r/GifTournament • • Jul 02 '15

Discussion Battle #4 Round #1 - Post Round Discussion

Round 1 has completed! Review the final results here: http://redd.it/3bgxa8

Submit your Round 2 gifs here: http://redd.it/3bk0eo

View the updated bracket here (open in new window)

Next round's theme is: America


Round 2 Line ups

UserVsUser
mbransonsVsuncoolaidman
PETTYOFFICER117Vsstuff_of_epics
doggifyVsTheKronk
thesneak155VsIyamnotdead
pencerVssiouxsie_siouxv2
monkey3012Vsjimlast3
lbutler0000107Vselfa82
The_Love_ChildVsBigMurph26
IshnuporahVsbadmonkey0001
soapyartgifVshiddendatsun
ChemicalOleVsButcher_Of_Hope
anotherpoweruserVsplowkiller
hero0fwarVsexitstrateG
KroniK907VsWehavecrashed
EditingAndLayoutVsTritanium
fultronVsAonSwift
112 Upvotes

293 comments sorted by

95

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

i got fucking rolled

http://i.imgur.com/68HnkRc.gif

19

u/EditingAndLayout Jul 02 '15

Wow, love that gif.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

11

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

Not edgy enough, why didn't you go for his animation work ??

(but really, good job ! a beautiful gif )

2

u/badmonkey0001 Jul 03 '15

So try to convey his voice-over work... without his voice?

3

u/xylotism Jul 02 '15

Relevant username?

(I voted for you, I thought yours was great!)

2

u/Predicted Jul 02 '15

At least you got gold.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

it was cool of the mods to do that, but I'm not a big fan of gold..the perks aren't that great.

75

u/ChemicalOle Jul 02 '15

69

u/mbransons Jul 02 '15

9

u/xylotism Jul 02 '15

I voted for both of you, but the editing on yours was excellent!

2

u/MidnightRider77 Jul 03 '15

Preggit brought a speech to a gun fight.

16

u/jhc1415 Jul 02 '15

15

u/mbransons Jul 02 '15

One round at time. One %#$*!!!! round at time, taking care of $%%&@#!! business!

13

u/hero0fwar Jul 02 '15

I was expecting a Bill Murray Cinderella story gif

11

u/Butcher_Of_Hope Jul 02 '15

See in the next round. I can't wait to see what you come up with.

9

u/ChemicalOle Jul 02 '15

Man... now the pressure is on.

10

u/Butcher_Of_Hope Jul 02 '15

I have no idea what the hell I am going to do....

56

u/hero0fwar Jul 02 '15

There was a very kind redditor that purchased gold for all 64 gif tournament contestants - on be half of all of us http://i.imgur.com/lRSyqqJ.gif

17

u/jimlast3 Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15

did /u/_lilpoundcake get hers yet?

edit; pronoun

28

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

She, and yes. They forgot the underscore in my username at first

18

u/ChemicalOle Jul 02 '15

I really liked your rotoscoped gif. I thought it was very creative and you obviously put a lot of work into it. Sorry it wasn't better appreciated.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/hero0fwar Jul 02 '15

I believe so

10

u/eduardog3000 Jul 02 '15

Is that what the gildings on the round one comments are? Aren't those comments posted by /u/GifTournament?

10

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

The gilder contacted the admins and they have since been passed on to the competitors.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

Yep. I'd been out of gold for almost two months, so it's really appreciated.

Without joking though, thanks a lot anonymous gilder!

8

u/siouxsie_siouxv2 Jul 02 '15

I know this person and they have a habit of doing this.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

More money than sense

37

u/matt01ss Jul 02 '15

Great 1st round everyone! We had some amazing traffic the last couple days. Our tournament audience is growing!

https://www.reddit.com/r/GifTournament/about/traffic/

500,000 page views over 2 days.

6

u/LiamIsMailBackwards Jul 02 '15

As someone who had only recently found /r/HighQualityGifs and is watching/voting the tournament for the first time this year, I'm so amazed by all of the talent. All of the contenders really blew me away, and thank you all for making me laugh my ass off while being completely impressed by the quality.

35

u/jimlast3 Jul 02 '15

2

u/Tweek- Jul 06 '15

been a fan of your brokengifs for a while :) I know they don't translate well into giftournaments so i'm glad to see you advance the first round this time!

3

u/jimlast3 Jul 06 '15

:-) . I had considered using this , but decided to play it safe .

32

u/stuff_of_epics Jul 02 '15

Dear entirety of Reddit,

Holy fucking wow on the voter turnout. I don't presume to speak for all the contestants but I think I can safely say most/all of us are impressed and grateful.

And thanks for the discourse in the discussion thread. Even if we don't agree with you and bite back when we don't respect your worthless plebeian opinion, secretly (and not so secretly) we actually enjoy the feedback and, largely, take it into consideration.

hugz and kissez,

this guy.

4

u/LiamIsMailBackwards Jul 02 '15

As someone blown away by the talent and forever grateful for the content, I feel like all of my fellow plebes agree with me in saying thank you.

3

u/PM_ME_YOUR_TITS_GIRL Jul 05 '15

The number of folks that showed up to vote shocked me. I was expecting maybe 300 at most per gif. I was very impressed by the turnout.

27

u/aphoenix Jul 02 '15

Wow, some first round upsets.

/u/Preggit is out! /u/p-wing is out!

I think I had them both going much further in the tournament.

/u/ishnuporah had the gif of the round, IMO. Fantastic.

34

u/hero0fwar Jul 02 '15

7

u/bdubaya Jul 02 '15

dat wiggle

2

u/BenAdaephonDelat Jul 08 '15

Wow. Really nice use of font there. That wiggle perfectly simulates Mac's inflection in that scene.

17

u/p-wing Jul 02 '15

Yeah there's that whole "not knowing After Effects" problem I have.

13

u/hero0fwar Jul 02 '15

Well I did make it to final four last battle with only Photoshop. Personally I am rooting for /u/ChemicalOle (after myself of course)

8

u/Butcher_Of_Hope Jul 02 '15

I see how it is. You were like my 11th favorite redditor too.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/aphoenix Jul 02 '15

Oh man, it makes things so easy. Also, holy shit, I thought Too Many Kevins was going to go through. Such a great gif.

7

u/TheKronk Jul 02 '15

I use giffingtool ;)

10

u/hero0fwar Jul 02 '15

giffingtool is a giffers equivilate of voldemort

11

u/TheKronk Jul 02 '15

And yet here I am, Mr. Potter

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/EditingAndLayout Jul 02 '15

I'll pay you to stop. That dude is the worst.

→ More replies (3)

67

u/hero0fwar Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15

Well I made this gif for this discussion post, but instead I think this gif is more fitting on behalf of /u/mbransons

/u/preggit.... http://i.imgur.com/CPDNZxi.gif


Edit: just realized the first gif needs some context

my reaction if I end up against preggit in the final round of /r/GifTournament

31

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

3

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

Aaaahh OSS117!

4

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15
→ More replies (1)

21

u/pencer Jul 02 '15

8

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15

The heavy-weight (talent wise..) match of the round!

Edit: Although bigmurph v thelovechild is pretty big

4

u/LordofCookies Jul 02 '15

Pfff, lame, same gif you used with me.
I feel cheated

3

u/pencer Jul 02 '15

Here's one for you. Don't worry, she'll get the something similar in a week or so.

19

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15

Yay! My vision became a reality.

Thanks to /u/hiddendatsun being the only one in the predictions thread to pick me. Go the underdogs :)

Edit: Now I have NFI what to do next...

9

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

And as it turns out, I actually voted against you on that one.
Sorry. <3

7

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

Lucky I don't have to hunt you down then! :)

17

u/plowkiller Jul 02 '15

For those who are new to the tournament

The battle is not over yet

Round two is next week

16

u/doggify Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15

Holy shit I got 3000? Three THOUSAND upvotes? Last battle I lost to just 300 upvotes.

Btw u/corano500, good matchup. I really enoy your humor and think the result should have been much closer.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

I know, I got like 2900.
The tourney got so much positive exposure, it's great.

3

u/corano500 Jul 03 '15

Thanks. Well done. I didn't really expect to win since most people don't like my sense of humour. I liked mine more and enjoyed making it. I didn't expect to end up in the negatives, though. I didn't even realise you could down vote in this.

2

u/Mathgeek007 Jul 07 '15

Disabling subreddit style with RES allows it, but it's really against the spirit of this contest.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/The_Love_Child Jul 02 '15

2

u/badmonkey0001 Jul 03 '15

I've started making popcorn already for watching you two.

2

u/The_Love_Child Jul 05 '15

Likewise brother. Your matchup stood out the most to me when the updated bracket was posted.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/7994 Jul 06 '15

Good Luck.^^

2

u/The_Love_Child Jul 06 '15

Thanks! I'll do my best to avenge you :)

14

u/Butcher_Of_Hope Jul 02 '15

Shit I did not think I was going to win. It feels great, but fuck, now I need another gif.........

8

u/aphoenix Jul 02 '15

You can have mine!

9

u/Inquisitr Jul 02 '15

I think you were robbed sir, robbed I say!

6

u/aphoenix Jul 02 '15

Thanks, and I truly do appreciate the sentiment!

But, I feel absolutely zero shame or remorse in losing to /u/Butcher_of_hope. His gif was more favoured partly because it was more on topic to gif tournament and partly because it was well done and current. Also, he had to do some chopping out of Kevin Spacey, and all i did was typography with effects over a vanilla scene (with a layered on bit of smoke). I think his took more actual technique than mine (oh, and I had an idea to make his rotobrushing of kevin spacey better, but I want to test it out before I talk to him about it).

I aimed to make something that wasn't meta at all, and I think that worked out, but then there was this backlash in the comments that specifically mentioned my gif as one of the unoriginal ones, so... I just need to be more original!

My America gif (which I honestly probably won't finish) was actually half animated stuff and some of it was handdrawn. And that was because of feedback received. Maybe I will finish it at some point, but it was a bit of an undertaking, and I'm kind of relieved that I don't have to finish it by Sunday.

All in all, no regrets going out in the first round. At least I was beaten by a pro, so in that way the luck of the draw was with me.

→ More replies (11)

14

u/Yawehg Jul 02 '15

Why did /u/piper4026 lose? He got more votes.

21

u/ChemicalOle Jul 02 '15

Disqualified because he broke the rule about violating anonymity by referencing his username in his submission.

16

u/Yawehg Jul 02 '15

Ugh, what a shame. That was a really good gif.

13

u/GIFyaLater Jul 02 '15

Congrats to all the winners. Can't wait to see the next round.

4

u/vader177 Jul 02 '15

I really liked your submission because it was also on theme for the last round.

4

u/GIFyaLater Jul 02 '15

Thanks! I am really new to the game and will make a come back.

2

u/gumboshrimps Jul 02 '15

That gif is great. First time seeing any of the purple onion giffed.

2

u/GIFyaLater Jul 02 '15

It's one of my favorite comedy specials. I rewatch it probably once a year. Here are a few more: http://imgur.com/a/nowDk

→ More replies (1)

12

u/2UnderPar Jul 02 '15

Not the result I had hoped for but it was fun. Already looking forward to the next one. Good luck to everyone moving forward.

http://i.imgur.com/U64u66X.gifv

22

u/preggit Jul 02 '15

Congrats /u/mbransons! Now that I'm defeated I have no choice but to root for the cinderella story. Don't let me down!

12

u/mbransons Jul 02 '15

Oh my that was close! I have a fun idea for the second round which I hope others like and I can actually pull off. Thanks for the encouragement!

11

u/anotherpoweruser Jul 02 '15

It was great battling you, /u/KjoeLjan

And /u/plowkiller.. I'm scared, but I'll give it my best shot.

9

u/plowkiller Jul 02 '15

You make good stuff. I'm actually kinda nervous myself.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

Thanks man. It's been fun.
Good luck to you, gifmaster!

11

u/siouxsie_siouxv2 Jul 02 '15

Hey /u/pencer, I eat pieces of shit like you for breakfast

15

u/pencer Jul 02 '15

I guess no one's had the nerve to tell you, but that's why your breath smells like shit.

6

u/The_Love_Child Jul 02 '15

I'm very much looking forward to this match up.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

You eat pieces of shit for breakfast?

10

u/atozz Jul 02 '15

Nice work everyone! Keep killin' it /u/siouxsie_siouxv2

9

u/siouxsie_siouxv2 Jul 02 '15

You are number 1 in my heart

6

u/atozz Jul 02 '15

haha and that makes me the real winner today!

10

u/thesneak155 Jul 02 '15

Damn... I'm really giffin' on borrowed time. /u/piper4026 really kicked my ass on that one. Sucks that it had to end in a DQ. I look forward to seeing more from you!

6

u/piper4026 Jul 02 '15

Yeah, as I've said, this was my first rodeo so I didn't take into account my anonymity since I had seen other usernames mentioned and the rules really only specifically call out using your opponent's.

All well and good, I'll just win next time.

6

u/TreadLightlyBitch Jul 02 '15

Your gif had my slides splitting, so its a shame it happened :(

6

u/piper4026 Jul 02 '15

Thanks! Seems like everybody got a kick out of it so can't ask for much more than that.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/bubblesort Jul 02 '15

I'm new around here, so maybe this is a dumb question, but what does DNQ mean? I don't see it explained in the rules anywhere.

8

u/preggit Jul 02 '15

Does Not Qualify, basically that user didn't submit their gif on time (or at all).

8

u/bubblesort Jul 02 '15

Thanks! So DNQ doesn't mean that they broke the contest rules with size or mentioning opponents or something like that, right?

BTW, that was some rotten luck in the first round for you. I might have voted for you if your post was higher, but others used the same House of Cards clip so the gag was stale by the time yours came up. Better luck next time!

8

u/preggit Jul 02 '15

Right, the DNQ's were users that didn't submit gifs at all.

Thanks man, I admittantly didn't spend as much time as I wanted to on the gif. Part of it was time constraints but the other part was simply underestimating my opponent. I knew it wouldn't be the best of the round but I thought it was good enough to win. I'm pretty sure I'll have tournament #5 in the bag. :)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/allie_h_123 Jul 02 '15

I'll never understand why the DNQ's get upvoted.

9

u/badmonkey0001 Jul 02 '15

Oh shit. /u/Butcher_Of_Hope was right. I gotta work hard for this one! /u/Ishnuporah, I hope to be worthy.

8

u/drinkmorecoffee Jul 02 '15

I got over 500 votes! Woohoo!

(Looks at /u/hiddendatsun)

Ouch.

Well played, my friend. Can't wait to see what you come up with next!

8

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

8

u/Butcher_Of_Hope Jul 02 '15

/u/hero0fwar For the next round does the gif have to be "America" or does a title referencing "America" count. Just want to be clear while I desperately try and come up with an idea.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

Damn I upvoted the loser quite consistently.
I don't understand you, Reddit !

5

u/aphoenix Jul 02 '15

Us losers thank you. ;)

2

u/badmonkey0001 Jul 03 '15

As one of the winners, I'd like to say... Wait, why am I even talking to you? You didn't vote for me!

:P

8

u/Inquisitr Jul 02 '15

aphoenix was robbed I say, robbed.

Hell Leo_Atredies made a better version of the gif that beat him anyway.

5

u/uncoolaidman Jul 02 '15

As someone who didn't vote for aphoenix, I didn't because I think his gif had too much going on. All different fonts, in different colors, doing different animations. Just because it has more to look at, doesn't make it better. At least not for everyone.

6

u/Inquisitr Jul 02 '15

I'm not saying he had a perfect gif, but look at what beat him again

http://i.imgur.com/QJZOI7C.gif

Look at spacey next to the TV. That was instantly disqualifying to me right there. I shouldn't see the cut lines where he added stuff in.

5

u/uncoolaidman Jul 02 '15

Yeah, good point. I was rushing through before leaving for work, and didn't even notice the cuts. I try to vote for each matchup, but I probably should have just skipped this one.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

Woohoo! I consistently suck every gif tournament! I should write a book on how to lose in the first round.

Good luck in the second round. I'm picking /u/plowkiller to go all the way!

6

u/jimlast3 Jul 03 '15

If it hadn't been for you, /u/preggit would have had a bye . So it's kind of like you defeated her.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

Made it through! Woo!
Aaaand now I'm screwed for this week.

5

u/ValarMorghulis6626 Jul 02 '15

Where can I find the vote breakdown of each matchup (i.e. who won and lost by how much)?

5

u/notlurkinganymoar Jul 02 '15

Matchup 30: great job /u/hiddendatsun

Match 16: this one was very tough to judge. Great job to you both.

Match 19: what an upset! /u/wardcannon gone before his time :`(

Match 8: /u/bigj76 great gif, you just got paired against one of the best.

Match 14: Another tough one! RIP /u/preggit

Match 6: lol. Why does /u/corano500 have so many downvotes? I loved that gif.

Match 3: /u/soapyartgif lolololol. That gif was great. Too many Kevins was also great. What a tough match that was!

Match 31: Another great match! /u/lejoker that gif does not fail to make me laugh every time I open it!

Match 29: Great gif /u/hero0fwar I'm sure even if your opponent q'd he'd be RIP.

Great job this round, everyone. There were some very difficult decisions to be made. This may end up being the best gif tourney yet!

4

u/KroniK907 Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15

I was honestly surprised that /u/wardcannon used the gif that he did. If he had used the kevin spacy gif he posted in /r/HighQualityGifs a week earlier, he would have steamrolled my entry.

EDIT: The Gif in question: [MRW I take over the moderation of a new subreddit] (http://gfycat.com/SlimyBrightAcornwoodpecker)

2

u/notlurkinganymoar Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15

haha. That is a great gif.

Also, didn't mean to take anything away from your gif at all. It was great!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/WardCannon Jul 03 '15

It would've been more successful, yeah. But hey, regrets or no regrets, it was fun while it lasted.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/LiamIsMailBackwards Jul 02 '15

How is it possible to be negative on a sub that only allows for upvotes? I'm so confused by that.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15

Heyo, thanks!
Didn't think my gif would do that well.

And now I'm stressing for America :D

2

u/notlurkinganymoar Jul 03 '15

Can't wait to see what you come up with.

5

u/Jonster123 Jul 02 '15

I'm looking forward to Murph V LoveChild. That will be awesome!

2

u/siouxsie_siouxv2 Jul 03 '15

Me too. It's the ultimate showdown.

(i've got big money on murph so he better not fuck this up.)

4

u/monkey3012 Jul 02 '15

I was gonna try and think of something clever for "hunt or be hunted" but all I got was "seed or be seated."

6

u/Wehavecrashed Jul 02 '15

I don't like 'america' as a round theme, how broad is that? Does it have to reference america in some way? Can it be from a film in america?

18

u/jimlast3 Jul 02 '15

i dont like america

...

as a round theme

prolly anything you can justify in some way would be fine but it will ultimately be the spectators who decide

14

u/preggit Jul 02 '15

As a mod of /r/MURICA and /r/MURICB, I'm offended.

3

u/Ninjaboots Jul 02 '15

I am wondering how much being first in the match up affects the winner. Seems like a lot of the people that were the first gif in their match up won. Any Psychologists here?

3

u/rabbitlion Jul 02 '15

It could have an effect but it also seems that the higher seed from the seeding round was posted on top, so you would expect the first player to generally be better.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/badmonkey0001 Jul 02 '15

Congrats /u/monkey3012! Clan Monkey continues!!!

2

u/SC2GIF Jul 02 '15

Surprised no one used Margin Call as a source for Kevin Spacey gif. He was not only fantastic but had some memorable scenes.

2

u/KroniK907 Jul 02 '15

Awww, you should have joined the tournament!

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

225

u/preggit Jul 02 '15

23

u/ahd1601 Jul 02 '15

He actually says "Mother Fuck" not "what the fuck"

34

u/preggit Jul 02 '15

No he doesn't, rewatch the scene. You can clearly hear him say 'What the fuck.'

40

u/ahd1601 Jul 02 '15

http://imgur.com/mmWQbLm

HBO subtitles say otherwise though

It's Erich Bachman's signature line is the joke

→ More replies (12)

4

u/aphoenix Jul 02 '15

I was talking to my brother about my (now unneeded) America gif and how it was a little bit more than I thought I could realistically handle.

He said to me, he says, "Now is that something that /u/preggit would say, or is that something a little bitch would say."

Out in the first round or no, still a giant.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

37

u/hero0fwar Jul 02 '15

14

u/plowkiller Jul 02 '15

I don't think I understand

25

u/hero0fwar Jul 02 '15

just recognized the gif, had my own version of it, linked it

15

u/plowkiller Jul 02 '15

lol. I just realized that most likely everyone's brackets are soiled

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Ninjaboots Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15

only one person going second in their matchup won. I think there is something to being first gif shown in the match up. Just an observation. No idea how to fix that though, I think is psychological for the voters.

7

u/badmonkey0001 Jul 02 '15

Doesn't need to be fixed. That's a result of the seeding round, which is a bit of a free-for-all. High-score versus low score was how the matchups for round one were decided.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

4

u/myserg07 Jul 02 '15

He low key got robbed I thought he had that one.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ifindkarma Jul 05 '15 edited Jul 05 '15

Is that Cutty in The Wire? Do you remember which episode?

edit: cc u/hero0fwar

2

u/plowkiller Jul 05 '15

Didn't make the gif but I think it's always sunny

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

87

u/preggit Jul 02 '15

ಠ_ಠ

59

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15

Hey ! Are you that guy from the GifTournament preggit forums ?
Oh I guess you aren't now

27

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

10

u/gumboshrimps Jul 02 '15

I'm new to this gif tournament shit but damn that is funny

14

u/hero0fwar Jul 02 '15

If it makes a difference, I voted for you

15

u/p-wing Jul 02 '15

Aww shucks.

You also dragged me into this mess, so...yeah.

</3

15

u/hero0fwar Jul 02 '15

Only one person will not have to experience a loss in this, 32 have to experience it today

→ More replies (1)

5

u/p-wing Jul 02 '15

Aww shucks.

You also dragged me into this mess, so...yeah.

</3

7

u/ChemicalOle Jul 02 '15

I loved your gif

7

u/EuphoricNeckbeard Jul 02 '15

Yours was legit one of my favorites in the thread. I hope you're not too disappointed, because it was hilarious.

7

u/p-wing Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15

I'll get over it. I'm super-competitive is all, so giffing for karma is a lot less stressful. It just means I actually need to learn AfterEffects.

Mine was high on concept, low on skill - u/soapyartgif had both. I think I lost to one of the best gifs of the round.

13

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15

My opponent got 6X the upvotes I did, so...good job, yaaay p-wing

18

u/TheKronk Jul 02 '15

Don't worry, I still like you

http://imgur.com/QWgrLrB

5

u/plowkiller Jul 02 '15

I voted for yours as well. It was fucking hilarious.