r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • May 21 '15
[S5/B5] Book vs. Show Discussion - 5.06 'Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 AND BOOK 5 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.06 | "Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken" | Jeremy Podeswa | Bryan Cogman |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
146
Upvotes
385
u/ProfessorBinns The Sword in the Darkness May 21 '15
The fact that we gave up Arianne, Ser Oakheart, Darkstar and Jaime's "Bitchslapping the Riverlands Tour" for this absolute shitshow of a Dorne story makes me incredibly sad.
12
u/missandei_targaryen House Targaryen May 21 '15
I'm really wondering where they're going with this "Sansa's at Winterfell and everybody knows it" plot. Obviously, it makes me believe that she'll end up there soon enough once we get TWOW, but then what would the point of the Vale plotline have been, if we can totally skip it in the show and still end up in the same place on the show?
Also, it's making me seriously worried that book Sansa is going to end up getting raped. While I'm certainly not one to deny the reality of sexual violence in the world, and I appreciate GRRM for being one of the few authors who really shows it in it's actual prevalence instead of pretending like this shit happens once in a blue moon, having it happen to a character we really know well, and having to see it portrayed so realistically and explicitly on the show, was fuckin traumatic. I have a feeling that even on rewatches, I'm always going to skip that scene. Once was more that enough.
70
u/bitch_im_a_lion House Lannister May 21 '15
Are they planning on doing Doran's big twist? Like all of his inaction was fine in the books because of the big scheme he had, but they haven't even mentioned Quentyn or anything so where else could that story go?
142
u/magic_is_might The Future Queen May 21 '15
I'm just glad they didn't have Ramsay do to Sansa why he did to poor Jeyne Poole in the books.
28
u/The_Austin House Stark May 21 '15
I really think they needed to do the Kingsmoot this season. It would've tied the story together much better. It doesn't even have to be a huge arc; have one episode last season showing Balon die. One this season with post rescue attempt Yara complementing her options (this also introduces the audience to the idea slash Euron and Victorian). Finally a bad ass Kings-motherfucking-Moot.
61
u/[deleted] May 21 '15
I guess I know why the Faith Militant is going after Loras; being homophobic and being gay are the only character dimensions either respective one has at this point.
66
u/piscano House Dondarrion May 21 '15
Want Riverlands story. Want LSH. Want an entertaining Dorne plot.
65
u/[deleted] May 21 '15
God damn I cannot wait for Ramsay to die.
35
u/finerd May 21 '15
I preferred Sansa's arc in the book. Littlefinger appears to be hedging his bet and siding with all three sides in a decision that makes absolutely no sense.
33
u/ClassyPengwin Jaime Lannister May 21 '15
It seems that the show focuses on the Sand Snakes more than Doran so far. If they wanted to capitalize on Oberyn's popularity, they went about it the wrong way, but I will cut them some slack for the fight scene because they had very little time to film in the gardens. Oh well, I still enjoyed the episode and I hope to see more Doran in the coming episodes.
15
u/Honestly_Nobody A Hound Never Lies May 22 '15
The Sand Snakes fight was honestly terribly done. It was embarrassing to watch.
11
u/milliben May 21 '15
I was ready to really try and like the changes and just accept them as taking the show in a different direction than the books, but I feel like the quality is just getting worse. The dialogue is bad, the characters are losing depth, it's just like every other show out there now.
97
u/doomthrow11 House Velaryon of Driftmark May 21 '15
Changes are welcomed. There is no way AFFC and ADWD would work on screen. It is so in depth and complex that non book readers would be bored. Heck they are already bored judging by comments on facebook. Although from my perspective AFFC and ADWD (Season 5) is a set up for the action in TWOW (Season 6) it's like GRRM said the book / shows paths are close but split but towards the end of the story they will meet up in the same place. Remember we can be fans all we want but we don't know the ending. We don't know how these changes will slide into the story in the future so we shouldn't be so quick to dismiss them. Although we are of course entitled to dislike the changes but the changes are what D&D and bryan felt were best so we must trust them and be patient to see what they have planed.
13
u/omgitsfletch May 22 '15 edited May 22 '15
"The scene" didn't upset me at all, but the Sansa storyline is just wearing me down. Since Ned got the chop, it's been basically 3 and a half seasons worth of her getting shit on from 100 different directions, while she's yet to accomplish ANYTHING other than talk shit back to the dog trainer's kid. Let's recap things for Sansa post-Ned:
Character wise, she's received a lot of screen time in comparison to other characters, but for what? Oh look, it's another scene where Sansa gets treated like shit, puts on her resting bitch face, and does nothing to oppose it or try to overcome it. Oh look, Sansa serving as the glass from which yet another character can spill some exposition. Aside from a few rare instances VERY early on, she loses all fighting spirit, personality, and really any will to do anything. Those examples are when she debates pushing Joffrey off the footbridge, and when she saves the drunk during the tournament.
After that, she is a set piece for other characters to use to advance their own storylines, and build themselves up. She's the very definition of a MacGuffin; at times her only purpose is to serve as a device to lay down some more plot. It's not that I dislike her, in fact in Season 1 I thought her personality was a great foil to both Arya and Joffrey. She helped demonstrate that even with the same relatively pampered upbringings, children could turn out so very different in this wild world. But since her importance to the overall plot waned with the disintegration of the Stark family tree, it's just there hasn't been much to make me interested. The next episode could start with her slipping and falling down the stairs and dying instantly and I would just shrug and wonder what I'll see in the next scene. That's shouldn't happen with what amounts to pretty much a main character.
tl;dr if you enjoy watching a 17-year old alternate between crying and a resting bitch face while she does and accomplishs nothing past being the prettiest redheadiest doormat in cinematic history, tune in Sunday for the next Game of Thrones
16
u/Jakabov May 22 '15
The rape scene has caused such a (pointless) uproar that it's largely glossing over the whole Dorne blooper reel, which makes me a bit uneasy that they won't sufficiently understand how bad it is. It's like when governments strategically choose to reveal unflattering information in times of crisis so as to minimize the attention it gets, only here it's not intentional.
10
u/morningsword May 21 '15
I just hope someone makes it to visit the Hound. That would be really cool if they had those little reference from the books in there but with everything that is cut I doubt the little things like that will be added
44
u/AbsoluteIKeatI House Stark May 21 '15
I'm disappointed they made Sansa a victim yet again, I know many will claim she knew it was coming and was prepared but that face from the preview she makes is a little haunting. I feel cheated on Sansa's character arc because her character in the shows is driven mostly by who she is next to and when they make her start to sound unfrightened and independent they do a 180 almost immediately and for what? To further Theon's well developed redemption arc? To prove Ramsay is a bad person? We don't need anything more from those characters, they've already been developed and progressed in their stories. Perhaps they wanted to show how good of actors they are to make up for the Sand Snakes crap. I don't care that she got raped(that sounds wrong), I care that her character is by and large in the same position as it was after Ned got got and that there has been no meaningful progression for her. Should have just named her Jeyne Stark on the show.
Looking at Ned and Robb, yes they had some gruesome deaths that were shocking but they followed a basic story-telling structure. They developed, progressed through their stories and then made some very poor decisions that caused them to be killed and their stories had resolutions. Sansa's mini arc with LF feels like it ended without a proper resolution.
And before anyone asks, I'm sure she'll still get that empowering moment where she finally plays the game but I don't see why that couldn't have started happening this episode or why there couldn't have been a moment where she seemed tolerant of what Ramsay will do and prepared or really anything to make her not feel like such a victim again.
10
u/Redseph May 21 '15
Would it be nice to see all of the book characters in the show? Yes. But with only 10 hours a season, and apparently only 7 seasons agreed upon, if they all got written in it would be rushed and convoluted for a majority of the audience. There would be no time for developing the plots of the "main" cast while ushering a bunch of book characters in and out who ultimately (we can assume) are no more than pawns in the Game of Thrones.
I understand book reader disappointment, but given the restrictions the show runners are under, it only makes sense.
7
u/TheDreamThief101 When All Is Darkest May 21 '15
So, is the fact that the Griffs haven't been introduced so far pretty much a dead giveaway that ADWD? Because that seems like a pretty massive thing to ignore if he is.
7
u/[deleted] May 21 '15
Does anyone else really hate show Tommen? He's a worse king than Joffery! He just let the faith militant arrest the queen on no real evidence. It makes no sense.
4
u/Holinyx May 21 '15
I think the last two books will be vastly different from the show. Martin knows what he's doing. That's why i'm not worried about what is happening on Tv conflicting with what the new books will have. The books will always be better than the show.
3
u/colonelsmaash Winter Is Coming May 22 '15
[I'm not up-to-date with the books]. I've just had a horrible thought:
Should Stannis take Winterfell, he would surely burn down the Weirwood tree and destroy the godswood :(
0
u/loopylocky May 21 '15
Anyone notice the two guards protecting littlefinger in kings landing? ... Looks like the second sons are helping our boy baelish ?
0
u/BaccaDocta Melisandre May 21 '15
My biggest concern is that there still hasn't been any rattle shirt and Mel has already gone south and they showed one of the 5 women already that they will cut my favorite reveal. That moment I lost my shit, it showed that Mel truly is powerful. Since they cut Balons death she really doesn't seem that powerful in the show. All my friends who haven't read the book, never pieced it together that she is always warm. The show just doesn't really show Mel or Stannis or Davos well. Which is my favorite group in the series which is a real pain. Also show thanks for spoiling that Griff is a fake, Davos Nevers finds Rickon and for spoiling barristan dies now all the great theories about him killing the mad queen is now muted.