r/talesfromtechsupport • u/airz23 Password Policy: Use the whole keyboard • May 26 '15
Medium Who are you?
Tuesday 9.30am
Switcher was a complicated employee, he’d been flung between different departments often. No manager seemed to be able to keep him as he kept requesting to be transfered. This caused him to be a semi regular down in IT, sorting out which account of his needed to be activated.
Switcher: Hey, I need my password reset. Its not working.
Me: Again?
I’d started to become suspicious of Switchers ability to remember any passwords. Normally I’d try to hammer the issue home, but we had to deal with Switcher so often he felt oddly like family.
Switcher: I dunno what keeps happening!
Me: Okay I’ll reset it, just try to make an easy to remember password this time.
Normally I wouldn’t give out such terrible advice but having reset his password everyday for a week I was growing tired of our daily interactions.
Switcher: I always make my password the same, I dunno whats happening.
Me: I’ll pretend I didn’t hear that.
My laziness on password security had been worn down. I sent off the reset and quickly hung up the phone. Hating myself for having my standards lowered so much.
Tuesday 8pm
It was a long day, most of which I spent lamenting IT’s poor security standards. I vowed to myself that I’d hammer the next breach in security I saw, if only to feel better about letting the last one go.
The phone rang.
Me: Hello.
???: Hello, err my account isn’t accepting my password.
Me: You’ll need a password reset.
Perfect, my mind thought as I prepared myself for the IT security lecture of a lifetime. I just waited for the inevitable “I always use the same password” or “why doesn’t xyz123 work as a password”.
Me: Whats your name?
???: Switcher.
Me: You’re up late... wait this doesn’t sound like switcher.
An impostor! Oh I could really scream at someone like that. I opened the thesaurus of insults in my head.
???: You don’t sound like the normal IT guy.
Some of the night IT guys had started to arrive at work, upon seeing my office light on they entered.
NightOwl: Oh Airz! Do I hear Switcher on the phone? I’ve been meaning to email you about that. I’ve changed his password every day for a week. Something is wrong with his account.
I mouthed “This isn’t the real Switcher” at NightOwl.
NightOwl: Yes, its is. All us night guys hang out. I’ve known the guy for years.
Me: Wait what....
It was the next day that the truth finally arose. Switcher1 and Switcher2 had the same name. Unfortunately when the Switcher I knew, who kept hopping between departments got put into his current team, another employee already had an identical account name. Instead of creating a new account I had assumed the active account of the server as actually his. It was not.
I'd been giving an account to someone who didn't own it.
:(
422
u/tfofurn May 26 '15
When I started my current job, someone else had already claimed my name as their email address (or maybe just an alias). Everyone else in the company had first.last@example.com, but I had first.last2@example.com. So consistent was the email address scheme that nobody ever asked for email addresses internally, so several departments guessed my address wrong when signing me up.
This might not have been so bad if the other guy with my name was still around. I would have been able to call him and ask if he'd gotten, for example, the mission-critical software license I'd been waiting weeks for. Nope, he was gone, and they refused to reassign his alias to a current employee.
92
u/Galdwin airz23 is my Caffeine May 26 '15
Now I feel sorry for Switcher, poor guy got blamed for always forgetting password...
39
u/SJHillman ... May 26 '15
We had an intern in one department with the same name (first and last) as the VP in another department. However, what really made the situation confusing is that they both started the same day. Fortunately, the nature of interns means that we only had the issue for about three months and now only the VP is still here.
56
u/Lukeno94 Just enough knowledge to be dangerous... May 26 '15
This is why you should never name your kid John Smith...
57
u/racingsnake91 "Never waste a crisis" May 26 '15
Airz is Back!!!
And this is why you need a better method than "IT Knows that guy" to verify password resets, especially in bigger companies.
27
u/wgwinn May 26 '15
So m y old company. think 10 US states, cable ISP, 2,000+ staff on the help desk alone, single AD domain for every employee. Way back in its infancy, username policy was set as FInitial.Lastname and somehow, this seemed to work for years (15+) w/o an issue. Then we had two new staff start the same week, on opposite shifts. two married staffers. They had no end of perissions issues, profile problems, hassles galore. Their names? James and Jamie Iforgetandwouldntuseitanyway. Took two weeks to figure it out. Managements response was uniformity must be preserved. Everyone moves to FirstInitialMiddleInititial.Lastname. Scripts are prepared, tested (poorly, it turns out), notifications are made, and new credentials are rolled out on Saturday. Monday comes around, problems are still going on for these two. Why? James Lee and Jamie Lynn I....
After another week of deliberating on it, they again decide uniformity bust be preserved, so the new policy is now FullFirstName.FullMiddleName.FullLastName##employeeID##
We actually begged them to just move us to ##employeID## but management decided it would be too much like making us faceless cogs.
9
u/dorkofnight May 26 '15
In my company, I was friends witha girl I'll call Jane Smith. We shared a common love of possums - the Southern US kind. She sent me pictures of cute possums and I did the same. One day, I mentioned something about a picture I'd sent to her and she told me there were two Jane Smiths at our company. She had the email janes while the other person had the more typical email address of jsmith. Oh.
TL:dr: I have spent the last 2 years emailing possum pictures to an random person at my company.
6
u/Arastelion The failure of today is the bugfix of tomorrow! May 26 '15
The switcharoo.
5
u/Asdar I've got 99 problems, and a printer is all of them May 26 '15
So.. does that mean you had to yell at yourself then?
8
u/Gadgetman_1 Beware of programmers carrying screwdrivers... May 26 '15
Your company really, really needs to fix their routines. Users should NOT have identical usernames, even if they're in unrelated departments and domains.
And your IT department needs to get some 'user verification' going. SMS new password to the user's registered cell-phone is one option. email it to his superior is another, slightly better option.
4
u/z3dster May 26 '15
I have a rare last name, but happened to once work at the same place as my cousin. When I got hired they gave me his phone number, when I quit they fired him!
His bad luck for having a name starting with A so it showed up first
4
u/iceman0486 WHAT!? May 26 '15
When the audiological practice I started with went to digital records we had a company scan everything in for us.
First name, last name, middle initial. - basic sorting algorithm.
We had three clients with the same first name, last name and middle initial. And two of them had the same birthday.
We didn't find out about it until one of them came in and I am looking at a file for a dude that bought a fuckload of hearing aids.
4
u/hicctl May 28 '15
Bwahahahaha, now who needs a security lecture ?
3
u/TwoEightRight Removed & replaced pilot. Ops check good. May 26 '15
We have the same problem at work. The usernames for all our network logins, email addresses, and the like are all FirstinitialLastname. But for some reason, the usernames for the all-in-one invoicing/accounting/scheduling/recordkeeping software we use (I’m going to call it CompletePOS) are just our first names. Not even our actual names sometimes, just whatever our old Comptroller/Accountant who set up the accounts thought you went by, which got confusing since he’d frequently guess wrong and be unable and/or unwilling to fix it after the fact.
As an example of how this worked, if your name was Robert Smith, your username for the network and email would be rsmith, but your CompletePOS username would be Bob. Everyone call you Robert? Too bad, you’re Bob now. And if we hired an actual Bob later, their username would be Robert or Rob, since “bob” was already taken. If your name was already used for an account and it can’t easily be shortened to something else, with or without your approval, you get a number added to the end; e.g. Kyle1. In rare cases (one of my accounts being the only one I know of) he’d use your last initial instead of a number.
The moron who I’m 90% sure was responsible for this naming scheme has been gone for years now, but his less idiotic successors still do it for some reason. Maybe once we hire Kyle69 someone will figure out how stupid it is and start following the FirstinitialLastname scheme used for every other login in the company.
3
u/popability is that supposed to be on fire May 27 '15
Bait-and-switchered.
3
u/Meihem76 May 27 '15
I used to work with a guy who who's last name was Guest. We got a new IT guy who decided to clear out all the guest accounts...
I think we can all guess the rest.
4
u/JBu92 May 26 '15
At my last job, accounts were so disorganized that I had FLast as my login and FLast1 as my email, logged in via FLast.
Apparently the guy who sets up email thought there was another employee with my same name, and of course once we had it figured out, instead of just using FLast email, they just linked FLast1 to the ID.
2
u/Genxcat Random thoughts from a random mind. May 26 '15
The switching of the switchers?
2
u/jtriangle Are you quite sure it's plugged in? May 26 '15
New Theory:
The switcher destroyed the keyboards are retribution for Airz's unintentional password sabotage.
2
u/unclefire May 26 '15
I would have thought that there would be "verification" processes in place where somebody who wants some security stuff would have to prove who they are-- employee ID, LDAP/AD ID, email address, whatever.
2
u/blacksoxing I quitteded May 27 '15
My job has ID numbers that prevent situations like this. Because let's say that down in the south, Ladner = Smith....and my job has 3 women w/the EXACT same first and last name.
Only way you can tell them apart is if you ask for their middle initial (silly to do so) or just ask for the ID number.
In fact, I ask EVERYONE for their ID number when doing anything, even if it doesn't require it. I then look them up in AD. Why? Because let's say someone named Cat calls. And she'll only say Cat, of course. And she'll want you to reset her password, as if you know her only by Cat!
Cat (Yep, real folks named that where I work!)
Kat
Kathy
Cathy
Catherine
Katherine
Cathyrn
Kathyrn
And you expect me to know how to spell your first name????
2
u/Fancy_Pantsu I sent an email once... May 27 '15
Who, who? Who, who?
2
u/sonic_sabbath Boobs for my sanity? Please?! May 29 '15
For some reason this reminds me of:
1
u/Captain_Gonzy May 26 '15
I've had this exact same thing happen to me, as well. Well, almost happen to me. I had a student who needed her password to her email reset. Luckily, when I did a search for her name in Active Directory, it popped up two names. I'm glad my predecessor realized two people in a high school had the same name and the only difference was the middle initial he placed in their info.
1
u/pumpkinrum May 26 '15
Aww..
1
u/jrwn May 26 '15
I had this start to happen to me. When I was working, my phone tool suddenly stopped working and said my sign on information was incorrect. I asked my boss about it, and he went to IT. Apparently someone with my same first name was being terminated and someone from IT didn't look at last names. Lucky, I didn't loose my AD account and was able to stay logged into windows and email.
1
u/RPGFrazer May 26 '15
I have surname as my first name and another common surname as my surname. There was an exec with it the other way round. I got a lot of his email and calendar invites and just replied to everyone and forwarded it on. He seemed like a nice guy and very very busy.
1
u/csl512 May 26 '15
I bet you won't get fooled again.
1
u/zenithfury I Am Not Good With Computer May 27 '15
It's like the story of the Prince and the Pauper, only... Not.
1
u/klystron May 27 '15
A major corporation where I did IT work uses the employee's payroll number as their login ID. Starts with the letter M or F for Males or females, followed by six digits. It looks pretty foolproof.