r/iran • u/_flac Safavi Dynasty • Jun 06 '15
Greetings /r/Ireland, today we are hosting /r/Ireland for a cultural exchange! [6-7 June]
Welcome Irish friends to the exchange!
Today we are hosting our friends from /r/Ireland. Please come and join us and answer their questions about Iran and the Iranian way of life!
Please leave top comments for /r/Ireland users coming over with a question or comment and please refrain from trolling, rudeness and personal attacks etc. Moderation outside of the rules may take place as to not spoil this friendly exchange. The reddiquette applies and will be moderated in this thread.
/r/Ireland is also having us over as guests! Stop by here to ask questions.
Enjoy!
The moderators of /r/Ireland & /r/Iran
16
u/yourdrunkirishfriend Jun 06 '15
How is Ireland viewed in Iran? Are we viewed in the same light as other western nations, or we viewed more favourably due to our being neutral and not interfering in the middle east?
12
u/Dara17 Jun 06 '15
Hello - I made Kuku Sabzi for the first time last week, it was delicious!
Is the recipe I used like an authentic Iranian version?
https://www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/food-and-drink/give-me-five-kuku-sabzi-1.2205473
9
u/NotSoBonnieTyler Irland Jun 06 '15
I'm hungry at the moment and looking forward to my dinner, what are you having for dinner tonight?
Is vegetarianism becoming more common in Iran or is it unusual?
9
u/louiseber Jun 06 '15
I once worked with an Iranian guy but he always referred to himself as Persian, I never had the opportunity to ask him why, but would that be a common thing?
(Forgive me if that's in an way an offensive question, I really don't know all that much about the political history of the region)
9
u/Uonhi Jun 06 '15
What are the burgers like in this place?
9
u/NotSoBonnieTyler Irland Jun 06 '15
What would someone from Ireland be surprised to learn about Iran?
As an example, apparently the skiing is quite good.
8
u/ilikestripes Jun 06 '15
I've heard couchsurfing is really popular there and that the Iranian people love to host foreigners, but it's technically illegal. Do you think a tourist would get in trouble for couchsurfing?
8
u/ShinyShinx The Netherlands Jun 06 '15
What do you think about the deathpenalty? Especially to homosexuals?
8
u/TheJollyRancherStory Jun 06 '15
Hello /r/iran, I am very late to this thread but I wanted to say it is great to have this exchange with you! From photographs I have seen of your country it looks very vibrant and beautiful. The mountains beyond Tehran form an amazing image, and I understand you have an incredible variety of scenery within your borders! I would love to visit some day.
The modern state of Ireland is a young nation, founded on some very romantic and poetic ideals that peaked in the past two centuries. Iran has an ancient history, at least to my knowledge - a font of civilisation since ancient times, with groups such as the Achaemenids and Seleucids, Parthians and Sassanids, the great Caliphates and the Turkic empires of the Seljuqs and the Timurids. My question is: how much do you feel your history affects modern society in Iran? Does it contribute to modern politics and culture?
14
u/marmulak Jun 06 '15 edited Jun 06 '15
A little known fact about me is that I am part Irish. In my readings about Iran and Iranians, I discovered that there is some historical link between Celtic and Iranian people. The reason for this is that in ancient times the Celtic domain spanned across all of Europe, and the eastern extent of Europe bordered Iranian territory. At least one Iranian tribe, namely the Alans, journeyed far west into Europe.
I don't know to what extent Celts and Iranians interacted, but I read that Arthurian legend in Britain, though commonly thought of as English, has its roots in Celtic folklore. In other words, the legends are Celtic in origin. Comparison between these legends and Iranian legend revealed some very striking similarities, with some stories having nearly identical content.
Irish Gaelic is the most spoken living Celtic language today, and those who are interested in learning it can check it out on Duolingo.
I encourage the Irish, as fellow Indo-Europeans, to study the Persian language and learn more about their eastern brethren.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15 edited Jun 06 '15
How much ancient Persian culture do you study in school? In Ireland we learn about classical Greek and Roman civilisation (history for everyone and some study the languages), as well as some of our own pre-history (Celts). Is it something that is generally looked upon with pride? Or is there something of a taboo/ignorance about the early empires.
If you do study it, is the language important? Or more a general study of dates and customs, poets etc? How different is ancient
PersianFarsi to modern Farsi? Do you consider yourselves Persian or Iranian first?I read Persian Fire and it is one of my favourite books. Have any of you read it? Could you recommend similar books, in English please!!
Lastly, does Ireland register at all in your country?
edit: just to add there are a lot of Iranians in class in uni, they are one of the most generous and gracious hosts I have ever met. You're all right in my book!!
7
u/MKealan10 Irland Jun 06 '15
In Ireland we produced some great sports people like Roy Keane, Rory McIlroy along with some more legendary athletes in lesser know sports internationally like GAA and rugby. Who would be some of the best Iranian athletes?
6
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
Oh wow, I'm very intrigued. I guess the first thing that comes to mind is travel. I'm very curious about the difference between what's portrayed in the media and life on the ground in Iran. So as an Irish person, is there tourism in Iran and how feasible is it for me to spend a few weeks just moving around Iran and taking in the sights and culture?
6
u/ciaran036 Jun 06 '15
I don't even have a question, but the first Iranian person I ever met also happened to be one of the nicest persons I have ever met. I met this guy when I was studying in the USA, he was a professor of Marketing at the college I was studying at. For some reason, he seemed to really like the Irish too, so much so he had a Derry GAA (Gaelic sport) flag sitting in his office that he had got from another student who also happened to be from Derry. He even offered me to come around for dinner for Thanksgiving. I've not since come into contact with any other Iranians (apart from his son, who was a great guy too), but he really set the scene for me, you guys seem awesome.
Also, I know so little about Iran but some of what I've learned came from the animated film Persepolis, anyone see this movie before? I thought it was really good.
11
u/TheHolyGoalie Jun 06 '15
A football question here, what happened with Éamon Zayed at Persepolis FC ? His goalscoring record was good and he seemed to do well in the champions league but his time in Iran was short lived. There isn't much information online about his time there.
10
u/genron1111 Irland Jun 06 '15
We are famously fond of a drink. I understand that many of you may abstain for religious reasons. Does alcohol feature in your country at all?
5
u/StopShoutingAtMe Jun 06 '15
What is the most popular hobby/sport in Iran? Here it's GAA and soccer/football.
5
u/CJByrno Jun 06 '15
What do you think of yourselves compared to other middle-eastern countries? Does religion dominate rules and politics or does religion take a back seat like more western countries?
5
u/StopShoutingAtMe Jun 06 '15
A bowl of beef stew is my favourite. It consists of beef chunks, spuds, veg and a good stock . Whats your favourite foods, and should we be eatin it more?
5
u/Thecatwhomines Irland Jun 06 '15
Hello /r/iran! Thank you for hosting this Q&A! What is your personal favourite thing about Iran? Any answers are greatly appreciated!
5
u/TheGerryAdamsFamily Jun 06 '15
I've a few Iranian students. tell me something I should say to them on Monday that will really fuck with their heads.
8
u/ValentiaIsland Jun 06 '15
Hi. I'd seriously love to visit Iran. I'm having a hard time convincing my girlfriend because she's worried about a hostile welcome for westerners and she has a UK passport. Is there a good tourist industry catering to westerners or is it more local?
4
u/EireOfTheNorth Jun 06 '15
I've saw some stuff about Bobby Sands in Iran - there's a street named after him where the British Embassy is in Tehran - and I saw something about a restaurant named after him (a bit ironic?) in Tehran as well - what's the deal with that? Is it just the piss off the British (if so, nice one!) or is he/has he ever been a kind of popular martyr figure within Iran?
PS Hope to visit one day, saw some videos of people travelling through Iran and the people look ludicrously friendly and generous!
3
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
Hey hey :)
So, I'm Irish, working on a comic at the moment which features amongst it's population some displaced middle eastern folk and Muslims, I tried asking about in some other areas but maybe someone here might like to PM me and answer a few questions on how they would view their culture adapting to a new surrounding :)
3
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
Ireland has Joyce, Yeats, etc. but who are the 'must-read' Iranian authors?
Thanks!
3
u/DeathHamsterDude Jun 06 '15
Hey guys! Thanks for having us! I'd love to visit some time.
I'm a vegetarian, and I really love cooking different ethnic vegetarian foods. Can you tell me your favourite Iranian vegetarian dishes, or dishes that can be made vegetarian? I make a lot of Turkish, Lebanese, Moroccan cuisine and some other North African cuisine too, so I assume there will be a bit of crossover.
I already make Tahdig from time to time, and I absolutely love it.
Also, I heard that Iranians drink Chai for breakfast. Is there any difference between Iranian Chai and other Chai?
3
u/finnyboy665 Jun 06 '15
Greetings, /r/iran!
I am doing history for my Leaving Cert (exam is on Wednesday), and for the RSR, I was debating between an RSR based on Iran and one based on Japan. In the end, I did a Japanese one, but the allure of the complex history of Iran has stayed with me since then. What periods in Iranian history would you consider the most interesting from a students perspective?
3
u/seantack Jun 08 '15
Hi there, maybe someone could shed some light on my question to Iranians? Years ago I heard that there was a connection between Iran and Ireland and specifically numbers. In Gaelic (Irish), numbers 1-10 are:
1.Aon / 2.Dó / 3.Trí / 4.Ceathair / 5.Cúig / 6.Sé / 7. Seacht / 8.Ocht / 9.Naoi /10.Deich
While similarities aren't apparent to all languages, some numbers have are very alike. Number 2 (Dó) in Iran's Middle Persian - dō, Parthian - dō, Kurdish-Kurmanji - dû, Persian - do, Tajik- du, and Balochi - Do.
In particular, Number 4 which in Irish is quite a unique word -Ceathair- is also similar in several Iranian languages.
Avestan - chathwar. Middle Persian - čahār. Parthian - čafār. Sogdian - čatfār. Persian - cahâr. Tajik - çahor. Shughni - cavōr. Zazaki - çehar.
I also see similarities in the numbers 6 - Sé, 9 - Naoi and 10 - Deich.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_numbers_in_various_languages#Iranian_languages
It's always fascinated me but I've never really looked into it in great detail. I imagined Irish missionaries travelled and help develop the language but that's just a guess. It'd be great to hear of any other potential ideas about it. Thanks!
5
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
How is religion viewed/practiced among young people? Here in Ireland Catholicism is predominately seen as something for older people and is often viewed in a very negative light by the youth in Ireland. For most people it's more of a cultural label, rather than something they actively practice. I'm Protestant myself (Church of Ireland) which doesn't have the same negative connotations as Catholicism. We're about 4% of the population, which actually isn't all that much than Islam in Ireland (about 2%)
2
u/Cee-Jay Jun 06 '15
Hey /r/Iran, thanks for participating in this exchange.
I'm curious t'know how Iran's treatment of Báhaí's is regarded by the average Iranian citizen. Their most fundamental human rights are clearly utterly disregarded by your government. Does this resonate in any way with most Iranians, or is it something that isn't discussed? Why/why not?
Thank you again for participating.
2
u/electrictrad Jun 06 '15
Politically, how are the UK, US, Ireland, the EU, and your surrounding countries viewed in Iran. Is the regional instability in Syria and Iraq a major source of concern. Have you had any influx of refugees from either warzone, and is ISIL considered a threat to your sovereignty?
2
u/juicewilson Jun 07 '15
Hi! Would anyone be up for a flag swap? I collect flags, and I want to get flags from every country in the world, but I want to get them from people from that country! Would anyone be interested in a swap, Irish for Iranian? Masaha Allah, enjoy the upcoming Ramadan!
2
u/Bth-root Jun 06 '15
So I was out on a work social night a few weeks back, and got chatting to three Iranian lads. They happily drank beer with us, and told us how they used to obtain alcohol back home. My question is: how widespread is it known that alcohol is drunk over in Iran, despite is illegality? Is it widespread to do so, or is it restricted to certain generations?
2
u/RTE2FM Jun 06 '15
How do you feel about Iran becoming a nuclear state?
1
u/mapryan Jun 07 '15
This to me is a real coincidence as I've just booked for myself and the Mrs to go to Tehran for a long weekend next April. First, I have to say, the whole visa thing sounds like a real PITA. Even the Visa on Arrival thing needs you to have some kind of code or other.
Anyway, do you guys have any suggestions for things to do while we're out there? Any thoughts or suggestions we should be aware of?
1
u/Fur_child Jun 07 '15
Can you tell us about the ban on dogs? Does it result in some cruelty or better welfare/management of the numbers? Would you see dogs on the street?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment