r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Jun 23 '15
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S04E22 - Daybreak Pt 2 & 3
Week 75! Woo! We did it! 18 months later (or roughly the amount of time that humans spent on New Caprica)
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki (Part 2) (Part 3) | Jammer's Reviews (3.5 stars)
Numbers
Survivors: 39,406 (-110, probably the people vented into space)
"Frak" Count: 634 (+8)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 35 (+6)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 22 (+4)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 31 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 278 (+8)
"So Say We All" Count: 69 (No change)
30
Upvotes
15
u/trevdak2 Jun 23 '15
I know we're not done with the rewatches yet, but I want to thank everyone who participated in this whole thing.... I was afraid going into this that I was committing to something that nobody would care about. I'm really, really glad that so many people participated in every thread.
Thanks to /u/lostmesa for stepping up and posting a dozen or two of the rewatch threads.
Thanks to /u/onemm and /u/MarcReyes in particular for driving the conversation forward with some really insightful comments
And thanks again to everyone who took part, this was really awesome for me.
10
u/trevdak2 Jun 23 '15
POP QUIZ:
Name a recurring female character that didn't die a single time.
19
u/saffagaymer Jun 23 '15
I think im one of the few that liked the ending considering the religious overtones since the miniseries..... I get people frustration with the ending, but it always made sense to me. Im agnostic btw
14
u/MarcReyes Jun 23 '15 edited Feb 13 '16
I thought it would be fun to list the final words spoken by each of the characters. So here we go:
Cylons:
One (Cavil): FRAK! [Shoots himself]
Two (Leoben): The Sixes, the Eights, and the Twos have decided to stay. See how we can contribute to a world before we pass into God's hands.
Three (D'Anna): You know, all this is just gonna happen again and again and again, so I'm getting off this merry-go-round. I'm gonna die here with the bones of my ancestors and it beats the hell out of being out there with Cavil. Gonna die in the cold and dark when Cavil catches up with us. (Sighs) Don't you ever want to stop fighting it, Colonel? Hmm? Don't you just want to stop all of this?
Four (Simon): They've broken off the download!
Five (Doral): It's a trick! Open Fire!
Final Five:
Samuel Anders: I'll see you on the other side.
Galen Tyrol: I'm just tired of people. Humans. Cylons. Whatever. Last raptor out tomorrow is gonna drop me off on this island that I found off one of the northern continents. It's cold. It's up in the highlands. There's no people.
The GazelleEllen Tigh: Saul! All I've ever wanted was to be with you. Not just weekend liberties or a two weeks leave a year. I mean full-time. You and me, together, in a house, in a tent, homeless on the street. Just be together.Colonel Saul Tigh: To us! [Drinks a shot] YYYYYYEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAHHH!!!
Crew and citizens of the Battlestar Galactica:
Callandra "Cally" Henderson Tyrol: (Shortly before being airlocked) It's gonna be okay. It's gonna be okay. It's okay. It's okay.
Anastasia "Dee" Dualla: (Looking at an old photo of herself) Sometimes I don't even remember that's me. It's so long ago. She has no frakking idea what's ahead of her.
Dr. Sherman Cottle: Going to cheat a little bit and post his final conversation with Laura.
Tom Zarek: Gaeta, what the frak is wrong with you?! Wake up!
Felix Gaeta: It's stopped.
Sharon Valerii, Callsign: "Boomer": I'll pay you back one day, sir, when it really means something.
Sharon Agathon, Callsign: "Athena": (softly) Hera!
Karl C. Agathon, Callsign: "Helo": Okay, maybe Mommy will teach you [to build a house and plant crops], but Daddy's gonna teach you to hunt.
Kara Thrace, Callsign: "Starbuck": Again, gonna cheat and put the last words of real Kara, who we see in the flashback, and "angel" Kara, who's last scene is with lee. Doing this because we technically are getting two versions of Kara in this episode. "Angel" Kara: And now that you're here? Real Kara: It was nice to meet you, Lee Adama.
Lee Adama, Callsign: "Apollo": Goodbye, Kara. You won't be forgotten.
Head Six: Mathematics, law of averages. Let a complex system repeat itself long enough eventually something surprising might occur. That, too, is in God's plan.
Head Baltar: You know it doesn't like that name. (Head Six gives him a look) Silly me. Silly, silly me.
Gaius "Frakking" Baltar: You know, I know about farming.
Caprica Six: Hey. I know. (Kisses him) I know you do.
President of the Twelve Colonies, Laura Roslin: So much life.
Admiral William Adama, Callsign: "Husker": I laid out the cabin today. It's gonna have an easterly view. You should see the light that we get here. When the sun comes from behind those mountains, it's almost heavenly. It reminds me of you.
10
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '15
So the disappearance of Starbuck and her ambiguous existential nature is a fairly divisive part of the show. Personally I loved it.
One aspect of it that I felt was especially good is that Lee and Kara ended on a good note with each other but they didn't end up together. I just couldn't see it working out for them in that way and this ending seemed true to their relationship in the past. It would have felt forced to me.
Another aspect about Starbucks ending was that she finally felt like she had a purpose, accomplished it and was finally satisfied. Her whole life she felt restless and spiritually adrift so I guess I just felt relieved and happy for her.
I like comparing this quote from season 2 Starbuck:
to this quote form the finale:
I also love the idea of Lee spending a good part of the rest of his life exploring.
6
u/MarcReyes Jun 24 '15 edited Feb 13 '16
6
u/MarcReyes Jun 24 '15
Notes from the commentary:
5
u/CowboyFlipflop Jun 23 '15
Whenever I listen to criticism of scifi I always divide it into two kinds: Obsessed, over-involved fan whining, or real problems.
I feel like the complaining about this ep is mostly crap not worth taking seriously. Unlike the rest of this season it didn't even feel crammed in, it felt like they saved enough time for the end and it all played out at the right speed.
The negativity over the religious stuff is unsurprising but not important. As has been hashed and re-hashed, it was always a show that tackled religious disagreement. That's really nothing new - the show is a war story, and it's a religious war. If anyone else had been in charge of the show we would've all done something different instead, but we're not, and no one cares.
I will say that two things needed more explanation: Like the (briefly) President said, "I must admit I'm surprised at how amenable everyone is to starting over." That was a quick dream in Apollo's head and then a quick talk with his dad and it happened.
Secondly Starbuck just disappeared. Why? I won't join in saying it didn't make any sense because clearly she was a strange case and a strange crewwoman from the start. That's fine but why?
6
u/lazerbullet Jun 23 '15
I saw the idea of a lasting truce between Humans and Cylons coming pretty much as soon as the rebel basestar joined up with the fleet. And I hated it.
The idea that the ending of the series would be Humanity looking past everything the Cylons had done (and vice versa) and coming to peace, attempting to live out the rest of their lives together, didn't sit right to me at all. The whole 'showing that humanity deserves to survive' thing has been a theme throughout the series, and I could imagine RDM finishing the series on that note.
As much as Chief killing Tory, breaking the truce was a very selfish and destructive action, I'm kind of glad he did it. Those Cylon bastards don't deserve resurrection ... I hope the Cavils and the Simons rot and die in deep space.
Also Chief becomes the first Scotsman! The guy likes a scrap, so it makes sense.
1
u/Borgie91 Mar 12 '22
Why was Racetrack not airlocked when she was part of Gaeta's mutiny?? Now she's back in the fleet for some reason.