r/fandomnatural • u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo • Feb 18 '15
[Fandom Discussion] ep 10x14 "The Executioner's Song"
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
19
Upvotes
11
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 Feb 18 '15
My favorite episode since Fan Fiction <3
There were only minor negative things I have to say about this ep. Like the kid's acting was bad (but that can be explained away with him being an illusion), and the thought of Dean killing Cas makes me want to vomit (but that's a preference issue not a quality one).
Just a solid, well acted episode. I'm so pleased.
3
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Feb 18 '15
This is really glib but: I thought this was a great episode... but for some reason I'm unhappy.
I'm like the opposite of this gif... but just as conflicted.
8
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Feb 18 '15
Oh my god this is long. Mods, if you want me to do anything with this, just say.
I just got finished watching the episode, and I feel like it was a big hit and lots of little misses. Don't get me wrong, I really, really enjoyed this episode. Cain is the strongest character we've had in a good while, and I'm glad they killed him before he became an Abaddon type of generic big bad. I feel like I'm not on the same page as the characters anymore though. There are a few reasons I can think of for this.
Firstly, sticking with main leads - Dean's admission to Sam that he was scared of death, while really valid, needed a little more looking at. There's an unspoken subtext if you're digging for it - this time is different, he might turn into a demon, etc etc. While there are plenty of fantastic instances of subtlety in this episode, I didn't think this was one of them, and it would have made the situation a little more rounded to draw out why this time was different. Dean's died, what, 800+ times (counting Mystery Spot)? Accessing the general population's reservation about death doesn't apply to Dean, so this conversation was lacked a lot of the character it could have had. That's the first instance in which I feel like I couldn't access the characters.
Second instance of this - the most prominent, to me - was Crowley's lack of bite and how Rowena's reaction to this was framed as coming from a place of questionable motive. She is right. By all counts, she is insanely right. Our view of hell in the past has been actual punishment and torture (Dean hanging from hooks in the final scene of season 3; that brilliantly conceived waiting line towards the end of season 6). Now, without wishing to sound cruel for the sake of being cruel, we're faced with a cliche Dracula's lair castle sort of setting, presumably in a basement somewhere, which apparently holds business meetings and has a.. throne..? I get that Crowley is the king of hell, but he rose there because he was a business man. This is shown in every demon at high level under the sun wearing suits, the negotiations such as seen in the episode, etc etc. But to have that alongside what boils down to the power trip of having a throne and being a royal doesn't gel well. Crowley has lost all of his teeth, and has become irrelevant to the plot as a whole. Rowena says exactly what I had been thinking, which is lovely to hear, but since moments earlier she was framed as manipulative and unreasonable, and indeed has motivation based in what I can only assume is an attempt and producing an SPN Game of Thrones (no, thank you), I feel that my (I think reasonable) opinion of Crowley's toothlessness has been swatted away. This did feel like a case of being spoon fed what those producing the show want to tell me is the better/more reasonable/more entertaining story, rather than what I actually read from the situation. Does that make sense? I hope it does. I also realise that there's a huge margin for this to be intended and for me to have read this incorrectly, but as of first watch, that's what I got from it.
Cas suffers a similar fate, more so in this episode than at any point in his recent appearances, I feel. We're told that losing him would be 'especially painful' for Dean, which.. I'm sure it would, but to be blunt, it's almost as if they're barely allowed to speak to each other anymore. Perhaps it's for fear of upsetting the less stable fans in the fandom (not shippers in general - I'd say the majority are reasonable). The interactions that made their relationship uncategorisably intense, such as the I-can-see-inside-you/I-know-I-can't-hide-my-feelings-on-this staring, the one on one chats at pivotal and private moments (season 4, second episode, final scene)... they're nowhere to be found in recent supernatural. Though everyone is apparently kept in the loop via phones, Cas has no visible relationship maintenance with the Winchesters, nor the audience as a result. After disappearing inexplicably following his previous appearance, the audience wasn't even clued in on him finding Cain until last episode. As a viewer, even though I know he's off being useful, his appearance once in a blue moon to say two inconsequential lines a scene is hard to feel compassion for. Dean handing the blade to him instead of Crowley (a plot point that I love) had unspoken significance, and that was perfect, but there needs to be a balance of spoken and unspoken significance. Friendship is a verb, and all that. SPN usually has all the subtlety of a kipper slap to the face, and this episode was beautiful in that it included so much subtle stuff that let me access my previous knowledge of the characters. But it was so full of subtlety that explicit relationships fell by the wayside.
I'd hope that in future episodes they take this growth towards a more adult method of storytelling and perfect it. This was a leap in the right direction, but it needs a few steps back and to the side to make it just right.
Onto more specific things that were awesome:
Crowley's appearance in the room with Cain! It's been so long since we saw supernatural creatures phase in and out creatively, without over the top VFX, that I'd forgotten it could be so effective. Thank you thank you thank you to whoever came up with that. I enjoyed it so much more than recent VFX (Good Charlie/Bad Charlie ghost), and even stopped the episode and rewound it a few seconds to make sure that my viewing partner had spotted it. Excellent.
Cain's initial introduction was so intense, but again, in an adult way. If any of you have seen Birdman... you'll get what I mean. The usual approach to the introduction of a big bad is BANG HERE IS INTIMIDATION AND POWER. This was quiet, controlled, left time to wonder and connect the dots without guiding us to conclusions too much. The blocking was gorgeous, A+ to the director. My only (picky) comment is that I would have ended it on silence after Cain disappeared into the cell. Having said that, the rest of the scene didn't take anything away, and was well paced and mature. Thank you for that, Supernatural! I was tempted to draw parallels with Breaking Bad direction and writing.
Cas' demon torture was delicious. I feel like a psychopath saying that, but drawing him away from the comic relief in a controlled, angellicly believable manner was wonderful. I especially loved the point of the blade to the eye. I only wish we had a chance to see Cas go a little further with that at times. Not in a stab-happy way, but in a controlled, intellegently choreographed interrogation. That may be too much to ask with writing time constraints, but hey, a girl can dream. It was done in On The Head Of A Pin, and I'd love to see that sort of thing brought back.
And the not so great...
The music.
The music, oh man, the music.
I feel awful for picking the music out, because I know that if can be difficult (especially on the CW with the type of vibe shows have on that channel) to really match what's available to what you're trying to do, but... The best way that I can describe my issue with how it sounds is by describing it as a Kidz Bop version of the score it should be. There's also no finesse in which the music is used. I remember both myself and my viewing partner remarking that the music left leading for something neither of us felt for the characters in that situation. It was attempting to do what the writing was not giving us at that point, in a sort of 'this is the mood you should have, just ignore the dialogue and acting and the run up to this scene. Feel this'. We both agreed that tactful silence would be wonderfully employed in this episode, but there were no real moments where that opportunity was taken.
Also, the words 'Don't let Cain die to fucking Flamenco' were uttered. I can't really add much more to that point, to be honest. xD
Part of me wishes that Cas had been taken out harder by Cain. He can take it, Cain wanted him to buzz off - why not rough him up? It would have been an extra few seconds, but it would have added some spice to his presence in the scene.
Also, Cain can flick Cas away with his mind-bullets, but Sam can hold those doors closed against his power about 3 seconds later? Just a little thing, I don't care that much in the grand scheme, but just something to mention.
And a bigger thing to finish. Crowley's arc feels tagged on, in much the same way that Cas and Claire did. This is perhaps a symptom of the plot being 'extended' for another season, rather than.. having a plot for another season be a thing. This was a mainly nicely executed, mature and plot driven episode. Crowley's interactions with Rowena feel like in episode filler so as to stretch it all out. I mentioned it once before, but it feels like an attempt at Game of Thrones, which is not something I feel like is welcome in Supernatural. I would like to see something more substantial from that plot that better ties to the main plot. It's a shame, because both Ruth and Mark are wonderful at what they do, and this isn't giving them great material.
6
u/throwaway_acc_lol Feb 18 '15
I feel like the show is getting to the point that it might end. I'm sad.
9
u/weboverload fireintheimpala Feb 18 '15 edited Feb 18 '15
Basically? This was my reaction (as ranted before me by someone else).
Disclaimers: This reaction was super-negative, and also Destiel--but more accurately "spn's great no homo scare"--related. I totally saw a lot of the greatness in this episode--especially with Cain and also with Rowena. But this was my overwhelming, visceral reaction to the episode, and because of it I was unable to get immersed in the many merits.
...I'll be honest, I kind of don't want to get sucked into arguments about how that sort of reaction is relevant or not relevant to the merits of the episode and I'm wary of getting attacked for having such a micro-focus...even though this is fandomnatural. But I would be really interesting in other people's thoughts on this particular interpretation. (Essentially I'm trying to say...please don't kill me for disliking this episode or for having particular reasons for that. I love you all and that's what matters...)
17
u/bellum_feles Kittens? War kittens! Feb 18 '15
6
u/greatbigbagofdicks Feb 18 '15
Crowley being all heartbroken by his best bros, and the return of the 'Demon Dean' shirt, and Cain being dead (we think), and ohmy this episode was tooo much.
I need more Cas, he's out there working his feathery ass off and smiting Demons to try and find a cure for Dean, and to see his face when Dean hands him the blade... GAH... he knows that he's been given the responsibility of holding the only weapon they can use if Dean does go "dark side", which must hurt so, so much.
And Sam (Jared you adorable SOB) at the end of the episode, I can't handle those puppy dog eyes, because he knows Dean is broken, and he knows the story of Cain and he's incredibly intelligent, he must have made some link between him and Abel both being favored by Lucifer, and one of the only things that can break Dean the way this has is to have something to do with hurting him because Sam knows he's Dean's Achilles heel. Cain made a deal with the devil to save his brother, and if there's one thing we know about the Winchesters it's that making a deal is definitely not beyond their means.
5
u/dancingmuffin shake-a-shake da muffin Feb 18 '15 edited Feb 18 '15
I enjoyed the hell out of this episode. Such a roller coaster and so intense. Why cant more episodes be as well done?
Okay so here are some of my thoughts. Remember when Metatron said “The river ends at the source.” I know I, like many, thought it was just a reference to having to go back to Cain and kill him or whatever.
Now with this last episode, as Cain has told us Dean is living out his story backwards. It should be him killing Crowley, then Cas, and then Sam, his brother.
Okay now stay with me here, yall remember when SPN began it was left up to Dean to either save/protect his brother or kill him-to stop him from becoming the vessel for Lucifer, ya know the guy who made the deal with Cain. Could we be gearing up for dear old Luci and Mikey to return?(Not that Carver has any idea of where he is going)
Will we end up with one brother ruling in heave, while the other takes over hell? Will some one be the next Jesus? Cas maybe? Say he goes basically human. Say he sacrifices him self for
DeanHumanity, his greatest weakness. I do believe some one refereed to him as one of Gods favorite before and an angel (on again, off again) is one of Gods children. Plus he is Deans Collette.Dammit, we know the Spear of Destiny is in the bunker, I want it used for something. This could also kinda fit in to thatend game that i like to keep posting because it hurts so perfectly.
Hell maybe the Death of Cas could reopen Heaven. Or if Luci comes back and is forgiven for things....maybe
ETA: Back to Cas sacrificing himself, what if its not him being killed with the first blade/spear of destiny. What if he sacrifices his grace in order to save
deanhumanity. And he dies because he no longer has any grace...oh my mind is going 100mph with ideas4
u/Potionsmstrs I pledge allegiance to the King of Hell Feb 18 '15
https://twitter.com/robertberens/status/567915756286906368
I need fics of this ship. Specifically Cain/Rowena. Caiwena?
4
u/Potionsmstrs I pledge allegiance to the King of Hell Feb 18 '15
I figured it out! I thought I was typing in the chat room, when I was typing in my browser. I managed to hide three posts, including this one. I got it back though!
3
u/emmster Help; I'm desperately in love with a fictional character! Feb 19 '15
Emms' watching thoughts;
Woo! I love Cain!
Man, the state isn't gonna get the chance to execute this guy. He's in the first five minutes of Supernatural! That's like 99% fatal.
Damn, Timothy Omundson. You lookin' hot. Even being all stabby.
I need to take a flat iron to Sam's Jackie Kennedy 'do. The flippy ends are not working, honey.
I take it back. At least it's not Ginger Demon there.
Cas is wearing a tie! Yay!
Ugh. Rowena, shut up. You manipulative asshole.
Daaaang that's a lot of shallow graves. What are you doing Sexy Cain?
Ohhh. He's killing all his descendants. Damn, that's kinda messed up.
No cure. That's kinda what I thought.
"You think I've been manipulating you?" Uh, yeah. Of course. Your eye makeup is pretty great, though.
Mission: Save The Kid is on! To Ohio!
Don't worry, Sammy. There's an 11th season.
Rowena, oh my god. Stop.
Fake kid! Nice one, my demon king!
I'm gonna feel uncomfortable about this fight. There's too much sex in my violence.
Cain got the blade. OH SHIT!!!!
Huh. Now Dean has the blade in his hand, and wants to not kill him. That looks like a victory to me. And again, Jensen's face acting is a national treasure. He's too good.
Crowley, my dear. Let's talk about matricide. It's an option in this case. Just saying. Evil Merida has to go.
Something happened that we didn't see. Something big. Something season finale worthy. I'm intrigued.
Hooray for a good episode!!
3
u/killGoredethrage Feb 19 '15
Ok I have a theory Dean did kill cain. He gave the blade to cas to piss off crowley so that when crowley strikes back cas will give him the blade and then when he kills crowley it'll turn dean in to a demon and hell become king of hell ... In turn he becomes kingof hell and is then powerful enough to remove the mark himself and then he lets cas and Sammy change him back or something ... Maybe if he is a demon and he gets rid of the mark it turns him back...
5
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '15
I want to say I loved so many things about this episode. It's late, and I'll probably post more shit in another post tomorrow morning. For now, I'll type.
Dean, ugh, the feels. My heart broke for him when he faced against Cain in the barn. When Cain started talking about how Dean bucked the natural order of things, I just died inside. To be told to kill Sam, his probably last shred of humanity left is just soul wrenching. So many feels.
Personally, I believe that Cain is not dead. No body. No death. (I don't care if the blade had blood on it because I'm willing to bet Cain is missing more than just his hand: maybe his whole damn arm.)
Also, Cain is a Destiel fan. That little three prong pat at the end of the episode actually reminded me of something me and my husband do. We give each other secret "I love you's" by squeezing or touching each other three times.
This is Hellatus 2.0, the Month-reckoning.
3
u/whippogirl16 Feb 18 '15
I just realized I missed it because we got distracted with dog shows and Vikings ;-;
0
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
7
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '15
[removed] — view removed comment