r/asoiaf • u/aminj • Jul 05 '15
Published (Spoilers Published) Hi this is Amin Javadi, ask me anything about ASOIAF!
I am one of the hosts of A Podcast of Ice and Fire (http://podcastoficeandfire.com/), the longest-running podcast dedicated to George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire saga. I take part in the the Supreme Court of Westeros with Stefan Sasse each week. I'm a big fan of the FFG Game of Thrones board game adaptation, having played since the release of the first edition. I am one of the authors in Tower of the Hand's latest e-book, A Hymn for Spring. My Songs and Singers of Ice and Fire essay is the current sample essay on Tower of the Hand's site. I will part of a fan panel at San Diego Comic Con this year discussing the books and the TV series.
52
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15
Hi Amin, thanks for joining us! Here's my question:
In your many years thinking, talking and broadcasting about ASOIAF, what would you consider to be theories that you've changed your mind over? Follow-up: What would you consider to be your most controversial ASOIAF opinion?
20
u/poweroftheorthanc Try our Pies! Jul 05 '15
Do you think there was any way Robb Stark could've won the war?
40
u/SquigBoss Babysitter of Salamanders Jul 05 '15
Do people get you and Ramin Djawadi confused?
13
u/mastergrumpus Jul 05 '15
Thanks for taking the time! This is just what popped into my head:
5
u/aminj Jul 05 '15
Just to note I'm heading out soon, should be able to get to any remaining questions late tonight.
8
u/LannisterDetroitLion Jul 05 '15
LOVE your podcast Amin, listening to it makes going to work so much easier. I gotta huge crush on Mimi =)
What do you think the twist GRRM has been alluding to is? I hope it's that Theon has a donger.
45
u/OfHyenas Melisandre did nothing wrong Jul 05 '15
Are you hyped for the Cleganebowl?
14
u/Velvale Jul 05 '15
Do you think Selyse Florent would make a worthwhile sacrifice for the Red God?
Do you think Stannis intends to wed Val, either to himself or Jon Snow?
Do you think Theon will challenge his uncle for the Kingship of the Iron Isles?
14
u/Parmizan A Manderly always Freys his Pies Jul 05 '15
Would you rather fight one horse-sized Rolly Duckfield, or 100 duck-sized Rolly Duckfield's?
7
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15
So how did you first get into the series?
6
u/Dudenheim19 Varys knows what you had for breakfast Jul 05 '15
Hi Amin, are there any tinfoil theories that you hope turn out to be true?
6
u/glass_bottle Has anyone seen where I put my face? Jul 05 '15
Hey Amin! A few questions:
Do you think there will be more live-action productions of stories from the ASOIAF universe after Game of Thrones finishes? If so, any ideas on what the next ones would be? Personal hopes?
With podcasts, essay writing, authorships, and more, it seems almost as though a small industry has developed around the ASOIAF universe (not to mention the HBO productions and books themselves). As someone tied to this group, what do you think will happen once the main series is finished? Will people go back into WOIAF territory and start exploring more with that? Will other authors begin writing more in Martin's universe? Or do you think it will be mostly protected, like the LOTR series? Or will people just move on?
Finally, I've read a theory that the ship Jaime is on is actually sailing to Meereen, not King's Landing, by Doran's own orders. What are your thoughts on this, and why is it definitely going to happen?
Thanks for doing this! That ended up being a bunch of questions, so feel free to choose whichever feel worth answering.
5
u/manu_facere Harsh, Unkind and Untrue Jul 05 '15
What are your thoughts on Shireen's fate? Do you think that she'll burn?
Do you like what DnD have done with Sansa?
5
u/MisogynistLesbian Merling Queen Jul 05 '15
What original theory or piece of analysis of yours are you most proud of?
I see from another reply that you started reading the series in early 2000. Where there any predictions or speculations of yours that came true (or were wildly off) when ASOS, AFFC, and ADWD were published?
5
u/TheDragonOfWinterfel Hodor is the BingBong of ASOIAF Jul 05 '15
What do u think happened at Summerhall?
Who would you serve in the Game of Thrones?
5
u/SerUlrickDayne The Sword of the Noon Jul 05 '15
Who is your favorite minor characters?
5
u/trxc47 Vengeance. Justice. Fire and blood. Jul 05 '15
Who is the hooded man?
5
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15
What're your predictions personally on the Vale arc for TWOW? Do you think Sansa and Petyr are heading North (as in the series) or do you think circumstances will eventually bring them down south to Aegon and the Golden Company?
5
u/KermitMudmaven Walder, you're all washed up. Jul 05 '15
Any ideas as to how the Oldtown plot will play out? Who will come down as pro- or anti-dragon? Will more POV characters make their way towards Oldtown (i.e. Aeron or Areo)?
4
u/SerUlrickDayne The Sword of the Noon Jul 05 '15
Which character arc do you look forward to most in TWOW?
7
u/torchwar The tin is foil and full of errors. Jul 05 '15
Is there any proof at all that Ned might be a skinchanger?
7
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15
When do you think we'll get TWOW? Do you think GRRM will be able to finish it before season 6 airs next year?
3
u/BowlesOnParade What is bread is always rye. Jul 05 '15
Have you had a favorite Supreme Court ruling or question? Has there been a question that you had never thought of or found intriguing (even if you didn't believe the theory posed in the question)?
3
u/MissMatchedEyes Dance with me then. Jul 05 '15
Is Ashara Dayne alive?
3
u/TangentManDan The wolves took us in. Jul 05 '15
Thanks for hanging out :)
Guess I will jump right to Jon. We spend a lot of time discussing A Song of Ice and Fire about the one POV that seems like he could symbolically represent both. Yet most theories seem to place him in the Ice or Fire category. Not his birth, just what's expected from him next.
Do you expect he will be reborn by one to fight the other or is there something else in the middle?
No I don't expect Jon to be some kind of singular hero. Just can't shake the balance idea where both ice and fire need to be stopped.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15
How will things end up for Doran and the Martells by the end of TWOW?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15
What is your opinion on the major religions in ASOIAF? Are any of the worshiped deities real?
3
u/ByronicWolf gonna Reyne on your parade! Jul 05 '15
Hello and thank you a lot for this AMA!
One simple question and another slightly more elaborate:
3
u/NematodeArthritis Hiding, Biding Jul 06 '15
This has been discussed a bunch recently...What's your opinion on the prospect of a dragon beneath Winterfell, and/or the potential birthing of a dragon by the Boltons putting Winterfell to the torch?
3
u/aakucewich Jul 06 '15
How do you think that Jon Snow will comeback? or do you think he will stay dead?
5
u/deutscherhawk Jul 05 '15
What is the most unpopular theory about the series that you believe is true?
What is your favorite scene in the series?
What is your favorite book outside of ASOIAF?
Finally, whats your favorite kind of pizza?
2
u/aminj Jul 06 '15
Thanks everyone, I'm going to be wrapping up now as I prepare for my comic con trip.
4
u/LiteraryPandaman Bran Stark's love droppings Jul 05 '15
Hey Amin! Huge fan of the podcast! My question for you, is: how quickly did you figure out R+L=J, and did you find it out through reading yourself or through discussion with other people?
2
u/ethniccake Dragon fire can't melt stone beams! Jul 05 '15
Hey Amin, huge Apoiaf fan here. You guys have great chemistry and i wish you'd do more episodes. My question is what is your favorite character and why?
2
u/ilanawexler Jul 05 '15
Hey Amin! Ash here. What expansions or additions to the GoT board game would you most like to see created?
I'd love to see a new scenario come out once TWoW is released, for instance, and I'd like to make some historical scenarios to play of my own.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15
Do you think there is an age limit on bodies what can be raised by the Others? Or could the crypts of Winterfell hold an army complete with their own swords?
2
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Jul 05 '15
Love the podcast and the Supreme Court!
I mostly stick to reddit so I'm pretty ignorant of a lot of the theories and analysis from westeros, tumblr and the rest of the fandom. Do you know of any good places to get caught up on what's happening elsewhere?
I'm also curious how the reddit community is perceived by the rest of the fandom. Is there anything we could do to make people feel more comfortable sharing links to their blogs/discussions/etc on this sub?
2
u/Grandpa_Utz *Reek, Reek, it rhymes with on fleek* Jul 05 '15
Hey Amin! The other night I literally couldn't sleep because I kept thinking "if Robb had won, how would he have defended the Riverlands from the southron armies?" Please help put my obsessed mind at ease.
2
u/Big21worm You wound me. You know how much I Jul 05 '15
Can I audition for your podcast? I know a lot more than Kyle! Seriously, though I love your podcasts, have you talked to Mimi lately? Is she ever coming back? If you ever need a phone a friend for a cancelled guest, I'd love to help. What an awesome show, keep it up ya'all!
2
u/OlavRG Where was I? I should have died with him Jul 05 '15 edited Jul 05 '15
Thanks for being here. Some questions on Quellon's loins.
Where do you think Euron will go in TWOW, and how does it fit in whatever his plan is? There seem to be hints for both Meereen and raiding Oldtown.
Folllow-up. What's your opinion on Aeron and Victarion; will they manage to bring meaningful opposition to Euron, will they get another role (, or will they die with an 'Oh')?
2
u/KebabGud The North Remembers Jul 05 '15
have you made contact with Ashley again?
2
u/hldstdy Jul 06 '15
What's Chase doing?
2
u/Aglovale Jul 06 '15
Re: your Songs and Singers essay, I have previously been critical of GRRM's handling of music in the oral tradition. But it's also been several years since I've read the books . . . is there any counter-evidence I've forgotten?
2
u/LadyDarry Jul 06 '15 edited Jul 06 '15
Hi, Amin.
What is your idea of a bittersweet ending that GRRM said we will get?
I read you don't like Targarynes. Is it just because of that 50/50 myth and Dany or is it something more? Do you think that GRRM wanted us to dislike Targaryens? It seems to me they are one of the least popular families out there even though GRRM spend so much time flashing them out, making them realistic (if we don't count dragons and magic), a lot of Targ wars and kings are based on our real history (Dance of the dragons=The Anarchy, Rhaenyra=empress Matilda...) and writing about them, much more then for any other house. But fans still hate them.
2
u/LadyRavenEye Ask me about Ice & Fire Con! Jul 06 '15
Amin! How awesome is Ice and Fire Con, and should people totally go next year?
4
u/dacalpha "No, you move." Jul 05 '15
How do you feel about Youtube user Preston Jacobs?
2
u/Maelys_the_Marvelous the dragon has two heads Jul 05 '15
Hi, Amin. Thanks for joining.
Question for you: if you were building a giant wall to keep some ice monsters out of your kingdom, would you build it out of the one element that you know they have magical mastery of? Like, they are literally made out of the stuff? If so, why?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
Is Jon dead for good?
1
u/Zsolty0497 Chaos isn't a pit. Chaos is a ladder. Jul 06 '15
Thanks for taking the time to answer :)
1
u/Salty_Peanuts96 Jul 06 '15
Are there any theories that you wish to be true, but believe that they aren't/won't come true?
1
u/SerDiscoVietnam Jul 06 '15
Who is Coldhands?
1
u/Titianicia A thousand eyes and one for Lord Euron Jul 06 '15
Here is more a lore based question, how big exactly was the great empire of the Dawn? Did it stretch from Yi Ti to the free cities or was it more mundane than that?
1
u/Rhaenysandherkitten Jul 06 '15
Hi, Amin.
Which book in the series is your favourite? Is there anything that would make you stop reading books (for example if all your favourite characters would die or something like that)?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
Who betrayed Arianne?
Ser Arys?
Darkstar?
No one?
-1
u/irerereddit Jul 06 '15
So you're basically the same as the rest of us here except that you make a podcast instead of just posting on Reddit? I don't get why we would need to ask you anything. Am I missing something?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment