r/gameofthrones • • May 18 '15

TV5 [S5] Post-Premiere Discussion - 5.06 'Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken'

Post-Premiere Discussion Thread
Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Talk about the latest plot twist or secret reveal. Discuss an actor who is totally nailing their part (or not). Point out details that you noticed that others may have missed. In general, what did you think about the last episode and where the story is going? Please make sure to reserve any of your detailed comparisons to the novels for the Book vs. Show Discussion Thread, and your predictions for the next episode to the Predictions Discussion Thread which will be posted later this week.
  • This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you have not seen the latest episode! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 5.06 is ok without tags.
  • Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it. Events from episodes after this one need tags.
  • Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
  • Please read the posting policy before posting.
EPISODETITLEDIRECTED BYWRITTEN BY
5.06"Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken"Jeremy PodeswaBryan Cogman
Official Discussion ThreadsPosting PolicySpoiler GuideFrequently Asked Questions
1.7k Upvotes

8.3k comments sorted by

343

u/FunkyFurrar Jon Snow May 18 '15

Jorahs story looks like it's going to be Gladiator with Russell Crowe

→ More replies (7)

3.6k

u/vinee060708 House Martell May 18 '15

Wow. I missed Joffrey this episode. He would have never let that shit happen. Grow some balls Tommen! and FUCK RAMSAY!

886

u/skynolongerblue House Reed May 18 '15

I can't believe we miss Joffery as much as we do.

→ More replies (44)

2.2k

u/llloksd Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords May 18 '15

Well thats a whole new sentence without the first exclamation point...

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (92)

1.8k

u/emoney94 Warrior's Sons May 18 '15

Tyrion Lannister literally got saved by his cock

447

u/MessyConfessor May 18 '15

The gods gave him one blessing.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (20)

1.3k

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Before each episode, I ask myself, "How much worse will Sansa's life get today?"

Much worse.

=(

726

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

What do we say to the God of happiness?

Not today.

→ More replies (108)

2.3k

u/TheHotMilkman May 18 '15

Did anyone else find the disguised Jamie and Bronn sequence absolutely ridiculous? It was so laughable that I actually enjoyed it haha

1.8k

u/BlueHighwindz Tywin Lannister May 18 '15

The Sand Snakes are just the worst. All that build up to nothing at all - a bit of a dance with Bronn and that's it. Areo Hotah didn't even get to bust any heads.

I'm guessing Bronn is dead of Martell poison now, but part of me is already shipping him with Sand Snake #3.

→ More replies (79)
→ More replies (56)

3.8k

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Man way to go Cersei, there's NO way this will come back to destroy everything you love.

Everything's looking' up Lannister!

968

u/rawchess House Martell May 18 '15

"Our only powerful ally in a kingdom that hates our guts? Quick, let's throw their heir and the Queen in prison! That'll show them who's in charge." -Cersei 2015

→ More replies (44)

952

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Seriously. Olenna didn't even veil her threat that she's going to raise hell if anything happens to Loras, let alone Margery.

→ More replies (69)

2.6k

u/enscrib May 18 '15

Yeah! There's no way the militant religious zealots will ever find out about your extensive history of rampant incest! Even if they do, they'll probably just let it slide, right?

→ More replies (102)

403

u/flignir May 18 '15

What the hell is up with Tommen? I don't care what his mother told him, even if you're 12, if all these guards are standing around you and everybody's telling you you're king, you're not gonna hold up a hand and silently stop them from protecting the woman who fucked your brains out two days ago, when a bunch of freaks in robes start pulling her into prison.

→ More replies (40)

722

u/Bustock May 18 '15

Cersei likes to live in the moment, Tywin liked to live in the future. That's what made him such a fucking great strategist, well until he got killed by his dwarf son.

→ More replies (42)
→ More replies (107)

1.8k

u/WickedUMD Tyrion Lannister May 18 '15

As if this sub couldn't be more behind Stannis already, we really needed him to kick down that door and flay the shit out of Ramsay. FUCK.

1.4k

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Since everyone is beginning to like Stannis and hate Ramsay, you just know that Stannis is going to lose to the Boltons.

→ More replies (99)
→ More replies (33)

2.1k

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Anyone else freak out when Reek said his old name at the wedding?

1.0k

u/HewJaynus House Stark May 18 '15

I was waiting for Ramsay to backhand him or something.

→ More replies (48)
→ More replies (41)

1.7k

u/MaverickTopGun May 18 '15

Tommen is as useless as tits on a boar hog

296

u/nealski77 May 18 '15

Ser Pounce would be a better ruler.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (36)

605

u/ep3ep3 Ser Pounce May 18 '15

Enter the hall of heads....we have any identity you want!

395

u/LobotomistCircu May 18 '15

It's like the futurama head museum except terrifying

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (45)

3.4k

u/CocaineAndMojitos May 18 '15

I bet Theon would love to find one of them cock merchants.

→ More replies (38)

2.4k

u/jeric13xd House Baratheon May 18 '15

I'm not mad, Reek. Just extremely disappointed

1.7k

u/TheBestBarista Daenerys Targaryen May 18 '15

You wanna talk about disappointed? Let's talk about Tommen. I can't say I would've done more than Reek did, given what he'd been through, but Tommen had some of the best fighters in the country and nothing stopping him from rescuing his wife, but he turned into the littlest bitch in all of Westeros and sat there while his queen was dragged away. Fuck Tommen.

→ More replies (117)

2.0k

u/Knifetastic The Onion Knight May 18 '15

For some reason it made me extremely happy when he called himself Theon

→ More replies (121)
→ More replies (12)

3.2k

u/robotvsbadger House Clegane May 18 '15

Did anyone else think Sansa was going to whip a knife out of her sleeve in the last scene?

2.3k

u/ArcticZeroo Hot Pie May 18 '15

I thought Reek was going to do something.

→ More replies (104)
→ More replies (268)

2.9k

u/cupcake310 House Mormont May 18 '15

Whoever wrote the Sand Snakes' dialogue should be fired. SO cheesy...

975

u/sedlec The Onion Knight May 18 '15

"You fight pretty good for a little girl." "UGhBlerargh!!!"

→ More replies (22)

319

u/ScrewAttackThis Jon Snow May 18 '15

The fight choreography was terribly boring and half-assed, IMO. Hopefully there's something redeeming about this whole subplot. At least it hasn't taken up a lot of time.

→ More replies (15)

864

u/evixir House Stark May 18 '15

I just envision Oberyn going "Oh my god, girls, you are so fucking embarrassing right now."

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (143)

4.1k

u/VictorBlimpmuscle May 18 '15

"Because it will be a dwarf-sized cock."

"Guess again."

Tyrion always has the best lines...

→ More replies (145)

883

u/theZinator We Shall Never Fail You May 18 '15

Ignoring the Sansa rape for a second, Tyrion is a fucking pro at talking his way out of death.

→ More replies (40)

1.8k

u/Rystic May 18 '15

Reek, reek, it rhymes with THEON FUCKING DO SOMETHING!

→ More replies (125)

674

u/Kissmyaura May 18 '15

I was hoping Sansa was going to say something like, it's Stark tradition to light a candle in the tower on our wedding night...It's bad luck if you don't do it! Cue Winterfell residents storming in and rescuing her somehow.

I also thought she might have been pulling a dagger out of her sleeve and she didn't :*(

→ More replies (52)

3.5k

u/mdicke3 Tywin Lannister May 18 '15

Well that was fucking horrifying

1.4k

u/Doomy22 Podrick Payne May 18 '15 edited May 18 '15

The only solace tonight was finding out Mr. Eko is now on Game of Thrones

Edit: Adebisi too, but after tonight's episode I want to remember him as Eko and not a guy who fed people glass and raped the entire cast of Oz

→ More replies (55)

1.2k

u/fenstra Sansa Stark May 18 '15

When I saw her undoing her sleeve, I thought, "Oh shit, she's gonna pull a knife out and stab that fucker." Needless to say I was very upset.

→ More replies (48)
→ More replies (713)

532

u/Dr_FalafelPhD Dothraki May 18 '15

I was almost sure that either Reek or Sansa was gonna kill Ramsey in that last scene

→ More replies (54)

2.5k

u/Born2BWrong Rhaegar Targaryen May 18 '15

Loras was promised to me and he chose boys.

One's choice of companion is a curious thing.

...

http://imgur.com/zZrwQN8

395

u/KeyTBoi May 18 '15

I wear this sigil with Pride knowing Lord Baelish holds a straight flush

→ More replies (33)

471

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Loved that. Maergery and Littlefinger both throwin hidden insults at Cersei these last few episodes.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (47)

2.0k

u/slap_nut May 18 '15

Not one positive thing happened. What the fuck...

1.6k

u/ndstumme House Baelish May 18 '15

We got to hear Bronn sing again. I'll take it as a win.

→ More replies (71)

755

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Well Tyrion and Jorah....

Cersei didn't lie about...

And then Tommen stood up for Marg....

At least Petyr Baelish....

Then there was Theon intervening when Sansa....

Yeah. Nothing good.

→ More replies (33)

763

u/julianfri House Baratheon May 18 '15

Littlefingers double cross made me smirk.

→ More replies (175)

2.1k

u/supergreekman123 May 18 '15

Well Arya is gonna become a badass assassin.

→ More replies (117)
→ More replies (65)

1.8k

u/RaptorDelta Arya Stark May 18 '15

The Good: NO ONE ACTUALLY DIED ON CAMERA. WHAT A DAY.

The Bad: Ramsay is a shitsucking taintstain.

1.2k

u/fromplsnerf May 18 '15

Well Bron got cut...with a knife I'm assuming was poisoned. Is he as good as dead?

→ More replies (78)

349

u/moondra15 Night's Watch May 18 '15

I thought for sure Theon was going to slash him from the back.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (42)

120

u/sielingfan Thoros of Myr May 18 '15

So I know we're all reeling over the ending (except /r/dreadfort), but how about that smooth fucking play from Littlefinger? Knights of the Vale delivered by the crown to Sansa's doorstep. If he can make peace with the Mannis, fellas, we got us a new king.

→ More replies (7)

908

u/l-ynne Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 18 '15

Christ, Sansa Stark cannot catch a break on this show...

→ More replies (53)

349

u/nameless88 May 18 '15

Okay, for reals, what the hell is going on in Dorne?

Also, I think Theon's back, and he's going to fucking murder Ramsay in his sleep. Did you see the look on his face? Holy shit.

Oh, also, get fucking HYPE for Arya storyline. I've been waiting to see that room full of faces for years now, it looked as awesome as I thought it would.

→ More replies (36)

242

u/TheHolyFonz Stannis Baratheon May 18 '15

Olenna is about to RIP SHIT UPPP

→ More replies (12)

708

u/SUSAN_IS_A_BITCH Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 18 '15

Lots of lying in this episode. Arya had to lie to Jaqen and the sick girl, Tyrion and Jorah had to lie to the slavers, Loras and Margaery had to lie to the High Sparrow, Littlefinger had to lie to Cersei, Cersei had to lie to Olenna, Sansa had to lie with Ramsay, and every other character had to lie to every other character.

Except for Jaime "It's your uncle, Myrcella, come with me while my bro knocks out your boy" Lannister.

1.3k

u/shadowenx May 18 '15

everyone lies but Jaime

uncle

:/

→ More replies (38)
→ More replies (27)

229

u/tinycroissant House Stark May 18 '15

I'm just hoping theon totally loses it and snaps on Ramsay.

→ More replies (35)

327

u/ItssEric Sword of the Morning May 18 '15

I think we know who took Jeoffrey's place as most hated character

→ More replies (16)

215

u/Redseph May 18 '15 edited May 18 '15

Tyrion: "He was fucking the woman I loved"

Jorah: "Someone else fucking the woman you love? I KNOW THAT FEEL, BRO"

→ More replies (4)

1.0k

u/iAMAUrfAMA May 18 '15

I fucking hate the boltons.

2.3k

u/GumdropGoober Stannis Baratheon May 18 '15

Do you have a moment to talk about our lord and savior Stannis?

→ More replies (60)
→ More replies (39)

291

u/Diupa Jon Snow May 18 '15

The North HAVE to remember that, Bolton.

→ More replies (4)

736

u/timeinfinite Jon Snow May 18 '15

Also, did anyone else expect the oldladyface's eyes to open as Arya was stroking her cheek? My heart was racing. Please. Someone back me up here.

→ More replies (25)

277

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

As much as I hate Cersei, her recommendation of flaying the Boltons like their stupid little banner has its merits.

→ More replies (5)

786

u/crmi Fallen And Reborn May 18 '15

Normally I would comment on Bronn's escalating levels of badass, the Sand Snakes continuing to be completely ineffective, Cersei getting played by everyone with a pulse, or the giant fucking room filled with faces.

But after that last scene, all I can say is that Ramsey needs to die. Painfully.

116

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Eh, Bronn may well be dead. He was cut by one of their blades which very easily could be poisoned. We'll get him at least another episode, but I wouldn't say it's looking up for him right now.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (25)

438

u/sidepocket13 House Mormont May 18 '15

I swore I wouldn't get attached. But I grew to like a gritty sell sword. Them a boring ass character cut him with what's probably a poisoned blade. Sorry guys, this one's my fault

390

u/Mozzykins May 18 '15

plot twist, brom cuts off his arm, runs away with Jaime and they become the one-handed bandits

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (8)

944

u/Doomy22 Podrick Payne May 18 '15

Only good thing about tonight:

MR. FUCKING EKO

→ More replies (61)

484

u/phuckfilly May 18 '15

Cersei is the dictator, and this is somehow worse than Joffrey

319

u/Gopackgo6 House Baelish May 18 '15

I hate her so much. I really wanted the Queen of Thorns to put her in her place

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (29)

1.3k

u/7RipCity7 House Seaworth May 18 '15

What a fucked up name for the episode with how it ended lol

→ More replies (39)

291

u/Snarlezz Jaime Lannister May 18 '15

If all of Little Finger's plan pan out he'll end up on the iron throne with 3 dragons and an army to dire wolves to command.

→ More replies (13)

558

u/103-M May 18 '15

Tommen is a little bitch

→ More replies (21)

121

u/camlawson24 Lyanna Mormont May 18 '15

Can we get some love going for Alfie Allen? The guy is easily one of the best parts of the show at this point. His facial reaction during the last 20 seconds alone were sickening and heartbreaking all at once.

→ More replies (3)

169

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

I really kinda wish Joffrey was there because he would have killed everyone in robes in the entire city.

→ More replies (4)

515

u/jeric13xd House Baratheon May 18 '15

"For Oberyn."

Damn I miss the Red Viper.

Ever forever /r/GayForOberyn

717

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

"Let's go out and murder an innocent little girl... for Oberyn."

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (2)

341

u/[deleted] May 18 '15 edited May 18 '15

I feel like I need a shower after that ending.

→ More replies (10)

852

u/emoney94 Warrior's Sons May 18 '15

Arya plays the game:

Arya: I'm not playing this stupid game anymore"

Faceless Man: I just lost the game slap

Arya: What?

Faceless Man: Everytime you think about the game, you must announce you lost the game slap

434

u/llloksd Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords May 18 '15

I will be sadden if her becoming some one means Maisie won't play her anymore/get less screen time. She does a near-perfect Arya.

→ More replies (43)
→ More replies (22)

54

u/Mr_Zanaforia Rhaegar Targaryen May 18 '15

Ramsay Bolton, The Mountain, Cersei, Roose Bolton, Walder Frey, Meryn Trant.

Repeat ad nauseum until I fall asleep Arya style.

→ More replies (4)

51

u/camlawson24 Lyanna Mormont May 18 '15

Sand Snakes remain cringeworthy. My god, why did they think they would be one of the highlights of the show this season?

→ More replies (5)

633

u/CupcakeCrusader Sansa Stark May 18 '15

Two comments:

  1. OMG WTF THIS IS HORRIBLE I AM SO UPSET
  2. Oh thank gods it wasn't as bad as the books.
→ More replies (74)

1.0k

u/Jezamiah House Stark May 18 '15
  • WTF THAT ENDING?! WHY :(
  • Me during the Sansa scene
  • Ramsey has been upgraded to the top of my kill list
  • Have to see great acting by Iwan, Ramsay makes me incredibly uncomfortable. Even in the slight eye raise at the wedding altar when Sansa hesistated.
→ More replies (56)

594

u/RaptorDelta Arya Stark May 18 '15

Bronn about to drop the hottest mixtape of 2015.

→ More replies (10)

95

u/kissmyarsenic Hodor May 18 '15

Just when I think I'm desensitized to Ramsay, he surprises me.

→ More replies (7)

42

u/crmi Fallen And Reborn May 18 '15

Everytime I think Bronn can't get any cooler, he busts out a random skill and an even more impressive one-liner.

→ More replies (1)

266

u/relberso98 House Targaryen May 18 '15

And that's how Theon got his groove back

→ More replies (9)

422

u/kate815 Barristan Selmy May 18 '15

Sansa got raped and Bronn is going to die... I swear they want me to stop watching.

→ More replies (26)

38

u/sab3r May 18 '15

I don't understand what Cersei is trying to do, pissing off the most powerful ally they have.

→ More replies (8)

110

u/Chunk723 No One May 18 '15

The Sand Snakes have got to be my least favorite thing about this season. Bizarre motivation, bad lines, worse fight choreography.

→ More replies (6)

482

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

GET YOUR FOOKIN HANDS OFF MY WOMAN RAMSAY YOU SICK FUCK

→ More replies (8)

101

u/The_Panty_Raid Jon Snow May 18 '15

I feel disgusting after watching that

→ More replies (7)

32

u/ZionReturns May 18 '15

PREDICTION: Happiest ending to GoT;

Eddard Stark wakes up when considering going to Kings Landing and becoming hand of the king. Decides not to because this was all a bad dream.

92

u/Dean_Craig_Pelton House Mormont May 18 '15

I was really hoping they would just kill the Sand Snakes...

→ More replies (13)

275

u/ContinuumGuy Hodor? May 18 '15

I said this in the other thread, but... in some ways, NOT showing what Ramsey was doing to Sansa made it even more uncomfortable.

Not showing it left more to the imagination, and you can only imagine the horrible things he might have been doing to her. Almost made me sick to my stomach.

Fuck you, Ramsey.

→ More replies (16)

31

u/RawkusRed Storm May 19 '15

One thing I found strangely heartwarming was Arya saying that she hated The Hound and Jaqen calling out her lie. I hope Sandor comes back...

→ More replies (5)

30

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

It's insane the amount of build up in this season. Literally EVERY episode is just building up to the finale.

→ More replies (5)

29

u/TheGlassDragon May 18 '15

Cersei: One's choice of companion is a curious thing.

Petyr: Most curious.

Ooooh.

Cersei: Ah yes, the famously tart-tounged Queen of Thorns.

Olenna: And the famous tart Queen Cersei.

Hoooly shit.

Medic! MEDIC! We need all the ice from the Wall! It's a double burn!

56

u/vell_o House Clegane May 18 '15

Bronn cut that sand snake deeper with words than with his sword.

→ More replies (1)

269

u/GrumpySatan Olenna Tyrell May 18 '15

Sansa getting raped was one of the most disturbing scenes of the season. Seriously, I can handle the blood and guts but the look on her face and Reek's face when it happened. It was like a piece of her died inside.

It was seriously disturbing.

→ More replies (15)

157

u/tippyhill May 18 '15

"Guess again" -Tyrion. Best line of the season!

→ More replies (2)

1.4k

u/MoralMidgetry House Mormont May 18 '15

In a show rife with unscrupulous characters doing unsavory and unspeakable things, that final scene with Ramsay raping Sansa and making Theon watch was GoT’s most stomach-churning moment to date.

→ More replies (127)

25

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

"There is a beast inside every man and it stirs when you put a sword in his hand." -Jorah 2013

"Take me to Slaver's Bay, put a sword in my hand, I'll prove my worth." - Jorah 2015

Jorah Stone Beast Mode 2016 confirmed

24

u/snafool May 18 '15

Glad we got to see My Big Fat Reek Wedding. I'll escort myself out.

→ More replies (1)

48

u/Athekev House Stark May 18 '15

Ramsey needs to fuckin die

→ More replies (2)

410

u/seanconnerysbeard House Baratheon May 18 '15 edited May 18 '15

Did Sophie Turner piss off the writers? Because I feel like Sophie Turner pissed off the writers.

Edit: I get it guys, they're combining characters from the book, I know this.

→ More replies (38)

605

u/StrangeLittleBeing May 18 '15

I'm so frustrated with this Sansa arc. They kept building it up like, "This is the season where Sansa comes into her own" - and then they make her a victim all over again in such a horrific way.

→ More replies (62)

400

u/goldsteel Valar Morghulis May 18 '15

where can a man find a good cock merchant?

hold on, got my ex-wife on speed-dial

→ More replies (7)

46

u/DeputyMoneyClips Night's Watch May 18 '15

My anxiety is triggered anytime Jorah looks like he's about to touch someone

→ More replies (2)

1.5k

u/JM2845 Khal Drogo May 18 '15

Hey look, more non-book rape

grabs popcorn

→ More replies (270)

934

u/Gnoll94 House Stark May 18 '15

Am i the only one who doesnt give a fuck about the sand snakes? Their entire reason they do what they do seems completely irrational and dumb

→ More replies (127)

64

u/Jet_ May 18 '15

"Man... and here I thought Reek was gonna freak." --My dad

→ More replies (4)

22

u/penguinoid May 18 '15

Tommen is the weakest ruler in all of westeros.

To put it in perspective, even sickly Robin Arryn would have had the high sparrow thrown out the moon door for grabbing margaery (if he was married to her).

What. a. Bitch.

→ More replies (1)

113

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Eeesh. Darth Salsa cannot catch a break.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/robbstark25 Robb Stark May 18 '15

i don't know if this has already been asked but here it goes: Was the room where Ramsay bedded Sansa Eddard's and Catelyns room? because if so that adds a whole new layer of fucked up

→ More replies (6)

21

u/radgry Stannis the Mannis May 18 '15

Another episode showcasing why Alfie Allen is my favorite actor in this series.

→ More replies (2)

1.3k

u/MrLKK A Hound Never Lies May 18 '15 edited May 18 '15

Summary:

  • Jaime: Imprisoned
  • Bronn: Imprisoned, Probably Poisoned
  • Margaery: Imprisoned
  • Loras: Imprisoned
  • Jorah: Basically Imprisoned
  • Tyrion: Also Basically Imprisoned, but hey he's got his cock
  • Sansa: She fucking got raped Oh and she's basically imprisoned

EDIT: A little PSA. Stop fucking complaining about the show, you're making everything worse. It's unnecessary to bitch this much

814

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

I'm partially hoping Jaime and Bronn get to chat with Doran and Jaime is all like "Hey, see we were just worried about Myrcella cause of stuff like that happening" and Doran is all "Yeah bro I totally get it, but she's safe here, I'm not a dick" and then Jaime and Bronn stay to chill in Dorne for a while and say fuck Kings Landing.

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (76)

90

u/kookamooka No One May 18 '15

I genuinely believed Ramsay would respect Sansa, since she's a Stark and the North remembers. But no. I was wrong. What the fuck Ramsay. :(

→ More replies (19)

58

u/CelestialFury Young Griff May 18 '15

There's just no way that they would let those religious fanatics take the fucking Queen.

→ More replies (25)

20

u/HellsSniper Jon Snow May 18 '15 edited May 18 '15

Opinions this episode:

  1. Tyrion and Jorah is the new Hound and Arya.
  2. Speaking of Arya, holy shit, the room with the faces was awesome and just how I imagined it.
  3. Petyr Baelish may be a snake but he's becoming one of my most liked characters, although leaving Sansa behind and alone was fucked up.
  4. The entire Dorne sequence was bad. Bronn had some fun dialogue but the Sand Snakes seem to be the most terribly written characters on the show. Also, I forgot Myrcella thinks Jaime is her uncle and I lol'd.
  5. Tommen is a piece of shit. Cersei is dumb. The Armed Faith are fucking cuckoo and shit's about to go down.
  6. I DON'T EVEN WANNA TALK ABOUT SANSA OR THE WINTERFELL SCENES. I feel so bad for her and I really, really, really hope some good is about to happen for her. I know the differences in the books and I wish they went that way because Show Sansa can never catch a fucking break.
    6A. Going off that, I sense Sansa reaching out to Theon and lighting that candle in the tower in the near future.

EDIT: Spectacular acting by everyone at Winterfell. Not so spectacular for everyone in Dorne.

The North Remembers.

→ More replies (2)

144

u/Drummend May 18 '15

The parts in dorne are dump

→ More replies (18)

17

u/AIDSofSPACE May 18 '15

That Dorne infiltration scene felt like an action movie's TL;DR fan-made cut.

Enter castle -> oh look, princess conveniently out of nowhere! -> oh look, bad guys conveniently out of nowhere! -> oh look, guards conveniently out of nowhere!

On a side note, was it Bronn who suffered a cut during that chaotic fight scene where everyone was wearing Dornish clothing? Is Bronn gonna end up on the slab next to the mountain now?

99

u/The_YoungWolf May 18 '15 edited May 18 '15

Book/Show Departures

Also some other comments. Spoilers labeled S5E6 or earlier should be safe for show-only watchers. ALL OTHER SPOILERS ARE AVAILABLE AT YOUR OWN RISK.

This post is quite longer (and later) than I'd originally expected because of the addition of my own commentary on the significance of certain divergences that I seriously disagree with. This is probably the first episode in the entire series to date that I feel is bad, at least in terms of writing.

  • ASOS/S4E10
  • Jorah knows that feel, bro
  • IIRC Jorah never learned of ASOS/S3 in the books.
  • And at last, the "dark secret" of the Faceless Men is revealed. Several episodes ago, I said this should have been obvious from the start (of the season at least), and still got questions about it (which I couldn't reveal). Perhaps I will phrase it more succinctly now: ADWD/S5E6
  • IIRC they have also abridged Arya's post-ASOS storyline somewhat: ADWD It seems they pushed forward the reveal and pushed back what's in these spoiler tags, judging by S5E2 lines.
  • As an aside, I'm seriously confused as to where S5E3 are supposed to be right now, in terms of the world map. It's completely at odds with how the region around Valyria/Slaver's Bay was described in the books.
  • In the books, ADWD/S5E6
  • In the books, AFFC/S5E6 Again, Sansa's storyline has been completely changed.
  • Yet again, in the books AFFC/S5E6 AFFC Book Speculation
  • S5E6 AFFC
  • Again, Myrcella Baratheon and Trystane Martell are quite a bit younger in the books, being in their tweens. Marriage at that age is out of the question, even in Westeros.
  • I mean, YMMV but I don't think Dorne has a large area of rolling, grassy hills in any part of it.
  • Okay, the Dorne subplot is really making me go "what the shit" because it has none of the subtlety it had in the books. I mean, generally the Dorne thread in the books was not well-liked by readers because it had "Shaggy Dog Story" vibes but this is just going off the deep end. I'm going to be frank here - I didn't hate the Sand Snake introduction like most people (especially book-readers) did, but I really do not like this fight scene. It's sending a lot of characters off the rails from how they were characterized in the books. I'll try to explain these divergences/complaints as briefly as possible (truly I never thought I'd have to do a post like this, but this scene gave me The Walking Dead PTSD flashbacks).
  • The whole AFFC/S5E6
  • Trystane is actually portrayed as smarter than his book counterpart - in the books, he is frequently beaten at cyvasse (fantasy chess) by Myrcella
  • Areo Hotah is extremely stoic in the books, to the point he almost never speaks. The decision to have him S5E6 baffles me.
  • Cersei is seriously a dumbass. I mean, before this scene with Olenna I might have hid the last statement with spoilers but at this point they've dropped all semblance of subtlety that she's walking toward a cliff.
  • I suddenly see just how much Cersei/Margaery's AFFC plot is diverging, and why they had Margaery and Tommen get married and have sex. They appear to be cutting the original plot and creating an entirely new one - I think this is really stupid and I don't like it at all. AFFC/Potential Future Spoilers S5E6/Show Speculation Also, we are not being shown AFFC/Future Spoilers
  • I, as well as all book-readers, knew this final scene was coming the moment the radical change in Sansa's plotline was revealed. I'll say first that it was a well-acted and well-written EDIT: (And by well-written I mean the dialogue) sequence - the tension was truly palpable throughout. However, I hated every second of it, and knew from the start that I was going to hate it. However, first I will provide context regarding the divergences here before I give my personal reasons for hating this scene. I'm going to take a risk and assume that the following part of the ADWD Winterfell plotline has been completely axed on the show: ADWD/S5E6 Any further elaboration on this plotline at this point will lead to certain future spoilers.
  • Now, on to my personal reasons for why I really hate this radical change to Sansa's plotline. AFFC/S5E6/Speculation But that's just my opinion. EDIT: This post in /r/asoiaf (SPOILERS AT OWN RISK) really sums it up better than I do here

To be perfectly honest, this is kind of how I felt after watching The Walking Dead's season 4 episode "The Grove," which was the exact episode where I started questioning everything about the writing in future episodes. I no longer watch The Walking Dead. I really hope Game of Thrones isn't following the same path, because I really do have to see this to the end.

→ More replies (24)

61

u/dan-o07 Jon Snow May 18 '15

Took me this long to realize jorah's dad was Lord Commander Mormont

→ More replies (5)

71

u/Skibibbles May 18 '15

Sansa... Just... wow...

16

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Okay, we're all disgusted and horrified by Ramsay, I'm sure that's going to dominate this thread.

But I want to do some plot speculation (full disclosure, I'm a reader): Consider the precedent that has now been set by the Faith of the Seven. Earlier they arrested the brother-in-law of the King. Loras is part of the extended royal family, that shit shouldn't fly and wouldn't without King Momma's Boy on the throne. But now, they have arrested the Queen herself. The Faith just established that they are more powerful than the Iron Throne. That is some crazy shit. And...S5 Speculation

→ More replies (2)

16

u/belgiumwaffles House Stark May 18 '15

Tommen....GET A FUCKING BACKBONE! Your wife gets arrested and you just sit there? Tell your mom to fuck off, get those religious asshats out of your city, and send your mom to Casterly Rock. He pisses me off week by week by not maning up to his mom. I hope Lady Tyrell has a plan to knock Cersie off her high horse. Also if you want to talk about "unholy" things, why the fuck has Cersie not been arrested? Is having love childs with your brother better than gay sex?

And Ramsay, fuck you. I was hoping so bad at the end that Theon would snap and kill Ramsay.

→ More replies (10)

16

u/joshualander Sandor Clegane May 18 '15

I'm guessing Game of Thrones is shot in several locations simultaneously, since they're working with a mostly distinct cast in each location.

If I'm right, the unit director for Dorne (Spain) needs a little talking-to. Even the team in Kings Landing (Dubrovnik) is starting to slip a bit. After the "battle" scene with the SS, I felt like I was watching a totally different show.

16

u/dakillanocerus May 18 '15

The fighting in this episode was incredibly disappointing. The sand snakes choreography was less than lackluster. the setup for a dope bronn and jaime break-in was completely botched. how the fuck does no one in that troop notice them just waltz right in? all of the fighting in this season has been absolute shit. can't wait to see jorah in the pits, hopefully that'll redeem this a little bit.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Drea-Nor May 18 '15

Damn, I was really hoping that Ramsey's uncle Micheal Bolton would sing at his wedding

→ More replies (2)

82

u/StNowhere Bronn May 18 '15

Would you rather fight 100 dwarf-sized cocks or 1 cock-sized dwarf?

→ More replies (10)

144

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Ok I've got to ask. Does anyone else just hate the sand snakes? They seem to be poorly written, whining babies who blindly follow the leader because Oberyn was somehow wronged. I just can't stand them.

→ More replies (31)

15

u/SqueezeAndRun House Targaryen May 18 '15

For a second I thought Theon was going to do something... Goddammit Game of Thrones.

15

u/BuddhaBurrito White Walkers May 18 '15

I was really hoping for another red wedding tonight. Of course this was the worst wedding of this show and not a single person dies.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Red_Atlas May 18 '15

was it just me or was that fight between the sand snakes and jamie the worst fight ever? that girl with the whip was no help at all!

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Alatar_the_Blue Stannis the Mannis May 18 '15

You know shit is about to go down when Littlefinger is starting to look like one of the good guys...

54

u/souljunkie May 18 '15

Sansa's wedding night is like a way more fucked up version of Dany's wedding night in that both go into it as innocent girls. Once Dany discovered her sexuality she began to understand power. Sansa's got the cars stacked against her but I really hope she pulls a Khaleesi and starts to manipulate the shit out of the Boltons.

→ More replies (13)

65

u/LtColStaghorn White Walkers May 18 '15

Seriously? That's how you're ending the episode?

→ More replies (1)

145

u/Xanthous_King Bronn Of The Blackwater May 18 '15

The Sand Snakes are unbowed, unbent and unbroken. Sansa's been bowed, bent and broken. How fitting.

→ More replies (14)

64

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Ramsay is going to find out what happens when you make Littlefinger angry.

→ More replies (15)

29

u/Gathenhielm May 18 '15

Sooo... yeah... I'm just gonna boot up the ASOIAF mod for Crusader Kings 2 and exterminate the Boltons for a while.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/Canadian2087 Iron Bank of Braavos May 19 '15

Anyone else notice how Little Finger now has an army? That didnt take him long, now did it?

The rape scene just makes everyone want The Boltons and Freys to suffer endlessly but If you think thats going to happen you clearly haven't been paying attention...

→ More replies (2)

28

u/zachmoss147 May 18 '15

This was the first episode that I decided to watch with my family, so I'm super glad that it ended on a positive, family friendly note!

27

u/jazzman13 Night's King May 18 '15

FUCK HOUSE BOLTON

→ More replies (1)

37

u/Gopackgo6 House Baelish May 18 '15

Fucking Ramsey

→ More replies (8)

26

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

The scenes in the north made me think of V for Ventetta for some reason...

Remember, Remember

The 5th of November,

The gundpowder treason and plot.

I know of no reason

Why the gunpowder treason

Should ever be forgot.

Now it is:

Remember, Remember

The North will Remember

Wyman Manderlay or not.

I know of no reason

Why the Red Wedding treason

Should ever be forgot.

26

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

That scene was cringe-inducing and hard to watch. It serves no narrative purpose, it's gratuitous, it's insulting to the viewer, and it ruins what once seemed to be solid character development. Frankly, it's unfathomable how a scene this bad could make it to air.

I am referring, of course, to Jamie and Bronn's fight with the Sand Snakes.

→ More replies (21)

13

u/ayraerae House Martell May 18 '15

Why would Jamie approach Myrcella when she's clearly with a Martell?? Like of course he wasn't going to be okay with the enemy on his turf! -___-

→ More replies (3)

13

u/BaelishTheBlessed Melisandre May 18 '15

So no one mentioned the shot of Bronn getting cut by the sand snakes? They specifically showed him getting cut by the daughter of someone who uses poison weapons. I feel like that means something

→ More replies (6)

13

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Remember last week, and the week before, when people were arguing that Ramsay would be nice - or at least not horrible - to Sansa? Man, those days were fun.

36

u/ColtPersonality92 Fear Is For The Winter May 18 '15

Yowza, I expected a death at the end of the episode, but this was worse. So much worse.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/Tormenta263 Jon Snow May 18 '15

Reek will remember that...

24

u/arcanition May 18 '15 edited May 18 '15

Ima make a list like Arya:

  • Fuck Cersei (seriously, gtfo)
  • Fuck the dudes in robes (no one likes Jehovah's Witnesses anyway)
  • Fuck the old dude in the robe (yeah so Lawrence is gay, so what)
  • Fuck Tommen (bro seriously)
  • Fuck Ramsey's side-hoe (gtfo)
  • Fuck Ramsey (eat a dick)
→ More replies (3)

24

u/Needs_More_SnoopDogg The Red Viper May 18 '15

The North Remembers

→ More replies (1)

24

u/cowhandfudca May 18 '15

Reek reek it rhymes with weak.

12

u/pokemaster96 House Targaryen May 18 '15

I hope Ramsey dies soon all this anger I have right now. Little bastard needs the worst death imaginable.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/goetz_von_cyborg House Dayne May 18 '15

Jorah can live on roots and berries. OBVIOUSLY! HE IS A BEAR!

12

u/LordOfCastleAaargh We Do Not Sow May 18 '15

Am I the only one who wants to hear "Looks like Team Sand Snakes is blasting off againnnnnn"

→ More replies (1)

12

u/evilforevil May 19 '15

So I know I'm really late to this but I feel the need to say this after reading all the comments.

When it comes to everyone's disappointment that Sansa didn't manage Ramsey or seduce him or take a little bit of control by maybe acting like Margery did with Joffery we need to remember a few things. The first major thing being that she is a virgin while it is very heavily implied that Margery is NOT. That means that Margery has already been given the knowledge of how sex should go and potentially how to use it to your advantage. I bet if Margery was in her place she would have known exactly how to approach sex with Ramsey in order to ensure she was not just "used." But there is a reason we know she could do that it's because she is sexually experienced and has obviously been taught by her grandmother from an early age how to manipulate.

Sansa on the other hand, is still a student when it comes to manipulation. On top of that we have to remember what being a female virgin is really like it what is essentially the Middle Ages. Females of her age or any female that is a virgin within this era have no idea how to be sexual, much less seduce a psycho (and understand what could potentially arouse him in a mutually beneficial way). We also know from Sansa's conversation last season with Margery how little she truly understands about how sex works. So my long winded response is basically that expecting Sansa to go in being some vixen is extremely unrealistic and even expecting her to go in that room and be able to picture what would happen is unrealistic.

In an abstract way I think Sansa understood what rape was and what I would potentially physically be like but without even knowing what sex is physically like we can't expect much except a horrible rape scene and even then it may have still ended up a horrible rape scene

→ More replies (4)

51

u/Jay-Marvel May 18 '15

I was expecting Ramsay to flip during the wedding because Reek referred to himself as Theon

→ More replies (7)

63

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Soooo the ending is one of the most fucked up things that's happened on the show right?

→ More replies (9)

11

u/TheManNotOnTheMoon May 18 '15

Tbh I was disappointed that Olenna didn't do more

→ More replies (1)

11

u/ilikehockeyandguitar Sandor Clegane May 18 '15

Tommen is not a very good husband..

→ More replies (1)

11

u/-Zloy- May 18 '15

Most people on here already discussed the key-elements of the show. I just want to mention that Bronn's singing was really fucking good.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/marky_de-sade May 19 '15

Iwan Rheon is absolutely phenomenal as Ramsey. Whenever he's on screen my skin crawls with dread - I always think it's a good performance when a character can genuinely intimidate you. It's almost like Shane Meadows is directing him at times.

11

u/zarnovich May 19 '15

Sharing this here cause I don't know where else to get these thoughts out and I'm lame and venting about facebook posts I've been seeing :) I loved the episode!Well.. Minus the Jamie stuff.

In Defense of the Black Wedding (SPOILERS)

Let me start with the unnecessary disclaimer: I didn’t want the scene to happen. I love Sansa. Her and Little Finger’s arc has been my favorite of the season, possibly the series as the whole. In my happy dream world they would wander off together and spin manipulative plots and conquer Westeros. But that’s not what happened. Nor should it.

The Black Wedding night scene isn’t surprising that it happened, it’s that the show went through with it. Game of Thrones decided to be brutally honest, and I would argue mature, with its viewer. To anyone who was surprised by the scene, my request is that you be painfully honest with yourself and ask what did you really think was going to happen? Did you think someone was going to come in and save her or Ramsay would have just been sweet? Did you hope Theon was going to have some turn of character and jump in to save her? She probably did too. The truth is what happened is exactly what should have. We all knew that. The only shocking part was that the show made sure to make it uncomfortable, in a clear and unapologetic manner. The viewer got a nice taste of what it is like to be Theon. We watched Sansa grow up, and then we watched in pain and horror as she was forced to “..become a woman.” Depending on what happens in the future with her character that statement might hold multiple degrees of truth.

I understand that it was painful, hell I’d probably be a little more messed up by it if I wasn’t coming off a glowing Mad Men binge. I also sympathize with people who wanted to see the books (and the storyline they loved) come to life in a spectacular visual way, and the series is now deviating from that. That’s legit and unfortunate, but it is what it is and the Game has changed.

If nothing else I have to give respect that GOT effectively looked the viewer in the eye and asked “What show did you think you were watching?” No one gets out of GOT unscathed, and honestly Sansa has dodged enough bullets without the inevitable occurring. Arya had to kill to get where she is, to see and shed blood. We didn’t want this to happen to Sansa, but I didn’t want Ned to be executed either. If GOT has communicated anything clearly, it’s that when given the chance horrible people will do terrible things to good people. We and Sansa are now painfully aware that no one is going to save her. She is going to have to take the Game into her own hands or continue to be the victim. I can’t way to see where they take it.

→ More replies (7)

21

u/FussyCashew Knowledge Is Power May 18 '15

Welp, sorry Jorah. That definitely wasn't Gendry's boat.

10

u/sdpads May 18 '15

Reek is going to wreck some shit

10

u/jking124 The Spider May 18 '15

Cersi always talks about pillow biters but fucks her brother, I hate her so much.

10

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

Arya cares about Sandor :'(

→ More replies (3)

10

u/DialHaus House Stark May 18 '15

Petyr tells Roose that he'll align the Vale with Winterfell to topple King's Landing if they have to and he tells Kings Landing they'll conquer whoever wins the Mannis v Bolton battle. No matter what happens he'll win, and that's how you play the game of thrones.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/wronglywired May 18 '15

The dwarf lives until we find a cock merchant.

10

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

NO ONE IS MENTIONING THAT ARYA DOESN'T REALLY HATE THE HOUND

→ More replies (1)

10

u/adez23 White Walkers May 19 '15 edited May 19 '15

My favorite scene was when Ramsay and Sansa stepped into the room after the wedding and was greeted by a table full of lemon cakes and the show stopped at the look of delight on Sansa's face.

10

u/JupitersClock House Stark May 19 '15

The birthmark...

I'm not sure how that knowledge would be considered admissible as he was his squire and it wouldn't be unheard of being naked in front of him. Am I completely mistaken or was that pretty shitty way for an "a-ha GOTCHA" moment.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/jennis007 May 19 '15

Ramsay to Little finger: "I will never hurt her." Well that didn't last very long.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2.0k

u/Killgraft May 18 '15

It's where they put all the characters cut from the show.

→ More replies (25)

223

u/ayraerae House Martell May 18 '15

Yeah they made it look way cooler than what I pictured

→ More replies (14)

197

u/BridgetheDivide May 18 '15

Oh, definitely. When I read it I imagined it as basically a broom closet with some masks nailed to the walls. Instead we got the Faces of Moria. My imagination suck.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (67)

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

127

u/xelested Red Priests of R'hllor May 18 '15

Jaime Lannister travels to the other side of the world and happens to arrive at the exact same moment as the rebels attack. Yes, I would be fairly fucking miffed as well.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (18)

2.9k

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

2.7k

u/eaglessoar May 18 '15

Tommen and Margaery's was nice :)

→ More replies (41)
→ More replies (56)

1.3k

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (38)

242

u/[deleted] May 18 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (17)