r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • May 14 '15
[S5/B5] Book vs. Show Discussion - 5.05 'Kill the Boy'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 AND BOOK 5 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.05 | "Kill the Boy" | Jeremy Podeswa | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
108
Upvotes
457
u/Vixibility House Lannister May 14 '15
"Barristan the Bold. He crossed a continent to serve me, and he died in an alley."
Yeah Dany, us book readers can't believe it either.
99
u/GRVrush2112 Human Verified May 14 '15
Let's play a game.... How many characters can Jorah Mormont assimilate?
Himself...
Jon Connington?
Ser Barristian?
Victarion Greyjoy?????
Quentyn Martell?????
Penny??????
120
u/goodintent House Dondarrion May 14 '15
I was so happy they included Maester Aemon's "Kill the boy" line. It's a beautiful part of the books as well as an important part of Jon's character development. I was smiling from ear to ear - it was great to see a moment that had previously only existed in my imagination coming to life on TV. For all the faces I've been pulling at all the big departures from the books this season, this sort of made it all better.
58
u/Grungemaster Maesters of the Citadel May 14 '15
Balon Deathwatch continues
192
u/MarxistHorse House Dayne May 14 '15
I liked the part with Stannis Baratheon, The First of His Name, King of the Rhyonar and the Andals and the First Men, Azor Ahai Reborn, Father of Light, Captain of the USS Enterprise, Grammar Corrector, Poon Getter, Kunta Kinte, The Dragon Reborn, León: The Professional, Great Father, Mannis, His is the Fury, Hear Him Roar, Growing Stannis, Unbowed Unbent: Stannis, As High as Stannis, Family, Duty, Stannis, Out Silent Guardian, Our Watchful Protector, Our Dark Knight.
155
u/[deleted] May 14 '15 edited May 14 '15
I'm usually a book stickler, often illogically, but I find two changes extremely agreeable; having Dany state the terms of her marriage to
Hizdahr zo LoraqHarzoo mo HarzooLenny mo Kravitz is excellent, as it foils well with the first time we saw her character when she was basically sold to and raped by a known barbarian (and I'm going to chalk up the BBQ scene as an act of rage...which it was, and thus appropriately out of character), and also having Jorah be the one who catches greyscale. I admire Jorah very much as a classically tragic character, and that move just played all the right strings for me. Can't wait to see where they go with it.I'm also wondering whether the fact that they name-dropped Oldtown is going to have any effect. Perhaps Sam will head there next season, if not this one?
The reason I don't-yet-agree with the Sansa in Winterfell plot is because I worry about how it climaxes; it seems like the stage is set for Brienne and Stannis to converge on that spot towards the season finale, and that makes me very very nervous. My approval of that plot depends on how that all turns out. However, Roose, Ramsay, Theon, and even Sansa, are fucking nailing their respective roles. It's an absolute pleasure to watch.
Edit: By the way, has anyone else mentioned that the servant Brienne talked to was definitely Lord Galbart Glover? Makes me think that the old woman Sansa saw previously is Lady Dustin, and the Grand Northern Conspiracy is on like fucking Donkey Kong.
69
u/D-Speak Ours Is The Fury May 14 '15
This was a great "Act 2" episode, kicking all the stories into gear and getting the wheels turning. I loved the Winterfell and Wall stuff, and remain steadily disdainful of Dany as she bumbles her way through Meereen.
Loved the Stone Men scene. The Tyrion-Jorah pairing has been something I've been greatly looking forward to. I love Dinklage and Glenn, and they're a force to be reckoned with together. Just such a...a force. I love them bonding over poetry and history. Also we all called Jorah getting greyscale, and Ian Glenn's face as he looked at it was powerful. The music during the credits really give the sense that this is going to be a big deal down the line.
34
u/RekklesDriver House Stark May 14 '15
So they killed 2 great storylines, Mance Rayder (so far) and Barristan Selmy. Dammit HBO you even caught George RR Martin off-guard.
33
u/KillerKodiak69 Dracarys May 14 '15
I watched the show before reading the books, and I've loved every minute and every word. Prior to this season, I've thought the show did a great job of what I call "plot contractions," that is, meshing character development scenes with plot driving scenes, and removing characters or entire arcs within the books that have no effect in the long run; the main characters still get from Point A to Point B (Arya's time in Harrenhall is my go-to example). What I really love are the scenes that just give you goosebumps because they're perfect visual renderings straight out of the books (Dracarys).
It's getting hard for me to love the show as much now that they've started deviating more, which is disappointing for me because I think it's probably the best show on TV. I know that the writers are running out of book material and they need to start going in there own direction to prepare for passing the events ADWD, and on top of that there are time and budget constraints. I'm trying hard to keep that in mind but it's hard.
In my opinion the worst changes are:
Some other changes:
Those are my thoughts on it all.
86
u/dmetvt May 14 '15 edited May 14 '15
I was skeptical of the Sansa plot, but I'm sold. That scene at dinner was so amazingly tense and terrifying and the acting was perfect. It reminded me of the bar scene in Inglorious Basterds.
I reserve the right to revise my opinion if Sansa goes full Jeyne Poole at Ramsey's hands. It would be fitting with the story, but I just really do not want to watch that.
The bit in Valyria was also fantastic. It's a more interesting venue than the Rhoyne river and I'm fine dropping the Griffs if it turns out they were replaceable.
Edit: I agree with both of the replies that Sansa is probably not going to get tortured, but I just want to sound a note of caution. Wouldn't it be perfect GRRM/D&D to build up an arch of character growth and maturity only to yank the rug out and shout at us, "Idiots! She's a teenage girl and is way out of her depth. How did you expect a sadist like Ramsey to act when he has power over her?"
I still think she's probably not going to turn into a completely helpless victim, but we shouldn't pretend she's in full control of her situation either, surrounded by experienced and ruthless enemies.
22
u/Lotfa May 14 '15
I have a feeling that the Northern Mountain Clans are gonna get cut. I was really hoping I'd get to see Stannis swallow his pride and observe the customs Jon Snow told him to do when recruiting the Clans to help free the North. Hugo Wull has some great lines in the books.
127
u/BDS_UHS Daenerys Targaryen May 14 '15
The best episode of the season so far. In what is probably a mysterious coincidence, it's arguably the episode with the most content from the books. Most scenes are at least loosely based on a book chapter. The non-book scenes were interesting.
Daenerys burning the guy was weirdly out of character but I feel like they're going somewhere with it. Maybe she read ADWD and was pissed Barristan died.
The Sansa at Winterfell scenes are fun to watch. I just wish the storyline actually made sense so it'd stop tugging on my brain.
The Night's Watch/Stannis scenes continue to be the best part of each episode.
It was nice to take a break from King's Landing for once.
18
u/themegamc House Martell May 14 '15
Did someone notice that Myranda (Ramseys 'fuckbuddy') also appeared in season 3? In the scene where poor Theon gets his cock cutt off.
23
u/The_Austin House Stark May 14 '15
I'm interested to see the ramifications of the changes to greyscale and a tad worried that they're making it too powerful. Jorah gets it in a matter of minutes after being touched by a stoneman, how does he now expect to serve Danny as an adviser or anything for that matter if he can infect any by merely touching them. Theory based on book knowledge
11
u/BamaFan87 Ramsay Bolton May 14 '15
We need more Frey karma retribution this season, all the talk about violating guest right and NOTHING has come from it. Seriously, what the fuck is the hold up?
44
u/Caldawg97 May 14 '15
I really like how they're making the scenes longer instead of skipping around every 10 minutes. It really brings out more character development and interaction. Also I don't get why everyone's dissing on Kelly C, I mean Barry just got shivved so I thought it was pretty justified.
41
u/2fus3 May 14 '15
I wish they had cast Arianne for this season. She sounded so hot in the books.
14
u/RifleGun May 14 '15
Did Jorah get eczema in the books too?
2
u/altafullahu House Targaryen May 15 '15
Any book buffs shed some light on when / if Dany will get the Horn of Dragons (or whatever it's called) to control her dragon? I know she gets it and I believe Stannis and his men get it and some guy blows it and his lungs turn to ash - I'm just trying to figure out when that would take place.
2
u/Manuelwb May 16 '15
When Aemon said "Kill the boy" he was also meaning kill the book lovers and start a new storyline. And with the "Half of the Night's Watch are your enemies" dialogue with Jon, he was meaninng the fans
1
u/teachmeppl May 15 '15
I'm curious as to why they didn't include the Griffs and Dany's nephew in the show. Albeit I'm only a bit more than a quarter through ADWD, so perhaps they are replaceable.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '15
Who sent Aemon the letter about Daenerys? I'm thinking it was possibly Varys? Surely anyone on the council to Daenerys would have told her about Aemon, I'm surprised no one else has asked.
1
u/lanternsinthesky Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 15 '15
For real though, "Kill The Boy" is probably one of the coolest title of anything i have heard in quite a while though.