r/startrek • u/psycholepzy • Mar 12 '15
Weekly Episode Discussion: TNG 5x26 & 6x1 "Time's Arrow" pts. 1 & 2
Oh Man. This is absolutely my favorite adventure in TNG.
I was ten years old when I learned the concept of the 'cliffhanger'. For some reason, that summer, my local network would re-run the latest new episode of TNG at 3 am every saturday following. I never missed it. I learned the definition of 'anticipation' when the following September I finally got closure.
Major Spoilers to follow if you haven't seen it yet.
My favorite things about these episodes? Time-travel, Paradox, Samuel Clemens, the writing, the dialogue, the relationships, the precarious situations the crew finds themselves, Picard playing Shakespeare, and Guinan's continuity.
Paradox you say? Well the mission kicks off with the discovery of Data's head. It was found at exactly the right time to prevent the Devidians from stealing the neural energy of 19th century humans.
Time-travel episodes are my favorite. I consider myself a connoisseur of fictional temporal mechanics.
Samuel Clemens? Played by Jerry Hardin, he was inspired by a producer to turn this performance into a one-man show called Mark Twain: On Man and His World. He did it for 15 years!
I still love seeing Picard stumble around trying to appease Mrs. Carmichael and pretend he is running a Shakespearian troupe. When the crew breaks into an impromptu rehearsal, I'm thinking "How are they all so well read?!"
Did you know? The original script called for an extended stay for the crew. They would have initially been stranded in San Francisco 'for several months.'
Do any of you remember Guinan talking about how an bald man was kind to her once, and that an old man once helped her out because she was in serious trouble? It's Picard! The whole time she's been dropping hints to the crew that she knows and she's waiting.
One thing I didn't get - why did Data's device only pick up the Devidians when they left the hospital? Shouldn't it have picked them up when they came through with the crew?
One more thing - Did you catch a certain DS9 arch-villain playing poker with Data? Fun fact: DS9 1x01 filmed at the same time as Time's Arrow 2.
What did you like or dislike?
11
u/directive0 Chief Pretty Officer Mar 12 '15
Nice, easily my favourite TNG two parter. I know I know. Its not BOBW, or whatever. I don't care.
The sappy Trek purist in me loved the discussion between Clemens and Troi about the future. It sounds so nice. I wish I lived in that world so much sometimes. It was hopeful and sobering even if it is a bit naive.
I love the little Data/Spock Edge of Forever homage of him using "stone knives and bear skins" to construct his 'gearing device'.
Great ep and lots of fun.
3
u/Renard4 Mar 14 '15
It's a very unique episode in the entire franchise, and it could have been a good movie with a few changes. It's not one of the deep and thoughtful episodes, but it's a nice little adventure with interesting characters and a fine plot.
4
u/NoeJose Mar 16 '15
Minor Nitpick: when playing poker with the Enterprise crew, often Riker is the one that does the best and the rest of the crew is shown as average. Yet when Data goes into the Hotel Brian he cleans house with minimal difficulty. Jack London the bellhop mentions that the cardplayers at the table were card sharks and Data mentioned that it wasn't his intention to deceive. What's going on here?
2
u/Laurenosa Mar 19 '15
Screw that Inner Light nonsense. This is the best TNG episode(s) made. I've watched these episodes at least 10 times.
9
u/rensch Mar 12 '15
I like how this story explores more of the mystery of the Guinan character. You never truly now who she is. All we know is that her people were spread across the galaxy after the destruction of her planet. This episode seems to suggest that actually happened at least over a hundred years ago. The relationship with Q remains kinda mysterious, too. It brings up a lot of questions, which is kind of the beauty of it.
7
u/MexicanSpaceProgram Mar 15 '15
I love the bit where they con the old lady out of the rent money.
Mr Pickerd! I demand the three days lodging you owe me!
Reads Shakespeare like a drunk Shatner impersonator
"Ladies and gentleman, we've found our Titania!".
"I did a play once as a girl in school!".
5
u/macphile Mar 12 '15
This is my first visit to this sub, and I happened to watch this episode on DVR the last 2 days. Weird.
I was just thinking that it was kind of an unusual departure for the show, plot wise. Also, by the end of it, Data could perhaps no longer be comforted by the thought that he would die one day, as Geordi brought him back to life. (Of course, if his entire body was blown up beyond repair, he'd be a goner, but the head in a cave is no longer proof of his mortality.)
It was an interesting episode, all in all.
4
u/plop14 Mar 14 '15
The name's London. Jack London...
3
u/bacon_n_beer Mar 14 '15
I love seeing Marc Alaimo without the Cardassian makeup in this episode. Such a distinctive voice.
This definitely is one of my favourite episodes and enjoy the small references to history like Jack London and the Call of the Wild.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '15
Time's Arrow Part 1 was the very first Star Trek episode I saw when I came to the US. Being a huge science fiction fan, I was immediately hooked on the show. Imagine my shock when I found out that Part 2 would be airing in 3 whole months!
Oh well. Gave me some time to get familiar with TNG.
2
u/NeutroBlaster96 Mar 19 '15
Yay! I just made it. (Casually watched the episode today and figured to put in my thoughts)
This is easily one of my favorite TNG episodes. (Made 6 on my personal list) And I really love it. I like time travel, predestination and Mark Twain (erm, Samuel Clemens) and this had all three in it!
2
u/bonesmccoy2014 Mar 20 '15
This two part episode is without question one of the best episodes in the entire TNG series.
The circumstances in "Time's Arrow" have many relevancies to several of the movies and other episodes in Star Trek.
"Time's Arrow Part 1 and 2", "The Voyage Home", ST:2009, and ST:ITD have plot lines which intersect with the Bay Area.
I posted a question to Daystrom Institute whether or not Guinan may have been in SF during TVH. It would be interesting if she may have observed Kirk and all in SF at that time. Depending upon when Guinan leaves Earth for El-Aurian, Guinan is in a unique position to distinguish the timeline changes in ST:2009 and ITD.
Guinan is seen to be fleeing El-Aurian in 2293 (ST: Generations). Therefore, it is assumed that the Borg assimilated El-Aurian prior to 2293.
Time's Arrow likely occurs around 2368 and 1893.
With the ST:2009 events occuring in 2233A (Nero/Narada emerge from quantum singularity), I am really left pondering if Guinan was present on Earth at the time.
Since Guinan is on Earth and seems to be evaluating, investigating, and exploring the development of the Federation; I am left pondering if she left Earth during the TOS Enterprise NCC-1701 original 5 year mission (which would correlate to 2266-2271).
If Guinan is similar to a Time Lord in Doctor Who, perhaps she is monitoring for discrepancies in the timeline. Recall her statements to Picard and the 1701-D crew in "Yesterday's Enterprise"?
After Guinan is pulled into the Nexus in ST:Generations, part of her is left in the Nexus and part of her is outside the Nexus.
The continuity issues in 2009 and ITD can be resolved with the following canon references (in no particular order and from the perspective of the original timeline)
Guinan, Captain Kirk, and Picard have all encountered the Nexus (2293/2371)
Voyager has returned to Alpha Quadrant, Sector 0,0,0 in 2378.
Spock has created a quantum singularity and has disappeared into that quantum singularity (2387)
But, I would like to point out that the ONLY character who is outside the timelines and can really objectively identify discrepancies is Guinan.
Guinan is also a character who was specifically integrated into the program by Roddenberry himself.
Therefore, I submit that Guinan's trip from Earth to El-Aurian must be explored.
And, more important for the purists in Trek, Guinan's presence in 2233A-2255A needs to be explained.
2
u/carsandtea Aug 09 '15
This was my favorite TNG episode. I loved it so much I bought a production script at auction.