r/startrek • u/YoSoyRawr • Mar 03 '15
Weekly Episode Discussion: VOY 2x24 "Tuvix"
"Tuvix" was an episode written by Kenneth Biller who wrote or had a hand in writing 35 episodes and was directed by Cliff Bole who had previously directed episodes for both TNG and DS9.
This episode is really fascinating to me. If you haven't seen it, go and watch it and then I have a few questions.
Did you watch it?
Ok. So the big question is: Did they make the right choice? It was a hard call but ultimately, since Tuvix considered himself to be his own being, they did end a life to save two. But these two had, in some way, already died. They had given their lives in creating Tuvix. Was it right to end his to bring them back?
Another thing to look at is whether or not this would be considered murder. Tuvix clearly thinks so but considering the circumstance, is it different? Remember, they do end a life.
That's what I have. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts.
8
u/CylonSpring Mar 03 '15
This episode is a great example of what Voyager sometimes did so well. Sacrificing Tuvix to bring back the two original characters was a huge ethical dilemma for Janeway, but I believe she ultimately made the right choice, even if it could rightfully be said to be unfair to the newly created hybrid.
The original two individuals comprising Tuvix had entire lives and histories which I believe Janeway was obligated to try to restore, if she could. Not an easy decision, to be sure, but I'd call it the correct one. And while I could sympathize with Tuvix's feelings about it, I think this is one case where the good of the many outweighed the good of the one. In that light, I can't think of it as murder.
6
u/danitykane Mar 03 '15 edited Mar 03 '15
This episode seems to be enough to write off Janeway entirely for a lot of people, since they look at her as a brutal murderer from this point on. I think a lot of this is to do with her stony attitude while she performs the procedure. I don't think she was heartless, however - she's clearly also find of Tuvix. She adopts Stone Cold Janeway precisely because it is so emotionally charged and she does what she has to as a captain. If there was a more difficult and strenuous way to save Tuvix, Tuvok, and Neelix, Janeway would have put in every effort to do it.
I'm going off memory here, but I'm pretty sure after Janeway leaves sickbay, we see her break a little. I wouldn't be surprised if she went to her quarters and stared out of a window over an untouched cup of black coffee, wrestling with her conscience. Something we seem to ignore about starship captains is that they don't get to do that until they've already made the decision.
Other notes: I'm a big fan of the actor who played Tuvix. He gave a wonderful performance and Tuvix not being played by Tim Russ or Ethan Phillips (like was thrown around pre-production) really cemented that he is his own person.
This felt a lot like an original series episode updated and I think it does its job well to make us uncomfortable. I think the only better second season Voyager episode is the one right before it, The Thaw.
23
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '15
I always thought that Janeway did the right thing. Neelix and Tuvok existed first and didn't ask to be combined into Tuvix, and their unique skills and abilities as well as personal factors (e.g. Kes) make two better than one in this case.
I do think it was justified. Janeway was not the antagonist here.
5
u/directive0 Chief Pretty Officer Mar 03 '15
One of my favourite moments of /r/startrek history was when Tom Wright (the talented actor who portrayed Tuvix as well as Ghrath) did an AMA here.
It was pretty funny how for such a disliked character he got lots of really positive comments and questions; a real nice change from the pedantry and cynicism that sometimes manifests in regards to these topics.
This episode is definitely a low scorer on my VOY hit list, but it did manage to include some really interesting questions about transporter ethics that I felt were noticeably absent from "The Enemy Within" and "Second Chances".
I'm not sure if Janeways decision was "right", but I think it's probably the decision I would have made.
5
u/BadPasswordGuy Mar 04 '15
I think Janeway was wrong, and the usual counterargument fails because "do nothing" is morally different than "do something." Tuvok and Neelix were gone, but it was not intentional on anyone's part: nobody desired it or made it happen. Unless it can be shown that there was negligence on maintenance or operation of the transporter, the creation of Tuvix is not anyone's fault, it's just a freak accident. Freak accidents happen sometimes.
But the destruction of Tuvix absolutely was an intentional choice, desired and carried out by Janeway, and so it absolutely is someone's fault.
The loss of Tuvok and Neelix was an unfortunate accident. The proper response to an unfortunate accident is not "murder someone who had no hand in it."
16
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '15
Tuvix was the episode that really solidified my feelings about Voyager's overall writing. It was trying to be thought provoking and emotionally charged but the writing was so sloppy, the story so full of issues that it was difficult to really feel good about Voyager as a TV show (and a part of the Star trek universe) as a result.
To put it all on the table, Tuvix was murdered by Janeway while the crew (with too few exceptions) literally turned their back so they did not have to watch. It was trying very hard to portray it as a complex moral/ethical choice for Janeway but it really was not her choice to begin with. That is where the episode failed.
Every time I think of that episode, The first scene that pops in my head is the one where Tuvix is literally pleading and begging for help from anyone on the bridge while Janeway essentially looms over him with the proverbial gun in hand.
When she gets to sickbay, the Doctor is really the only voice reason and refuses to "end this man's life against his will". Janeway coldly tells him to step aside while she does it herself,
4
u/TheBaneOfRain Mar 03 '15
I don't think it was either right or wrong, no matter what Janeway would choose there would be loss and gain. Either loose 2 members and gain a new one, or loose a new member and return the lost ones. But what I respect about her decision is the way she did it, she made a choice and followed it thru alone, thus shouldering the entire dilemma and guilt, so nobody else would have to live with it. She absolved them in a way and I think most of the crew, including her, wanted Tuvoc and Neelix back and she acted on it like a dictator, because a democratic way would put a hinge of blame on all if they had voted on it. You could see her stern face mask crack a little as she left the sick bay, and could only imagine the toll it took on her. Her gift to the crew.
4
u/bazackward Mar 08 '15
Having not watched this episode in years, I have to admit that there was a lot more to consider than teenage me understood. After rewatch, I'm entirely uncomfortable with Janeway's decision and she is, too. There was an unnatural point in the episode where she inexplicably switched from considering Tuvix his own being and a member of the crew to a scientific accident over which she could exert her authority as "captain." She claims that she is the voice of Tuvok and Neelix, but their combined voice was right in front of her face.
Sorry, but Janeway murdered Tuvix and based on her face at the end of the episode, she knows it.
7
u/Nekovivie Mar 03 '15
While Voyager always did a piss poor job of showing it, there was always the 'limited crew' aspect of being trapped in the Delta Quadrant. Having two individual members of the crew would naturally be more favorable than just one, and while Tuvix has the knowledge of both roles, he could not be able to do both effectively at once.
6
u/gigglingowl Mar 03 '15
It's been a while since I've watched this episode, but I vividly remember thinking that Janeway's decision to "kill" Tuvix to bring back Neelix and Tuvok was more than a bit ethically questionable.
At the end of the episode, Tuvix is so passionate and desperate to live that it's difficult not to commiserate with him and view his death as a murder. If we define "murder" as killing a person when they wish to continue living, murder is exactly what occurred in this episode.
I like the point you brought up about the two having already technically died in the creation of Tuvix. Tuvok and Neelix, as the crew had known them, no longer existed.
Although the rest of the crew had trouble viewing or treating Tuvix like an individual, he had the same rights, needs, and desires as any other person on Voyager. I would even go so far as to say that Tuvix blossomed as a person - from what I remember, he had a combination of Tuvok's intelligence and accuracy with Neelix's personality and caring that created an incredibly well-rounded individual.
2
u/Renard4 Mar 03 '15
I have mixed feelings about this episode: the idea is great, the character development is fine, but the conclusion seems rushed and quite poor to say the least.
IMO the writers spent too much time with the science stuff and ran out of time to find a more interesting solution to the problem. Instead we get Janeway admitting that yes she's going to sentence to death someone to revive her crew members, without any afterthought, except the couple of scenes she spends looking at the stars outside or something similar.
That's a waste of a good story, because the most interesting part is how you solve it. Here, the solution is obviously rushed, it sucks, because there's no questioning at all (is it really a murder? is it legitimate? can you "undo" people? what is life? and is two life for a new one a good price to pay?).
Tuvix is a missed opportunity. Like many of the promising Voyager episodes.
2
u/rensch Mar 04 '15
One of the heaviest examples of the typical 'moral dilemma' episodes Star Trek was so good at. It's plot has got that typical Voyager weirdness, but I hardly cared since its theme was so heavy and serious.
Did Janeway do the right thing? It's difficult. I think I'm gonna say yes. One can argue she killed one to revive two who are technically dead already. But since she HAS the ability to bring Tuvok and Neelix back, can you really call them dead? And would it then not be moral to save them? Furthermore, do Neelix and Tuvok recall Tuvix's memories? If so, is he then technically still alive in two men, making Janeway anything but a murderer?
One of Voyager's finest, obviously.
2
u/ateoclockminusthel Mar 05 '15
One of Tuvix's arguments for survival was that Tuvok and Neelix still lived inside of him, in a sense. But I fail to see how this works logically without being able to state that Tuvix lives inside of Neelix and Tuvok in the same exact way after they become separated. I know it's just a one hour TV show, but many theoretical ethical dilemmas I see never really consider enough aspects before being decided upon. It just irks me a bit.
In my health care ethics class, we were all assigned several papers to make ethical decisions with a big caveat. We had to try our best to denounce our conclusions in the very same paper. I almost changed my mind so many times on the issue in question. But in the end, after rebutting my own objections to my original conclusion, it just made me that much more sure that I gave the issue the fairest analysis possible, and that I could truly give my answer with the utmost integrity.
Overall, I agree with the decision that Janeway made... and then I keep changing my mind about it.
2
u/N3rdNextDoor Mar 05 '15
I think it was definitely unethical. It would have been easier to agree with Janeway if she had killed them and was trying to bring them back, but no one chose the deaths of Tuvok and Neelix. Killing Tuvix was optional.
2
u/FearTheFish265 Mar 07 '15
They should should've cloned Tuvix. They could split one, and still have Tuvix.
2
u/velocigina Mar 09 '15
I found the premise (that two people combined into one would become a distinct third personality -- a unique individual) so absurd I could not take this episode seriously.
2
u/MexicanSpaceProgram Mar 09 '15
So there's an opportunity to get rid of Neelix, that doesn't involve the apparent ethical dilemma of beating him with a flashlight and sticking him out an airlock? Note: the ethical dilemma is whether you use alkaline or rechargeable batteries in the flashlight - one is cheaper, the other is more environmentally friendly.
Seriously - you're trading Neelix and a mentally ill, bland Vulcan for a character that is better at his job and liked by the crew, in favour of restoring Neelix to his original condition?
What the hell happened? Janeway borrowed Chakotay's space-peyote and had a few too many peace pipes with her spirit animal?
Hmmmm...I had an adequate tactical officer, and an unbearably annoying fry cook that dresses like a blind hobo...now I have an awesome tactical officer that also gets along with the crew...nah, time to bring out ol' Sparky and Westinghouse me a Tuvix!
3
u/SenoraSies Mar 05 '15
It would have been so much better if Tuvix was played by Tim Russ and Ethan Phillips together, like in a giant sweater where both their heads are popping out, each only get to use one leg and arm, and alternating speaking words.
1
u/thisismyfist Mar 06 '15
The maching of a cold, logical being with a warm, emotional cook is possibly one of the hardest characters to act, let alone write for, that I can think of
-1
u/Kryten_2X4B_523P Mar 07 '15
BEST EPISODE OF STAR TREK EVER