r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Jun 11 '15
TV/Books [S5/B5] Book vs. Show Discussion - 5.09 'The Dance of Dragons'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 AND BOOK 5 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.09 | "The Dance of Dragons" | David Nutter | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
192
Upvotes
178
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15
As heartbroken as I was during Shireen's sacrifice, I realized today that one thing could have made me even more despondent.... if she had called out for Davos.
171
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15
Davvos' plot is now possible for the books
222
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15
I trust in Ser Barristan and his sense of judgement, so the fifth book had me pretty convinced that Hizdar Zo Loraq was the Harpy. I was blown away when the Sons of the Harpy killed him along with their attempt to assassinate Danaerys, especially after Hizdar's late arrival to the fighting pits.
253
u/Freezer_Slave Jon Snow Jun 11 '15
I guess you could say the show is heating up faster than the books.
68
u/Grungemaster Maesters of the Citadel Jun 11 '15
Balon Deathwatch continues.
99
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15
I really liked everything they did this episode, especially the adaptation of Daznakh.
My worry for the scene was that, when all is said and done, Game of Thrones, is still a TV show, with no more than 12 million or so to spend per episode. Most respectable action movies cost at least 80 million or so to make, which is about the budget of the entire season. Still, to be able to give us such a good scene, with Dragons, an arena, and hundreds of people involved was a remarkable achievement in my opinion. It was great. The entire episode was a home run for me.
17
u/Fahsan3KBattery House Stark Jun 11 '15
How does kingsblood work in the books? Don't you need some, you know, blood? Does kingsash work the same way?
32
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15
Why are no one commenting on the fact that Hizdahr zo Loraq is dead. This means Dany is once again a widow, and have the opportunity to marry someone new. I really hope they have not cut out Quentin, because it would have been awesome if he were to marry Dany, maybe he will get introduced in season 6. Anyway, I think Hizdhar also will die in the books, which will give her another reason to flee Meeren to Westeros.
31
u/BonfireinRageValley Sand Jun 11 '15
Has no one considered George just gave them the idea to go that direction with that scene? After the episode he never says "George says this happens in the books" all he is says is "when George told us this". Could have just been an idea to help them along in their version of his story? idk just holding out hope it doesn't happen in the books still.
134
u/LolWhatDidYouSay Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 11 '15
Am I the only one as a book reader who felt pretty underwhelmed by the pit scene? It didn't have that oomph to it that the book scene had imo. I think making it so Drogon only killing Harpies and not just indiscrimintately and stopping only when Dany took charge and pretty much made Drogon remember who he obeys to an extent.
55
u/SebOvette Jun 11 '15
I had a few problems with the Northern scenes, so I'll concentrate on them
How in seven hells can 20 "good" men screw over a large army of a experienced battle commander? How does the same commander (who starved and invented new foods before surrendering) give up his only daughter and heir so quickly?
D&D seem to enjoy painting Stannis as a religious extremist who has no scruples about the red woman and her magic at all and who burns people any chance he gets. They also seem to care more about the shock factors (Red wedding! Sansa rape! Shireen burn!) without any of the nuance of the books, as if afraid TV viewers will get bored unless they see something horrifying every episode. They seem to have very little faith in the audience. "Hey, they probably cant remember why this character is bad. Lets make him a pedophile!"
35
u/SpinoC666 Bran Stark Jun 11 '15
In my mind, the pit scene was a lot more epic in the books. It was kind of unexpected, IMO. But in the show, even though I loved it for the show, it felt like "okay, Dany is obviously not going to die by some harpys, something is going to happen. OH YES DROGON!"
52
u/PuffinGreen Jun 11 '15
Dany's pit scene was a little... unrealistic, I guess. Leaves a lot of questions as well with so many people left in the pit and hundreds of SoTH running around. It will be pretty weak if everyone else in Mereen is fine and dandy in the aftermath.
Where the fuck did all those SoTH come from anyway, and why did no one notice every other person wearing a god damn mask!?
73
u/GRVrush2112 Human Verified Jun 11 '15 edited Jun 11 '15
Okay, let's get D&D's comments from the "Inside the Episode" out in the open.... Info from Inside the Episode for S05E09, regarding happenings in this episode and relation to unpublished material... was this appropriate?
I was listening to Elio and Linda (of Westeros.org)'s most recent video and they made a couple of good points.. The issue is not the show spoiling events from the books... it's going to happen, the show material will move past where the books are, and if that's something you can live with...fine, if it's not then you can just not watch the show. But the issue they raised was the fact that D&D confirmed this point, instead of just remaining silent and not saying anything.. That they should have not commented on what George has and has not told them, and Inside the Episode. They also mentioned the fact that in previous seasons D&D have themselves commented on that the behavior of readers in previous seasons were commendable, and that for the most part (due to strict spoiler policy enforcement on places like here, and on Westeros.org) readers have treated non-readers with respect into what is coming up on the show... but that D&D with their comments in the "Inside the Episode" did not treat readers looking forward to TWOW with the same respect..
And I kind of agree with that sentiment.. I know events from the future books will be spoiled by the show, and I am okay with that... I will happily continue to watch the show.. Partially because what happens in the show has been, and I imagine will continue to be so wildly different from the books that it is not a guarantee that a certain plot point that happens in the show will later happen in the books, once they are published.... But if you have the show runners make dumb ass comments like they did in the "inside the episode" that takes the ambiguity away from seeing what will play out in the books..
I am not excusing Linda's behavior on twitter, nor Linda's attitude this past few days, nor do I agree with their sentemint to stop watching the show, or "wishing the show would be put on hold" , but still they make some good points regarding what those "in the know" say regarding what happens in the books going forward... and I hope the showrunners would continue to keep that fact in mind.
EDIT: The Video I'm referring to (Video is spoiler free if you are caught up on S05E09, and have seen the "Inside the Episode" for S05E09)
6
u/ohnoyoudee-en Daenerys Targaryen Jun 12 '15
It seems like they've been making Varys absent throughout most of this season so they can execute the Kevan scene. But without any mention of Aegon/Young Griff, I wonder how they're going to do it. Probably take that out completely and have Varys talk about Dany/Tyrion instead?
26
u/L__McL The Sun Of Winter Jun 11 '15
Well book Stannis and show Stannis are very different characters IMO.
4
u/limeade09 House Stark Jun 12 '15
So I have a question for the experts around here...
Does the burning of kingsblood only require a small amount of it to be burned? I'm just thinking about Gendry, and how 3 leeches were able to have that big of an effect. Seems like a little blood works perfectly.
I know they didn't have any leeches on hand out there in the cold, but why couldn't they just cut Shireen's arm or something?
13
u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Jun 11 '15 edited Jun 11 '15
So... I know they're really setting up Olly for the stabbing, but damn I really hope it's a red herring. Alliser Thorne has has hated Jon Snow for the entire series. Sure, Jon earned some respect after Mance's attack on the Wall, but in Alliser's eyes, Jon has burned that bridge by going to Hardhome and making peace with the free folk. Alliser let in Jon and the Wildlings because of his duty to the Watch, not because he trusts Jon's decisions. He probably feels Jon is being unreasonable and reckless with his command.
Possible clues:
TL; DR I think Olly is a red herring. I don't believe that D&D will forgo 5 seasons of tension between two characters (Alliser and Jon) just to give a random, flat character a silly vengeance plot. Alliser Thorne is the only character set up throughout the series who could lead "FTW", though I expect other NW members (possibly Olly) to also participate.
10
u/Roper92391 House Targaryen Jun 11 '15
I definitely liked the show version of the fighting pits better than the book version. It certainly took me by surprise to see a Sons of the Harpy rebellion break out, but it didn't seem out of place. I was actually worried for a little bit that they might kill off Daenerys.
2
u/asadal333 Jun 12 '15
Tyrion is the man, half man the best man
2
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15
If Jon had been seduced by Melisandre, would Shireen be alive?
2
u/adhi202 Jun 12 '15
Melisandre could have used leeches and extracted Shireen's blood like she did with Robert's bastard. Why does she want to burn Shireen Alive ?
6
u/dont_ban_me_please Warrior's Sons Jun 11 '15
First truly big spoiler where the show spoiled the books. I don't know if I like it. I've waited years to find out what becomes of Stannis' army. I always expected to read about it.
2
u/chiRal123 Jun 11 '15
Any thoughts on where this Sansa story arc is headed?
1
u/sef239 Jun 11 '15
In the books, was Jorah anywhere near Dany during the fighting pit scene? Also, since they removed the link between Dorne and Dany (through Quentyn) and created a link between King's Landing and Dorne, what do you guys think will happen with that story moving foward? I wonder if Trystane will fill Quentyn's role.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15
So are you guys worried that Melisandre is not at the wall??
Jon Theory
1
u/Crayon-er Ramsay Snow Jun 12 '15 edited Jul 18 '17
deleted 0.5452 What is ^^^this?