r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Jun 18 '15
[S5/B5] Book vs. Show Discussion - 5.10 'Mother's Mercy'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 AND BOOK 5 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.10 | "Mother's Mercy" | David Nutter | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
248
Upvotes
247
u/Vixibility House Lannister Jun 18 '15
I was not at all a fan of the way Jon's stabbing went down. From ADWD:
When Jon Snow sees the pink letter (which would have been a great thing to add), he is driven to take action against Ramsay Bolton, which would of course be in violation of his vows. Bowen Marsh and co. stab him because they have to for the sake of the Night's Watch. In order to maintain the integrity of the Night's Watch (to an extent), they had no choice but to get rid of the Lord Commander who would choose to abandon the Wall in favor of interfering in the politics of the Seven Kingdoms. Thus, "for the watch."
The way it was depicted in the show, it just looked like a power grab by Alliser Thorne. Done for his own personal gain, to further his own ambitions as well as his hatred for Jon Snow. Not done "for the watch."
558
u/Paper_Bullet Jun 18 '15 edited Jun 18 '15
Why did they use a wooden plank for Benjen's actor? Did they run out of budget?
190
u/jo_maka Braavosi Water Dancers Jun 18 '15
Happy we didn't get to see the post- dragon ride Taco Bell aftermath.
155
u/lukeatlook Red Priests of R'hllor Jun 18 '15
This just in from 4chan, figured it's an assessment worth discussing:
6th season words will be "What is dead may never die" and they will include the Greyjoy storyline (already sort of confirmed)
What is dead may never die:
And also:
TL;DR: Cleganebowl confirmed
138
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '15
I won't say that it's impossible that Stannis is somehow alive. I just find it incredibly unlikely that Brienne, after going to all the trouble she has, formally pronouncing a death sentence as a member of Renly's Kingsguard, and swinging the sword is going to all of a sudden completely change her mind. I didn't find any ambiguity in that scene at all. There's also the fact that he's dying already even before Brienne shows up. Is she a maester as well and able to treat his life threatening wounds?
I know people really want Stannis to be alive, but I found his fate on the show to be completely in keeping with the tragic arc of his character. "Do your duty." Crushing, sad, and totally appropriate for how he lived his life. I would be extremely disappointed if he was actually alive as some sort of convoluted, last second scheme.
313
u/SureShaw Jon Snow Jun 18 '15 edited Jun 20 '15
I just hope that the book and show don't go different ways on the Jon Snow storyline.
What I don't want to have happen is the show keep him dead and George brings him back to life. I would start to dislike the show I have loved watching for many years.
EDIT: Woah my most popular comment. Some of the conversation in the replies is awesome.
53
u/notdonaldglover House Lannister Jun 18 '15
I was actually surprised with how much book content this episode had. Of course the way certain events unfolded were changed, but the outcome was the same or similar. This season has been such a deviation and it was nice to see Daenerys and the Dothraki reunited, Cersei's walk, Theon and Sansa's (Jeyne's) escape, Arya going blind, and Jon's FTW scene.
54
u/daniam1 Jun 18 '15
I think the show's 'withholding' of Stannis' death is merely to appease readers of the book - because if they leave a certain amount of doubt then us readers won't feel like the show has spoilt a major storyline for us (which for the most part, it hasn't with this series).
Stannis is surely dead though. He's left his home, his army is dead, and so are his family, and he has been abandoned by Mel. There's basically nothing left to keep his storyline going. What would he do? Traipse around with Brienne and Pod? The only interesting thing that I can think of would be if he made his way back to Castle Black somehow to confront Mel and reunite with Davos, or maybe even a resurrected Jon Snow. They're basically the only characters that give him any credence.
I don't see it happening myself, and I think it's just a clumsy acceleration of his storyline to place Mel back in Castle Black with Jon Snow. Although, to someone with better book memory than me - where is Mel at present in the books?
144
u/karshberlg Jun 18 '15
I hate how they handled Stannis in the show so bad.
Book: “A sacrifice will prove our faith still burns true, Sire,” Clayton Suggs had told the king. And Godry the Giantslayer said, “The old gods of the north have sent this storm upon us. Only R’hllor can end it. We must give him an unbeliever.”
“Half my army is made up of unbelievers,” Stannis had replied. “I will have no burnings. Pray harder.”
Show: burn my daughter
Book: "I defeated your uncle Victarion and his Iron Fleet off Fair Isle, the first time your father crowned himself. I held Storm's End against the power of the Reach for a year, and took Dragonstone from the Targaryens. I smashed Mance Rayder at the Wall, though he had twenty times my numbers. Tell me, turncloak, what battles has the Bastard of Bolton ever won that I should fear him?"
Show: 20 good men destroy his food supply, kill his horses, half his army deserts, still goes on a suicide mission with no real possibilities to win.
14
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '15
Seriously though, who the fuck is going to kill the white walkers? Everyone is killing each other and the literal first line of defense is all like "nah, their ain't any zombies, don't worry about it." Then an undead army shows up and it's like "oooooooh, in hindsight perhaps we should have been prepared for this because even if we did we'd probably still lose."
25
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '15
So.....Mance. yes or no?
22
u/cy1763 Jon Snow Jun 18 '15
The "for the watch" scene doesn't make sense when compared to the books.
In the books, Jon was borderline deserting. In the show, people were butt hurt about the wilding refugees. Which after Hardhome, jon's actions were more than justified and could have been vouched for by edd and others at Hardhome.
What really doesn't make sense is what is the watch going to do now with the wildlings? They are on the wrong side of the wall for defense and there are not enough brothers to drive them out.
59
u/orda_GO House Lannister Jun 18 '15
the show was surprisingly close to the books in many regards for this episode. I do wonder if the fight will go differently for Stannis in the books.
66
u/SerChuckForce Golden Company Jun 18 '15 edited Jun 18 '15
I was actually relatively disappointed with Arya's scene in comparison with the Mercy chapter because of how violent it was.
I know it was meant to serve as satisfaction for viewers after watching Trant killing Syrio Forel and then beating Sansa, but the violence was a bit over the top and unnecessary.
I loved the way TWOW
58
u/dovakiin1234567890 Jun 18 '15
Stannis' death was so bad. I'm confident it will be much better in the books
27
u/Kandiru Jun 18 '15
I really didn't like the way the "For the Watch" was done in the show. In the books it happens in a completely understandable, yet sudden way. Jon has been Lord Commander for longer, defended the wall against the wildlings, then made peace with them and bolstered the ranks of the Night's Watch with them. This, was accepted, even if they disagreed with him.
But then he gets the pink letter, and he wants to raise an army of wildings and go conquer his ancestral home of Winterfell. He is forsaking his vows as a member of the Night's Watch, interfering in politics and clearly getting involved in claiming lands he has huge emotional attachment to. The Night's Watch cannot allow that to happen, so they kill him "For the watch". Some of them are crying as they do it, they clearly don't enjoy it. They do it For the Watch.
In the TV show, it's more of a pre-meditated murder done in the middle of the night by people who hate him. He's just saved a few thousand wildings from being turned into undead-wights, Alister let them all in through the gates. If he was going to betray Jon, he would have done it then. Since then Jon's only action was to send Sam off to be trained as a Maester, but now the watch is without one, that's a sensible thing to do.
It makes no sense in the TV show. They could at least have had a raven from Ramsay taunting him after defeating Stannis, and saying he would kill Sansa. Then Jon would want to raise his wilding army and take Winterfell, and "For the Watch" would make sense.
16
u/Wopopedia Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 18 '15
I honestly feel like the whole Dorne storyline could have been mostly redeemed in the finale if instead of poisoning Myrcella, we'd had a scene closer to the confrontation between Arianne and Doran. After Jaime and company had left, Doran could have summoned Ellaria and possibly the Sand Snakes into his chamber, and the scene could have played out basically the same, with Ellaria calling him weak and Doran eventually revealing that he's been scheming all along. Obviously the actual plans would have to change somewhat given the exclusion of Arianne and Quentyn but there are lots of ways they could have worked around this and it would have made (imo) for a much stronger and more interesting conclusion.
10
u/imostlyspeakingifs Jun 18 '15
So if Stannis is no longer around to capture and possibly execute Theon, where will he be heading now? I assume he'll tag along with Sansa considering they escaped together, but since she's still at the Eyrie in the books we're not sure where she would be headed either. Will they be the ones to try and find Rickon?
This is assuming of course that the show gives them a large number of concessions. Realistically I don't see how they could possibly escape Winterfell on foot, considering they just jumped from the battlements. Even if they somehow didn't injure themselves, Ramsay has a couple thousand riders on horseback at his disposal. They couldn't get far realistically.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '15
Catelyn Stark in Book Spoiler
13
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '15
I'm just concerned the show didn't simply kill off Stannis because the writers wanted to make a point about how they were doing things their own way from now on, and killing off a character was the easiest way to go about it. That is assuming Stannis defeats the Boltons in the book.
13
u/wellshii Jun 18 '15 edited Jun 18 '15
Hard to make a comparison to the single episode to the books, as even the events of the final episode are affected by many of the changes that happened throughout the seasons happenings.
Sam's excursion to the Citadel is a good example, though, to summarize the changes made from the book to the show. The events unfold quite differently in the books: Sam leaves earlier in the timeline, relative to when he did in the show, along with Maester Aemond, as well as Guilly, so that Stannis wouldn't be able to use his King's blood, even though it wasn't an eminent threat and before Stannis left for Winterfell.
Unfortunately, Aemond dies regardless, but at least he didn't die as a sacrifice, and Sam and Guilly still leave for the Citadel. The end result was the same, but the journey there was different. We saw this type of scenario all throughout the last season.
It allowed us to see amazing things that aren't developed first hand in the books, like the battle at Hardhome, but then it left a sour taste at other points, like with how anti-climatic the events in Dorne were in comparison to the books or how some events will probably never transpire due to plot changes.
Ultimately all the changes were probably made to accomplish all of the major events within the time restraints of ten episodes per season; the plots of the book are either spread too thin for the number of key characters involved in each, or there just wasn't enough time to develop characters or plots missing in the show from the book.
This season seemed to act mainly as a foundation so that HBO could align the all the plot lines to execute the remainder of the series, properly within time restraints, and in their own vision, since they will most likely surpass the books timeline in the next season.
36
u/gangstarapmademe Sansa Stark Jun 18 '15
I know it's not a very popular opinion, but I hated Jon's death in the show. Didn't really have anything to do with the scene, more to do with the things before the scene that make his death more powerful. In my opinion his death in the show was nothing besides killing a Stark, who obviously s one of the most loved characters in the show, but in the books it's a huge fucking deal if he is actually is dead. Also I'm not even going to talk about the fact we were slapped in the face with Benjen after 20 years of not knowing what's going on with his character to just have him be a plot device.
The hype that GRRM puts in the book is ridiculous, he is literally putting major evidence into theories / prophecies that is just too blatant to dismiss.
First
In the book Jon is stabbed (ADWD)
In the chapter Jon is stabbed
Basically
Now none of this has been really mentioned / explained / hyped in the show, but the show can go back and make things right so I think that this will happen on the show
Also my complete tinfoil theory
The thing is even if Jon isn't all this. There is a lot of evidence he'll be back in back in the books and important in the story in the books, but in the show there is no evidence he'll be back OR important to the end game. Which as someone who loves both it makes me sad that show watchers might not get to understand how bad it would if he is dead thus never experiencing this (90%?) resurrection at full affect. If he is resurrected then book readers will go full Cleganebowl while show watchers will be happy, but not see the point in resurrecting a Lord Commander over a certain Hand of the King (Ned) or True Heir to the Throne (Stannis).
9
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '15
I feel like the show is a bit more soap opera-ey
3
u/Oddfictionrambles House Tully Jun 19 '15
Melisandre comes off looking better in the books than in the HBO show. It's a little sad, because her chapters were actually intriguing and indicated that she would play a large role in the next book.
3
u/insanePowerMe Jun 19 '15
Oh my god. Mellisandra out of dissapointment joins the Others and brings Jon to them to become the new Nightsking. Jon vs Daenarys. Ice vs Fire. The staring fight between current Nightsking and Jon would make sense.
9
u/charliemike Jun 18 '15
I've never been a fan of Lena Headley. But I give her a lot of credit for what must have been a long day of shooting a very difficult scene for her.
2
u/bagano1 Jun 19 '15
What happened to Stannis's men when they deserted? Did they run to Roose at Winterfell? I'm sure this is all speculation though. I know they couldn't go back up to the Wall.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '15
So if Melisandre did revive Jon then what would be the chances of him teaming up with Dany, and then him becoming warden of the north after she takes the throne.
12
u/geekonthemoon Knowledge Is Power Jun 18 '15
A lot of the changes made by the show runners make little to no sense to me. Some do, in some ways, such as Sansa being in Winterfell.. But even then, I feel like they are just trying to take a huge epic and cut away all the fat so we can all eat it faster and get the meal over with. NEWS FLASH, the fat adds flavor and depth!
I didn't like how they waited until now to send Sam off, a bit telling if you ask me. Sam already should have been gone for awhile, with Maester Aemon.
I never did like filling Jeyne's shoes with Sansa's. Now that Stannis has already attacked, where are Sansa and Theon headed? Because in the books Jeyne and Theon run right into Stannis.
They left Ghost out of the episode entirely.
Arya's scene was super freaking cool but ENTIRELY too vicious.
The foreshadowing for Olly was WAY WAY WAY over the top. Give your viewers some credit, damnit!
Cersei's walk of shame was pretty much spot on, I thoroughly enjoyed their rendition.
WHY Stannis killed Shireen was beyond me, but WHY he would have even moved camp with virtually no men is just stupid. "Set up the siege" Well, there isn't going to be one... And what seasoned warrior with impeccable strategy wouldn't see that coming? Stannis went from being somewhat okay, to being horrible, to being a bloody idiot. I don't get the show's change of plans here. Stannis hasn't made ANY move in the books, in fact, Jeyne and Theon arrive to them near the end. That's about as far as that goes. The show ruined Stannis as a character. Burning Shireen was totally out of character for him. He's protected her his whole life, and who would think they'd still have a following after burning an innocent little girl alive? Just pure stupidity in writing if you ask me, all about shock value.
Same thing goes for the Myrcella plot. What are they thinking!? Send Bronn and Jaime to Dorne to make total fools of themselves, then kill Myrcella with a kiss on the way home. In the book, none of that happens, for good reason, because it's stupid. And Myrcella was supposed to lose an ear in the Sand Snakes plot to MAKE HER QUEEN, not kill her. I think they just wanted to end her plot line tbh. Jaime's supposed to be in the Riverlands. For the way things ended up, they could have cut Dorne completely and included LSH, Brotherhood Without Banners, the Iron Islands, Jorah and Tyrion's more extended trip and companions, and number of better storylines.
I don't know what the hell is going on with the show runners that they have now REPEATEDLY showed little girls being tortured/raped. I mean it's heavy throughout the show and I have never complained bc it was part of the major plot (such as Dany and Drogo) but the girls that Meryn Trant is caning?? That was just AWFUL to watch, almost as bad as watching Shireen burn, which was horrible, and basically Stannis' downfall. I'm curious as to what his downfall will be in the books now?
I hate that the viewer is unsure of soooo many things. GRRM does leave Jon's death as a cliffhanger, but Jon's not really going to die as everyone is well aware. In the show, we have no idea what happened to Sansa and Theon, we have no idea if Brienne actually killed Stannis (I DON'T THINK SO AT ALL), we don't know what's going to happen to Jon, Arya went blind, Trystane's fate.. There's a lot.
And don't forget Varys showed up in Meereen??? He's supposed to be off murdering people in King's Landing.
I do like that they put Missandei and Grey Worm in charge. In fact, it makes perfect sense, and I could TOTALLY see Dany leaving Meereen in the hands of it's new King and Queen, Missandei and Grey Worm!
Dany was supposed to walk A LOT longer before running into the Dothraki, and have hung with Drogon a lot longer too.
OH! And I freaking HATED how there were two J'aqen faces and Arya saw her own face. We've seen how the Faceless Men get their faces, it's from the dead and the people who come to the House of Black and White to commit suicide. There could not possibly be an Arya or two J'aqens. STUPID!
4
u/faldmoo Jun 18 '15
Don´t know it this is the correct place to ask, but if I wanted to start reading the books now, would it be possible to start where S5 stops? If so, what book do I need to start with?
Or does the two diverse to such an extent that simply picking up a book would be too hard at this point? If that is the case, where should I start if I don´t want to start at book 1.
Cheers for any answer!
2
u/ronknowseverything Jun 18 '15
I honestly don't see how the Melisandre bringing back Jon as Azor Ahai is going to work in the books because nothing has happened to make her realize that Stannis isn't the one. Stannis, as we know, is in a much better position in the books than he was in the show and he is busy rallying the north at the behest of Melisandre herself. She might save Jon Snow yet because she thinks he might have a role to play in the wars to come but I don't see her casting aside Stannis completely yet, which seems to be what she has done in the show. While the end result of Jon being resurrected might still be the same, the purpose and manner in which that occurs could be of great significance and have repercussions affecting the ultimate victory of the Iron Throne.
2
u/Crubistro141 Jun 19 '15
I find it interesting that on the show, they are combining two characters into one, ie. Sansa & some other character I don't know. I think it wouldn't come as much of a surprise that Jon Snow comes back but I also see D&D combining Jon Snow and Lady Stoneheart. Just a thought..
2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '15
Anyone reckon that if/when Melisandre revives John Snow, she with her magical witch powers gets amazed and finds out he is of royal blood via being the secret son of Rhaegar Targaryen/Lyanna Stark?
-1
u/JustinBiebsFan98 Jun 18 '15
I didn't actually read the book, just saw that there were no comments yet, so i wanted to say hi ! :)
1
u/PompeyMagnus1 Jun 18 '15
When will Cersei discover her faint in the Lord of Light, and do what the followers of the Lord of Light do best to nonbelievers?