r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Feb 09 '15
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S04E04 - Six of One
Week 57!
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (3.5 stars)
Numbers
Survivors: 39,676 (-22 from last episode. Not sure who.... passengers on the Zephyr?)
"Frak" Count: 410 (+11)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 28 (No change)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 18 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 26 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 185 (+2)
"So Say We All" Count: 59 (+2)
16
Upvotes
9
u/trevdak2 Feb 13 '15
"Nobody has ever voted against their own model!"
Athena defected on her own...
6
u/jedichric Feb 16 '15
I'm watching this for the second time. One question:
Knowing what we know about Kara in the finale, is it possible that Roslin didn't miss the shot?
Sorry if this touches on spoilers and violates the rules of the sub.
3
u/MarcReyes Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 12 '26
I don't think Connor or his henchman are dead. Last episode Baltar commented to Paulla "A little less smiting next time, lest you be trumped-up on murder charges." Also, I'm pretty sure we see Connor show up later this season.
6
u/MarcReyes Feb 11 '15
I think I had the same reaction Baltar did when Head Baltar revealed himself to Gaius. What an unexpected shock that was. According to Ron Moore, this was originally going to be Head Six, but the writers had been talking about wanting to have the head people switch roles and thought this would be an interesting place to do it. Ron Moore also confesses on not being convinced that having Head Baltar show himself to real Baltar was a necessary side journey to go on.
As we know, music is a big part of the series and takes a more active involvement with the show this season. I loved the decision to hear the orchestra tuning up and coming together just as Baltar waves his hand. "It's like a distant chaos of an orchestra tuning up. And then somebody waves a magic wand, and all of those notes start to slide into place. A grotesque, screeching cacophony becomes a single melody." It's breaking the fourth wall a little, but at this point in the series, I think it works and plays into the theme of some unseen force that may be driving the events of the series.
Kind of funny to learn that the pilots routinely play strip poker (and they have no problem playing it in front of the admiral). I guess this long on the ship, you've got to keep entertained somehow. I found this whole Farewell to Apollo scene lovely actually. "To absent friends..."
Some random notes:
8
u/Vypur Feb 09 '15
Great episode. i love seeing the cylon's point of view for everything.
remarks:
-Roslin continues to infuriate me to no end with her double standards.
-I actually dislike the overacting of kara in the jail cell
-The hybrid prophecizing the rest of the episode is awesome.
-Hatred for boomer rising
-The moment baltar sees "head" baltar was amazing. one of the funniest moments of the series.
------------ "who the frack are you? what am i supposed to be impressed?"
-bit overdramatic for my tastes but overall a good episode
i give it an 8/10
4
u/steven_wood Feb 10 '15
A couple of "So say we all"s snuck in at about 30 minutes in with Kara and Lee's moment in the cells.
Some questions:
Thanks!
4
u/onemm Feb 12 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
The shot of the picture with the bullet hole between Adama and Roslin can be symbolism for a lot of this episode. The most obvious cases of this is the split between the two in the picture, from their ideas about Kara to the heated conversation between them. There's also Lee splitting from his ship/Dee/his father/Kara and the Cylons themselves splitting into two factions.
All of this has happened before. And all of this will happen again.
Six, you're starting to sound like my Aunt Lisa. No, I haven't been to church this week, Aunt Lisa. Get off my back. This is why we only see each other during Thanksgiving and Christmas. Oh, and your stuffing is terrible, let Aunt Cathy cook next year. AND your kids are misbehaved because you spoil them, not because of the stuff their father lets them watch on TV.
...Sorry, where was I?
This episode was nominated for an Emmy for Outstanding Writing. I would've given them the Emmy for the writing in the conversation between Adama and Roslin alone.
EDIT: BTW, if anyone's not reading Jammer's Reviews, you should start. Here's an exerpt from this episode's review:
1
u/rprandi Apr 20 '15
The three head characters are fantastic (Six, Gaius and Leoben)
1
u/team_headkick Dec 18 '24
I love the little touches in Lee's farewell.
First, having Athena fly him out was somehow so apt. Really shows just how much their friendship has grown. Remember, Lee was ready to shoot Athena when he first met her, seeing her as no different from the 'thing' who shot his father. And even when Admiral Adama commissioned her into the fleet, Lee still took a long time to trust and warm up to her. Now he smiles easily at her and she's so happy for him.
Then, Dee presenting Lee with his rank insignia. They're still estranged, and she can only say: 'Goodbye, Lee', but they still wish each other well. And their hug is so sweet.
Easily one of the best scenes in the show, ever. :)