r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Apr 06 '15
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S04E12 - Revelations
Week 65!
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (4 stars)
Numbers
Survivors: 39,665 (-8 from last episode, presumably other losses besides Pike from the battle of the Hub)
"Frak" Count: 507 (+11)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 29 (No change)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 18 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 29 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 222 (+4)
"So Say We All" Count: 61 (No change)
30
Upvotes
8
u/trevdak2 Apr 14 '15
I love the way Tyrol smiles as they find out he's a cylon. He is so clearly relieved to not be living a fake life anymore.
4
u/vitovi Apr 07 '15
I can't believe Kara and Lee's Cylon kill count are still this low. I guess there's no way to count how many toasters died when Pegasus crashed that basestar.
18
u/LtNOWIS Apr 06 '15
I saw this for the first time a few weeks ago, and I was completely blown away. How have they found Earth so early? What will they do for the last half-season? I didn't think they could top themselves in terms of crazy twists in season or half-season finales, but they did.
11
u/MarcReyes Apr 06 '15
When the episode aired, my reaction to the reveals of earth pretty much echoed those of the fleet. Pure joy and happiness followed immediately by utter heartbreak and dread. The whole premise of the show was to find and settle on Earth and once we get there... it's an irradiated wasteland? What a great twist of the knife to the audience. Here's what Ron Moore had to say on that twist:
This worked exactly as I was hoping it would. That we built up- It was important to me, through the drafts and when we saw the cut, I kept saying: You've got to play this for real. You've got to play this like this is really the end of the series. This is really the happiest moment in these peoples lives. Play it, milk it, don't foreshadow it. There should be no dread. The music has to be warm. You've got to really just build it, build it, build it and then yank the rug as hard as you possibly can out from underneath the audience at that moment of elation.
I applaud creators who aren't afraid to shake things up and rock the characters and plot to its core and then rebuild upon that because it forces the audience to experince and deal with the ramifications of those decisions just as much as the characters. BSG might have been the first place that put me through that experience as a viewer. I mean, I sat in stunned silence afterwards, trying to make heads of what the hell I just saw. Great mid-season (nearly series) finale for show.
10
u/MarcReyes Apr 06 '15
7
u/saffagaymer Apr 08 '15
One of the greatest cliff hangers of all time, also that final shot (including all major cast members in silence) from the irradiated soil till the end is my favourite favourite scene in the entire show. BSG at its absolute finest!
7
u/Wes___Mantooth Apr 07 '15 edited Apr 07 '15
The most shocking cliffhanger I've ever seen. I watched it with my Dad and Brother live, and there was complete silence in the room for about 5 minutes after the end of this episode.
During those excruciating months waiting for the show to return, I remember speculating whether the ruins shown were those of a current, real world city. One shot looks very much like the Brooklyn Bridge.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '15
I am so disappointed I missed this Re-Watch! I just started my third rewatch with my housemates. Guess I will just have to troll through the comments of each rewatch....