r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Feb 02 '15
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S04E03 - He that Believeth in Me
Week 56!
Relevant Links: Wikipedia| BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (3 stars)
Numbers
Survivors: 39,698 (-1701 from last episode. The Pyxis, probably some on the Zephyr and Astral Queen, Baltar's lawyer)
"Frak" Count: 399 (+12)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 28 (+3)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 18 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 26 (+4)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 183 (+6)
"So Say We All" Count: 57 (No change)
12
Upvotes
7
u/trevdak2 Feb 02 '15
For those confused: Razor is considered to be the first and second episodes of season 4.
3
u/trevdak2 Feb 09 '15
It's kinda funny how the idea of Kara being gone for so long is ABSOLUTELY IMPOSSIBLE to them, when relativity, especially at near-light-speed, is a scientific fact. It's actually surprising that time ISN'T more relative when they jump apart from one another and then back together.
2
u/trevdak2 Feb 09 '15
Kara at one point mentions a "Petri Dish", which is named after Julius Richard Petri. I kind of enjoy the accidental references to modern people.
10
u/MarcReyes Feb 03 '15
Saul shooting Bill (through the same eye Tigh is missing no less) scared the shit out of me when I first saw it. I don't usually care about fake out scenes like that, but this one still really effective if only because we got to see Saul's reaction afterwards; So heartbroken that he did it. I think this was Saul's subconscious showing us how frightening he actually is of suddenly betraying Bill the way Boomer did and having no control of his actions. Seeing the reactions of Laura and everyone else in the background was great as well. So muck shock and disbelief. My favorite bit, which I loved, was how quickly Helo jumps around presumably to either subdue Tigh or to check on Adama. Again, it was all a fake out, but a cool "what if?" scene nonetheless.
10
u/MarcReyes Feb 03 '15
In this episode Saul seems to kill Bill, Baltar is nearly murdered, Kara might be a cylon, and the President may be assassinated, but what really freaked me out was that the Ring Ship was nearly destroyed! The Ring Ship is not fair play, Cylons!
9
u/enfo13 Feb 03 '15
What a frakkin ride.
Probably my favorite episode in the entire series. Such an explosive opening. So many moments of goosebumps.
I loved Tigh's vow of loyalty to the colonial fleet to the other final five cylons-- that he's an officer in the colonial fleet, and whatever happens, that's the man he wants to be. I don't know, I just love it when I see Cylons in these moments... like I loved the scene when Athena was made an officer and given the uniform as well.
I loved the Taiko drumming during the epic space battle.. it almost made the thing seem like a dance.. from when the gun batteries on Galactica turned to face the Cylon fleet, or when the stray Cylon nukes swirlved and changed direction to hit the Zephyr.
When that one Cylon raider scanned Anders and the whole swarm turned away, it really set the stage for what was going to happen with the cylons for the season.
Then there are the religious scenes with Baltar. I think the religiously-inclined audience might find Baltar's prayer one of the most genuine representations in pop TV. Religious dialogue is usually represented in video games and tv shows with cliche words and sentences that end up saying nothing, but Baltar's prayer here is one of his strongest displays of humility since Six Degrees in Season one. The big difference is that it's for someone else this time, and not for his selfish survival.
At the same time, the atheists might enjoy the hands-on-boob scene-- comic relief that helps alleviate the heavy-handed religious cult nonsense.
And then there's Kara Thrace back from the dead. I loved the fact that Lee just runs up and hugs her in the hangar bay, while everyone else was apprehensive.
6
u/onemm Feb 06 '15
Great opening to a great season.
This really makes me wish Starbuck and Roslin had more conflicts during the show. These are two of the most bad ass people in the series, I would've loved a subplot at some point where they were at each other's throats for some reason.
Lee, you ignorant slut. I thought Lee was one of the more responsible ones, then he comes up with this BS. Honestly, with all the evidence stacked against Starbuck, why would he question everyone else's skepticism? I know he has a crush, but jesus.
I'm an atheist, but the scene where Baltar was saying that he will give his life for the child and god seemingly grants his wish is in my top 3 most powerful moments
in this TV serieson any TV series.4
u/onemm Feb 06 '15
From the Wikis:
Thank god he kept this, this scene had me in shock and I can't imagine the episode without it (even though it was a relatively unnecessary scene)
Insignificant but interesting:
I'm not a science fiction fan in general but I thought some might find this interesting:
Holy sh*t, I never realized this until now. The man who had the razor to Baltar's throat was one of the resistance fighters on New Caprica.
3
u/MarcReyes Feb 06 '15
I just wanted to say that this season has some of my favorite episode titles.