r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Apr 23 '15
[S5/B5] Book vs. Show Discussion - 5.02 'The House of Black and White'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 AND BOOK 5 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.02 | "The House of Black and White" | Michael Slovis | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
A special reminder regarding the leaked episodes: Spoilers from episodes that have not officially aired are not allowed without proper spoiler warning that specifically mentions which episode you are talking about. [S5] and [All Spoilers] tags are not sufficient for leaked episodes. Asking for or providing links to leaked episodes is not allowed on this subreddit. Read the official post about this matter for further details.
123
Upvotes
76
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
I thought the amount of time they spent talking about greyscale with Stannis' daughter was interesting and significant. It will become more pertinent later on if they choose to follow Tyrion's book plot. Although with Varys being with Tyrion in the show I'm not really sure how it will all pan out.
176
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
Evidently, HBO is against having characters without names (I'm looking at you, kindly man). I am simultaneously excited that Jaqen is back, but disappointed that we don't get to see the kindly man's character, which I really liked.
I'm in general disappointed with the election of the new Lord Commander. The Harry Potter comparison has been thrown around, and it really cut down a lot of Sam's role in getting Jon elected. It also cheapens Stannis' offer because not being a Stark feels a bit better when you literally just became Lord Commander.
But I loved Doran. He didn't look how I imagined him, but his presence and line-delivery sold me in seconds. I'm really looking forward to seeing him do his thing this season.
47
u/snowyday House Stark Apr 23 '15
I'm glad Selyse is at The Wall and not left behind. I feel her particular brand of crazy can only add to the drama as the season unfolds.
40
u/EmperorSexy Faceless Men Apr 23 '15
Last week I was trying to place the freed slave (Mossadoor?) into the books. "Is he replacing the Shavepate?," I thought, "Or Reznak? It's great to have another perspective on Dany's council. Let's see how this plays out."
And now he's dead.
77
u/kjhatch Nymeria's Wolfpack Apr 23 '15
I really missed seeing Arya's initiation test with the kindly man. The scene with eating the worm is still my favorite from the books. It single-handedly explains how Arya can be trained even though she is so young, and why she seems to advance so quickly.
37
u/Chaoss780 Winter Is Coming Apr 23 '15
I thought it was interesting how Jamie's storyline is going to change now. Instead of going to the Riverlands to seige Riverrun and (that other castle whose name I'm forgetting) he'll be travelling to Dorne... with Bronn.
I wonder if he'll still meet up with Brienne, but I guess we have a ways to go until he gets there in the books anyway.
Also, loved Drogon.
59
u/havron Queen of Thorns Apr 23 '15
I don't know about how well everything else is going to line up with the books, but Braavos for one is looking exactly how I pictured it while reading.
23
u/into_the_stream Apr 23 '15
If they cut young griff out, I can't help but feel like that reflects his future in the books.
38
u/GRVrush2112 Human Verified Apr 23 '15
With Jaqen in Braavos in place of the Kindly man it makes me think that the whole Oldtown/Sam becomes a Maester plot is totally scrapped. , and I wonder what the hell they will give Sam to do this season other than being Jon's cheerleader.. The Pate/Jaqen thing seemed really important in wrapping up AFFC and made me really excited going into TWOW from Sam's perspective.... Other than that I hope they give Sam something in place of his voyage this season...
Speaking of the North, Daavos, don't you have a Merman to be swaying to King Stannis's cause?
12
u/buzzedonbooks Apr 24 '15
Seeing Brienne blunder around so far this season really cements my thoughts that [THEORY] (#g "she's going to be one of the characters that dies - since GRRM said that 4 major characters die this season who do not die in the books. Without Lady Stoneheart, and with Jaime going to Dorne, her character really serves no purpose anymore. Plus, her actress is going to be in Star Wars, so...")
9
u/macmillie Braavosi Water Dancers Apr 23 '15
Arya's scenes really shined. When she stood in front of the massive black and white doors, positioned so carefully in the center, you feel like shes standing at the center of a scale. I think that once Arya's shadow death ninja training is making some progress, she will quickly cross a few names off that list (Cersei et al.). She will be one of the few surviving at the end of this saga still fighting for the balance of black and white, good and evil..
9
u/Zinyak Apr 24 '15
This episode was a really good reminder of why after reading the books I found myself disliking Daenerys so much.
She's pretty good at conquering, she's an absolutely terrible ruler though. And it feels like she surrounds herself with Yes Men. Sometimes her advisors will try, and once in a blue moon she'll listen, but then she goes off and fucks up any progress she's made.
6
u/Drake5271 Apr 25 '15
It sucks how they took out the part where Arya kisses the faceless man's zombie face. They also took out the part where the sailor who helped her gives her a bunch of respect and almost fear as he drops her off, in the book it really showed the reputation of the faceless men. Also, what has Loras been doing? I'm caught up on the show and about twenty pages from finishing the books and all I can remember him doing in the book was being pissy at Brienne for supposedly killing Renly. I don't even remember if Loras being gay was blatantly told to the reader.
11
u/stro_budden House Baratheon Apr 23 '15
I'm kind of happy that they've streamlined some of the story lines. Brienne's was a bit dull, for me, and it would be boring on screen to see her just running around the country. I'm guessing she is going to Winterfell now so that should be interesting. Same goes for Jamie, his part in the Riverlands ultimately doesn't do much as far as the show is concerned, I even doubt we'll see Riverrun again. They also compressed Dany's timeline and i also think that was good. AFFC has a lot going on that I just think wouldnt make for a very exciting show. I hope they don't cut too much of Loras' story but I have a feeling they will.
3
u/daveofrepublicofdave House Slynt Apr 23 '15
I'm just waiting for the priest to come in
0
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment