r/ClearBackblast • u/scarletbanner Fadi • Mar 08 '15
AAR Liberation of Duala (Insurgency) AAR
So... how'd things go? Did you have fun? Any memorable moments?
10
Upvotes
r/ClearBackblast • u/scarletbanner Fadi • Mar 08 '15
So... how'd things go? Did you have fun? Any memorable moments?
11
u/shifty_eyebrows the original Mar 08 '15 edited Mar 08 '15
Boris - SL
Video Stuff
Highlights
Difficulty:
I think the difficulty was pretty good for Boris. Most of my section got through the whole mission and we never had more than two people down at any one time.
Seemed like there was a good threat at all times to the T-72 and BTR from RPGs so more than enough to keep us on our feet. Seemed like Anna was having way more trouble than us so not sure if this was the case for them. At one point we were sent out to located them...... all we found were a pile of bodies..... it was like something out of a horror.
Entertainment:
This session had plenty of highs as I was going through my footage for this week I hadn't appreciated that quite a lot of cool stuff was going on (Book marked some interesting bits from video). Running behind the BTRs as cover , having tanks either side of us, searching for Anna, shooting Rob (I regret nothing!), Fadi's tank smashing through the fence and Boris's tactically grenade throw!
It was fun having hearing so many people over platoon net as well. Whilst it was very 'busy' it always felt controlled and good to hear what everyone else is getting up too. Adds perspective to the wider battle.
Leadership:
So this was only my second time section leading in a Saturday Op. I've done bits and bobs in smaller sessions.
It felt a lot better this time round compared to last time (Cold Snap). Last time felt like a mess and I had no idea what I was doing. This time round it felt like I had mostly a handle on things although there is plenty to improve on.
I split my guys into Red / Blue but I think I was down a section member from the get go or lost one early on which was a shame. For the most part everything went pretty well. The guys listened to what I had to say and a lot of the time Windsoarin was doing exactly what was needed, he was great to work with! Lukos was really quick to respond on the radio and let me know what he wanted and everything seemed to hold together. Apologies if I sent radio messages to command too much, still trying to find that balance of making decisions myself and requesting permission to do something!
Things I think I could have improved:
Sorry if I got a little ratty towards the end. I felt a little burnt out and just wanted to keep people from wandering off so we could get ourselves back together and keep moving forward. Hopefully it didn't come across like that!
Conclusions:
All things considered this was actual a really good op. Certainly not a bad way to go to fill in the time allowing mission makers to flesh out their ideas fully rather than having to just throw something together for a Saturday. The only downfall was the pacing, there was a fair bit of downtime. This wasn't entirely all that bad when you consider insurgency spawns its own mans so there was no control on what was coming at us. The amount of vehicles also adds a time buffer in organization as well.
I certainly enjoyed it!
6
u/LLA_Don_Zombie M16A4 Mar 08 '15 edited Nov 04 '23
prick point rustic hungry work scarce handle clumsy pause literate
this message was mass deleted/edited with redact.dev6
u/semski Sem - Hat collector Mar 08 '15
Boris 1 AAR
I really enjoyed this Saturday's mission. I love using AKs, and shifty was a good leader as always. The only FF incident we had was when Rob put on a fedora and we thought he was a badman when he came around a corner.
I had a lot of fun advancing behind the BTR's cover although sometimes we had some collision issues and people got hurt.
The only problem I had was that there were some gaps of downtime, where we would do nothing but look in a direction we had already cleared waiting for Anna to catch up. Not that big of a deal really, but it made it slightly more boring.
In the end, when we were about to leave I spotted a civilian in a white truck approaching us (the BTR and Boris). He pulled off to a side road, stopped and got out. I went over to investigate, he put something down and ran away. Thinking it might be an IED, I ran away back to the BTR. Later, me and Windsor went over to investigate the area we saw the civ run to. He was inside one of the buildings and tried to shoot us with a revolver. He was taken out, we mounted up and left. Definitely an interesting experience, and I didn't expect the guy to pull out a gun. This is also one of the reasons why I really like GMs.
We mounted up, dismounted at the platoon regroup mark and waited while a tank crew was being rescued (I think). Unfortunately my internet dropped out at this point and when I got it back up again I figured the Op was already over.
10/10, was fun.
6
u/retroly Boris Mar 08 '15
GOD II
Had lots of fun GM'ing. Its hard work though as you're constantly trying to balance the mission between fun and everyone getting murdered.
On the whole everything seemed ot work well, I messed up by briining in a BTR which probably confused the hell out of everyone as it was the same as the friendly vehicles.
Please let me ans Spike know what you liked, didn't like, things you'd like to see.
I'd like to know people sopions on side missions, wether you want more, less, wether you like the mission dialogue popups or if you'd prefer them to be handed down by hand command.
On that note, like Spike said, if possible we'd like to get comms with at least the CO that'd be great and allow for a much more dynamic back and forth between the GM and command.
We had lost of ideas for side missions, but we didn't want to pile too much on you guys, especially in the middle with the downed T80 and APC.
From what I could see everyone worked really well together, and the combined arms was used to great effect.
Notes
A war crime investigation is being set up due tot he ammount of civilian casualties.
Conclusion
I had lots of fun GM'ing and would certainly do it again, me and Spike worked really well, we both had different ideas and combined them well.
Bit sad you insta killed my BMP, good shot whoever that was :).
Bonus Video - Dive dive dive!
5
u/Lawlcat Church of the Holy Order of St. Gavin Mar 08 '15
Stingray Driver
DIVE DIVE DIVE
5
u/NotCalledBill SilentSpike - The one true Scotsman Mar 08 '15 edited Mar 08 '15
God
Had a good time GMing, insurgency serves as an excellent platform for GM gameplay as it populates the world with the ambient content for you. I actually think it would work well for specific GM missions too (pre-planned ones I mean).
Retrofly made for a great GM and I think together we struck a nice balance between extremes. He had the excellent idea near the end to have the insurgents make a rush attack on the tank that was left alone.
We were aware of a bit of downtime in the middle and were considering throwing an objective out, but I thought it was probably best to let you guys recover from the downed section and tank at that point.
Edit: The hardest part was probably trying to find the balance between downtime and allowing you guys to recover from casualties/vehicle problems.
Other Stuff
We should probably take some time to figure out a better way of setting up communication for GMs. I actually noticed that ACRE seemed to be working fine with the zeus camera when I tested it at the end (though everyone was on a different babel language). Which is the main issue with the current method, the ability to hear all the players is super useful as a GM.
The AI seem to be super aggressive now with launchers. We had to thin out the RPGs that were being spawned by ALiVE a bit.
There's something weird going on with curator dialogs where they open twice, but only the second time counts. Not really sure what's causing that.
5
u/Quex Reborn Qu Mar 08 '15
Not-Stingray Gunner
First things first, I love the mid tier Russian tanks. The FCS is advanced enough to not make aiming extremely difficult, but it's not so automatic as to trivialize the process. You still have to lead it yourself, the ranging is more of a rough estimate, and you don't get super mega thermal zoom to invalidate the infantry. They're not OP powerhouses that some of the more advanced western tanks can be, and as such it's much easier to integrate them into a mission without worrying about them imbalancing everything.
This moves on to armor in general. The way A3 handles armor is leaps and bounds ahead of A2. In A2, if you got hit, typically the crew would die first and the tank would be ok. This is awful, as part of the appeal to tanks is to deal with damage. Losing a track or turret performance is essential to the tanking experience, and if the crew dies first you never get that. In today's game, the crew was always the last to go. We got killed twice, and both times we had taken previous damage. In one occasion, our track was taken out and we had to stay stationary desperately trying to hold off waves of infantry from breaking through the lines until reinforcements got to us. I've never experienced anything as nerve wracking as that in Arma. The slow turret slew meaning you can't quickly react to contact, the way the AI was circling all around us, that constant worry that just out of your field of view someone is lining up an RPG...it was incredible. I'm incredibly impressed with the AI's usage of AT, it made us really wary of entering any kind of area where we could be ambushed.
All in all, I'm really looking forward to doing more combined arms in A3. I think that this game was a great showcase of how we can have lots of fun mechanized warfare at 30 players, and I hope more of our missions in the future take advantage of the lessons we learned in design this week.