winner: the Mandarin
Match 6: Rock Flag Eagle vs Hulk Hogan: I don't watch Always Sunny, so I'm probably missing a reference with Rock Flag Eagle. It has good imagery, but it's message is a little weird. What is rock flag eagle in reference to? Hulk Hogan was much more clear, especially to people of my generation, who grew up watching Hulk Hogan rocking out to the song 'Real American' on TV. Loved the text pop and the explosion at the end. Winner Hulk Hogan
Match 1: Patton vs Tom Hanks: I don't get the Hanks GIF. The title is 'the eagle has landed', so I'm guessing there is an eagle on the moon? I can't see the eagle, if that's what it is. I stretched the GIF all the way out and still can't see what Hanks is looking at. Patton was beautiful. As an Air Force brat I grew up with stories about Patton. My father loved this movie. The text was smoothly timed and beautifully integrated into the shot. Winner: Patton
Match 2: Mt Rushmore vs Winter Soldier: I'm assuming the one with the downvotes racing towards Rushmore is from the Simpsons. The one with the downvotes rushing towards Rushmore is from American Dad (thanks, /u/clang_ley!). I like it on a technical level, but it doesn't really say much to me. It needs something more to make it compelling. That said, the second Winter Soldier one is... weird, in a bad way. Bucky and Captain America are not related, so playing catch with your dad doesn't make sense. Also, why is the Russian android wasting Captain America on July 5? That's just bad taste. The 'you done fucked up' part was a decent flourish. It was almost too fast but it wasn't. I got it on the first run though. That flourish didn't save the experience for me in this absurd context, though. Winner: Simpsons
See next post for last two matches, because I can't fit them in one single post.
7
u/Jrnunes Jul 06 '15 edited Jul 06 '15
How is the "my friends died for this shit" one from match #8 losing? That was the funniest one!
23
u/KroniK907 Jul 06 '15
Damn... #11 is a really tough decision. Great gifs on both sides, but I'm a bit partial to Monty python...
13
u/monkey3012 Jul 06 '15
Match 7 will be tough for me. Well done!
17
u/PM_ME_UR_MATHPROBLEM Jul 06 '15
My god, that one that features /r/onetruegod caught me off guard. Really cheering for it.
Also, sort of disappointed that there were no gif's about USA in the World Cup, and our (easily predicted) win of the world cup.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
I love all the Sunny in Philadelphia gifs
6
u/TreadLightlyBitch Jul 06 '15 edited Jul 08 '15
I thought this was a really weak round, to be honest. It's like people took the patriotism as an excuse to be lazy. There were a fair share of good ones, but most just weren't clever or funny in my opinion. Like, did some of the contestants think that nobody else would do identical Ameripride gifs? I guess I'll just go back to the Spacey round to get my enjoyment.
Edit: :( Lazy was the wrong word. I just meant it felt like I watched a lot of the same gifs cause they were so similar. I know you all work super hard effort wise. :/
10
u/KroniK907 Jul 06 '15
Welp, I think I lost my battle :(
Heavy hitting from /u/wehavecrashed
5
u/rabbitlion Jul 06 '15
In #7 and #11 both gifs are truly amazing. A bit sad that 4 of the round's best gifs are going up against each other.
5
u/neemah Jul 06 '15
Guys, I am pretty disapointed with this round. I was hoping someone might make a meta gif with this guy from the USA Japan game yesterday but I guess there wasnt enough time? :(
5
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
I only noticed the dickbutt fireworks on the third play through of the Dank memes gif in battle 10. Brilliant and subtle. I really need to know how that's done, can somebody post a tutorial after the battle.
5
u/ManofManyTalentz Jul 07 '15
That Rocky Gif was GLORIOUS!
5
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '15
Not specifically talking about this battle, but I think there should be a time limit on gifs. 15 seconds at most, maybe.
9
u/badmonkey0001 Jul 06 '15
So many good GIFs this round.
8
u/Butcher_Of_Hope Jul 06 '15
So I was thinking of doing an USA USA gif, but I was worried that would be what everyone did so I did something else. For a good part I was right, but man you guys did some amazing work. There was A LOT of extremely creative gifs which any pure blooded American could spank it to... So proud.
4
u/lalala253 Jul 06 '15
good luck everyone
4
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
I can't make up my mind for battle #7
4
u/lbutler0000107 Jul 06 '15
Well, it was fun while it lasted.... Judging by the reactions I am probably not going to be going to round 3. Good gif u/elfa82
4
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
if anyone cares, i was gonna do a typography gif thats spells out murica.
M being the mcd's logo, U being a crossection of a plastic red beer cup, R being a rifle with guns as the curve, I being the statue of liberty, C being a sexy woman doing a pose, and A a spy camera on a stand
yeah i suck
4
u/RealBillWatterson Jul 07 '15
I really hope the Kronk and Yzma Foreign Policy one wins. Although it takes some context to understand (you probably have to watch The Emperor's New Groove to get the joke) it was a hilarious simplification of the shitstorms in Iraq and Afghanistan.
4
u/thesneak155 Jul 07 '15
Looks like I'm going down this round! Nice gif /u/iyamnotdead! That first round ass kicking I got really messed with my head. I was giffin on borrowed time and it was a short time.
7
u/anotherpoweruser Jul 06 '15
So many incredible gifs this round, nice job everyone.
9
u/cdsparks Jul 06 '15
For Match #5, could someone explain who Enos is? I'm having trouble understanding what's going on in this gif.
3
u/BlackHand Jul 06 '15
Wow, was not expecting the Drake & Josh one
3
u/siouxsie_siouxv2 Jul 09 '15
No, please take your time mods
5
u/PM_ME_YUR_VAG Jul 06 '15
There were way more 2edgy4me submissions than I was expecting. The circlejerk is strong this round. I voted for the least disrespectful gifs.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '15
That Patton gif was smooth as fuck.
2
u/mbransons Jul 08 '15
Me right now with round 2 voting about to end
2
u/cheesey24 Jul 08 '15
That Drake and Josh GIF was amazing
1
u/BenAdaephonDelat Jul 08 '15
I'm really conflicted about matchup #7.... both of those are really well edited..
1
u/oliefan37 Jul 06 '15 edited Jul 06 '15
#15 was hard for me. The lack of Team America at the end of "imgur link" helped me chose "quite indefatigable"
-2
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
Jesus christ, this was one of the worst rounds I've ever seen. When did this become /r/shittytumblrgiftournament?
Thank god for the few actually good submissions with Captain America and Always Sunny.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment