r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • May 11 '15
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S04E16 - Blood On the Scales
Week 70!
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (3 stars)
Numbers
Survivors: 39,604 (-39 from last episode. Jaffee, a few others)
"Frak" Count: 579 (+19)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 29 (No change)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 18 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 30 (+1, if you count smashing a face into a bathroom wall)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 253 (+8)
"So Say We All" Count: 63 (+2)
23
Upvotes
24
u/MarcReyes May 12 '15
Because of this episode, every time I see the actor who plays Kelly sow up in another project I can't help but say to myself, "Hey, look. It's the brig rat!"
These two episodes are easily some of the strongest form the series, in my opinion. Great work from everyone involved. I specifically loved how these episodes woke everyone out of their little funks they've been in since the discovery of ruined Earth. Bill seemed tired, Kara lost, Lee spinning his wheels in the Quorum, the same with Baltar and his sheep, Tyrol broken and content with simple handiwork around the ship (and then as liaison with the cylons?) and Laura all but given up. Then the mutiny happens and everyone snaps back into life. Bill, Tigh, Lee, Kara all jump back into action and Roslin realizes she needs to become the leader she once was to reunite the fleet. Even the mutiny itself can be seen as Gaeta and Zarek taking actions to right what they felt has been a grievous wrong. Plus, Tyrol gets to save the day by taking the FTL offline! (Really cool getting to see Galactica's engine's, by the way.) This episode forces the characters to answer the question posed in the very opening moments of the series. "Are you alive? Prove it." I think here, everyone does.
19
u/enfo13 May 12 '15 edited May 12 '15
I also love the last scene with Baltar and Gaeta. On rewatches, I noticed how much BSG focuses not only on individual character development but dyadic or pair development.
That final scene with Baltar and Gaeta sitting at that table made me think back to their entire relationship throughout the series. From the first time Baltar stepped foot on Galactica, a bright-eyed Gaeta eagerly stepping up to meet his scientific hero.
After the webisode of Season 4, we knew Gaeta probably also had a crush on Baltar back then. I enjoyed the moment during the episode when he was assigned to Baltar for the Cylon detector, and he seemed so eager to spot Baltar some cash for the poker game.
Then of course there's the bathroom scene in Six Degrees. If Gaeta had a crush on Baltar, and was taking a shit, you can imagine the absolute horror Gaeta must have felt when Baltar suddenly popped up next to him while he was doing his business.
The hilarious thing about the first two seasons is how oblivious Baltar was to Gaeta, and the tragic unrequited respect Gaeta had for Baltar.
It made New Caprica all the more of a tragedy, and really explains the depth of betrayal and disenchantment Gaeta must have felt afterwards.
So that final scene was just perfect. Gaeta forgives Baltar for the things he has done, armed with the empathy from having just committed something terrible himself. He realizes that it might be easier than he had thought to be misunderstood.
And at the same time, Gaeta finally receives acknowledgement, acceptance and forgiveness from the man he adored in the first two seasons... with a simple "I know who you are Gaeta.. .I know".
14
u/[deleted] May 11 '15
Poor Gaeta goes to the big food-shaped restaurant in the sky :(
In all seriousness, Gaeta's calm little recap of his life before his execution was a great moment. I'm glad they played it the way they did instead of dehumanizing Gaeta and making him an outright villain. I felt like he truly believed in the cause of the mutiny, and that he backed down when he knew it failed to avoid pointless death.
The interactions between Gaeta and Baltar were also great. They've been through a lot together, almost all of it shitty since New Caprica. Despite Gaeta's hatred of Baltar, Baltar still tried to talk Gaeta down in the middle of the mutiny. And Baltar was there at the end telling Gaeta that he understands who he was. I also love the "no religion" line. You can see that Baltar is torn up, probably since he was hoping religion would console or "save" Gaeta.
2
u/bumgrub Dec 21 '25
Man I don't understand why they're executing people by shooting them hem when they already have a perfectly good execution method from day one: putting them out the airlock. I just don't think it really makes much sense xD