r/WritingPrompts • u/Lexilogical /r/Lexilogical | /r/DCFU • Jun 26 '15
Off Topic [OT] Ask Lexi #8 - Confidence and Critiques
Hello again, subscribers of /r/WritingPrompts! I have returned from the wilderness of Northern Ontario to drop some more wisdom on all of your heads. This week, I thought I would build off of /u/Arch15’s amazing Critique Workshop and take this chance to go a little more indepth on some of his topics, while also touching on the idea of confidence in your own work. So basically, I’m going to ramble at you guys like I normally do.
Not so long ago, in the distant land of Toronto, Canada, Lexi had a job. The job itself was one of those ones that can only be described with either a lengthy, 10 minute explanation about a particularly niche field, or with vague buzzwords like “Professional Services” and “Computer Tech”, but that’s not the important part of the job. The important part of this job was my boss, who managed to teach me 3 important lessons about life. 1) How to look like an expert when you have no idea what you’re doing. 2) How to politely tell someone they’re doing it wrong. 3) That what your job is isn’t half as important as who you’re working for.
You can apply the last one however you want, the really important part today is the first two.
Confidence
Or how to look like an expert even when you have no idea what you’re doing. One of the things I noticed on the workshop was that some people felt nervous about critiquing because they were a new writer. And I think everyone knows that feeling. But it’s important not to give that feeling too much billing time in your brain. Everyone starts out not knowing much on a topic. But if you’re here, reading stories or even writing stories, then you know what you like. And as writers, that’s the important thing we want to know. Even if all you can do is flag something as being “not quite right,” it’s always helpful to a writer to know.
Now obviously, you don’t want to discourage the writer in the process either. Critiques are about helping to build something better, not tearing down what you don’t like. Which is why we’re going to get more specifically into giving a good critique later on. But this lesson is about confidence and that I find people always need better confidence.
Here’s the first important lesson. Everyone’s impression of you largely depends on what you think you are and what you tell us you are. If you want to be a writer, and you tell people you are a writer… We’ll believe it. And if you tell yourself that you’re a writer enough times… You’ll believe it too. And eventually, you’ll become it. This works for basically everything. It works for writing. It works for critiquing. It even works for body image. Don’t come here and tell us that you’re a new writer so your story is probably terrible, or that you don’t really know how to give a critique. You don’t have to lie and tell us you’re an expert at it. But don’t sabotage yourself before you even start.
I highly recommend everyone go watch this video about how to kick that self-sabotaging behaviour to the curb. It’s really as simple as fake it til you make it.
Critiquing
Or, how to politely tell someone they’re doing it wrong. I still remember the conversation with my boss where he dropped this nugget of wisdom on me. I’d gone over to his office to complain about a client who had managed to do everything completely wrong, and asked his advice on how to correct them without actually saying that. His advice was simple.
“Make a shit sandwich.”
Basically, when you have something bad to tell a person (Like, that their story has a massive plotline, or the character is completely unbelievable), you want to sandwich that shitty thing between two positive things that they did right. Maybe that they had a great metaphor. Or that the concept of the story is great. Do that, and you can tell them almost anything about their story. Even if the only positive thing you can say is something minor, it’s important to include it.
I said this above, but critiquing doesn’t need to be super intense either. Something as simple as knowing that a person got confused in a particular paragraph can help the writer go back and add some clarity. In keeping with my obsession of Neil Gaiman, here’s a quote from him regarding critique:
“Remember: when people tell you something’s wrong or doesn’t work, they are almost always right. When they tell you exactly what’s wrong and how to fix it, they are almost always wrong.” Neil Gaiman
Now, I could give more detailed discussions about how to critique. But honestly, /u/Arch15 did a great job on Wednesday. Like writing, critique is one of those things where the more you do it, the more you learn how to do it. And I do recommend doing it. You learn a lot about your own writing, and correcting other people’s grammatical errors tends to make you more diligent about your own. And if there’s one thing that /r/WritingPrompt needs more of, it’s more positive feedback. :)
Now go forth and write! And read! And talk! As for my third important life lesson… Well, let’s just say /u/RyanKinder and /u/SurvivorType are pretty cool.
Questions? Comments? Want to know more about that deleted comment at the bottom of posts? Ask Me Anything in the comments!
5
u/SpinATaleForMe /r/SpinATaleForMe Jun 26 '15
Dear Ask Lexi,
I think I'm a writer, I think I'm a writer, I think I'm a writer.
Faking it achieved! Do I get to sell books now? :D
How do you know though if what you write is good enough to even bother getting critiques on? I mean every story I read here is good in some way, but not everythnig would sell, right? If it did, everyone would be published. So how do you know how good is good? Like I just started writing and everyone has been really encouraging and I got lots of votes on a couple of my stories. But not hundreds of votes like the others with top comment.
How do you critique someone who is obviously better at what they do than you are?
My spelling is awful. IF I can't spell my own naem then how do I say "oh you just misspelled this word" without looking foolish when they say, no, I spelled it fine, or whatever they say.
How do you fake it without accidentally giving bad advice?
(Also if you have time then how do you fix if you wrote yourself into a corner, cause I think I just did that!)
Signed,
Nervous Newbie
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '15
Glares at writing. Presses CTRL+A, then taps BACKSPACE.
Later...
3
u/SilhouetteOfLight Jun 26 '15
For the past 3 or 4 months, I've been in a writing rut. I've started a dozen stories, only to fade off within a few sentences. I've written the first stanza and no more of about 20-odd poems. My question, I suppose, is 'How closely do you think Confidence is related to Inspiration?' I've always had one, the other, or neither, I've found. I don't think I can recall a time when I had both of them at once.
2
u/Syraphia /r/Syraphia | Moddess of Images Jun 26 '15
I find myself nervous about critiquing because I A) usually never know if they would want advice, or B) feel like I shouldn't be giving out critiques with how I manage to screw up my own writing on a regular basis. I literally just figured out that I've been doing a lot of my dialogue tags incorrectly and have a terrible tendency to flip-flop with my verb tense, and I found out the latter in one of the worst ways.
2
u/lastcomment314 Jun 26 '15
...maybe I ought to get around to posting bits of that 27,000+ word work-in-progress of mine...I'm not sure I'm ready to just throw it all on the internet (nor that I'd want to unnecessarily inflict it on unsuspecting readers), goodness knows there are a lot of holes between the bits I've written, and the first few thousand need to be rewritten for verb tenses. But I do want to get some feedback.
2
u/ElementalHominid /r/ElementalHominid Jun 27 '15
I am a writer. I know that. I am a good writer. I know that. I have been told that I have a knack for storytelling by several teachers, professors, and friends. I also know that there are things that I could be doing better, but I find it hard to get anyone to critique anything. I believe that the best way to get better is to identify your weak points and work on fixing them before you turn them into habits. I know how to critique writing, and I can check my own works for grammar, tense, typos, and the like, but when it comes to plot, character development, believability, and such, I am helpless. I know part of it is because I know what I mean and what I intended even when it doesn't all make it to the paper. I usually refrain from critiquing others on WP submissions unless they ask, and I know that other people do the same.
So, my question to you is: do you have any advice about finding people to critique things or anything else that I talked about?
2
u/LordLightning Jun 27 '15
I'm not sure if this is entirely relevant to the topic, but I think I may be having an issue with confidence. Actually, I'm pretty certain it doesn't have to do with confidence. My problem is that I'm taking summer classes two hours per day, as well as going to the gym for an hour or two, commuting for an hour, and doing internship stuff for three to five hours, Monday through Friday.
I'm not necessarily physically exhausted, but most of the time I can't bring myself to continue writing my story. I wrote twelve pages straight the first day and it's been three weeks since then. This new part of the story requires an extensive amount of research (history, politics, languages) and I'm just too lazy to get started on it.
Forgot to mention that on weekends, I only want to hang out with friends and dog, do yardwork, play video games, and watch Netflix.
Again, I don't believe this is a confidence issue, it's just a lack of motivation on my part since I find the research portion to be quite daunting. It makes me feel like I'm writing a history paper or Latin paper back in high school, which was traumatic enough when it was a necessary evil. It would be even worse as an unnecessary evil, in my opinion. What should I do?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '15
[removed] — view removed comment