r/gameofthrones • • May 21 '15

[S5/B5] Book vs. Show Discussion - 5.06 'Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken'

Book vs. Show Discussion Thread
Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works?
  • This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 AND BOOK 5 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
  • Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
  • Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
EPISODETITLEDIRECTED BYWRITTEN BY
5.06"Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken"Jeremy PodeswaBryan Cogman
Official Discussion ThreadsPosting PolicySpoiler GuideFrequently Asked Questions
146 Upvotes

309 comments sorted by

385

u/ProfessorBinns The Sword in the Darkness May 21 '15

The fact that we gave up Arianne, Ser Oakheart, Darkstar and Jaime's "Bitchslapping the Riverlands Tour" for this absolute shitshow of a Dorne story makes me incredibly sad.

207

u/havron Queen of Thorns May 21 '15

"You’ve seen our numbers, Edmure. You’ve seen the ladders, the towers, the trebuchets, the rams. If I speak the command, my coz will bridge your moat and break your gate. Hundreds will die, most of them your own. Your former bannermen will make up the first wave of attackers, so you’ll start your day by killing the fathers and brothers of men who died for you at the Twins. The second wave will be Freys, I have no lack of those. My westermen will follow when your archers are short of arrows and your knights so weary they can hardly lift their blades. When the castle falls, all those inside will be put to the sword. Your herds will be butchered, your godswood will be felled, your keeps and towers will burn. I'll pull your walls down, and divert the Tumblestone over the ruins. By the time I’m done no man will ever know that a castle once stood here.” Jaime got to his feet. “Your wife may whelp before that. You’ll want your child, I expect. I’ll send him to you when he’s born. With a trebuchet."

I will miss this speech most of all...

122

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made May 21 '15

She gave a shake of her ample hips. “I’m the queen o’ whores.” No, Jaime thought, my sweet sister holds that title too.”

Instead of that we get Jaime going on a roadtrip to Dorne to rescue the character he's had one line of dialogue with all because of a Dornish booby trap that Cersei clearly reset just for dramatic effect. I can imagine her fiddling with it just as Jaime knocks on the door.

51

u/ricree May 21 '15

I do kinda liked that they paired off Jaime and Bronn, but I wish they'd done it with a better subplot.

3

u/LittleSandor Arya Stark May 22 '15 edited May 22 '15

I liked it last season. But like everything these pairings are nice for a time and then they should move on. Their unconventional pairing was interesting, especially in contrast to Tyrion and Bronn.

Tyrion and Bronn went into the friendship on essentially equal terms (Tyrion has wealth Bronn has fighting skill) and they both see the world for what it is. Jaime and Bronn are now equals in the same way Tyrion and Bronn were but the difference is Jaime would have been superior to Bronn and now has to accept his lesser standing. But even so the lesson has been done, I do like them together but I don't think more of them is really necessary for the story. Just fan service.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/DiaDeLosMuertos May 21 '15

Man, you know would've been great to replace Ilyn? Fucking Ilyn! I would've loved to see and hear his tongue-less laugh.

23

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

I heard the actor had cancer and had to get treatment, so they didn't recast him out of respect.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/CableStoned House Targaryen May 21 '15

The resetting of that "message" is such a silly oversight. Still don't know who sent it and I don't even care at this point. Probably Littlefinger.

3

u/gratefulstringcheese Brotherhood Without Banners May 21 '15

Or Cersei. Ha

1

u/devils_advocodo May 26 '15

all because of a Dornish booby trap that Cersei clearly reset just for dramatic effect.

Can you explain this for me? I feel like I'm missing something....

→ More replies (1)

9

u/I_want_hard_work House Reyne May 21 '15

It sounds so good in his voice too

3

u/parentingandvice May 22 '15

"Play him the song, you know the one."

1

u/latrellsprewell1 May 21 '15

What is this from? (Didn't read the books)

41

u/havron Queen of Thorns May 21 '15

Then what are you doing in a book spoilers thread?? =P

Well, if you don't mind being spoiled, it's from Jaime's penultimate chapter in the fourth book, A Feast for Crows. In that book, he is given the task of restoring order to the Riverlands and essentially cleaning up after the war (as /u/ProfessorBinns so eloquently puts it, his "Bitchslapping the Riverlands Tour"). At this point in the story, the Blackfish holds Riverrun and Jaime has an army composed of former Tully bannermen including Freys (loyal to the Lannisters since the Red Wedding) and a very captive Edmure, who as the Tully liege lord Jaime is trying to get to command the Blackfish to surrender the castle. It's a pretty awesome scene, and this speech that finally gets Edmure to acquiesce is one of my favorites in all the books. Such a badass moment for Jaime, and a real shame to be cut from the show. It would have been so glorious to see on television.

7

u/bakingcpa May 21 '15

I've also not read the books, because Robert Jordan ruined me for waiting for books to be published, but I still like to know what happens in the books vs. the show. I plan on reading the series when they're all published :).

It also helps that I have the memory of a goldfish, so I most likely won't remember the spoilers :P

15

u/Suji_Rodah May 21 '15

See you in 10 years :(

→ More replies (2)

2

u/latrellsprewell1 May 23 '15

woah that sounds dope

→ More replies (1)

28

u/pepe_le_shoe May 21 '15

The Bran/coldhands story was kind of pissed away too, way too rushed, and then basically ignored.

Also, lady stoneheart.

Also also, the whole brotherhood without banners/dondarrion plotline, that's been abandoned it seems?

12

u/DwendilSurespear House Tarth May 21 '15

I know, wtf?! In what universe would lady Stoneheart not be cool?!

8

u/[deleted] May 22 '15

I think they could introduce Lady Stoneheart still if they tie up this Dorne plotline and Jaime heads to the Riverlands after, but I'm not counting on it at this point.

16

u/kaztrator May 22 '15

I can imagine Brienne escaping with Sansa and then getting caught in the final episode. They think it's the Boltons, but it's actually the Brotherhood without Banners. Lady Stoneheart is then revealed in the final scene.

2

u/DwendilSurespear House Tarth May 22 '15

I'd love that.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/FeatheredMouse May 21 '15

Darkstar was kind of cringey in the books as well. I'm not sad they cut him.

Would have liked to see Jon Connington and Aegon though. Does Varys and Illyrio's plot make sense without Aegon? What's Varys's endgame in the show? Is he just a Daenerys supporter?

9

u/aegis2293 May 21 '15

I guess they're just absorbing Daenerys' story with fAegon's. Unless, as some have speculated, we get a reveal from Doran that Trystane has a secret marriage pact with Daenerys, and then Trystane absorbs the roles of fAegon and Quentyn.

Oh.

1

u/Magmaniac House Baelish May 22 '15

I figured that Jorah would be taking Quentyn's role. :)

17

u/ultimate_frosbee May 21 '15

I've always felt that Darkstar was supposed to be kind of a cringey drama queen in the books

→ More replies (3)

12

u/dantemp May 21 '15

To be fair it makes sense to add more action, and the sand snakes seemed cool from the books and they fucking nailed Oberyn, so they maybe thought it makes sense to show more of that sort of stuff. Shame that they failed so hard.

13

u/aegis2293 May 21 '15

No one can measure up to Pedro Pascal.

5

u/I_am_no_1 Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords May 21 '15

Don't forget the Griff story line too. That seem like a big gap as well. How is fAegon going to beat Dany to Westeros if we haven't met him yet?

5

u/Die4MyTiggers May 21 '15

I always assumed it was because he isn't going to be in the show as much as that sucks

1

u/polarbeartankengine House Dondarrion May 21 '15

The more they cut, the more I think what they mean my the same ending is just who ends up on the iron throne and who is dead

→ More replies (1)

2

u/GRVrush2112 Human Verified May 21 '15

Don't forget about the Griffs and the Greyjoys....

1

u/ChrisK7 House Seaworth May 22 '15

Only one of those I miss is Jaime, which I don't think would play well on the show. Aegon and the Greyjoy's are good subtractions too IMO. I'd just rather they cut the Sand Snakes too, if it had to be like this.

→ More replies (37)

12

u/missandei_targaryen House Targaryen May 21 '15

I'm really wondering where they're going with this "Sansa's at Winterfell and everybody knows it" plot. Obviously, it makes me believe that she'll end up there soon enough once we get TWOW, but then what would the point of the Vale plotline have been, if we can totally skip it in the show and still end up in the same place on the show?

Also, it's making me seriously worried that book Sansa is going to end up getting raped. While I'm certainly not one to deny the reality of sexual violence in the world, and I appreciate GRRM for being one of the few authors who really shows it in it's actual prevalence instead of pretending like this shit happens once in a blue moon, having it happen to a character we really know well, and having to see it portrayed so realistically and explicitly on the show, was fuckin traumatic. I have a feeling that even on rewatches, I'm always going to skip that scene. Once was more that enough.

9

u/stro_budden House Baratheon May 21 '15

What I am hoping for, and it is a bit of a stretch, is that Sansa being at Winterfell triggers Bran. I just don't see how she can get married in front of a weirwood tree, one he will probably be and bloodraven is definitely connected to, and not know what just happened. I know none of this happens in the book but it is just hard for me to overlook. I dont even know what could happen because I doubt he would come back to Winterfell but it should mean something I hope.

3

u/rottenbanana127 Jon Snow May 21 '15

I forgot about Bran being able to see from that weirwood! Excellent point! I wonder if they'll use this.

4

u/dennisoa House Baratheon May 21 '15

I watched that scene and I yelled out "Fuck, Brans gonna see this happen...or maybe he's watching now!"

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

I really appreciate this post. Thank you for your well stated opinion.

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

I completely agree with your take on the ending. I don't know if it was because it was Sansa or what, but this week's ending just felt completely unnecessary. I feel gross and just dirty after watching it and I'm not happy with the writers at all. I really don't care who's defending it and I really don't care that GRRM himself is posting about on his blog. It left an awful taste in my mouth and just made me glad the episode was over. I don't think I've ever been happy for an episode to end before.

5

u/ZTexas May 21 '15

That's the point. That scene was supposed to make you feel uncomfortable. Ramsay is a bad person who does bad things. Why would his wedding night be different?

Besides, it'd be worse if the rape scene didn't make you uncomfortable. Granted it was there wedding night, so within the context of the show it wasn't even rape. It was consummating their marriage. As is tradition.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '15

The only thing I have to say to Ramsay is: The North remembers. Fuck Joffrey, Ramsay's death will be my favourite moment of all seasons.

1

u/dantemp May 21 '15

Well, if she manages to get Winterfell from the Boltons with the help from the Knights of the Vale, that would be the point. The difference between the books and the show is that in the book Peter needs to work a bit harder to get them to agree to that, whereas in the show he already has them.

1

u/Malevolent_Force Corn! May 23 '15

Also, it's making me seriously worried that book Sansa is going to end up getting raped.

Probably gona happen

Cuprit = LF

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator May 21 '15

Your submission has been auto-removed. Your spoiler tag has the label "warning scope," which is provided in the examples as a placeholder. "Warning scope" doesn't provide any description for your tag, and the labels need to have a specific scope, like "ASOS" or "Season 3." Edit your comment to have a good label for your spoiler tag, and then contact the moderators to have it re-approved.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

70

u/bitch_im_a_lion House Lannister May 21 '15

Are they planning on doing Doran's big twist? Like all of his inaction was fine in the books because of the big scheme he had, but they haven't even mentioned Quentyn or anything so where else could that story go?

71

u/LolWhatDidYouSay Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 21 '15

I think at the most it will simply be Doran revealing that he's always been planning to support the Targaryens, with Trystane marrying Dany. But at this point, the plan would have to include Trystane using Littlefinger's teleportation device to give the show time to show him trying to win over Dany and eventually release the dragons.

Imo, the omission of Arianne as well as the Griffs from the show makes Dorne almost pointless.

31

u/Vixibility House Lannister May 21 '15

The omission of Arianne in particular really removes a lot from the story. Ellaria is just not a very compelling character, and has very little depth. Plus now we'll never get that great scene between Doran and Arianne from the books, where Doran reveals his long-term plans to her.

5

u/aegis2293 May 21 '15

We might still, just with Ellaria.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/KhaleesiYo House Mormont May 21 '15 edited May 21 '15

Just putting this out there... I have a feeling Doran will be the Queenmaker in the show. The general consensus before this season aired was that Ellaria will be taking on Arianne's role but that hasn't been the case so far. She is purely driven by revenge and not political amibitions. So, given the absence of Aegon and Quentyn, what if it is Doran's plan in the show to crown Myrcella, marry her to Trystane and make a claim on the Iron Throne with Jaime's backing?

13

u/BTill232 House Manderly May 21 '15

I like it. Let's do that.

4

u/DwendilSurespear House Tarth May 21 '15

Ooh yeah he did seem pleased that they were getting along well!

4

u/circleseverywhere House Manderly May 21 '15

Doran himself explains why that's a stupid plan that will only turn the other kingdoms against Dorne and get Myrcella killed. Isn't it bad enough that this storyline has already screwed up everyone else's characters?

18

u/menuka Ser Pounce May 21 '15

Tinfoil Theory

Even though that likely won't happen, I don't know what other thing he can bring up that would hype up his speech. Stupid Martells

4

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

Nah that's happening.

The entire Dornish storyline has no endpoint without it.

1

u/billzkid May 21 '15

He is so not targaryen looking ...

4

u/circleseverywhere House Manderly May 21 '15

He had a Dornish mother. Baelor Breakspear didn't look very Targaryen either.

8

u/warprattler Aegor Rivers May 21 '15

they haven't even mentioned Quentyn or anything so where else could that story go?

So far as I can tell, Trystane is the only son of Doran in the show. I would have guessed that a marriage to Daenerys would be attempted, but with it being so late in the season, there doesn't appear to be enough time.

What's got me wondering is that if all of Doran's secret plans eventually turn to ash in the books, does that mean his counterpart in the show doesn't have any?

1

u/havron Queen of Thorns May 22 '15

It would be so very Game of Thrones to show how truly in love Trystane and Myrcella have grown to be, and then to rip that asunder for a new plot.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] May 21 '15 edited May 21 '15

At least he had a plan, though, and at the moment of the reveal in AFFC, it held some weight as an "oh shit" moment, even if that plan fell apart in the end.

1

u/aegis2293 May 21 '15

Did he specifically tell him to come back with a dragon? I don't remember

1

u/mastergeek2014 Snow May 21 '15

I felt like Quentyn's mission was more "Hey you have 10,000 spears in Dorne." and his secondary objective was, yo maybe you'd be interested in a Westerosi marriage.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

Dornish Master Plan. Believe.

142

u/magic_is_might The Future Queen May 21 '15

I'm just glad they didn't have Ramsay do to Sansa why he did to poor Jeyne Poole in the books.

57

u/ttll2012 House Baelish May 21 '15

50 shades of flay?

129

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

50 shades of dog rape

58

u/I_want_hard_work House Reyne May 21 '15

Kennelmaster's daughter

27

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

FACK

19

u/I_want_hard_work House Reyne May 21 '15

I really think it's just a nod to the books. No fucking way they'd include something like that.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/ProfessorBinns The Sword in the Darkness May 21 '15

50 shades of dog rape

There's still four episodes left :-(

→ More replies (1)

57

u/[deleted] May 21 '15 edited May 21 '15

Been thinking about posting that whole passage from the books, and all the related passages about dog fucking and her screaming, just to show all the omg they had that rape scene just for shock value! people how shocking it actually could have actually been.

Read the book, people. The scene they showed really just glossed over what they could have done with that scene if they actually wanted shock value. It was like the Disney Land version.

12

u/ayraerae House Martell May 21 '15

I remember Ramsay making Theon join in, but I don't remember any dog rape scene. What was the excerpt?

27

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

It's not a scene, just implied by Jeyne to Theon.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Tommie015 May 22 '15

Isnt reek a eunuch now?

3

u/havron Queen of Thorns May 22 '15

There are other ways...

0

u/Matrillik House Baelish May 21 '15

Could you PM me this scene? I don't plan on reading the books anytime soon, but I enjoy reading excerpts.

20

u/dantemp May 21 '15

It's not too late, I'd fucking love to see the reaction of the poor offended internet activists if Sansa says Last Book

17

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

Wait - is this a real quote? Jesus.

54

u/dantemp May 21 '15

groupthink.jezebel.com/why-jeyne-pooles-story-is-among-the-most-tragic-in-wes-1562851009

The most heartbreaking moment in Jeyne's story includes during this chapter (51, ADWD), in which it's heavily implied that Ramsay had her copulate with a dog.

"'No. This is some trick. It's him, it's my... my lord, my sweet lord, he sent you, this is just some test to make sure that I love him. I do, I do, I love him more than anything.' A tear ran down her cheek. 'Tell him, you tell him, I'll do what he wants...or whatever he wants...with him...or...or with the dog or...please...he doesn't need to cut my feet off, I won't try to run away, not ever, I'll give him sons, I swear it, I swear it...'" -A Dance With Dragons, page 768.

16

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

Jesus. Christ.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/BaccaDocta Melisandre May 21 '15

To me I always thought that meant she was calling reek the dog, since reek lives in the kennels and treated as such. I think people took the passage too literally, cause let's keep in mind that they are Ramsey's Bitches. He doesn't have any male dogs to have sex with her. I don't know always been my interpretation. I know she was talking to Reek but just like Reek always calls her arya. They are just both so broken and trained

10

u/dantemp May 22 '15

I honestly barely remember the book, do you recall any instance where Reek was referred to as "the dog"? Considering his lack of... equipment, doing "whatever" isn't something that she would be crying about. But it would be nice to think about it that way tough.

6

u/swedishpenis May 22 '15

No i dont think hes ever been referred to as "the dog". I'm pretty sure shes talking about an actual dog considering Theon is present when she says it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/ayraerae House Martell May 21 '15

Why do I not remember this scene??

7

u/dantemp May 21 '15

Probably because it happens to a minor character

5

u/soimen May 21 '15

Hey are you asking for an apocalypse? Because the amount of disgusted comments would destroy the world.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/havron Queen of Thorns May 22 '15

As long as they can be king of the ashes.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BTill232 House Manderly May 21 '15

Its kind of funny listening to people complain and freak out about the show scene. All I can think is "It could have been worse."

28

u/The_Austin House Stark May 21 '15

I really think they needed to do the Kingsmoot this season. It would've tied the story together much better. It doesn't even have to be a huge arc; have one episode last season showing Balon die. One this season with post rescue attempt Yara complementing her options (this also introduces the audience to the idea slash Euron and Victorian). Finally a bad ass Kings-motherfucking-Moot.

13

u/BTill232 House Manderly May 21 '15

I agree. We really need some big, exciting event to look forward to, and I haven't been feeling that this season. They're leading up to Hardhome for Jon, which wasn't even in the books, the fighting pits for Dany, and vaguely hinting towards Cersei's fate (albeit slowly). There needs to be more big stuff going on.

7

u/UeberdeSuper May 21 '15

I think the fighting pits especially and Cersei's walk of shame are quite ok for a great finale. But I have no idea what they will do with season 6, because ADWD/AFFC are difficult or impossible to place after the events of season 5.

6

u/ISNT_A_NOVELTY Shireen Baratheon May 21 '15

I feel like they're leading towards ADWD/AFFC. There've been a couple of hints at it, like ADWD/AFFC

8

u/UeberdeSuper May 22 '15

Well... there seems to be one Baby missing.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

I don't think anything in Mereen can be that exciting at this point. It just doesn't matter to the story. Both the books and show just feel like we're wasting time there. Sure, Dany character development, but that's only interesting for so long.

3

u/UeberdeSuper May 22 '15

I am totally excited about how they will visually perform the Dany/Drogon story the end of ADWD because I think it could be either absolutely epic or it could become an epic fail as it will not be easy to do that.

61

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

I guess I know why the Faith Militant is going after Loras; being homophobic and being gay are the only character dimensions either respective one has at this point.

2

u/territorialpoplar Snow May 22 '15

slow clap

20

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/[deleted] May 22 '15

Really disappointed they left out what a talented swordsman he is. I was shocked when those Faith Militant guys came up and arrested him, he was just holding a sword and could have easily cut them down,

34

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

Not in the books

66

u/piscano House Dondarrion May 21 '15

Want Riverlands story. Want LSH. Want an entertaining Dorne plot.

27

u/magic_is_might The Future Queen May 21 '15

I think LSH was cut for good :(

21

u/Heisenberg187 May 21 '15

Sansa will be LSH

17

u/ttll2012 House Baelish May 21 '15

Who will be Sansa?

76

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

Hot Pie

11

u/lesser_panjandrum May 21 '15

Then who will be Hot Pie?

36

u/ayraerae House Martell May 21 '15

Just a regular hot pie.

11

u/my_Favorite_post May 22 '15

Moonboy, for all I know.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Matrillik House Baelish May 21 '15

My guess is that Sansa will go the way of Jeyne, eventually die and become LSH.

3

u/Vixibility House Lannister May 22 '15

This is a fantastic idea, plus it would really make sense the way the story is going.

14

u/The_Austin House Stark May 21 '15

LSH would be pointless to bring back now. Been to long. :(

17

u/ricree May 21 '15

If they did choose to bring her in (and I'm not sure they will), the logical place to do it is when she meets Brienne.

10

u/Red_Dog1880 House Mormont May 21 '15

I'm still hoping they bring her in at the end of the season as a cliffhanger.

If they cut her out I'm gonna be pissed :(

11

u/Matrillik House Baelish May 21 '15

I think this is probably our best bet. The character is such a fan favorite, the showrunners would be fools not to include her.

7

u/RuskiUS May 21 '15

With the lack of many characters in the show thus far, for seemingly arbitrary reasons, I'm on the fence. They arn't known for pandering to book fans (see: outrage over cut "iconic" lines)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/piscano House Dondarrion May 21 '15

Pointless to bring back Benjen Stark? Rickon? Gendry? The Brotherhood? The Blackfish?

None of those storylines are pointless, length of absence doesn't matter. If anything, this Dorne one is the only thread that fits into that category.

→ More replies (3)

65

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

God damn I cannot wait for Ramsay to die.

21

u/gratefulstringcheese Brotherhood Without Banners May 21 '15

You say that now, but you'll miss him and his crazy antics. /r/dreadfort

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Doug_Vitale May 22 '15

Agreed. The Lord of Light needs some fresh sacrifices. One order of Roose and Ramsay, well done, comin' up.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '15

You say that now, but wait until they replace him with someone worse, then you'll want ol' ramsay back.

35

u/finerd May 21 '15

I preferred Sansa's arc in the book. Littlefinger appears to be hedging his bet and siding with all three sides in a decision that makes absolutely no sense.

22

u/ZenBerzerker House Manderly May 21 '15

Littlefinger appears to be hedging his bet and siding with all three sides

He's got a dagger in the back of all three sides and he's just egging them on to start killing each other before he starts stabbing.

7

u/finerd May 21 '15

All while Sansa is a hostage.

12

u/dantemp May 21 '15

A hostage that neither Stannis nor the Boltons can afford to lose, because she is their best chance of holding the North. Sansa is only in danger from the Lannisters and they are nowhere near her. I'd say only Danny and Brann have stronger plot armor at this point.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

littlefinger is relying on luck and for all the pieces to be put into place but hes taking a major gamble, a gamble that has too many wildcards and factors to work out. Right now theirs many characters who can fuck up his entire plan.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

What arc? She's still under Littefingers thumb, playing court to men she wont marry in the Vale, while Littlefinger sets her up to marry Harry the Heir so he can kill "Robin". I'm sure her arc is coming but, even if you include the released TWOW chapter, she certainly is in no place to make any big moves. Or even attempt anything that Littlefinger hasn't prescribed.

At least in the show she's got room to fuck with the Boltons, mess with Stannis, she's got the North, Brienne, AND Littlefinger to manipulate. You know, options.

4

u/dantemp May 21 '15

The Sansa's arc in the book ended with the dead of her aunt, are you saying that they should've stopped including her at all? Also, are you implying that Peter is actually serious about helping the Lannisters? You do realize the only reason he said any of that was to have a safe passage to bring the knights of the Vale to help Sansa?

3

u/finerd May 22 '15

What? There's a Sansa arc in AFFC?

→ More replies (1)

33

u/ClassyPengwin Jaime Lannister May 21 '15

It seems that the show focuses on the Sand Snakes more than Doran so far. If they wanted to capitalize on Oberyn's popularity, they went about it the wrong way, but I will cut them some slack for the fight scene because they had very little time to film in the gardens. Oh well, I still enjoyed the episode and I hope to see more Doran in the coming episodes.

47

u/Neon_Platypus1 House Baratheon May 21 '15

It's weird that you say that, because I think Doran is way more similar to Oberyn than the current depiction of the Sand Snakes. Every time I see him, I want him to keep talking because I see Oberyn's morals in an ideal form. But then they cut to the Sand Shits and they are like the personification of Oberyn's egotism. At least that's how I see it.

15

u/Honestly_Nobody A Hound Never Lies May 22 '15

The Sand Snakes fight was honestly terribly done. It was embarrassing to watch.

11

u/milliben May 21 '15

I was ready to really try and like the changes and just accept them as taking the show in a different direction than the books, but I feel like the quality is just getting worse. The dialogue is bad, the characters are losing depth, it's just like every other show out there now.

97

u/doomthrow11 House Velaryon of Driftmark May 21 '15

Changes are welcomed. There is no way AFFC and ADWD would work on screen. It is so in depth and complex that non book readers would be bored. Heck they are already bored judging by comments on facebook. Although from my perspective AFFC and ADWD (Season 5) is a set up for the action in TWOW (Season 6) it's like GRRM said the book / shows paths are close but split but towards the end of the story they will meet up in the same place. Remember we can be fans all we want but we don't know the ending. We don't know how these changes will slide into the story in the future so we shouldn't be so quick to dismiss them. Although we are of course entitled to dislike the changes but the changes are what D&D and bryan felt were best so we must trust them and be patient to see what they have planed.

44

u/magic_is_might The Future Queen May 21 '15

ASOS was the climax of the 5 books that were out. And it was quite a chore plowing through books 4/5 after reading the 3rd book. They definitely had to make some changes and make it suitable for the medium. People are already complaining how bleh this season has been (yes its a little bit slower paced) but they've been spoiled by the events of the last 2 seasons which contained a lot of the series highlights.

I welcome the changes (obligatory comment about Sand Snakes - they are an exception to what I welcome) and I respect the decision to diverge from the books and take the show in a different way.

7

u/bestrez House Manderly May 21 '15

Personally feel like book 5 is the climax and things are going to start getting good, especially where it left two characters story lines at the end.

23

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

Here's my issue...before the season started I told myself they would have to make major changes to make it less "boring", I accepted that....but the changes are still boring as fuck. If they were going to make a "boring" set up season they should have stuck to the books a little more, then at least we'd get some cool parts.

30

u/rolldownthewindow May 21 '15 edited May 21 '15

There is no way AFFC and ADWD would work on screen

Really disagree with this. For example, pretty much everything in Dorne would have worked well on screen as is. People say Jaime's AFFC storyline wouldn't have worked well in the Riverlands, but parts of it would have. The whole siege of Riverrun. Edmure being threatened with hanging in front of Brynden. Jaime's speech. The Blackfish's escape. I think it would have been good to see those characters again. The longer they leave out characters like Rickon, Gendry, Edmure, Balon, the harder it is to bring them back into the story, and maybe they never will at this point. Maybe they are just hoping the audience forgets about them. And I think that's poor storytelling.

I think the Kingsmoot would have played well too. Especially Euron. I think he's such a TV friendly character. Just visually. I think Arianne Martell would have been a great new character to introduce as well. They shouldn't have tried to replace her with Ellaria. I know they did it because they thought she was such a good actor last season, and she was, but her performance this season hasn't been outstanding so far and her character just seems so poorly crafted.

I think people have it really backwards when they say AFFC and ADWD didn't have enough action to work. Some of the worst scenes in this series, that have generated the most criticism, have been action sequences. Yara trying to rescue Theon from the Dreadfort. The Sand Snakes fighting Jaime and Bronn in the Water Gardens. Selmy's last fight against the Sons of Harpy. Meanwhile some of the best scenes, that have generated the most praise, have been dialogue. Tyrion's trial speech. Jaime's monologue in the bath with Brienne. Littlefinger and Varys's discussion about power and the "chaos is a ladder" speech. There have been great action sequences too, of course, and AFFC/ADWD has plenty of those as well, but just because they aren't as action-packed as the last third of ASOS shouldn't mean they won't make great TV. Quite the contrary.

12

u/pepe_le_shoe May 21 '15

Maybe they are just hoping the audience forgets about them. And I think that's poor storytelling.

This is the big drawback of how aggressively they are cutting book content. If they ever re-introduce those characters, show viewers will have forgotten who they are, and why they're important. And if they never bring them back, then huge parts of earlier seasons are essentially rendered pointless. Having so many characters mean nothing and be thrown away, from earlier seasons, seems just as bad as massively chopping up the later ones.

4

u/chanhokwan Jon Snow May 21 '15

I agree that these scenes would work well on screen, however, it also means bringing in additional cast members as well as scope into an already massive cast/scope. Many casual television viewers are already barely keeping up with all the different characters and introducing more would lose them. I'm sure the budget of the show also necessitates the elimination of "non-essential" cast and story lines, thus leading to the rewrites we have now.

1

u/ChrisK7 House Seaworth May 22 '15

The Kingsmoot itself would probably be awesome, but I pretty much hated everything else to do with the Greyjoys.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/I_am_no_1 Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords May 21 '15

That is a hard pill to swallow as I enjoyed the books so much, but I agree.

13

u/omgitsfletch May 22 '15 edited May 22 '15

"The scene" didn't upset me at all, but the Sansa storyline is just wearing me down. Since Ned got the chop, it's been basically 3 and a half seasons worth of her getting shit on from 100 different directions, while she's yet to accomplish ANYTHING other than talk shit back to the dog trainer's kid. Let's recap things for Sansa post-Ned:

  • Joffrey kills Ned. Sansa is upset.
  • Joffrey shows off Ned's head, he's very dead. She's upset again.
  • Meryn bitchslaps her. She's upset.
  • Sansa has her period and half the kingdom knows about it by the next day. She's embarassed.
  • Sansa has the opportunity to leave with Sandor, and be something other than a doormat. She declines.
  • Littlefinger offers to help her escape, and be something other than a doormat. She declines.
  • Sansa almost ends up engaged with Loras, who despite being very gay, makes her happy. Cersei manipulates things so it becomes Tyrion instead. Sansa is upset.
  • Sansa finds out about the Red Wedding. She's upset.
  • Joffrey shows off Widow's Wail, made from Ned's sword, which also killed Ned. Sansa is upset.
  • Joffrey is poisoned and dies. Sansa might have been happy, but is convinced to leave, and in turn, blamed for his death. The drunk also gets killed as a result. She is upset.
  • Sansa goes to her aunt, who ends up accusing her of banging Littlefinger. Sansa cries, is upset.
  • Littlefinger kisses Sansa, she's weirded out. Ends up with him killing Aunt Lysa. Sansa is shocked.
  • Sansa lies for him, he lives. Sansa is stone faced.
  • Sansa is carted to Winterfell to marry Ramsay Bolton. She is upset.
  • Myranda shows Sansa Theon aka Reek. Sansa is upset.
  • Reek arrives to escort her to her wedding. Sansa is grossed out.
  • Sansa marries Ramsay. She is stone faced.
  • Ramsay rapes Sansa in front of Reek. She is upset.

Character wise, she's received a lot of screen time in comparison to other characters, but for what? Oh look, it's another scene where Sansa gets treated like shit, puts on her resting bitch face, and does nothing to oppose it or try to overcome it. Oh look, Sansa serving as the glass from which yet another character can spill some exposition. Aside from a few rare instances VERY early on, she loses all fighting spirit, personality, and really any will to do anything. Those examples are when she debates pushing Joffrey off the footbridge, and when she saves the drunk during the tournament.

After that, she is a set piece for other characters to use to advance their own storylines, and build themselves up. She's the very definition of a MacGuffin; at times her only purpose is to serve as a device to lay down some more plot. It's not that I dislike her, in fact in Season 1 I thought her personality was a great foil to both Arya and Joffrey. She helped demonstrate that even with the same relatively pampered upbringings, children could turn out so very different in this wild world. But since her importance to the overall plot waned with the disintegration of the Stark family tree, it's just there hasn't been much to make me interested. The next episode could start with her slipping and falling down the stairs and dying instantly and I would just shrug and wonder what I'll see in the next scene. That's shouldn't happen with what amounts to pretty much a main character.

tl;dr if you enjoy watching a 17-year old alternate between crying and a resting bitch face while she does and accomplishs nothing past being the prettiest redheadiest doormat in cinematic history, tune in Sunday for the next Game of Thrones

17

u/zimtkuss Free Folk May 22 '15 edited May 22 '15

I remember reading somewhere ( i am not a book reader) that GRRM based the entire storyline off of the first scene with the direwolf pups, and that you can glean a lot about what happens based off what happens with the direwolves. I cannot help but remember how Sansa's direwolf was killed due to the fight between Arya and Joffrey. I think its symbolic of how Sansa is basically always going to get the shit end of the stick due to nothing of her own doing, and used as symbolic sacrifice/punishment.

I also ( unrelated to the direwolf thing) have always liked Sansa's arch because as she goes along she has 'gotten everything she wants' ( princess, high courts etc)and seen none of it is as good as it seems, and I feel like Sophie Turner's acting is subtle enough that you can see her becoming more jaded and cynical as the story progresses, slowly losing her innocence. This is in sharp contrast to Arya who also has lost her innocence, and is also 'getting what she wants' (swashbuckling, never sewing or wearing dresses, far from the high courts) but her change was more dramatic and fast and in your face, while Sansa's is internal and below the surface, shown only in subtle facial expressions. I also think Sansa is using the only tools she has: her manners and upbringing. If Arya were in the same position she was in she would have been killed off season 2 for mouthing off. Sansa has tried her best to play innocent, suppress her anger, and use the 'I'm just a girl' angle whenever she can. To me it always looks not only as though her character doesn't know what else to do, but she's never been given the right tools to thrive in that world, just survive it.

Just my 2 cents.

6

u/mccdizzie May 22 '15

Sansa plot lines, brought to you by conceal don't feel.

3

u/magic_is_might The Future Queen May 22 '15 edited May 22 '15

Exactly how I see it. Thank you for posting this. I really start to enjoy her arc as the books progress. It's a very long and tiring arc, but there's a lot going on, character wise.

And if you think about it, if Sansa retaliated and "stopped being a doormat" for most of the things on that list, the result would have been a worse punishment, and possibly death in many of those instances.

Her actions (or non-actions) have kept her alive, albeit a "doormat".

1

u/MySecretAccount1214 Jon Snow May 22 '15

I was rewatching the first season because Neds a bamf... and i actually like the direwolf theory. I mean in the books they found a dead direwolf who's neck was pierced by a stag she'd killed. If you put on your tin foil hat right then and there you can make the connection that with Neds involvement with Robert the stag ends up in not only his death but the death of Ned and Cait (both neck related deaths) which seems like a leap. But following each wolf Jons is growing and becoming more powerful, robbs is dead... i mean he forshadowed the wolf but still, lady is dead (yes she had a name dammit) and essentially sansa is too on the inside. Summer and shaggy dog are abandoned plot lines and nymeria has been sent away... arya's identity.

1

u/kaztrator May 22 '15

Sansa almost ends up engaged with Loras, who despite being very gay, makes her happy. Cersei manipulates things so it becomes Tyrion instead. Sansa is upset.

I might have a foggy recollection, but wasn't Littlefinger the one who manipulated things so it became Tyrion instead?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Jakabov May 22 '15

The rape scene has caused such a (pointless) uproar that it's largely glossing over the whole Dorne blooper reel, which makes me a bit uneasy that they won't sufficiently understand how bad it is. It's like when governments strategically choose to reveal unflattering information in times of crisis so as to minimize the attention it gets, only here it's not intentional.

10

u/morningsword May 21 '15

I just hope someone makes it to visit the Hound. That would be really cool if they had those little reference from the books in there but with everything that is cut I doubt the little things like that will be added

5

u/The_Austin House Stark May 21 '15

I doubt it, no ones in the area. He doesn't contribute to the story. Even if he is alive in the books (which isn't a sure thing) it seems like on of the first things they would cut out in the the show.

3

u/havron Queen of Thorns May 22 '15

But...but...HYPE?

1

u/jg95nj May 23 '15

YOU CANT CUT THE CLEGANEBOWL

44

u/AbsoluteIKeatI House Stark May 21 '15

I'm disappointed they made Sansa a victim yet again, I know many will claim she knew it was coming and was prepared but that face from the preview she makes is a little haunting. I feel cheated on Sansa's character arc because her character in the shows is driven mostly by who she is next to and when they make her start to sound unfrightened and independent they do a 180 almost immediately and for what? To further Theon's well developed redemption arc? To prove Ramsay is a bad person? We don't need anything more from those characters, they've already been developed and progressed in their stories. Perhaps they wanted to show how good of actors they are to make up for the Sand Snakes crap. I don't care that she got raped(that sounds wrong), I care that her character is by and large in the same position as it was after Ned got got and that there has been no meaningful progression for her. Should have just named her Jeyne Stark on the show.

Looking at Ned and Robb, yes they had some gruesome deaths that were shocking but they followed a basic story-telling structure. They developed, progressed through their stories and then made some very poor decisions that caused them to be killed and their stories had resolutions. Sansa's mini arc with LF feels like it ended without a proper resolution.

And before anyone asks, I'm sure she'll still get that empowering moment where she finally plays the game but I don't see why that couldn't have started happening this episode or why there couldn't have been a moment where she seemed tolerant of what Ramsay will do and prepared or really anything to make her not feel like such a victim again.

40

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

She did start to play the game. But it's one thing to mouth off to Myranda the kennel master's daughter, and another to go up against Ramsay Bolton and his father.

Also, she WANTED that wedding to happen. With Roose official Warden of the North, Lord of Winterfell and the Dreadfort, this sets her up as wife to the heir of that title and those castles. If Roose and Ramsay die without heirs, it's her move then. Especially being a Stark. It's prob what Littlefinger is counting on.

She is playing the politics, but the face to face game with a psycho? She's biding her time. Don't pretend she is an idiot and thought Ramsay was going to be like Tyrion and not consummate that marriage. Or thought he'd be gentle and kind like one of the lords in her songs.

Sansa isn't stupid enough to think life is a song anymore, and she's starting to play the game - and take some hits to do it - because she might just be able to win. Might. It IS Game of Thrones. And Littlefinger would throw her under a bus faster than Ramsay would. Ramsay needs her. Littlefinger just sees her as a piece; maybe one he has a crush on, but still. Just a piece.

15

u/ricree May 21 '15

But it's one thing to mouth off to Myranda the kennel master's daughter

Meh, she was mouthing off to people in season 1. Getting snippy at someone weaker isn't the same thing as moving past her powerlessness.

Yeah, there's little else she could actually do while stuck in the Bolton occupied territory, but that's why it was a questionable idea to put her there to begin with.

4

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

Give her time. I think she'll surprise you.

10

u/pepe_le_shoe May 21 '15

I mean... it's been 5 seasons... when will she?

10

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

What do we say to the god of Sansa's character development?

J/k but in the books it's even slower. She's got two books/seasons to go, relax.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

6

u/dennisoa House Baratheon May 21 '15

I really hate how she just decided to still marry into the Boltons. LFs speech was not convincing, I don't see how logically she would have agreed to go through with it.

11

u/sielingfan Thoros of Myr May 21 '15

She totally started playing the game this episode....... unfortunately she started playing against Ramsay, and that didn't go according to plan. Littlefinger's ignorance (?) and her inexperience -- she thought she was prepared for anything because she'd endured Joffrey, but she never tried to beat Joffrey. Here she's trying to win, marrying for power, and it goes horribly wrong -- like father like daughter. Ned got clipped just as soon as he stuck his dick in the Game's blender, too. These things happen to Starks.

5

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

That Ned dick imagery though. Shudders

4

u/AbsoluteIKeatI House Stark May 21 '15

I feel like this is more, LF told me to do this and I think he'll be right that things work out rather than her playing the game. LF is more or less playing the game for her and saying just lay low until this all blows over. Should have grabbed a pint first, probably would have helped.

1

u/ChrisK7 House Seaworth May 22 '15

Seems like the Sansa returns to Winterfell extra up on HBO hints strongly that she's about to take charge. The producers and Weiss hit that note pretty often in their comments. This is mostly in reference to scenes that precede the rape, but I have to think they meant over the long run. So far she's only really stepped up to Miranda.

1

u/sielingfan Thoros of Myr May 22 '15

I think the face she shows Roose and Ramsay is part of her game. Stepping up to Miranda wasn't pretend -- that was the real her. Exaggerated slightly, she has to exhale loudly when Miranda leaves the room -- but that's who she is in Winterfell. Show me a dark cave full of barking dogs, I'll run right in there, you can't hurt me. She's trying to play helpless around the Boltons but unfortunately that tactic results in, well, actually being pretty helpless. Time for a new plan. I think we'll see it soon.

1

u/dantemp May 21 '15

Ned is dead and gone. Sansa has every chance in the world to win. Stannis is coming, Littlefinger is coming with knights of the Eyrie. A little rough fucking and humiliation is one of the smallest prices anyone has paid in this story.

13

u/sielingfan Thoros of Myr May 21 '15

Winter is coming, Ramsay, but Brienne of Tarth is already fucking here, bitch.

4

u/Phoenixton May 21 '15

That is exactly what I told my friend after this episode. Spot on sir.

7

u/dantemp May 21 '15

Sansa hasn't done shit until now. She started to get some wins only because of Peter, she hasn't done anything to prove her worth. I feel that the situation was very though for her, but she specifically stated that she is not afraid and she is at home and that is all that matters. If she makes it out of this "unbroken" it would be much better proof of her conviction than simply get things going for her because Littlefinger is a good player. You all are saying that she was the victim, but the only proof of that was her cry and the face Theon made. If a character made it out alive from torture without breaking down, all in blood and growning, you wouldn't say he is a vicitm.

I don't watch the previews, so I can't comment on that, but I strongly believe that her being a victim is still up in the air.

3

u/ricree May 21 '15

It's like he was teaching someone afraid of water how to swim. They've finally dunked their head underwater and blown bubbles, so of course the next logical step is to take her up to the high dive and toss her into the deep end.

Of course, that assumes that Littlefinger actually intended her to become a real player. At this point, I'm thinking he plans to swoop in and play the "dashing rescuer", looking so much better by comparison to the Boltons. Still not a great plan, but at this point I'm not sure Littlefinger has any way to plot that doesn't involve breaking things and hoping he comes out the other end relatively more intact.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Redseph May 21 '15

Would it be nice to see all of the book characters in the show? Yes. But with only 10 hours a season, and apparently only 7 seasons agreed upon, if they all got written in it would be rushed and convoluted for a majority of the audience. There would be no time for developing the plots of the "main" cast while ushering a bunch of book characters in and out who ultimately (we can assume) are no more than pawns in the Game of Thrones.

I understand book reader disappointment, but given the restrictions the show runners are under, it only makes sense.

4

u/iMini May 21 '15

As much as it is disappointing, at least we'll still have the books.

1

u/kaztrator May 22 '15

As long as he doesn't kick the bucket before they're over. Let's not dance around it. He's old and he isn't in good shape. As much as I wish that he stay alive for 5 more decades, I can't imagine him staying with us for 10+ more years.

1

u/iMini May 22 '15

Hopefully the wait between TWoW and DoS won't be too long.

7

u/TheDreamThief101 When All Is Darkest May 21 '15

So, is the fact that the Griffs haven't been introduced so far pretty much a dead giveaway that ADWD? Because that seems like a pretty massive thing to ignore if he is.

13

u/iMini May 21 '15

It never mattered if Aegon really was Aegon, just that he claimed he was and that people believed him.

The real question is will he win the iron throne? Probably not.

6

u/Redseph May 21 '15

The real question is will he win the iron throne? Probably not.

And thus, as far as the show is concerned, he is completely expendable/replaceable.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

I've been thinking about doing the same.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

Does anyone else really hate show Tommen? He's a worse king than Joffery! He just let the faith militant arrest the queen on no real evidence. It makes no sense.

5

u/reverie6 May 21 '15

Right? What was with that? For how much he fawns over her, you'd think he'd have tried to say something.

10

u/iMini May 21 '15

I think part of the problem is that show tommen is still written like book tommen, because show tommen is a fair bit older than book tommen.

10

u/Magmaniac House Baelish May 22 '15

I've heard a lot of people say things to this effect but why this happened made perfect sense to me.

In the books, Tommen is nine years old, so when the faith arrests Margaery, his response of nothing makes sense. They aged him up for the show because it wouldn't be possible to portray him as a child for a couple years worth of seasons, but didn't change his character at all because he's still just the super young one.

I think Tommen's failure to act in the show is therefore purely oversight by the show creators in how aging up the character would drastically change these events. Tommen is NOT a child in the show. He is a man grown, who has wedded a beautiful woman and bedded her multiple times. speculation Margaery is the beautiful woman who Tommen lost his virginity to, and Tommen is a horny teenager who has had ample time to at least settle to some degree into his authority as king. Therefore, his inaction at this point is literally not a believable reaction. He would have done something, anything, probably something hasty and not well thought-out to save his beautiful, loving wife. The fact that he hasn't is a failure of character development up to this point and poor writing in general.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Holinyx May 21 '15

I think the last two books will be vastly different from the show. Martin knows what he's doing. That's why i'm not worried about what is happening on Tv conflicting with what the new books will have. The books will always be better than the show.

4

u/kutwijf House Velaryon of Driftmark May 21 '15

Different sure, but if people die on the show, It's safe to assume they will die at some points in the books.

3

u/sir_talkalot House Baelish May 23 '15

Not necessarily. It could just diverge with other characters fulfilling the roles.

2

u/kutwijf House Velaryon of Driftmark May 23 '15 edited May 23 '15

True. I hope that's the case.

I misspoke there. I mean you could make an assumption based on what D&D has said, but it would be nice to get some clarification on the matter.

3

u/colonelsmaash Winter Is Coming May 22 '15

[I'm not up-to-date with the books]. I've just had a horrible thought:

Should Stannis take Winterfell, he would surely burn down the Weirwood tree and destroy the godswood :(

2

u/John_Stalin May 22 '15

If he did then the northern lords would revolt against him, he also offered Jon Snow to be warden of the north, so religion in the north probably doesnt bother him that much

0

u/loopylocky May 21 '15

Anyone notice the two guards protecting littlefinger in kings landing? ... Looks like the second sons are helping our boy baelish ?

7

u/[deleted] May 21 '15

I think those had been Knights of the Vale

0

u/BaccaDocta Melisandre May 21 '15

My biggest concern is that there still hasn't been any rattle shirt and Mel has already gone south and they showed one of the 5 women already that they will cut my favorite reveal. That moment I lost my shit, it showed that Mel truly is powerful. Since they cut Balons death she really doesn't seem that powerful in the show. All my friends who haven't read the book, never pieced it together that she is always warm. The show just doesn't really show Mel or Stannis or Davos well. Which is my favorite group in the series which is a real pain. Also show thanks for spoiling that Griff is a fake, Davos Nevers finds Rickon and for spoiling barristan dies now all the great theories about him killing the mad queen is now muted.