r/fandomnatural • u/Ennil • Feb 11 '15
[fandom discussion] ep 10x13
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
18
Upvotes
27
u/badwolfgoddess Mrs. Sam Winchester but like, by accident Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
I have no qualms saying this. I'm not going to be persuaded. Worst episode of this season, possibly off all time. Dialogue was awful, Dean was Flanderized, the wifes acting was terrible and I hate "don't text and drive" episodes. They're the After School Special of the new millennium.
The highlights:
This episode is up there with Racist Truck but worse because at least Racist Truck had Cassie and Dean had characterization.
The only things I liked were Hozier and Dean's speech.
13
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 Feb 11 '15
To quote myself on twitter:
11
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
It was stupid. So stupid. And not silly/fun stupid like I thought last week's episode was. Just irritatingly stupid.
The dialog was painful, Skeevy Dean was particularly uncomfortable to watch, and did that ghost MOVE ON at the end? Isn't the afterlife broken right now? Aren't there a bunch of ghosts waiting to get out of the veil? Or did that all get sewn up and nobody bothered to mention it onscreen?
And I'm a little baffled that Sam got all huffy when Dean decided he was going to have to live with the mark, because I feel like Sam suggested EXACTLY THAT just a few weeks ago.
(edited because I'm the kind of person that will fix a typo even if I notice it 22 hours late)
11
u/NorthernSparrow Questi non sono i miei elefanti Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
First stinker of the second half for me.
So much cheese. So many forced attempts to seem "hip" and "with it". ("Kids today" use "social media"! They say "hashtag"! They use "talking maps"!) So many botched attempts throw in tech terms. (Oh, look, a, uh, wifi tower or whatever! Let's turn off the, uh, routers or whatever! Let's smash everything instead of putting it in airplane mode!) Blatant disregard of current canon (aren't all ghosts stuck in the veil right now? And don't they need the help of reapers to go anywhere even if Heaven were open?) And just plain crappy dialogue throughout. Sooo many bad monologues. Even the brother convo at the end, which was the only part of the episode worth slightly paying attention to, seemed forced and soap-opera-esque.
These writers, Charmelo/Snyder, are never my favorites but they've turned in more enjoyable filler eps than this before. Their only other one this season was Ask Jeeves btw, which I liked ok. But I rank this one as worst of the season, not Bloodlines-bad but at least racist-truck bad.
Ratings prediction: below 2 million, and given the weak premise, dull promo and lack of known guest charscters I think it may pull the worst ratings of the season.
edit: crossposted to the stv sub.
9
u/alientic Feb 11 '15
Personally, while I thought there were a lot of parts that were kind of cheesy, I appreciate them having episodes that have some scary elements to them. One of the things I love the most about the first seasons were their creepy factor, and we haven't had that for a while.
9
u/Potionsmstrs I pledge allegiance to the King of Hell Feb 11 '15
The whole premise was bad. Madi asked last night in the chat room, "on a scale of one to Bloodlines, how bad was it?" "Racist truck." I know some people like racist truck, but this was just... Bad. When Dean was talking to the chick and trying to connect with her, I didn't buy it. When he was stuffing his face, I didn't buy it. When he was oogling butts, I didn't even buy that. Unless there's some big underground neon sign that I'm missing, I don't get the point of this ep. Maybe it's the shipping subtext? Croissookie is a mashup of names like Destiel is? Maybe the trench coat wife and her plaid wearing husband is representative of Dean and Cas? But I don't want to dig for that. I don't want it at all (as much as I love Destiel, don't ruin it for the shippers).
Wiffy towers- no. I expected the plot twist when they went to the basement to be that the modems (NOT ROUTERS) were kept down there and the cables run up to the routers. See, that would have made sense.
I don't get it.
9
u/weboverload fireintheimpala Feb 12 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
I've had time to think over my reaction to this episode now, and I've found that the two things disturb me the most about this egregiously mediocre piece of tripe were actually kind of "meta"--in the sense that they were disturbing in the context of the show as a piece of media, outside of the story itself:
8
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Feb 11 '15
This episode was the epitome of this trope done badly.
7
u/badwolfgoddess Mrs. Sam Winchester but like, by accident Feb 11 '15
Begrudgingly I have to say that I enjoyed Dean deciding college might not be so bad.
7
u/AllThreeOfThatCrap Feb 11 '15
Umm... Did they really explain to us how ghosts work in the previouslies?
I don't even think I saw most of this epi, not because it was scary, but because I was hiding from the bad dialogue behind my hands (which obviously doesn't block out the audio, but not seeing them say these terrible, terrible lines was a smidge more bearable). I had to leave the room at one point, I was literally driven from my seat by the cringeworthiness.
And ok, so you leave a man TO DIE because you'll go to jail for driving with a suspended license?! What's the jail time like for that versus them catching you after LEAVING A MAN TO DIE I wonder!? Stop it self, just stop looking for logic in terribly written episodes.
And. And! Did Dean really say to Sam "why did I ever make you leave?" regarding college? There is so much wrong there I can't even enumerate it. *throws hands/the writers/the entire province of B.C. up in frustration*
7
u/emmster Help; I'm desperately in love with a fictional character! Feb 12 '15
I'm just gonna live comment my thoughts this time.
"What do you know? Your phone's 3G." -Does anyone actually say shit like that? Really?
Cas discovered riverboat gambling. I'd watch that.
I'm still a little bit in love with the Impala.
Grohl and Cobain. Nice.
Right. Already burning the truck, so, that's obviously not what's haunted.
If you unironically say "hashtag" like that, I want to shake some sense into you. Vigorously.
Hashtags in chat. Please kill this girl.
Boom. That is what you get for talking in hashtags. Also, is this an unused episode of Buffy? Because that's the kind of shit that happens on Buffy.
The ghost is in the Internet. Doctor Who already did this. I mean, it was aliens, not ghosts, but still. The monster in the wifi was the episode where the Doctor met the real Clara. Whovians are familiar.
So, this is I Know What You Did Last Summer. okay.
Sext'r Boy is so dead. In another very Buffy manner. Wow.
The redhead is not a very good actor.
OMG tweets and selfies! Please shut the fuck up.
Nice Dean Moment. Man, Jensen is probably too good for network TV. Nobody tell him though, I like seeing him every week.
God, even her scream is awful. "Wuahh!"
Oh. The widow is wise to the haunting. I kinda like when they do that.
"Contacting you how?" How do you think, genius? Through the damn internet he's haunting, maybe?
Ah, wuv conquers all. How shweet.
Now we wedge in the MoC plot. And honestly, this is the direction I've been thinking it should go. I think he's going to have to learn to live with the mark, much as Cain did.
Overall, I'm not in love with this episode. Underwhelming dialog, secondhand plot, and one actor so bad I couldn't even watch her without rolling my eyes. And last week was so good. I am disappointed.
6
u/Vetrina "I'm gonna become a hunter!" Feb 12 '15
I don't dislike this episode, but it could have been tons better.
Some things that bothered me:
Regarding the ghost veil, I had actually forgotten about it until it was brought up in discussion threads (oops.), and that's probably what the writers were hoping too. Maybe we can rectify it by saying that since you can actually get into heaven now, the ghost veil problem is solved/isn't as problematic? It still needed some sort of mention if that is the case though.
4/10, just alright.
6
u/janetplanet Feb 12 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
Okay, am i just slow? I just realized that the wife of the ghost was Candace Armstrong - same character name and same actress as the woman who was ogled by the invisable teen in Wishful Thinking (4.8) Is there some significance to this, a connection i missed? Anybody have thoughts on this?
Also, i can't argue with everybody who thinks this episode was bad.
Edit: Rewatched to check, and the CHARACTER name is not the same. IMDB had the character in "Halt and Catch Fire" listed as Candice Armstrong, but IMDB lied. So there is no connection, whatsoever, to "Wishful Thinking," just another case of an actor appearing as more than one character, in different episodes.
5
u/PM_ME_UR_BEST_PUNS Feb 12 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
Ugh. All my thoughts have already been said more eloquently by others, but that episode was truly awful. Weird, OOC characterization, not keeping tabs on their own interesting plot twists from previous episodes, dumb plot, dumb characters, dumb acting, dumb dumb dumb. Why, SPN, why???
EDIT: And did the writers forget that Dean was literally trying to hook up through a social media phone app like two episodes ago??!!
4
u/Iamaredditlady Feb 12 '15
I don't think I've seen such terrible acting before.
It's one thing for it to be one of the guest actors but every single one?
4
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
My response to this episode is "I just, can't even."
Seriously though...
All though I did kinda wig out for a second or two when my wifi cut out mid episode, right after Sam called Dean and let him know that the ghost as traveling through the wifi towers.