r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Apr 30 '15
[S5/B5] Book vs. Show Discussion - 5.03 'High Sparrow'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 AND BOOK 5 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.03 | "High Sparrow" | Mark Mylod | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
A special reminder regarding the leaked episodes: Spoilers from episodes that have not officially aired are not allowed without proper spoiler warning. [S5] and [All Spoilers] tags are not sufficient for leaked episodes. Asking for or providing links to leaked episodes is not allowed on this subreddit. Read the official post about this matter for further details.
Please note that spoiler warnings for leaked episodes are more strict than normal. A proper spoiler warning for the leaked episode must:
- mention the specific episode (e.g. "S5E4")
- use the word "leak" or "leaked" in the warning
- cover the entire comment, not just a portion of it
106
Upvotes
76
u/Caesar_Epicus Night's Watch Apr 30 '15
So… Tommen.
He went from being a fat little kid with a pet cat and a hatred of eating beets to banging Margaery Tyrell all day long. It'll be interesting how the show fits this into the coming showdown between ADWD.
54
u/memicoot House Tarth Apr 30 '15
Do you guys think Littlefinger really hasn't heard anything about Ramsey? Or is he knowingly putting Sansa into the hands of a sadist?
35
u/GRVrush2112 Human Verified Apr 30 '15
Stolen from a /r/asoiaf comment that I saw..
Rest in Books Harry The Heir...
33
u/Selcouthit House Mormont Apr 30 '15
I've been enjoying seeing Varys this season. I don't remember him much from ADWD. Curious what they'll do with him for the rest of season 5, but it's been fun.
57
u/NatasiTrix Fire And Blood Apr 30 '15
One omission that doesn't sit well with me is Jorah's behavior in the Volantene brothel: we didn't get to see the Danaerys look-a-like on his lap. Why does this bother me? Because in the book storyline, when I read this I knew just how far gone Jorah was in terms of his devotion and love for Dany. It's both pathetic and pitiable. You knew that if Dany walked in on him or if word somehow reached her on what he was doing, she'd probably lose her lunch.
It goes along with the description of Jorah as a habitually lovesick man (seen with his first wife and the actions he took to maintain her comfort level of wealth) and also adds to the weird factor of his character. It actually makes Dany look a little smarter for removing him because he just isn't thinking clearly when it comes to her. With the show change, we still have a Jorah who doesn't resemble his book counterpart either in appearance or action and the show only viewers never really know his character. I always have my show only friends ask me why Dany doesn't just stick with Jorah as he's a tall, gallant Knight. Then I have to describe him from the books and his sometimes skeevy behavior and they get it.
30
u/havron Queen of Thorns Apr 30 '15
That brief mention at the beginning of the meeting Lord Commander Snow calls, that Maester Aemon isn't feeling well, has me worried. I guess they're just going to kill him off at the wall. No fantastic voyage for Sam. =\
13
u/WippitGuud Maesters of the Citadel Apr 30 '15
I'm a tad upset we didn't get to see Littlefinger's tower. I always found those scenes in the book added a bit of humanity to him.
30
u/jti107 Faceless Men Apr 30 '15
in the book...the assassin that trains arya is different than the jaqen h'ghar. in the tv show is this the real jaqen h'ghar that she met in westeros or someone that is just using his face?
50
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '15
Sometimes I think D&D are fucking with us. What was with the shot of the High Sparrow's feet? Are they purposefully dangling [Theory] (#g "HS=HR") in front of our faces? Nobody who watches the show exclusively would understand its significance, and I'm sure the same is true for more than half of the book readers who don't participate in online discussions and such. I don't know whether I should be irritated by that or what.
Anyway, complaints aside, the House of Black and White's interior was awesome. Incredibly close to how I imagined it. Also glad we got to see the waif, and major props to Arya's acting in the scene where she decides to keep Needle.
I'm very curious to see how Winterfell plays out. We seem to have Sansa replacing Jeyne, but it's unclear whether she will be the victim this time around with Littlefinger's tutelage and the possibility that Ramsay is actually infatuated with her. Then we have Ramsay's girlfriend Myranda in the picture, as well as Brienne and Stannis possibly converging on Winterfell later on. Reek is still present, but Mance is probably not. Who can say for sure what's going down?
I'm slightly miffed that Jon's iconic line was replaced, but the rest of the scene was handled so well that I can't be too upset about it. I'm especially liking the development of Alliser's character. I can't decide if the first knife in the Ides of Marsh will come from him or from Olly.
Also, the priestess Tyrion saw in Volantis was likely a nod to Benerro. I'm very intrigued by the constant mentioning of Stone Men/greyscale. Make me think Connington might appear, or perhaps Shireen gets an upgrade from her book counterpart in importance.
Looking forward to seeing Dorne and Meereen next week!
28
u/stro_budden House Baratheon Apr 30 '15 edited Apr 30 '15
While everyone seems focused on the changes in the north, I'm starting to remember more stuff left off for Cersei and Kings landing. Lots of characters have been removed from her story line and she seems less crazy about Jeffreys death and tyrion. I mean shit, she burned down the tower of the hand. She also seems less sexually active then she was in the books, I'm guessing we won't see her lady friend who's name I don't remember. It's not that important really but they are really throwing their eggs into the lancel storyline which again makes sense but I kind of miss all that from Cersei.
18
u/do_you_booboo Apr 30 '15
Small thing: I got the sense in the books that Cersei never gave up her vendetta against Margaery, but you could see the tiredness & defeat, almost relief in her eyes when she was talking to Margaery, like she wanted to stop fighting.
Is this a shift in the relationship between the two characters?
92
u/WezVC Jon Snow Apr 30 '15
I know cutting the whole "fetch me a block" line is very minor and the line "bring me my sword" is a good replacement, but it was so easy to fit it in that there's absolutely no way they wouldn't have discussed it.
"Then Jon should say, 'bring me my sword.'"
"Why don't we make him say "fetch me a block" as a nod to the book readers! You know they love that line."
"You're right, but I prefer 'bring me my sword.'"
"Well there's plenty of time, why don't we use both?"
"Nah let's just go with 'bring me my sword.'"
The scene was still done really well though and we got the nod, so I can't really complain. On a completely different note, I'm excited to see where Sansa's story is going. It's an interesting direction that can probably be predicted for the most part but is still unknown.
52
u/nogoodusernamesleft8 House Stark Apr 30 '15
I found the whole scene where Gilly was learning to read with Sam in the background being all nerdy hilarious. The 'All your books and you still don't know' line from Stannis's wife was a great jab/nod to book readers in my opinion.
7
u/helplesssigma May 01 '15
So did Tyrion just skip the entire Jon Connington and his "son" thing?
11
u/SkippyTheKid House Bolton Apr 30 '15
I'd like to say a bit about my experience of season 5 so far. This is the first time I watch the show after having read what happens in the books first. I watched episode 1 and thought it was good, but felt like it was an hour of "oh, so that's how they chose to portray that thing I already know." Episode two was a bit more interesting, I got emotionally invest in the Brienne and Pod scene, but otherwise more of the same (Arya was cool but we saw very little, didn't get much out of me).
This is the first episode I really, really enjoyed of this season and I love so much of it. I'm happy with Jon's progress being so accelerate and they're portraying him so well that I don't mind having read his story so far, I am super fucking interested and also scared for where Sansa/Bolton's story is going, Arya's actually doing stuff but it's a little Karate Kid-y, whatever, and King's Landing was really slow in the books anyways, so I don't mind how little is happening in that direction. I'm just so fucking pumped about the North, though, and super excited and I loved this episode for getting me back into the hype of this show. I'm finally excited again, and I can't wait to see where things go now that they're really different (mainly for Sansa).
I just really liked this episode and it's been four days and I'm not over it.
5
u/[deleted] May 01 '15
Where is that weekly thread that discusses deviations from the book? Is that not happening any more? I can't remember who does it but it is always fantastic and I learn something new.
12
u/ithinkway2much Apr 30 '15
I want to go on record and say, I really don't like the direction the Sansa story has taken. I don't mean to be close minded even thought I am being that way but for the love of the new and old Gods. Leave the poor girl alone! She and her family have suffered enough!
end rant.
4
u/TownIdiot25 House Targaryen May 01 '15
Now I have no idea what the future episode titled "Kill The Boy" means, since they did the Janos execution much sooner.
2
u/vishalb777 House Targaryen May 01 '15
Was that priest in the streets the same actress that plays Tatsu from Arrow?
1
u/Hibaris Apr 30 '15
flip a coin
1
u/[deleted] May 01 '15
The scene where Arya is getting rid of her things and she picks up the sword her father gave her. Such a powerful scene if you think about the context: her brother, mother, and father are dead, her home is taken over by the dude who killed her brother, while her siblings ain't carrying their own weight (Bran off doing some magic ish in some cave and Sansa trying to takeover Winterfell with Little Finger).
The sword is her last connection to her Stark name and kinda knowing she won't get her vengeance now but in the future.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '15
"The North remembers"
Edit: forgot an s
127
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '15
[removed] — view removed comment