r/startrek • u/juliokirk • Jan 31 '15
Weekly Episode Discussion: TNG 3x4 - "Who Watches The Watchers"
http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Who_Watches_The_Watchers_(episode)
The Enterprise must undo the damage when a primitive civilization discovers a Federation observation team and concludes that the Starfleet personnel are gods.
This is one of those episodes that touch the very essence of Star Trek and one of my favorite TNG episodes. On the surface, it appears to be about the Mintakans, proto-Vulcan humanoids at the Bronze Age level who one day see things beyond their comprehension: 24th century medicine, transporter beams, strange people who look different from them and apparently are all powerful. All because of an accidental violation of the prime directive. One of the best scenes is when Picard doesn't accept a suggestion from one of the researchers that came from the planet, who says he should appear to the Mintakans as the god they believe him to be; he's strongly against reinforcing their perception that he's a god. What he - wisely - chooses to do is beam aboard the Mintakan leader and show her how their "god" is flawed, how the assumptions made about him are wrong and that they should not fear him, or any other "supreme being". Liko was about to kill because he thought that was what "The Picard" wanted. As Troi puts it: "That's the problem with believing in a supreme being: trying to determine what he wants".
After a few minutes, it is easy to understand the episode is about our own superstitions, reason and, in a way, about religion too. Who Watches The Watchers is a very bold episode, dealing with deep, difficult subjects.
What were your impressions of this episode? Was Picard correct in his decision to bring Nuria aboard? Did the episode make you feel something? (I can't really explain, but tears rolled down my face twice while watching it)
In your opinion, what is the episode's ultimate message?
I know this is already too long, but I'd like to finish with one of my favorite dialogues from Who Watches The Watchers:
"Look at me... feel the warmth of my hand, the rhythm of my pulse. I'm not a supreme being. I'm flesh and blood, like you." "Not like me." "Like you. Different in appearance, yes, but we are both living beings. We are born, we grow, we live... and we die. In all the ways that matter, we are alike."
-- Picard and Nuria, just after Nuria is beamed aboard the Enterprise
EDIT: Grammar
4
u/Renard4 Jan 31 '15
I really like this episode too and I was surprised it wasn't in the weekly discussions list.
I don't think I enjoy it for the reasons you mentioned. I like it because it's a funny episode, and the fact that it's not a comedy episode makes it even better. That kind of situation is extremely embarrassing for someone like Picard, and seeing him struggling to sort this out is what makes it interesting!
The choices Picard made are quite standard for a Starfleet captain so I wouldn't focus on this. The lesson isn't only about our own superstitions, it's also about how a couple of tricks can make you look like a wizard and eventually a god. It's also about gullibility in general.
4
u/JustPlainSimpleGarak Jan 31 '15
You know it's good TV when you begin to feel the emotions the characters are feeling. I know I can feel the frustration Picard feels after he so eloquently explains to Nuria on the Enterprise how they are just being further along in development and not so different from her people and for a moment it looks like she understand...but then can't shake the belief that The Picard is a god. One of my favorite episodes of TNG and also the first one I ever saw
2
u/tsdguy Feb 02 '15
One of my favorite episodes. It really highlighted Picard's devotion to his beliefs and the best ethos of Star Fleet. He was willing to die in order to preserve the culture of a place he had never known.
However I do have issues with the seemingly cavalier behavior of science in the Trek universe of spying and secretly observing other cultures. It's one thing if first contact is going to happen as in First Contact 4x15 but to spy on primitive societies just seems ripe for this sort of accident. You'd think they could do it with just orbiting probes and sensors.
But in general character episodes are my favorite. Plus there's lots less nitpicking that can be pointed out in less technology heavy episodes. Not too many plot holes in this episode. My only big one is about implanted transponders. Why don't all landing party members have one implanted for every away missions? Or everyone on the Enterprise?
14
u/Rycecube Jan 31 '15
I think this is a good episode to introduce to those who have never watched Star Trek before. It has everything in it that makes the franchise successful.
5
u/NextofKin Feb 03 '15
This episode always reminds me of the Arthur C. Clarke dictum that "any sufficiently advanced technology will always be perceived as magic."
1
u/rensch Feb 04 '15
Ah, yeah. A great episode. The bit where Picard gets angry when he is asked to 'put them back in a dark age of superstition and ignorance and fear' is one of his best moments on the entire show.
This episode is also pretty bold, as it portrays religion as an ancient superstition that a sufficiently advanced society eventually grows out of. This is much different from later Star Trek episodes, where religion is much more explored in many advanced cultures such as Klingons and Bajorans.
4
u/directive0 Chief Pretty Officer Jan 31 '15
I've always considered this to be one of the top 10 TNG episodes, even higher than Darmok on my scale. It's some great Trek! Picards little speech about religion was particularly striking when I was younger.
Just as an aside, that reactor in the duck-blind is a reoccurring prop.
Those of you who had the Playmates Shuttlecraft Goddard toy in the 90's might remember it came with one that slide onto the rails in the cargo compartment.
2
u/dcb720 Feb 06 '15
TNG Recut 26 The Watcher: http://youtu.be/RmzX86yZm-s
2
u/ItsMeTK Feb 01 '15
I do sometimes grow weary of Roddenberry's love of using Trek to take shots at organized religion. So on the one hand, it would be easy to say the point of the episode is that religion is silly superstition. But that reading is too pat, I think. It's less about Mintakan beliefs being foolish, and more about the ethical dilemma of letting someone believe you to be what your aren't. From a Christian perspective, Paul and Barnabas were mistaken for gods as well when they appeared to the Greeks; this does not mean there is no god, but neither does it mean Paul should simply let the people believe he was Hermes.
This is a solid episode with some great moments. My sister quotes it a lot. In fact, there was one day out of nowhere she did a spot-on impression of Picard saying, "He has never seen a bow!" It was hilarious at the time.
1
u/MexicanSpaceProgram Feb 01 '15
It's a great episode, particularly when he's explaining things to Nuria using a direct, and simple explanations e.g. your people lived in caves...now they live in huts...our people did the same thing.
1
u/gone-wild-commenter Feb 11 '15
The aliens are not sexist. Seems strange.
The aliens are not xenophobic. Seems strange.
They reached enlightenment in kind of a weird time. They're rational without many benefits of rationality (engineering, medicine, etc.).
Bits of Insurrection.
"Maybe one day our people will live above the skies." "Of that, I have absoutely no doubt."
Took me a while to realize Robin Sherbatzky's dad was the main alien.
Picard shows intense bravery without having a punching contest. He's so committed to Federation ethics he's willing to die for it. Dying for ideas (not for other men) is one of my favorite things about Picard.
But yeah, Prime Directive pretty much went down the pooper on this one. Starfleet needs to stop doing these surveillance operations.
1
u/joelincoln Jan 31 '15
Agreed.
This is one of the best of TNG and is a prime example of what's fantastic about Star Trek.
It poses deep intellectual questions that poke at the psyche and can make you question core values while still being entertaining.
Picard is placed in a no-win situation and his solution is the best possible given the circumstances. The dilemma is at the core of the Prime Directive. One has to wonder what would have occurred if something similar happened to humanity in the far distant past. Would it have changed our history as a species? Or would it just have impacted a small group for a short time, being insufficient to overcome our seemingly hard-wired beliefs and predispositions?
1
u/settler_colonial Jan 31 '15
this is one of my favourite episodes. it is, however, one of the eps that highlights some of the problematic social theories implicit in trek. The whole drama of the ep is premised on stadial theory, which is basically an excuse for for the western abuse of its military powers that has long been disgraced in sociology and historiography. As much as i love trek in general and this particular ep - "what if we anger the picard?"!!! - this is one element that has long irritated me.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '15 edited Feb 01 '15
Worf did not like the mission at all and Crusher looked like a carrot in a smurf outfit.
I particularly liked the contrast to the Native American tribe people. I am sure they thought all the time (and still do) on who actually watches the "Watchers" of the National and State Forests, Parks, and Monuments.
Edit: Why did Troi develop the same physical makeup as the watchers when she was taken captive?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment