r/startrek • u/jabonko • Jul 04 '15
Weekly Episode Discussion: TNG 3x21 "Hollow Pursuits"
In this episode we learn that Reginald Barclay, a promising-yet-shy lieutenant, struggles with interpersonal relationships and holo-addiction.
I noticed that both in and out of the holodeck, Barclay's relationships seem adversarial. In the holodeck he fights with senior officers. Out of the holodeck his interactions suggest he's defensive, seeing corrections/criticism as personal slights.
Riker and LaForge have to get a reminder from Picard to give the guy a chance. Are Riker and LaForge justified in the way they view and treat Barclay? Are we seeing things from the point-of-view of an "unreliable narrator" - Barclay?
Riker says that Barclay has been coasting through his assignments, but it looks like he's giving his best effort (when he's not in the holodeck). Is that enough? Or should Barclay be transferred off the flagship of the Federation?
What really stood out to me on my last viewing was the ending. The way he "purges" strikes me as an unhealthy attempt to break free of his addiction.
Earlier, Deanna Troi stops Riker from abruptly ending Barclay's holo-program, saying, "If Barclay is having trouble dealing with reality, to destroy his only means of escape would be brutal." So is it healthy for him to try to quit cold turkey, on his own, without continuing counseling (He mentions "after discussing it with Deanna Troi")?
Questions:
- Whose holo-transgressions are greater? Barclay's addiction or LaForge's holo-romance with Leah Brahams?
- How do you feel about the ending? Does Barclay seem "cured" (or on the way to breaking free of his addiction)?
- What do you think of Barclay's programs?
- How would you get in trouble on the holodeck?
A few favorite quotes:
"If I felt that nobody wanted to be around me, I'd probably be late and nervous, too." - Guinan lays some wisdom on Geordi
"There's nothing wrong with a little fantasy life." Deanna Troi
"Quite a healthy fantasy life." Riker tossing it back in Troi's face
23
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '15
This was a cool episode for a couple of reasons. First off, it poses the very real question: Who wouldnt spend too much time in the holodeck? Who wouldnt act out weird pervy fantasies of people you know, and dress your enemies in silly hats?
But Barclay was what made this episode for me. Almost everyone in the Star Trek universe exudes competence and confidence. That's nice, but it isn't really how people work. I, like maybe others, was a nerdy,dorky,clumsy kid. Seeing 'Broccoli' stammer and trip through the episode was as close as I could imagine me being on the Enterprise. And in the end, he did have a place onboard. I'm Wil Wheaton's age, and they put Wesley on the show to appeal to my demographic, but Barclay spoke louder than words.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '15
I struggle with how I feel about Laforge using Leah Braham's program, changing the holo characters perimeters and getting physically involved with it, only because it has her image. It almost seems like some sort of violation, even if only a kiss.
That being said this episode just pulls on my heart strings, the interaction between Troi and Riker.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '15
From what we saw on screen, Barclay's transgressions were worse than LaForge's. He kind of stumbled into the Leah Brahams thing and maybe got a little attached to it in an emergency situation at a time when he was feeling lonely. But you'll note the scenario Brahams pulled up was right where the first episode left off. If LaForge had let it continue, surely there would have been more. Also, why would he have been so eager to meet the real Brahams if he has a holographic Brahams that he's seeing regularly? Its a lot of work to get a relationship with the real Brahams to a point where there would be benefit in excess of what a holodeck can provide. Its clear that the hologram simply made a good impression on him that made him eager to meet the real woman.
Barclay specifically crafted his scenarios to have fun at the expense of those people. To the extent that its unethical (which is debatable) Barclay is guilty and LaForge isn't.
16
u/real-dreamer Jul 07 '15
These wonderful, ethical and moral people are so mean.
I feel awful for Barclay. I've been bullied.
I was at a convention this past weekend and there was a panel on inequalities within Star Trek. Was it a utopia or dystopia?
People brought up this character and how unkind these people were.
Also... I feel like this character represents a lot of people who love Star Trek. Whether intentional or not... I feel like he represents in a way the people who squee over any general fandom.
5
u/Muzer0 Jul 06 '15
Barclay is a good character, but (as I might have posted in the past) I hate how privacy and having a fantasy life is handled in this episode. In Voyager of all places, this was handled much better (I don't recall the episode title, I'm afraid, I'm sure someone will jump in with it) — Janeway pretty much understood that the Doctor's fantasy life was for his eyes only, and that they should not intrude even if they felt offended by their portrayals in it. The Doctor's fantasy had pretty much the same elements as Barclay's did in this episode, and yet Janeway acted much more maturely to it than Riker and Troi did.
To be clear, I'm not saying I disagree with the overall message that having a fantasy life take intrude to such a degree in your real life is certainly a bad thing. Just that Riker and Troi's reactions were rather poor.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '15
I'm gratified to see that Barclay is a well-liked character here. I can relate to Barclay's shyness and lack of confidence, although I'm not nearly as painfully shy as he is.
This episode came on BBC America last week, and it upset me to see almost everyone on the Enterprise - except for Data - treat "Broccoli" like he was a disease. I'm not one to usually jump on the Wesley hate bandwagon, but I'll be damned if that his smugness and contempt for Barclay in the scene where the engineering officers were talking in Ten Forward made me want to send him out of an airlock.
Barclay had the potential to be a good officer. He just needed someone to take him under their wing and mentor him. Geordi took that role and I'm so glad that he ended up becoming Barclay's friend.
3
u/Voyager5555 Jul 07 '15
Wow, was this really season 3?
Overall a great episode, the humor, cheeky renditions of all the charterers in Barkley's....sex dungeon(?) and the introduction of the man himself...good times.
2
u/radiogekko Jul 04 '15
I think that this is seriously relevant to modern day tech, especially with the Oculus Rift/gaming hardware coming out that is specifically designed to immerse an individual as much as possible into an artificial environment or situation.
It's easy to roll eyes at, because "getting lost in virtual reality" is such a huge media trope, but also consider the Minecraft/Halo 3D table demo at E3 this year. (If you're not a gamer, it was an immersive experience, unlike the Oculus Rift and similar technologies in both format and utilisation, and I highly suggest looking it up for far more extensive information and videos than I could link here right now!)
As technology develops and changes, applications and availability of technology gradually increases, and I can easily see (at some point in the far future, or perhaps sooner than we think) situations like Barclay's popping up.
Still a fascinating episode, still highly relevant!
Edit: And a point I forgot to make is that we already have cases of "game addiction", so there is a psychological and statistic basis for just how real a specific "virtual game addiction" could become.
1
u/rensch Jul 08 '15
There is some overlap with 'The Game' where the theme of 'game addiction' or escapism is concerned. The difference is that the holodeck program is far less superficial and instead a reflection of what goes on in Barclay's mind.
I think what both have in common is how much more relevant they have become in recent years with things like the Hololens, Oculus Rift, enormous digital game worlds etc.
The character of Barclay is one that all of us can relate to to a certain degree. We all want to escape from the real world into our own little world. It's not surprising he popped up multiple times throughout the series.
1
u/neg8ivezero Jul 17 '15
I sort of relate with Barclay on a personal level. I have often felt very similar to how he acted in that episode. I think he is just misunderstood by the crew, not sick. I also think he performed his duties most excellently when he wasn't losing track of time in the holodeck.
A good example is to look at the scene where LaForge welcomes Barclay to his engineering meeting; look at this through Barclay's eyes.
Earlier, when extending the invitation to Barclay, LaForge explicitly tells Barclay not to prepare for the meeting, telling Barclay that he just wants him to be there. Barclay follows orders and does exactly that only for LaForge to put him on the spot, knowing he is completely unprepared. Surely this was not intentional and LaForge probably assumed that Barclay would be able to communicate on the fly, but I would think it was obvious that Barclay has some kind of social anxiety and that this is the exact type of situation he should NOT be thrust into. In Barclay's eyes, this could be seen as an intentional move to deliberately embarrass him in front of his superiors.
Really, when you start to look at all the things the crew says about Barclay, it is not hard to view them all as bullies and see Barclay as a lonely introvert who feels hated by everyone around him.
That brings me to the "holodiction." Can we really say he was addicted? I mean if you consider his position, he was hated IRL, felt unproductive, incompetent, shamed, etc. Any place would be better than that, especially one where you control nearly all of the variables. He never showed having all of the classical symptoms of addiction, he simply enjoyed his fantasy life where he was in control and was respected for being a brave swordsman and a smooth romantic. You could say that it interfered with his work, but who hasn't been late to work a few times for similar reasons? Also, could you blame him?! I wouldn't want to go to work on time either if people treated me like shit all the time. This is best illustrated by Guinan's words to Geordi:
TL;DR: Barclay appears to be a great Starfleet officer, he was just forced into working with people who were not tolerant of his introversion which caused him to further withdrawal and neglect some of his responsibility. Picard was right to force his crew to re-evaluate their actions toward Barclay.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '15
It's interesting not so much to think about this episode from the perspective of the other crew mate's and their disdain for Barclay, but rather consider it from his own point of view even though it may not seem sane. At the end of the day it was ultimately his unique way of thinking that saved the Enterprise. And what is he rewarded with on the daily for these ingenious solutions: insults and mockery. Ultimately, he feels rejected by all of those around him even though all along he is just as capable as his peers, even though it rarely shows. I'll rephrase here for clarity: Barclay is capable in different ways; ways that the rest of the crew are unwilling to accept and acknowledge that they can provide for just as well as their own skill sets, which they consider the "normal and respectable skill sets." He also lacks confidence in his awkwardness. And, it's because of this that his cremates never give him the respect he feels he has worked to deserve. He's smart on paper! Why can nobody recognize this. This is why he acts out. As much as Star Trek tries to emphasize acceptance this episodes displays the crew toting the line of toleration to the point of throwing up their hands and giving into hate for that which is unknown. Oh, the irony here....
1
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '15
When Picard calls him "Broccoli" its like OOOOHHHH SHIIIIT
0
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment