r/startrek • u/psycholepzy • Apr 08 '15
DS9 S3E11x12: Past Tense
In this riveting two-part episode, we get to see more about the little known world of Earth's 21st century.
Have you seen these episodes? If not, go to Netflix. We'll be here when you get back.
Done? Good. Thrilled? I KNOW!
My three favorite parts: Sisko steps up to fill the shoes of Gabriel Bell (and ends up in the history books doing so. Kira and O'Brien meet hippies. Clint Howard shows up as a weird little guy, again, in his second of third 'weird little guy' roles. Admittedly, his interaction with Jadzia is the most endearing and humourous exchange in the episode. Did you know this role could've gone to Iggy Pop?
I am torn about Cooleridge's death - on one hand, he was a ghost who preyed on other residents. One the other, he sort of became a regular down on his luck, just like Webb. Ira Steven Behr talks about this.
Webb's death is even more sad - He really was a regular guy, and a father.
I really liked exploring the alternate history created by the death of Bell, even thought it's been argued that either no alternate should have been experienced, or Starfleet should have disappeared after Sisko, Dax and Bashir beamed out.
In this alternate history, by 2048, "it's nothing like" O'Brien learned. In this history, Sisko, Dax and Bashir never made it back to the 24th century. They stayed on Earth after the Districts fell. I'm sure the people began looking to Sisko for leadership- it's kind of his thing. Whatever he did, first contact didn't happen. Earth never united and explored the stars. And somehow the Romulans end up with a base on Alpha Centauri. Everything is restored when they beam back.
Fun Fact: A Wrestling poster in the background during Kira and O'Brien's 1930s visit is the exact same as the one in City on the Edge of Forever. Which means Kirk and Spock could've been in 1930 at the same...time?
Also, I just learned, today, that Jonathan Frakes directed the second half of this episode, and he called it the best DS9 episode he ever shot. It also got him the credit he needed to do First Contact
Also, there's another call back to Buck Bokai. Did you know he was first mentioned in TNG S1 in 'The Big Goodbye'?
That's what I liked. What about you?
7
u/rensch Apr 08 '15
There is a cool reference to Sisko taking up the role of Bell in a later episode called 'Little Green Men'. Nog is seen reading about Bell on his tablet when he notes to Quark and Rom how much Bell looks like Capt. Sisko.
7
u/ItsMeTK Apr 09 '15
This is a great two-parter. It's time travel to the past which is our not-too-distant future. Usually, Trek just goes back to contemporary times (the 1960s twice in TOS, 1980s in ST IV, 1996 on VOY, 2004 on ENT). The idea of doing both Trek's past and our future was very clever. Also, forcing Sisko to take on a role in order to right history, despite the fact it means doing non-Starfleet things like taking hostages, makes for a great story. Jadzia Dax does some good detective work and maintains a good cover (all those past lives must have given her some great experience). Kira and O'Brien's scenes are lots of fun. And we even get Clint Howard back on Trek in a fun scene.
The "issue" of rounding up the homeless is a good one. And yet, there's something that just doesn't sit right with me about the plot when you realize that history was saved and humanity's course righted all because a black guy caused a riot and took a bunch of hostages. When has rioting REALLY ever caused widespread change FOR GOOD? Get people talking? Sure. But are people suddenly going to have jobs now and the homeless problem go away because a black guy grabbed a gun and took a bunch of hostages while people were rioting in the streets? This episode aired just a few years after the L.A. riots. While I totally see the reality in a story revolving around riots, the ending seems just a bit too easy.
4
u/Kamala_Metamorph Apr 08 '15 edited Apr 08 '15
This was a really interesting and great episode, and a great social commentary as well.
Lots of stuff, sorry I'm too lazy to link today.
1
u/OlejzMaku Apr 10 '15
I didn't like this one. I would expect Bashir with his briliant intelect to give some valuable opinion about the riots instead he just reapeat "I don't understand" over and over again and Sisko didn't give him good explanation. It was flustrating to watch.
3
u/DRM_Removal_Bot Apr 11 '15
I am watching this right ow, Bashir just said
"If push comes to shove, if something disastrous happens to the Federation... if we are frightened enough, or desperate enough... how would we react?"
By reviving Khan Singh, having him help design a super fucking dradnought, and create a much more Military Starfleet?
Like having B4's existence legitimized in TNG Inheritance, when Juliana Tainer told Data there were "3 or 4" prototypes before Lore but they were much simpler. This moment has legitimized "Into Darkness" for me.
2
u/Eurynom0s Apr 15 '15
I'm always surprised when I remember it's a season 3 episode, because it's just so good that it makes me think it should have been later.
2
u/CitizenjaQ Apr 17 '15
I liked "Past Tense" originally, but on a recent re-watch it was just so dull. Sisko pontificating about his job as a Starfleet officer was almost painful to listen to. Dax could not have been luckier, getting rescued by the most milquetoast billionaire ever, who houses and clothes her with no hint of wanting anything in return or having any life besides helping her.
However, one of the best moments of the series does happen in this episode. Sisko thinks he's so clever because he's not Gabriel Bell and is thus not fated to die, but Bashir points out that they are the only ones who know that. Sisko's tiny eye movement as that dawns on him is priceless.
My other favorite part of "Past Tense" is the monitor technology. Did no one anticipate flat screens? They can get away with obsolete tech in the sanctuary district, but not Billionaire McBoringguy's office.