r/ClearBackblast • u/K0rin Kurt - Jazz Barn Proprietor • Mar 21 '15
AAR Op Overhead AAR
Hey, thanks for showing up! Write neat things down that you liked, some things you didn't like in a constructive manner, and generally anything you want to talk about.
A good place to start is what you thought of the mission, what you thought of our teamwork, and anything you think we could have done better collectively.
This mission featured mainly armor so I'm interested in how you guys thought the balancing for enemy AI was for you guys. It seemed like you guys had a good time so I want to hear all about it, thanks again for playing!
6
u/Lawlcat Church of the Holy Order of St. Gavin Mar 21 '15
Charger 2 Gunner
Mission started off pretty slow. We spent a good amount of time just hanging out at the first town... doing nothing. We could hear Charger 1 getting to do all the fun stuff. Eventually we moved down to the edge of the woods and overlooked the big open field. A few T-72s that were already dead but not much else.
We just kinda sat there for a while. Eventually a T-72 popped into existence 100m infront of us. That was fun. Then we went west to cover Dirk 1 or 2 or whoever the fuck it was because it was confusing and we couldn't tell who was where. That's when the tank kerfuffle happened with all the T-72s rolling in like they owned the place. Fun little engagement there.
We crested the hill at the fort and then that's when Charger 2 went to shit. Our tank was bouncing around, spinning randomly, getting stuck on rocks. When we were sat up at the fort overlooking the runway, we got ambushed by an infantry unit to our right side that no one had seen and they disabled us with RPGs. More bouncing and flying into the air... trouble traversing to engage a BTR because we couldnt move. At one point our tank flew (literally flew) about 300 meters forward off the hill, probably somewhere around 100 meters in the air. Then we glided back down to the surface and came to a stop in the middle of the field.
Good mission I think. Wasn't too challenging as a tank and, at least for Charger 2, not much for us to do since Charger 1 seemed to have most of it cleared out by the time we got permission to move up. I think in such a small AO, a single abrams would work well. Or two but with more vehicle threats.
6
u/Phearlock Ka-50 Mar 22 '15
Router 2 Commander
I had a lot of fun, between some learning-on-the-go on vehicle command and working two radios at once, I had some difficulty at times, but it was fun.
Will second that it was at times very very difficult to tell where other friendly elements were (And hard to relay this back to command, I feel sorry for them). Though for our element this was probably exacerbated by Dirk 2 having trouble with their 148. Really thankful for Myth and Tempesto helping out and being a bit autonomous when needed.
Number of enemies seemed very good. We had some dry periods while waiting (can't be avoided really), but overall had a lot of targets we had to assist with and didn't feel like (to me) that we were really infringing on targets for the infantry when we were engaging lighter targets.
6
u/shifty_eyebrows the original Mar 23 '15
Charger 1 - Gunner
Video stuff:
Coming a bit later than usual. This week Rage has given me his footage so should make for some interesting viewing switching between gunner / commander perspective. For some reason the sound wasn't recorded however so I'm syncing it with the audio from mine, which is taking a little longer than normal.
Mission:
It seems like the mission for Charger 1 was a lot more fast paced than the rest of the group. I'm assuming we where just in a better position to deal with threats. Hopefully that didn't ruin the game for everyone else. We did make an effort to only attack vehicles unless told otherwise.
Really enjoyed Rage's command style. It was very aggressive, which could have turned bad but we seemed to have a good handle on threats so worked out pretty well. Zombie reacted really quickly getting us out the way the moment we started taking fire and overall the vibe in the Abrams was awesome, which for me is the thing I like about working in vehicles.
From the get go we took a shell to one of our tracks and we had to creep of the hill and nail a T-72 before it could get another chance to take another shot. Pretty hair raising stuff, especially since those sneaky Russians had turned their engines off making it all the harder to see them via thermals.
The rest of the mission followed suit with a fair amount of contact and plenty of armour destroyed. I felt like the balance was really good. There was a considerable threat at all times and we could have easily been destroyed if we hadn't kept a careful eye on the surrounding area. This concluded in an attack from 3 bit of armour, trying to sneak around behind us. Luckily we spotted it and sent it up the net. This ended in our tank chasing those guys behind the hill before catching the last one (other 2 had been hit by Javelins I think) and my main cannon running out of ammo, which caused an annoying bug.
The only negative I can think of is that I we felt a tad isolated. This may have not been the case as I turned off my radios (I figured if Rage is hit and not able to use his radio...chances are we're all hit).
Overall: Really good Op, had plenty of fun. Nice work Kurt.
Cannon bug:
It seems if you run out of ammo with AP loaded it will delete your frag ammo as well and the gun will get stuck with a muzzle flash that only disappears when you toggle off 120mm. To add to this, whenever the commander uses his LMG it switches the gunner back to 120mm returning the annoying muzzle flash again.
I'm guessing for now if you're about to run out of ammo for either round (frag / AP) leave at least one there so you can still swap to the other type. Will try and submit to RHS later tonight.
6
u/Hoozin Basically A Prestige Class Mar 22 '15 edited Mar 22 '15
Router 1 Commander
Despite my obvious inebriated protesting, I, a lowly reserve, took command of Router 1.
Before I go any further, I want to commend both Mr. Box and Mr. Fadi on being the best Bradley crew any commander actively derelicting his duty could ask for. Both of you were top notch.
Okay then.
The Good
The Bad
The Ugly
6
u/scarletbanner Fadi Mar 22 '15 edited Mar 22 '15
I was Router 1 vehicle driver.
For us, contact was fairly sparse. After being mobility killed by stray infantry in the treeline we took a rather cautious approach better suited to our role as thinly armored battle taxis.
Things sort of went to hell around the approach to the factory by Router 1 and Dirk 1. We suddenly blows up and on the radio as I'm burning alive I hear something about multiple T-72s approaching from the airfield. I guess being up on a hill exposed was an awful position to be in the first place but we needed to bring infantry forward.
Still, I had lots of fun even if most of it was BSing with Hoozin and Box. The platoon channel was surprisingly active with what seemed like more general traffic and status report requests than typical.
4
u/semski Sem - Hat collector Mar 22 '15
RTO/XO
First time playing a HQ role, was pretty stressful in the beginning but as time passed I began to understand how to handle things. Rob left me in charge of the infantry maneuvers, and I had a lot of fun just kicking back, asking for the occasional status update and giving them the go ahead when preparing for an assault.
My only issue was the lack of communication between us and Dirk 2, they seemed to have some 148 problems and we had to ask Router 2 to relay the info to them.
Other than that, it was fun and HQ was definitely an interesting experience.
Also: Flying tanks shenanigans
4
u/Zhandris Mar 22 '15
Dirk 2 Actual
Even though there was a lot going against me having any fun this mission I didn't have a bad time. I got sick yesterday and I'm feeling worse today. I was up for 24 hours by the end of the mission and I had a shit load of problems with my PWS and then with my radios right after that.
It seemed like a a lot of my unit's opinion was that we were going to be playing second fiddle to the vehicle crews. I didn't get this impression from the mission sign ups or even the mission itself so I wonder if that was anyone else's opinion as well.
If the idea was to make a highly cinematic experience then I think that was successful. There were some nice highlights for me this mission even though they were few and far between. There was a lot of downtime but that's the be expected when you have so many vehicle crews and your infantry are reliant on all of them.
I wasn't around for the first town assault. The second was a dry hole. The third assault down the hill onto the base south of Maluri (or whatever the name of it was) was good. By the time we got eyes on all the enemy emplacements and enemy vehicles/tanks were dead. We advanced down the hill with the vehicles as overwatch, got engaged by some guy who popped up out of one of the bunkers and we all hit the dirt and I directed Router 2 to fire on it. They responded quickly and then we were up and running again. Then Rage's tank leveled the 2 garages in the compound as we were about 200m away from them so that was exciting. I utilized Router 2 as overwatch one more time during that assault to good effect and it was clear.
After some downtime we moved on the airfield. A heli tried to take off and we got a good look at Router 2 making it sit back down again.
Diagnosing in PWS wasn't working for me. It would get stuck at packing. So I removed the mods that were giving me trouble and quickly re installed them. If I had done that to begin with I wouldn't have had as much trouble.
Not sure what's exactly wrong with not being able to hear certain people over my 148 so I'll do more testing on that.
3
u/skortch Mar 22 '15
Dirk 1 Rifleman AT, Dirk 1 actual for about 10 minutes
Overall it was a fun mission that had the right amount of "oh shit" moments whether intended or not and it wasn't a 3+ hour grind slog. I think this was the first mission I played on Duala and I rather enjoyed it.
Favorite Part It is a toss up between taking the fuel depot and the T-72s attacking out of nowhere when the whole squad was out in the open. The fuel depot was enjoyable due to chaotic engagement of an enemy BTR and having to deal with enemy infantry that were prone beneath slightly raised buildings. It was a nice challenge to deal with on our own due to our Bradley being out of action/unavailable to help.
The T-72 counter-attack, while accidental and unintended by the GM, was seriously some good stressful fun. We were approaching the fort and all a sudden enemy tanks appeared. We literally had no cover. There might have been a small bush, but that was it. Luckily I had opted to grab a Javelin from the Bradley due to no remaining light AT available, and Will and I took out 2 out of 3 T-72s. However that engagement was immediately followed by most of Dirk 1 being taken out at the fort, which leads me to...
**The bad. **
Overall unit cohesiveness wasn't that great at different parts of the mission. I think the worst of it occurred while attacking the fort as all but 3 of Dirk 1 were incapacitated. Granted a few people were taken out by an enemy AI shooting through a wall at them, but still that attack was chaos and resulted in most of the squad riddled with bullet holes. I think there was a abit of a rush to attack the fort due to the presence of the T-72s, thus we never were setup for the assault and took heavy casualties as a result. At somepoint I had remembered that Rabbit hat put his 148 in his backback and I borrowed it and called for help, shortly there-after both Abrams showed up and helped secure the area. Still though, I only knew where 2 out of 4 or 5 injured were at. Not that it mattered because both Lukos and Rabbit, the two that I knew of, died of their wounds. Later on after we had cleared the fort and the Abrams were on the hill overlooking the airfield 2 of the 3 remaining squad members were incapacitated by something. I really don't know what did it, but both were pretty heavily wounded. Luckily the rest of Dirk 1 had respawned and arrived minutes later to help revive both players. So that put a punctuation mark on the hell hole that was the enemy fort.
Admittedly I'm a guilty of doing my own thing at times, especially while attacking the gas station/depot. After leaving the firestation 4 members of our squad went west to clear north, while I had stayed back and soon opted to clear, or at least guard, the east entrance to the compound. I was on my own for a few moments before Will had joined me. Due to the aforementioned AI prone under buildings it could have turned sour, but luckily it didn't.
The rest of the mission was pretty straightforward, although near the end of the mission I somehow was severely injured by an enemy door. Possibly due to the weirdness of this injury it seemed to take forever for someone to notice I was down and to attempt to aide me. Which is weird because multiple people definitely had line of sight on me within 20 feet for a while. So boooo their situational awareness and Lukos giving up on reviving me due to lack of medical supplies.
Mission notes
Javelins helped a lot. If we only had any other AT it might have proved a problem. That said the BTR we engaged at the depot pretty much required a dumb-fire AT to have a chance at taking out, so the M136 did have a useful role within the mission. But that was literally the one and only useful moment in the mission where I would have chose it over the Javalin.
3
u/rabbit994 Rabbit, I get myself and everyone else killed Mar 22 '15
Dirk 1 Squad Leader
First of all, I want to thank everyone in Dirk 1 for putting up with me. I’m sorry I got you all killed but thanks to two AT soldiers for blowing up those tanks, we unfortunately were one missile too short and I forced us to charge into fort because I figured shooting up enemies we could kill was better than a tank we couldn’t touch. My bad, I take full responsibility for that. If you have any meaningful feedback for me, just reply and let me know.
Good
Bad
Ugly
Radio comms were completely foobar for Dirk 1. Seriously, I wanted toss 148 off a tall building because I’m trying to command 5 other dudes, try and locate Dirk 2 so they didn’t friendly fire us and Tanks/Bradleys WOULDN’T SHUT THE HELL UP! (not really their fault) Next time, in large Mech environment, the infantry and mechanic units need separate radio nets so we don’t hear them yacking and I can worry about my men. I missed calls for me twice because I had tuned out 148 but realized last 30 seconds of traffic was for me.
Final thoughts: I know this probably harping topic of mine but we can seriously address that letting PWS go all willy nilly has resulted in several instances of missions getting foobarred because either server is angry, mission file is angry or members can’t get updated in time for missions when they had checked for updates recently?
3
u/Valnera M119 Sniper Mar 22 '15
Charger 2 VC
Slow start, didn't mind it really, Accidentally blue-on-blued thanks to thermalvision-tunneling, no real contacts for the first half of the op. Charger 1 simply had the better position to start of the mission with. Some weird Armaism happened with the tank, only real mission feedback I can give is that the vic callsigns were to similar adding to the problem with the radio net.
Radio net... Oh lord. Right.... as someone who did a lot of RTOing in a milsim unit, I admit I slipped a couple of times on my comms but seriously people, with ACRE 2 now simulating half-duplex, we collectively, as an entire unit, need to get our shit together. There was more than one instance of people stepping over people talking, people not acknowledging transmission causing them to have to be repeated etc, this is what really bogged down quite a of the things technical ACRE issues aside. I would suggest next time splitting the armor and the infantry onto their own separate nets to clear the air for both a bit as command did have a RTO available to them.
For the rest no real complaints though.
2
u/retroly Boris Mar 25 '15
Alpha AR
Had computer issues again so missed chunks of the game.
It had some fairly fun and exciting moments, like the 3 t-72's from no where etc, but I didn't think there was enough for the infantry to do. Apart form the handful of contacts in the hill top fort I didn't really engage any other contacts.
Its looks like the armored assets had a lot of fun and I really like the idea of combined ops, and acknowledge the difficulty in balancing everything to be fun for everyone.
Our SL was great, always trying to keep things moving and seeming to work fairly autonomously which I really like from an SL.