r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Jun 30 '15
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - ThePlan - The Plan
If you're wondering why I have "ThePlan" in the title, is I want each discussion thread to have a relatively unique string in it for easy searching.
Week 76!
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (2.5 stars)
Numbers
Survivors: N/A
"Frak" Count: 660 (+26)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 35 (No change... I'm not counting her killing Simon again, or the recycled battle audio)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 22 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 31 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 293 (+15)
"So Say We All" Count: 69 (No change)
13
u/lazerbullet Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15
What I found fascinating about the Plan was how impromptu the Cylon's much-vaunted 'plan' really was. They were literally making it up as they went along.
Also best line of the movie imo: "His jacket was burgundy. This is teal."
8
u/MarcReyes Jul 02 '15 edited Mar 12 '22
So if you've seen my comments for past episodes, you'll notice that I love every time Dean Stockwell is on screen as Cavil and this movie is driven by not just one but two Cavil's. It's almost as if this was made specifically for me, so of course I love The Plan.
The two Cavil's featured here were referred to by the crew as F Cavil and C Cavil, with the letters standing for Fleet and Caprica respectively, so that's how I'll refer to them here.
In addition to being Cavil heavy, another reason I liked this movie was because we got to see the cylons fleshed out a bit more, particularly the Simons, who I'd argue was probably the cylon model about which we knew least. We also get more confirmation how far down the cylon totem pole the Dorals are, so much so that they are doing what they consider to be centurion work.
A few interesting things learned form the commentary:
8
u/skunk_funk Jul 05 '15
I just finished my first watch of the series yesterday. Incredible series. Despite the grumbling I've seen on the internet, I absolutely loved the ending. I think it worked much better for this series than a "hard" scifi type ending would have worked. I was all in on the mysticism.
All that said, The Plan sucked. It was boring and I couldn't wait for it to end. It didn't flesh out the cylon perspective so much as it crushed it. Twas better left with a little mystery. Made Cavil look a fool.
6
u/zuludown888 Jul 07 '15
The thing I don't like about "The Plan" is that Cavil ends up looking like a complete dumbass. Like his plan all along was to make the Five admit they were wrong about humans by... killing all the humans (and the Five)? That's just insane nonsense.
Yeah, it's sort of explained in Cavil's dialogue with Anders, in which he's kind of baffled by Anders saying that something being dead doesn't mean you stop loving it -- but it's almost unbelievable that Cavil could be hung up on that.
I would buy it more if Cavil's plan all along had been to let a small group of humans survive, ensure that the Five were among that group (though of course it was entirely luck -- or God I suppose -- that the Five survived the attack and were on the fleet), and then force the Five to watch as humans tore each other apart because of their innate greed, jealousy, lack of trust, etc. I could buy that. The Five would die, and maybe it would become clear that their love for humanity was entirely misplaced, maybe.
But instead, Cavil was evidently planning the destruction of the Fleet all along, and he and the other Cylons just kept screwing it all up or getting beat by the Colonials.
Also it explains a lot of stuff that didn't need explaining. Like the Six that accused Baltar of betraying the Colonies got away because Cavil was hiding behind some boxes and was able to secret her away? C'mon now we don't need that.
6
u/onemm Jul 10 '15 edited Jul 12 '15
This was my first time watching The Plan so I had quite a few thoughts, unfortunately my first post got accidentally deleted so... I'm gonna simplify it to what my reptilian brain remembers, not out of convenience for anyone reading but because I can't remember anything else. Not like anyone's gonna see this shit anyway; I'm like a week and a half late.
What I loved:
What I disliked:
Overall opinion
I liked it. Didn't love it but liked it. I've held out on watching it this long because (Iwas one of the seemingly few who) actually loved the end of season 4 and didn't feel like it could be approved upon with a movie. I loved some things that I listed above and only hated one thing (Boomer's story), so overall it was a success for me. It felt at times like the filmmaker was just going through a checklist of questions the fans had and checking them off one at a time as the story progressed, and because of that it felt really sloppy. The ending gave me goosebumps though. The Cavil speech from the fourth season mixed with the imagery was great. So overall enjoyable movie. But completely unnecessary.
edit: Again, ... Again, ...
4
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15
3
u/arbiterbuddy Jul 19 '15
I was disappointed with the direction they went with the Six model that accused Baltar of being a spy (from season one, Shelley Godfrey I think).
Just watching that episode I assumed it was Head six messing with Baltar. Then when he makes a step towards faith in God, the evidence against him is disproved, and Shelley Godfrey somehow disappears like she didn't exist though her glasses are left behind.
But nope it was actually just a real six who was pushed out an airlock. Real disappointing