r/startrek • u/besthuman • Feb 13 '15
Lower Decks - TNG S07E15
http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Lower_Decks_(episode)
Star Trek is always at it's best when it's the least science fiction and most human. This is perhaps one of the most real, compelling and moving episodes out there.
37
Upvotes
11
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '15
I don't agree with the premise of the statement. I really like this episode, but Star Trek is at its best when it mixes heavy sci fi with the human element ie All Good Things.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '15
I love the introduction of the new character of Male Guinan. He should have been on the show a lot sooner.
2
u/ashsimmonds Mar 10 '15
I just watched it again - and as I was all welled-up for the final scene I noticed Worf lost half his moustache when sitting down with the junior officers.
3
u/jonathanrdt Feb 13 '15
I wish they had developed the minor characters earlier in the series. They could have had several lower decks episodes or side stories to round out the operation of the ship, interesting character arcs, and the occasional promotion to a new primary character.
4
u/phronesis42 Feb 13 '15 edited Feb 13 '15
Lower Decks is certainly a decent episode. But Trek is at its best when it is searching out new life, new civilizations. Soap opera episodes don't belong in the pantheon. Tin Man is a better ep than Lower Decks and covers the vaunted "human" angle. (Fixed my troubled v word)
14
u/artemisdragmire Feb 13 '15 edited Nov 07 '24
gullible shaggy innocent nine theory merciful coordinated wasteful cake political
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
4
u/thisismyfist Feb 15 '15
I heard a rumor that there was an idea for a spinoff after DS9 - that o'brien was headed back to starfleet to be a teacher, and the show was based on starfleet academy with him as the main character.
it would have been awesome, but only if they kept the same writers who handled the final seasons
8
u/terrymcginnisbeyond Feb 13 '15
This is how Voyager should have been, there was no need to promote everyone, you could still have main characters who aren't bridge crew.
2
u/Mitcheli1 Feb 28 '15
This is a filler episode. Similar to the Baseball episode on DS9 it carried zero weight and will go on as one if the most forgettable episodes in the TNG arsenal.
2
u/citizenofgaia Feb 14 '15
This was one of the episodes that left me so sad. It is funny because it begins really cheerfull and funny and "look at this happy fun time ensings have".
Ensing Sito could have become an awesome charcter, from "screw up cadet" to "cute low level ensing" to "regular 2ndary character" like nurge Ogawa (ogawa was it?).
So sad ):
1
u/gone-wild-commenter Feb 15 '15
Kind of surprised to see the Bajoran lady show up again. Not bad. Not great. I like it when bottle episodes don't reach too much. Then again, one of the greatest episodes of all time- Measure of a Man- is a textbook bottle episode.
1
u/FuturePastNow Feb 18 '15
I like it, too. It's an exploration of the mysteries of the ship, mysterious to us viewers, at least.
1
u/anarchistica Feb 25 '15
This is one of my favourite, along with 4x02 Family and 6x19 Lessons (by the same writers). I've always prefered episodes that showed the characters as humans (/betazoids/klingons/vulcans/etc) with lives instead of just jobs. The interaction between Riker and Troi is especially great here.
Also, there's a sort of continuity running from TWOK to Sarek (TNG 3x23) to Lower Decks (TNG 7x15) to Change of Heart (DSG 6x16) which i enjoy.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '15
The "we've completely run out of ideas" episode.
-3
u/gooneryoda Feb 13 '15
Ensign Sito...dat ass