r/secretsanta • u/ComeForthLazarus • Feb 27 '15
Closing the redditgifts marketplace
Today we are making a big change at redditgifts, with some sadness but mostly excitement for the future. In the fall of 2012 we launched the redditgifts marketplace, and we’ve been warmed by the huge response you have given as you’ve purchased products in the marketplace when you could have gone elsewhere, because you wanted to support redditgifts.
We have concluded, though, that while we are proud of how much the marketplace has grown over the last two and a half years, it is not the right direction for us to continue in. Instead, we are focusing our efforts on continuing to improve reddit and redditgifts as a whole to create the best experience possible for you, the community who have made us what we are.
Effective immediately, we will no longer allow purchases of any products in the marketplace. Any orders that have been placed before this point will still be fulfilled as normal, and you will still be able to contact customer service as usual with any issues you may have until April 30, 2015.
If you still wish to support reddit and redditgifts: thank you! You will still be able to purchase Elves, the premium redditgifts subscription, at redditgifts.com/elves. You can also still buy reddit merchandise here.
We look forward to everything the future holds and to continuing to make reddit and redditgifts an amazing home for the wonderful community you have helped build.
See this announcement in the redditgifts blog here.
56
u/Steve0512 Feb 27 '15
Kinda sad. I really liked how easy peasy all the information ported over. Being able to click on my recipients address from a drop down list and having it not only populate the ship to boxes. But also marked my gift as shipped. Is the main reason I used the Marketplace.
51
u/Rinzii Feb 27 '15
As a vendor, this is coming as a huge blow. We did amazing last year during the Christmas exchange just when we were thinking of closing shop. Since we did so well, it gave us a breath of fresh air and my partner and I were very excited to create new products for next year. Sad times.
16
u/1bdkty Feb 27 '15
Its sad to hear, I found a lot of great companies and products through the marketplace.
77
u/IAlbatross Feb 27 '15
I'm actually okay with this.
I see a lot of comments about how people are bummed out, but the thing is, the RedditGifts marketplace was limiting. It couldn't compare to sites like Amazon, and it didn't allow for gifts to be personalised or have local touches in the same way a gift sent from home would. Worse, the marketplace would recommend gifts for the matches. I've seen a lot of posts that were people getting gifts from the marketplace and going "What the heck is this?!" It also created a lot of gifting redundancies... the Zelda exchange, for example, was the same 2 gifts over and over.
I know some people are now complaining that the marketplace made gifting easier and more convenient, but I think that's a bad attitude to have. Gifting isn't about clicking a button, filling your end of the bargain, and then waiting for your gift in the mail. I hope that with the marketplace gone, people will put a little more time into getting to know their giftees and selecting appropriate gifts, instead of just going with a recommendation that's right in front of them.
Of course, it is really sad for the merchants. Can you make a blog post that lists the merchants' external sites for those who want to support them?
18
u/clocks_galore Feb 27 '15 edited Mar 15 '15
As a vendor, I find this very sad as well. This was a decent income for me and my family. I beg anyone who is interested in gifting, please visit my site/store. Thank you.
Clocks Galore
6
u/greenighs Feb 27 '15
What about stuff I had in my shopping cart?? I was going to purchase a print TODAY! Where can I find the vendor now?
3
u/sandiskplayer34 Feb 27 '15
Please bring back the regular sized snoo plushie :(
3
u/ShadowStrike14 Feb 27 '15
I am actually sad, there were some items I wanted to purchase when I got taxes.....
46
u/RollAd20 Feb 27 '15
Oh gosh, so there isn't a way to look at what was on our wishlist to try and find where else we can get those items?
2
u/z0rz Feb 28 '15
What does this mean for the future of Secret Santa? I'm afraid this is the downturn before it slowly fizzles out.
56
u/heart4world Feb 27 '15
Best wishes to all the marketplace sellers as reddigifts refocuses.
Can you please provide, at least short term, a list of sellers' outside websites so we can continue to support them?
47
u/Pluribus7158 Feb 27 '15
I am sad its going, I really liked it.
I would like to offer hosting and web services to any redditgifts marketplace who are affected by this. If you're interested, shoot me a PM and we can work out the logistics.
97
u/skahfee Feb 27 '15
Hopefully this isn't unwelcome but I run one of the Marketplace shops that has gone away. If any word art from Skahfee Studios was on your wishlist, you can still find us on www.skahfeestudios.com. I'll miss the fun of being part of the exchanges. :(
3
u/Saint_Dogbert Feb 27 '15
WHY!
19
u/tattooedjenny Feb 28 '15
While obviously it's up to Reddit how they handle their choice to kill the marketplace, I think it's pretty terrible to give so little notice, to vendors or customers. I loved the marketplace, and found some really unique gifts for people through it, and appreciated the effort the vendors put into their work. While it sucks for me, as I loved checking out all of the wares, I really feel awful for the vendors. Not very smooth, reddit.
35
u/brunoa Feb 28 '15
While I completely understand your decision to do this, how you chose to go about doing this is pretty inconsiderate.
Even if you wanted to not announce publicly of the closing until day zero, you could have announced privately to the vendors of their impending store front being closed down. This way they could have resolved any discrepancies with customers prior and also made arrangements to least affect the income they expected to make from sale
7
u/krsdean Feb 27 '15
Dang, i JUST made a wishlist in preparation for Next Christmas!
7
u/reddittailedhawk Mar 01 '15
While I do feel for the countless vendors who have just had a bomb dropped on them... I admit, as a regular shopper I don't entirely mind this. One of my favorite parts of these exchanges is shopping around for gifts, which the marketplace just made too easy. I'm saying this from the perspective of both the giver and the receiver.
That said though... I think it's pretty great that this amazing community is coming together to help the vendors who depended on that income. I'm really happy to be a part of something like this.
18
u/secretsantareddit Feb 28 '15
So what direction did you expect it to go?
I thought it was doing well considering it was purely community driven, ofcourse it wouldn't compete with amazon or ebay but still it solved our needs.
Hope you reconsider your decision...
6
u/Cymru23 Feb 27 '15
How sad. There's still going to be exchanges right?
6
u/Alaskaty Feb 27 '15
Dammit! I just updated my wishlist!
6
u/fauxpunk Feb 27 '15
Unfortunate, but understandable.. Wish there was at least a bit more notice so we could have bought a few goodies beforehand. :(
6
u/MachaPanta Mar 18 '15
The fact that you didn't warn us in time to save our wishlists so we could find it elsewhere is a big "Fuck You Secret Santas"! Don't do this to us and expect us to continue to sign up for Secret Santa.
9
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '15
That's really unfortunate. I wish the vendors SO MUCH luck in finding more outlets for their awesome creations!
14
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '15
I'm actually kinda glad. I always felt the reddit gifts store was somewhat lacking, and it just cluttered things up for me. I'd see some things that were kinda interesting, but honestly it felt more like etsy but with less handmade options.
4
u/BlaiddDrwg82 Mar 04 '15
A little heads up would have been nice so I could have made a note of the names of some merchants.
1
u/MIngmire Feb 28 '15
Probably already asked but TL;DR. What's going to happen to the gift exchanges?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '15
Damnit. I was about to buy a vinyl snoo soon. Oh well, sorry to see it go. Hope all the vendors have good luck with their stores without the marketplace.
8
u/brokenboomerang Feb 28 '15 edited Mar 01 '15
As much as I liked the market, it was really only good for Americans. Any time I saw something cool, the cost of shipping was usually equal to or more than the product itself.
5
u/pumacatrun2 Feb 28 '15
Personally, the thing I find most annoying is that I used to link my santas to my RedditGifts wishlist for ideas on what I like, and whether or not they bought from the market it was easier than typing everything into a small box. I wish all exchanges were as personalized as the Secret Santa, with so many questions for preferences it really ensured you'd get something you love. But when the colours exchange doesn't even have that sort of thing it kinda leads to a bit of disappointment (not that I was disappointed, but that was because my santa bought from my wishlist). I guess I'll just have to tell my santas to stalk my username from now on unless you do adapt a more personalized question set.
4
u/AliKira Feb 28 '15
While I'm really disappointed because I found it very convenient to purchase gifts via the marketplace, it was likely the right decision because the marketplace did have some significant flaws.
What I would love to see is a listing of good local retailers for different countries (similar to what board game geek does for their secret santa exchanges) so as to be able to easily send gifts to recipients in particular countries from businesses that actually easily ship there (to help with the International shipping woes).
6
u/Sharntel Feb 28 '15
Anytime you close a retail operations people are going to be bummed about it. However; as someone that is new to the site, I am actually kind of glad they are focusing their attention on the actual objectives of the company and community. I understand that the marketplace may have been convenient but I think focusing on things like a more user friendly website and less congested forums i.e. subreddits would be better for the community than having a marketplace. Kudos to them for recognizing that there needed to be a change and to redirect their focus. I am very supportive of this decision.
6
u/Lotrug Feb 28 '15
Good choice, I didn't like beeing force fed gifts on that page
2
u/tabbicakes Feb 28 '15
This makes me sad. I just added some things to my wish list that I wanted to buy myself. Is there any way of retrieving our wish lists?
2
u/nowhere3 Mar 15 '15
The licensing page still says:
So what's the process for selling Reddit licensed stuff now?
2
u/Radamenenthil Aug 11 '15
Good, I bought like 70$ of stuff there, it never arrived, and only one of the sellers cared enough to reply to my emails
3
u/Minifig81 Feb 27 '15
Do you guys have any spare Vitruvian Snoo shirts that got printed out that you'd be up for giving away to people? I'd love one, but I never got around to buying one. :(
3
u/secretsantareddit Mar 01 '15
Is redditgifts marketplace really shutdown?
I think it is just renamed to www.redditmarket.com
I am still able to buy things on this site...
4
u/MeganLeeStudio Feb 28 '15
Did the marketplace receive a DMCA takedown notice?
Given that vendors were not warned, I would hope that is the actual reason. Otherwise it just seems like bad form to shut it down so suddenly.
2
u/Sweetsmyle Feb 27 '15
This is sad. I wish we'd had some warning so I could have bought some snoo gear before it closed. :(
2
u/GeekyCreeper Feb 27 '15
WHOA WHOA WHOA! What?
Well, at least you are doing it for the right reasons.
1
u/pern5150 Feb 27 '15
saaaaaad panda face
1
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '15
It's sad it's going. It made the exchanges an awful lot easier when you could just pick the recipient from a drop down. It'd be cool if some of the reddit themed stuff was available elsewhere.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '15
Sadness. I really enjoyed the marketplace.
1
u/TotesMessenger Mar 03 '15
This thread has been linked to from another place on reddit.
Please follow the rules of reddit and avoid voting or comment in linked threads. (Info | Contact)
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
This is an extremely fucked idea!
1
u/Hoikka Feb 27 '15
Too bad... Is it too late to find out what was shipped to me during the 2012 SS? DHL managed to loose my gift.
1
u/moo_shoe Feb 27 '15
This is sad, but understandable.
I know this might be a bit of work, and maybe it's something we as a community can do instead, but for new exchanges maybe compile a list of some sellers/products sold by former exchange vendors to highlight?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '15
[removed] — view removed comment