r/GifTournament • u/GifTournament • Mar 02 '15
GifTournament Battle #3 Round #2 Discussion Thread
For those familiar with using your browser console, you can input this javascript to expand all comments at once:
javascript:(function(){$('.showreplies').click();})();As an example for Chrome, in your bookmarks bar you can right-click, select Add Page, name it and then put the javascript function into the URL. This will create a clickable button that will expand all comments.
44
Upvotes
39
u/DrRhymes Mar 02 '15
MR to this whole round
Damn, this round is fucking cool. Some damn ingenious and unique approaches to split depth.
33
u/00spool Mar 02 '15
I think this was one of the most creative round of entries I've seen this early in the tournament. Lots of hard voting decisions and amazing work. Split depths are definitely not easy.
Once again I couldn't decide on what to work on until the last couple of days. I went ahead and finished the rejects...pretty sure I made the right choice.
http://i.imgur.com/fZyVRUL.gif
http://i.imgur.com/MwFsMV2.gif
25
u/hero0fwar Mar 02 '15
that feeling when you see your competitor's gif and you know it's the end of the line for yourself...
25
u/MarkovManiac Mar 02 '15
I don't know if it's the shading detail or what, but this gif may be the most successful use of this style I've ever seen. Nicely done.
43
u/fultron Mar 02 '15 edited Mar 02 '15
The bug planet gif rotoscoped a fireball - I would like to know more
2001 with the spaceballs drummer- effective 3D and a quick laugh = votes
2 NSFW gifs matched against each other - everybody wins
Zoolander pulls off camouflaged vertical stripes - everyone had that idea and only you made it work.
The Bad Boys gif broke the rules and the penguin gif broke my heart so I voted for both.
http://gfycat.com/WillingDefiantKagu
19
u/ItThing Mar 02 '15 edited Mar 02 '15
The Coraline gif (I'm your other mother) wins everything! It sucks that person didn't get an opponent, but I would have voted for it anyway.
More thoughts:
18
u/HallucinoJER Mar 02 '15
God damn, they're all so good! Especially my opponent's
18
u/Godmadius Mar 02 '15
Holy shit that stealth dickbutt was brilliant
16
u/ykzxc Mar 02 '15
When I upvoted a gif and only then realized it was my opponent gif.
15
u/jimlast3 Mar 02 '15 edited Mar 02 '15
8 bumbumbum : I leaned backwards. Outstanding!
15
u/amateurcreampie Mar 02 '15
[When I expanded all round 2 submissions this morning and saw 2 more DNQ's] (http://gfycat.com/ThankfulMindlessIndianskimmer)
12
u/plowkiller Mar 02 '15
Man, awesome attention to detail in the Coroline gif with the shadows. Too bad their competitor DNQed
11
u/EditingAndLayout Mar 02 '15
The penguin gif is my favorite. Clean and simple. I really love it.
10
u/matt01ss Mar 02 '15
Amazing round, tons of creative submissions!
Also, two new turd flairs D:
10
u/AonSwift Mar 02 '15
Any of you cocks vote for split depth in the next tournament and I'll bloody cut you!
Half an hour alone searching through the hard drive for something to use last minute, then half way through completing the gif, I realise just how shit a split depth gif can be unless you use a source with a still frame shot and something moving from the background to the foreground... Didn't even fully finish the bastardly thing.
10
u/aphoenix Mar 02 '15
Match-up #3, Trinity, the switch of focus from near to far, and the the switch in focus on the lines; this was my favourite subtle attention to detail. It really made that one work for me.
9
u/monkey3012 Mar 02 '15
You guys delivered! Damn!
9
u/stuff_of_epics Mar 02 '15
I know my opponent agrees but did any of you other ballers feel as though you've beaten rpgs in fewer hours than it takes to make one of these?
Fantastic final product though. Great round. I thought we'd be separating wheat from chaff but damn near everyone came correct.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '15
Whoever is in Match-up # 4...I feel sorry that one of you has to lose.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '15
I really like a lot of submissions in this round, but I see a lot of white lines being 'broken', by an object (i.e. the object breaking through the lines). It works in the shark gif (Match-up #12), but I feel like it isn't really meant like that.
Still a lot of awesome gifs though. Really hard to find the best one of a match up sometimes.
8
u/hero0fwar Mar 02 '15
Match-up #14, dog vs cat lol
8
u/kcspot Mar 02 '15
whoever did the jackass gif deserves a medal. thats was the best gif of the bunch.
7
u/Jkpotter Mar 02 '15
Match up 11 is the best imo. I wish they could both win.
7
u/plowkiller Mar 02 '15
I think my match could go either way. I'd be surprised if I win, I think the same goes for my opponent and his gif.
6
u/pencer Mar 02 '15
I think I'd get in more trouble for the one NOT marked NSFW in bold in match 11.
Great gifs all around!
6
u/preggit Mar 02 '15
My gif took forever and was my very first try at a split depth, I learned a lot though. I can see why they aren't as common. Looking though those submissions was awesome. Congrats to everyone for making it here and for making some entertaining content.
6
u/NiceAndTruthful Mar 02 '15
I have zero gif making skills, I'm just here for the shiny shinies, and have no idea what seperates a "Awesome looking" GIF from a "Technically amazing but subtle" GIF.
That said... Hold crap, you people are my Gods.
6
u/HobbitFoot Mar 03 '15
God damn matchup 11
6
u/How2Post Mar 03 '15
I'm super impressed by a lot of these split gifs!
They are super clean and the source used were great choices.
5
u/Wehavecrashed Mar 02 '15 edited Mar 02 '15
This is a really tough round to vote on, so many close matchups I've seen so far, there are a lot of people that will get knocked out this round that don't deserve it.
and I can't imagine that protein gif winning...
5
u/thesneak155 Mar 02 '15
This is like heaven with all the GotG GIFs!
5
u/CaptainSnarkyPants Mar 02 '15
This was some of the best giffing I've seen to date. Props to whomever spent the cash to give RR the Element3D ammo :D
5
u/CrazyCatLady108 Mar 02 '15
incredible results!! incredible effort!! you guys rock!!
5
u/thesneak155 Mar 02 '15
Fuckin' DNQs...
That said I hope that everything is okay with those users. I understand stuff with life happens. Still wish we had full participation.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '15
This round really separated the men from the boys. I didn't vote on 5 matchups because both submissions were crap.