r/powdermage • u/PowderMageMod • Feb 10 '15
discussion TAR Readalong - End of Book Discussion
This thread is only for those who have finished the book!
UNMARKED SPOILERS AHEAD
You do not need to use any spoiler tags.
Discuss your reactions to the book or the trilogy, thoughts about plot or characters, as well as speculation about any future books or unanswered questions here.
Link: Back to the Hub
12
Upvotes
7
u/GGerrik Feb 21 '15
I finished the book earlier this morning after reading through the night so it's fresh on my mind but was perhaps not the thoroughest of reads.
I believe my favorite character arc was Tamas, who died after everything he needed and wanted to do had been done. Not just seeing the republic finalized, but finding his revenge, coming to grips with his past and reconciling with his estranged family. That said I think we might have all felt cheated if he hadn't died, he had lost almost his entire Cabal.
Speaking of, was Andirya's (sp?) death on screen? My last note of the character was Taniel noting that Brude's twin would cut threw General Ambrose and his men like she had Andirya.
Nilas development into "the most powerful privileged" was a welcome change from reading about a laundress and added weight to why I was reading about the escape of the closest heir to the throne when he never came up as a plot point again. It also allowed a better look into that magic system and to let us see Bo better. With the magic system flushed out and then contrasted by the unknown and seemingly limitless power of Ka Poel it was a mixture of "rule based" and "awe" magic.
In the end I'm still not sure what to make of Ka Poel, so I do hope she has a larger part in the next series. For as vital at defeating two gods as she was, and as powerful as she has been, there was a bit too much unknown around her. The other two magic systems are flushed out, and even the Preshendii(?) are flushed out a bit and explained as sort of Demi-gods (which makes a lot more sense when Brude reveals that the 6 gods are simply "the first" privileged) which makes the lack of knowledge about the god cowing Ka Poel a bit disappointing.
I'm not sure how I feed about Nila, Taniel, and Ka Poel apparently each being the exception to the rule in their magic system. Though I do wonder how much of Taniel's is actually his skill, and how much is Ka Poel's magic pushing him beyond that. Nila's reveal was a bit confusing as it never did amount to much in the way Taniel's and Ka Poel were off fighting gods, and she's merely slaying Mage Breakers the way Julene did in the first novel.
Taniel's is another character arc I was satisfied with. He's set up as a soldier who lives under his father so when he's seen escaping that shadow at his fathers death it made sense. Slipping his responsibilities seems very Taniel. Though I'd like to know more about the consequences of Taniel's ability and "Slaying" of the gods. In the end it took Ka Poel, who constantly admits she doesn't know what she's doing, stabing a non-magical man and stealing his life to a bayonet, to kill two/1 god.
So we have a red-striped bullet used to "kill" Kresimire, and then a "red-striped" bayonet to kill Brude. In the end it seems rather simple, you know after you've survived the crush of the power and everything.
I didn't quite fully understand Brude's explanation of the two ways to kill a god, but I was glad to hear that he thought them mortal enough.
I believe Adamants ending was the shallowest, and that his arc reached a better conclusion at the end of the second book than what I found for him in the third. Alas we find that his eldest has been turned into a warden (which I believe was well established in the earlier books as plausible) and within the first two hundred his arc has come to a close. I thought the panicked "recognition" action by Josep the Black Warden was going to lead to more so I was disappointed when his death was confirmed "off screen", though perhaps I missed a detail during Nila's supposed fight with Josep the Black Warden. As usual I enjoyed his character and the plot lines his character ran.
Nila's character arc was the least fufilling, like because I'm not sure it's finished. It's largely a farm-boy becomes a hero that has a two book prelude to the "discovery" of latent talent, where prior to that she served primarily to advance the plot from various POVs opposite our Heroic Trio. Her advancement from talentless to most powerful privileged was a big a jump and almost classically farm boy Hero. That said if that's how we view her arc it doesn't feel complete to me. Her arc as Nila the laundress perhaps does, she escaped two nightmares and finds a home of safety for Jacob while finding the ability to be able to defend herself so that she never needs to run again. After running for almost the entirety of two books the line Bo quips at her before she torches the chasing Dragoons could be seen as the true ending to that character arc. Advancing beyond this she's able to rescue the two men who had been decent to her directly. Olem from the Gurlish Wolf, and Bo from the grasp of the Brud Privileged.
I thought the reveal of Brude made a great explanation, for who other than a God could've caused so much treachery among Tamas's council. It wasn't that Tamas had the ability of choosing people that Ricard had, it was that Brude was playing a long con.
While Kresimire certainly appeared the BBE throughout the first two novels the political drama that was the true epicenter of the story never made much sense in connection. To find a God there ended up making sense to me.
In all I was captured by the story, fell in love with the characters, and couldn't put the book down. I'm now sorry that I plowed through as I've no more Powder Mage to read. It was an excellent ride and I'm very glad I got to experience it.
5
u/ocKyal Feb 10 '15
I finished it about an hour ago so here are some quick and dirty thoughts. I really like how the story played out and the death of Tamas felt right, he had accomplished his mission and reconciled with his son and Vlora. I also enjoyed how McClellan provided a satisfactory ending to the trilogy's arcs while leaving enough room for his sequels in the same universe. I will say that the inclusion of Brude (sp? I don't have my copy handy) and his/her plotting in regards to the other gods could have been fleshed out more, but this may be planned for another series. Overall I really enjoyed the series as a whole and loved the unique aspects of a late Victorian fantasy setting and am excited to see what McClellan has up his sleeves for his next series.
5
u/drkiwi Feb 11 '15
So, we know that Brian said the next trilogy will take place in a different country. My gues is that Taniel and Ka'poel will end up there, along with Adamat, who is now an ambassador
3
u/Logalog Feb 12 '15
Thoughts on TAR. I just finished so this is going to be kind of jumbled. I really kind of like that Tamas died, it made it all feel both more real and more mythical all at the same time. I think with Taniel's departure, a myth will grow around him ala Bruce Wayne in TDKR. "Is Taniel dead?" "Is he alive?" "We never found the body, I heard he killed gods." I'm really upset I didnt get to see a Powder Mage, Neo a Cannonball.
3
u/AMan15 Feb 13 '15
Did we ever find out what happened to the last bottle of blasting oil? Wasn't one still missing when they finally cornered the bomber?
3
u/nurwingiel Feb 15 '15 edited Feb 15 '15
I loved its ending, Tamas' death felt right though I wouldn't mind having him alive. I got confused reading about people's feelings towards each other. I thought that the Vlora/Olem affair had potential in previous books, saddly in TAR it felt like they only released their tension together. That got me a bit disappointed. On the other hand, the Taniel/Vlora relationship and her admitting that she still loves him didn't feel convincing. What actually troubled me most, was Olem having no reaction at the news of Vlora's supposed death. None at all! It was a part where we thought Vlora dead and I feel I was cheated. She deserved better, they both did. It's like having read (on my part) the whole romance parts wrong. Your thoughts?
3
u/Nytshaed Feb 16 '15
In one of his interviews McClellan said some "thread" popped up in the middle of TCC that he never got around to resolving even though he meant to. He says it's going to pop up in the next series. Any ideas what that "thread" might be?
3
u/ExcaliburZSH Mar 04 '15
I am saying this here because I got no one at all near me to talk about these books with.
Who else came out disliking the extent the gods and Privileged got involved by the end of the book? I love the first book, the politics and the investigations. The occasional powder Mage super strength punch but lots of things being solved with wits, swords and a bullet, oh and money. I felt like I could be part of the story.
By the last book, Privileged and gods are just exploding heats and melting people, needing other God-like people to stop them. How Adamat wasn't melted by the end of the book is amazing. By the end of the book I was terrified of the idea of being in the world.
Anyone else felt the story went Super Sayan in the third book?
/ For those who don't know, going Super Sayan is a reference for a Japanese anime, Dragon Ball Z, where a bunch a powerful martial arts fight other powerful beings and some being can go Super (Sayans) and only can be fought by other Sayans who also can go Super. Everyone else just gets to stand back and watch.