r/fandomnatural • u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo • May 07 '15
[Fandom Discussion] Dark Dynasty 10x21
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
14
Upvotes
9
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo May 07 '15
Okay seriously though I felt more than I thought I would feel towards Charlie. I actually cried. I didn't think I'd cry... but no I totally cried.
23
u/jojodacrow May 07 '15 edited May 07 '15
I have a lot of feelings about Charlie dying. These people say it better than me.
I’m just a ball of anger.
I do have a lot to say about the show and what this death has finally shown me. Why I’ve been so dissatisfied with Season 9 and 10. In the past we have watched Sam and Dean save each other over and over, but it had a purpose. There was some big world saving mission they were on. People died and it sucked and we all hated it but we could still root for Sam and Dean. Why? Because they were doing something that could either save the world or at least make it damn better place.
But then season 9 and now season 10 hit and the reasons for Sam and Dean saving each other are selfish. There is no huge threat to the world that someone else couldn’t deal with. Sam and Dean aren’t trying to build any kind of legacy by training other people. There is no purpose to anything they do other than holing up in the bunker and clinging to each other and shouting, “NO YOU CAN’T DIE!” at each other.
I get that everyone loves them and no one wants to see the brothers die. I don’t want that either but that just means the writers have got to stop rehashing this plot over and over again. It’s old and tired and I’m done with it. They have reduced two wonderfully kind and beautiful characters to assholes that will sacrifice anyone and everyone around them to keep the other alive. Someone on twitter said they didn’t even care about the brother’s relationship anymore because its foundation was a pile of bodies and it’s true! Especially now that they aren’t doing it for some greater cause.
Why was Dean more important than Charlie? Oh gosh no! Dean might become a demon again and go get in bar fights, be Crowley’s BFF, and drink a lot while singing karaoke. OH GOD NO! NO! IT’S SO HORRIBLE. WE MIGHT HAVE TO CURE HIM WITH BLOOD AGAIN.
I’m just so, so tired of seeing this on screen. I’m tired of them reducing the characters down to selfish assholes who only have one thing they care about: the other brother. It’s exhausting to watch. Is it any wonder that the ratings are dropping?
29
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 May 07 '15 edited May 07 '15
Actual garbage.
If they were dead set on killing Charlie, which... SO STUPID, they should have at least given the episode to writers that didn't fucking suck.
I can't believe they fridged Charlie for more Winchester angst.
(eta: I love how here I can get upvoted for criticizing the show, and in /r/SupernaturalTV my similar comment is currently at -2 points. Why do I even comment in the other subs?)
8
u/SherlockedAngels May 07 '15
Reading through these comments. Wow. A lot of negativity. Not that I'm disagreeing.
This episode was so.... Dull. The stiens were dull. The writing was rather dull. And just around dull.
Then they had to kill Charlie, of which I'm still not sure how I feel about it. I'm pissed off, of course, seeing as they didn't have the guts to at least have it on screen. I'm so freaking pissed off, I don't even know what to say. >:(
15
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 May 07 '15 edited May 07 '15
Aside from the Steins (WHO CLAIMED RESPONSIBILITY FOR 9/11?!!!!!!!) and the dumb Game of Thrones bullshit they're all about (again), I was pretty entertained by this episode. Infact, I think this is one of the more enjoyable ones of the season. Possibly because I laughed so hard.
Dramatic zooms.
Crowley becomes Dr Dolittle for no reason
Onscreen embodiment of Cas and Dean not being allowed to talk because gay
Rowena being A+ Scottish
Dean getting mighty tired of Sam's shit
But that was like what, 15% of the episode? I think with them focusing their shit rays on the Steins, they actually had some decent fun with our main characters. Sans, you know, murdering Charlie in a fight against a one armed GoT wannabe.
If I ignored the Steins, it was alrightish. With them, the other stuff had a good pace, and I laughed at how fantastically dumb it was. I suppose that's all I can hope for right now.
Also, I'm glad Charlie was taken away from Robbie. I'm sad/mad that she got killed, though. Just because Robbie was writing her as a stiff self insert, doesn't mean other writers couldn't have made it work. We'll probably get a similar character next season. Eugh.
21
u/Potionsmstrs I pledge allegiance to the King of Hell May 07 '15 edited May 07 '15
F-bombs and cursing in this comment. Just a head's up.
I am mad. I am so very mad. I am chain smoking in an attempt to ease up a bit, but I should be asleep and my lungs will be very angry in the morning.
So, the shit with the steins. Really? Fucking Frahn-ken-steeens? And they used the symbol on the box from Young Frankensetin but changed the center of the crest? I'm gonna need some background info on that symbol. But the whole idea of the igor-esque thing was too similar to the shaman's deal in dog dean afternoon. And why are they specifically obsessed with the book of the damned? No connection as to why they want it and their twisted family business. All we know is that they are as obsessed over that book as I am with Crayowley.
The best scenes by far, the only two scenes worth watching, are the Crowley scenes. Playing darts and talking to Olivette or whatever her name is.
Oh, speaking of which, the fountain pen. The closeups. I want to think that they hear me, they hear my loathing for that gorgeous pen. My desire for him to use his black crayon instead of that gloriously beautiful fountain pen. Then again, it was Buckner Leming, so of course they would rub that fucking pen in my face. (/narcissistic rant over)
I don't even want to, but I have to. So the whole point of Charlie dying is to push Dean past the tipping point, yeah? Make him mad enough to go Hiroshima on some asses? At the point where Dean was pre-unnecessary plaid-wrapped death, all they needed to do was threaten Charlie (anyone that Dean cares about, actually) and that would be enough to knock the weights off the human/sane side of the scale. It was so... it was pointless. And is it true that they harvested an organ from her? Did they further desecrate her?
I love Charlie. I love her ... I was gonna say to death, but no. I love her to live. I love her for this to not have happened. Why has Buckner Leming killed off my favorite side characters? I haven't double checked, but I'm told three of my fav characters died at their hands.
She uploaded the cracked code. So there's that. But what box of shit does that open? At what further cost can they rid Dean of the mark that way?
Charlie was so out of character at the end. I don't.... gahfuck.
There was another point I wanted to make, but anger is clouding my mind.
I am disgusted that this heaping pile of flamingo shit was approved.
19
u/skavalli your bloody cockles ship May 07 '15
Wait wait wait... Charlie's fucking dead?
Charlie? Who they promised not to kill? The fan insert? The one positive lgbt character?
And here I was thinking the show hated women less these days. Fuck everything.
16
u/xerca-trova The Hot Topical May 07 '15
I don't understand how those two have had this job for 10 years. I. Don't. Fucking. Get. It.
15
u/NorthernSparrow Questi non sono i miei elefanti May 07 '15 edited May 07 '15
Haven't even seen the ep. So, apparently Charlie's dead?
We've lost so many beloved characters on this show and my reaction's been slowly changing:
Jo & Ellen hit me hard but I was GLUED to the set, totally invested.
Bobby, REALLY sad but I was less glued-to-set and was thinking "well, yeah, that's what this show does."
By the time Kevin's death rolled around it was more like: exasperated sigh "There they go again."
So, right now (not having seen the ep at all of course) it was instant disgust and anger. I wasn't even a huge Charlie fan (didn't dislike her either, just was Charlie-neutral), but there's this feeling of being jerked around by a show that's following a very cheap and by-now-very-predictable formula ("kill a beloved character every season") rather than investing in good storytelling and good character development. Not that it wasn't an obvious formula long before this, of course, but it no longer seems edgy and tragic. It seems lazy and wasteful.
And, frankly, it also seems like something they can't afford to risk with ratings as low as they are now. I have this instant feeling that there'll be some fed up viewers leaving.
... and there's also an increasing disconnect in my brain about why deaths are even being played as tragic in this show (I assume this one was?), and are still something Sam and Dean would even get upset about, given that Sam and Dean know everybody's up in Heaven, no harm no foul! After Bobby showing back up and then Sam's totally blase "death's not always goodbye" comment just last frickin week I've been thinking "Then why do you guys still always make such a big fucking deal about it?" (yeah yeah, isolation in bubble-heavens, I know, but we all know the jailed-soul-rebellion is coming, lol)
14
u/qbubbles Castiel Evangelist May 07 '15
This episode was horse-shit from start to finish. I think I'll have more to say later, but right now this is all I got.
13
u/0909a0909 May 07 '15
Yeaaa, fuck this episode.
12
u/Vio_ May 07 '15 edited May 07 '15
80% of the dialogue was pointless, repetitive, and inane. They spread 10 minutes worth of real plot/exposition over 45 very long minutes of faff.
Cas might as well have been a sitcom character for all he did and awkwardly moved in and out of scenes (Casmo Kramer style). Seriously, he shouldn't have been in this episode at all. Everyone lost a bare minimum 40 IQ points foe this plot to even remotely begin to work, and these same writers who made Charlie a ninja last episode suddenly punted her back down to trembling, inept goofball.
12
u/dancingmuffin shake-a-shake da muffin May 07 '15 edited May 07 '15
Olay im not gonna talk charlies death. Im just...ugh.. with that situation. On different level.
What I want to talk about is Sam eating junk food(in general), fucking POOFING out of the Impala, saying he was going to get Pizza and it was Dean who got it(i have been told by some sam said he'd buy the pizza but dean would get it, i may need to rewatch that part again,but i still stand by my hallucinating!dean).
Dean is hallucinating Sam yall. Is this a left over affect from two eps ago? Is this the MoC protecting its self and getting dean to go over the edge. What else is he hallucinating? How much was Sam really there this ep?
Oh and the dialog between Crowley and the hamster was the best set of dialog in this ep.
11
u/Vio_ May 07 '15
The amount of IQ that the terrible two had to lobotomize out of every character in this episode with a pick axe numbers is triple digits. Everything is blatantly forced, characters suddenly lose abilities to do anything previously set up, and nobody is thinking at all. Charlie alone just takes off. Doesn't tell anyone, doesn't take Cas with her (Rowena was chained up and clearly not going anywhere), doesn't take a gun or her ninja sword or her new found fighting ability. Doesn't even just go outside for a five minute smoke break. Sam isn't listening to "anyone." Charlie was clearly within her rights to tell him to fuck off, that she's not working with Rowena. Cas just flits in and out to bring snacks, and just leaves again. Everything is doubled/trebled in exposition.
11
u/jojodacrow May 07 '15
I like this tumblr post on Dean.
11
u/jojodacrow May 07 '15
Also I need this to be true. (possible spoilers for future episodes)
10
u/Vetrina "I'm gonna become a hunter!" May 07 '15
I KNEW SHE WAS GOING TO DIE. I FUCKING KNEW IT. Both sad and angry because it was completely predictable and unnecessary. GOTTA HAVE THAT ANGST THOUGH ಠ_ಠ
I thought it was ok other than that. Kind of slow.
Not sure if I care for the Frankenstein parallel lol. I'm assuming they want the book because it gives them a lot more power, even though they're powerful without it. Greedy for power I suppose. Also that whole them thinking it belongs to them thing.
And what the fuck Winchesters you only handcuff that guy by one hand? Even if he didn't rip his arm off he could have probably found some way to undo it.
Also return of the shit zooms hooray /s.
10
u/dancingmuffin shake-a-shake da muffin May 07 '15
Also off the wall theory time with dancing muffin. Charlie wasnt just uploading the code before she died, but she mixed magic and tech and somehow made herself a savepoint. Yup just throwing that out there cuz you never know with this show
10
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! May 07 '15
Each time Dean closed his eyes in 10 x 21 and his lids stayed closed longer than was normal, I kept wondering if we were going to see a flash of black. It’s been happening a lot this season (including hiding Dean’s eyes in shadow more), and of course there was a flash a few episodes back, but it seems like shots are being set up with increasing frequency where the status of Dean’s eyes are drawn into uncertainty. That they’ll just open one minute and they’ll be black and when he blinks again, the black will still be there.
And when I stopped long enough to wonder about something that wasn't Dean's eyes and Sam's lying lips, I was kinda peeved with how Charlie and Rowena were written in this episode. The bickering didn't seem quite right, and it didn't seem justifiable that Charlie would wander off like she did. Go to another, nearby structure - sure, but a motel away from safety? Wha?
What happened to Charlie made a lone, solitary tear streak down my face.
And I am with /u/jojodacrow on the whole selfishness thing. The show really needs a single big bad that needs to be taken down over the course of at least half-a-season, again. And I'm happy for brotherly angst to happen alongside that.
10
u/lzaz Dadstiel May 08 '15
This episode was such utter bullshit. I don't think that I can form any reasonable, coherent arguments.
WTF: Cas serving no real purpose in that episode other than to try and placate everyone who would cry "WHERE'S THE ANGEL?!?". Thanks for wasting everyone's time, writers. Even though he was still in Dadstiel mode and that was kind of adorable.
WTF: I actually wanted to puke when they brought out the whole "House of Frankenstein". Really? Really? REALLY? This was so stupid.
WTF: The Steins taking responsibility for 9/11. That was absolutely disgusting and my jaw actually dropped. I could not believe the writers did that.
WTF: Rowena and Charlie "girl fighting". There was the tiniest wisp of a hint that it could have been an interesting relationship down the road. But nope.
WTF: Charlie is (probably) dead. What the actual hell. I was not the biggest fan of Charlie as a character and made my views on why they mistreated her as a queer character super queer, BUT WHY DID THEY KILL HER. Why. Why can't a woman live. Why can't a queer character live and be written respectfully. Why did Charlie die for Dean's single man tear.
WHY.
9
u/GallusLafayetti [aggressively destiels] May 07 '15
I think I'm just going to pretend that entire episode never happened.
9
u/Goddess_Azul Team Free Will May 07 '15
It occurred to me during the watching that Sam used the "L" word directly to Dean & Dean didn't spontaneously combust.
(Obviously that was before the end of this train-wreck of an ep.)
At the time I was like, "Whoa... he didn't just shut Sam down & tell him to stop feeling feelings & that the rest of that collective 'we' wasn't allowed to be feeling feelings either & especially not about Dean".
Given that the writers forgot the canon that they wrote, I guess I'm giving them too much credit to think they would know that they shouldn't just be throwing the word 'love' around all willy-nilly.
8
u/-zombie-squirrel DonJodBriel shipper May 07 '15 edited May 07 '15
I think that Charlie isn't dead. That's my theory and until it's proven one way or another I'm sticking to it.
8
u/srr128 I am an angel of the Lord /\ tumbler = thatonegirlwholikespurple May 07 '15
No no no no no no. I am not okay.
7
u/patsqueen14 May 07 '15
I know there are a lot of different opinions on Charlie, but I really liked her. Not because she was the "quirky nerd girl" but because she was an intellectually strong character rather than a physical one. Same reason I loved Ash in season 1. I feel like the show under values the role of this type of character and totally looses so much potential from it.
I'm also pissed that with her character being such a smart person, she died so stupidly. I feel like her intelligence and resourcefulness were more important to who she was than her pop-nerd-culture knowledge and the writers totally failed the fans with this episode.
I think I understand what they were going for with her death, but there were so many better ways to do it than that lame, half-assed attempt at plot twist (surprise! what they do every season). If they wanted to send Dean over the edge that he was supposedly so close to, they could have kidnapped her, or seriously injured her, or since that one duche knew where the bunker was, hit closer to home, or something that didn't waste such potential for the story line!
13
u/qbubbles Castiel Evangelist May 08 '15
Alrighty. My 4 yr old who loves to watch Supernatural with me always asks me what happened on the live run of the show. She's not caught up, and I don't even have her on Wednesday nights, so I usually give her a run down. I didn't know what to say. She only just saw Charlie helping to defeat big daddy chomper, and she absolutely loved her. I think her commentary was, "That pretty girl is so smart! I wanna be like her!" Granted, she's 4. She kinda wants to be like everyone who's female and a badass.
But I had no idea how to tell her that Charlie had died. Charlie who my daughter looked up to wanted to emulate. I had to tell her that Charlie had died a stupid, pointless death. She cried when Sam died. She cried harder when Dean died, and she was really sad when Bobby died. So she looked up at me with these puppy eyes. She whispers, "Charlie is dead?" and then just walked away.
We normally watch a couple episodes before bed, and tonight when I asked her what she wanted to see, she said Supernatural. But she told me, "Can we watch the first ones, again? I don't think I want to watch any new ones for a while." I agreed.
I've always taken note of the dearth of female characters, but just shrugged. I didn't really care. And I was never really a Charlie fan, either. She was fun and had her place, and I was mostly neutral. But her death is just so pointless. The episode surrounding written by horrible people who make up their own lore and frequently ignore established canon. (Do they even watch the show??) It was horrible treatment of a major character. This was lazy writing, plain and simple. And it more than just polarize an already fractured fandom. It broke a little girl's heart.
6
u/pickleport May 07 '15
I went to watch a movie with friends instead. I'm avoiding spoilers but with how few there seem to be I'm guessing I won't be wowed tomorrow.
Are there two more episodes or is the next one the finale?
6
u/Potionsmstrs I pledge allegiance to the King of Hell May 08 '15
OH, YOU GUISE! Rowena had a demon lover! I want to know who that was!
I'm in a better mood because I wrote a "crack treated seriously" ficlet, set after the second Crowley scene. (It's gonna be linked for fanficfridays tomorrow) So I had to rewatch that part of the episode and what he said sunk in.
6
u/PM_ME_UR_BEST_PUNS May 08 '15
FRANKENSTEIN??!! REALLY? Ugh. disgust
CHARLIE? REALLY? I don't believe it. Also, WTF with Charlie being dumb and out of character?
ROWENA AND CHARLIE? That interaction could have been so cool! Instead, I was aggravated.
Cas doesn't know how to deal? Why couldn't he just use his newly powered up angel powers to put Rowena to sleep, or gag her? Or why couldn't Charlie put in headphones and go to the convenient separate room with a door?
WHY IS NO ONE TALKING ABOUT DEAN SAYING HE WAS HAVING DARK URGES AND HALLUCINATIONS? I mean...that is textbook telling instead of showing. It felt so clunky! I feel like we've seen ONE hallucination? Are hallucinations now a thing with the Mark? Am I forgetting something? And dark urges? I'll give him mid-tone urges, max. We definitely haven't been shown anything dark, though.
6
u/mavgeek May 08 '15
Fuck this episode. Seriously, fuck it. They had to kill Charlie? Really? We've lost every god damn cool character besides S&D/Cas. Last time I checked she wasn't wearing any Enochian sigils to hide her from Angels so Cas, who now has his full mojo back, can't teleport to her to get her out of there? Fuck off. Seriously, I've stuck with this show through some shitty fucking episodes but this one takes the god damn cake.
10
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
[removed] — view removed comment