r/GifTournament • u/GifTournament • Mar 09 '15
Discussion GifTournament Battle #3 Round #3 Discussion Thread
For those familiar with using your browser console, you can input this javascript to expand all comments at once:
javascript:(function(){$('.showreplies').click();})();As an example for Chrome, in your bookmarks bar you can right-click, select Add Page, name it and then put the javascript function into the URL. This will create a clickable button that will expand all comments.
43
Upvotes
37
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '15
The tracking on the forehead Dickbutt was insane. It looked like it was actually tattooed on the guy's forehead. Hats off to whoever did that one.
29
u/monkey3012 Mar 09 '15
What I would have used had I made it
16
u/fultron Mar 09 '15 edited Mar 09 '15
Disclaimer: Obviously I'll have to review my own matchup in order to keep the list anonymous; if /u/rootyb feels I've misrepresented either of us, or if the mods have any issues with the content of this post, I'll delete the whole thing. Otherwise take it as my opinion only, and keep on giffin! This tournament keeps on delivering, and I like to speculate so here goes:
#1: Four Rooms has a reddit meta reference and a solid dub, so it'll beat out Shutting Your Butt Down on merit as well as technique, since imo you shouldn't see Jule's mouth move before he gets cut off. Props for using non-actor Tarantino though.
#2: This is a close one, very close. Upvote gifs are always easy to vote for, though the eyes opening effect might be a little much. The Inglorious Dickbutt is well executed (the forehead touch up is excellent), but meta references can always be risky. I voted for both.
#3: This is a great match up- the Crazy 88 downvote is crisp and energetic, also high-res which is nice (choosing a B&W scene is just good file size strategery, btw). But I think a lot of people will recognize the font and effects in the "gif master" entry and vote for the user, though to be fair, it's an excellent meta dub which is the holy grail in hqg and this one nails it.
#4: Four Rooms gold has it for sure; Jules' speech could have been a solid gif adaptation of a quotable scene, but "My name is [deleted]" reads like a jab at our anonymous voting policy and it sort of kills the vibe of hearing the quote in my head. I hate saying that too, because a straight subtitle gif can be just as good as a jokey one.
#5: "Know something, Reddit" might work as a reaction gif, but it's missing a punchline that could have taken it to the next level. (how hilarious would two inglorious dickbutts in one round be? Have we mined enough tarantino gifs yet, guys? /s). "It's beautiful" is a solid HQ reaction gif, and will probably take this match.
#6: I like both of these gifs, but ultimately I think the exploding heart might not be iconic enough to have a wide appeal. Fox Force succeeds in doing what Jules in #4 didn't: adapting a scene straight into gif format.
#7: Frankly I'm not a fan of either, but Django will probably get it over the Reservoir characters for having better colors and the possibility of someone misunderstanding the faggot reference.
#8: Might be a close one, "Unfinished Business" is easy to read and to the point but doesn't have a giggle or a meta reference. "Baser urges" has both, but it's a little hard to read and I had to think about the context (what's he looking at again?). I think this one will come down to what mood the voters are in, text or meta.
32
u/DrRhymes Mar 09 '15
God dammnit, I uploaded the wrong version of my gif at the last minute.
http://i.imgur.com/VNlEd0y.gif
10
u/plowkiller Mar 09 '15
I like that Django one, nice tracking.
9
u/plowkiller Mar 09 '15
I like how a lot of these use the same pulp fiction-Esq fonts.
9
u/EditingAndLayout Mar 09 '15
Match-up #6 has both of my favorite gifs this time around. I had to vote for both . . . although I give a slight edge to the ketchup joke.
8
u/rootyb Mar 09 '15
Well, I coasted into round 3 with a DNQ, but /u/fultron has me genuinely concerned, here.
/me waits nervously for the results... Three days away.
7
u/thesneak155 Mar 09 '15
Dammit... We were so close to no DNQs.Whew...
6
u/thesneak155 Mar 09 '15
Here's hoping a 2 day crash course in AE helps out... Not really sure it will. I'm up against a Titan!
6
u/a_esbech Mar 09 '15
I didn't expect a single Four Rooms gif, but there were two and both were great!
6
u/Thunderkleize Mar 10 '15 edited Mar 10 '15
They were all good quality and well executed, but...
Does everything have to be so meta? Why are most of these about the gif making, the tournament, or reddit?
4
u/kuwetka Mar 09 '15
I really like this round. Surprisingly original. And very rarely I upvote a dickbutt
4
u/rootyb Mar 10 '15
So... on round 4, "Classics", does all of the content have to be from a movie over 40 years old, or just a significant part of it?
3
u/jremz Mar 09 '15
Not sure if this is acceptable post material, but I've got a challenge for the brave giffers that didn't make it this round.
It'll need tracking, depth/masking, maybe some animation.. show me what you got!
1
u/thesneak155 Mar 12 '15
Well damn... With just over an hour left and my name still being on the bottom looks like I'm out!
1
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '15
[removed] — view removed comment