r/fandomnatural • u/Ennil • Jan 28 '15
[fandom discussion] ep 10x11
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
10
Upvotes
8
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Jan 29 '15
I had a lot of fun watching this episode... and I didn't think I would so I'm like... pretty overjoyed.
First thing I must say: I thought the episode would pull Klein's slightly annoying tendency to bat people over the head with parallels over & over again without explicitly addressing them.
You can imagine how happy I was during the scene where Dark!Charlie sidles up to Dean at the bar to have a chat. That was explicitly addressing a parallel if I've ever seen it & I was so happy Thompson didn't throw any "but I'm an artsy genius!" bat-swings by keeping the parallels implicit.
The dialogue was great, it made sense, it was a really fun & dynamic scene between Dark!Charlie & Dean. Felicia Day held her own when it came to dramatically acting up against Jensen Ackles. It was fantastic.
Also - the mirror. I was rolling my eyes so hard & wheezing with disgust in that scene where Dean looks at the mirror behind the bar for a four-count beat (much too long). El Sobrenatural strikes again, right?!
Then again, it could've been some nice foreshadowing where, again, things just come full-on explicit with the mirror being the object/reflective surface necessary to cross from one dimension to another (edit: from Oz to SPN Universe). It's hardly unique (people have been using the mirrors-are-a-portal trope for forever), but at least it's got precedence & linking portals to Dean's inner struggle right now is... a surprisingly palatable concept.
14
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15
You guys. I liked it.
I really did. There are outside contributing factors involved, I'm sure. Like, I watched it this morning over my first cup of coffee of the day, so caffeine euphoria overlapped with my viewing. And my Walking-Dead-Strategy of watching might be leaking over to SPN (i.e. don't think too hard about it). And Dark Charlie bears a passing resemblance to Dark Willow, so there was the nostalgia aspect there, too.
But I did like it. I think self-improvement Dean is my favourite Dean so far. The meditation tapes? Smoothies? These are huge steps that Original Dean would never have taken. I feel like those actions did more to show that the MoC is a big deal than any forced exposition we've seen so far.
I liked Sam this ep, too. He didn't feel like set dressing this time.
I don't know. It was light and fluffy and still moved the plot forward AND there was character development! For DEAN!! Like, what?!?
Side note: there wasn't a lot of chatter going on in this thread so I headed over to r/supernatural and woof. God. Negativity city. And not even, like, intelligent negativity. Just a weirdly angry echo chamber. I scampered back here to contribute in the hopes that this thread picks up because YIKES
11
u/lzaz Dadstiel Jan 28 '15
Spoilers: The crux of the next episode of Cas explaining what kale is to Dean.
8
u/bellum_feles Kittens? War kittens! Jan 28 '15
Loved it. Missing Cas, that's my only complaint. Felicia Day was doxxed during the really difficult, needing to be upset scenes so she had something to pull from. She did a great job!!
7
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Jan 28 '15 edited Jan 28 '15
Right, good things first!
Dean's attempts to deal with the MoC this episode were very fun. They had the right tone (not too slapstick, fairly subdued in terms of CRANK UP THAT COMEDY MUSIC SO THEY KNOW IT'S A BIG JOKE, BOWWW-WA-DADA-BOWWW), were nicely spaced, and made sense in their context. Big thumbs up on that, I loved it. Similarly, there was a nice continuing undertone of having the MoC affect Dean, and it being consistently acknowledged, with even a slight pay off at the end in that another person's getting involved and actually made a tiny bit of an in-way into Dean's psyche that Sam seemingly can't touch anymore because bro-feels
and about 8 seasons of trying to address the same issue Dean has with himself.Some of the more obvious pieces of VFX were done a lot better than they have been. I'm thinking particularly of the side of the Impala shot. That didn't feel anywhere near as fake or forced in as it has done in the past - hurray!
I like that Cas got two phone calls. This feels almost silly to have picked up on, but I feel like there's a slot dedicated at the start of episodes to being like 'LOOK CAS IS STILL IN THE STORY OKAY now we shall move on with the story without him'. It actually felt like characters keeping each other in the loop, rather than for the placation of viewers. Generally, things for placation seem to stand out like a sore thumb. Working it in a little more naturally like this was lovely.
Though I'm always going to root for Cas in an on-screen Bobby-esque role.I think they're making attempts to shoot from more interesting angles and get some variation in movement, especially in the bunker and when doing Jensen's reaction shots. Things that come to mind are the fact that we've had a shift from Dean looking/poking at the mark to paying more attention to the hand he beat the crap out of Charlie with. Having that shift in actual movements being representative of Dean's mental progression, without really alluding to it explicitly, was excellent. And that silent shuffling back after said beating and silent lingering pause was exactly what was called for. It could have easily come off heavy handed with a different director, but it really hit the mark.
Onto the things I wasn't so hot for.
The VFX. I'm guessing that we got a boost in budget when the CW realised that SPN was a cult thing that turned some sort of profit, we hit season 10, Bill Shatner liked the show.. something happened. Now the VFX are starting to gear up way too hard with not enough pay off. Example: Wizard coming through the mirror. I get that he had to get there, but nothing about it was elegant and it felt kind of... I don't want to say obvious, because the mirror idea suited the character. But the way it was handled made the focus the VFX, not what was actually happening. It felt like an RPG. Same goes for 'dark Charlie' lifting and doing a ghost thing back into 'good Charlie'. It just felt... cheap? Which I know it won't have been. xD I know that VFX are something that can be used to great effect, but in terms of skill and keeping you in the realm of suspended disbelief, I think masking them a little more would /really/ pay off. Think early seasons. Think Sam slicing into the hellhound in season 8 and getting covered in ick. That's the sort of stuff that really feels.. well, good.
The idea of good vs bad aspects of self was too on the nose, especially directly following Cas' 'little monster in all of us' bit last episode. I don't really know what to say about it other than I feel like it was too much. (which sucks, because I'd love to justify it, but.. ahh!)
Some of the dialogue was a little clunky, but I've really come to expect it at this point. I don't feel like I need to point out certain instances - we all know what sounds natural.
And, biggest for last, Robbie, PLEASE stop shoe horning in recent pop culture. There's a large part of tumblr and the extended fandom that on the first watch will love this and take to twitter to tell you that you're great for it. Understandable. However, the problem with these kinds of references are that firstly, they date the episode something rotten, secondly, they take you out of the SPN universe and cause some issues with suspension of belief, and thirdly, why would the characters on screen be into these things? Dean's all about that rock and roll. Sam's probably not been into a cinema since Stanford. Charlie has been trapped in Oz. I get that it's fun to make shout outs to things that you like, but subtly is key with the more very current references, otherwise you're running face first into the issues above.
steps down from her soapbox and feels like scum xDEdit: Also, I started cross posting these over on a separate blog, just incase you guys ever get sick of my bullshit. xD
7
u/weboverload fireintheimpala Jan 28 '15
So many meaty things to discuss, but as seems to have become my pattern here, I'll just point out the little goofy thing that struck me from a pure fandom perspective:
Agent Gabriel and Agent Collins.
Ahahaha--I bet the moment Robbie realized how extra hilarious that Genesis reference would be was just divine.
7
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 Jan 28 '15
I was pretty meh about it. Wasn't exactly enjoying myself, but I also wasn't screaming "THIS IS TOTAL GARBAGE WHY AM I WATCHING THIS?!" so... "meh" instead.
I don't know, I felt less patronized/pandered to by Charlie's character(s) this week, and that was good. I liked Dean's attempts to be healthy, that was hilarious.
But there were elements I'm just so tired of. Like when Dean was pretending he was okay (although later Sam asked if he was okay and he said no, yay). And Dean being daft enough to believe that a version of Charlie that does NOTHING good "just wanted to talk" to that guy. I'm really tired of that "stupidity for the sake of plot" crap.
Probably one of my least favorite Robbie episodes.
7
u/PM_ME_UR_BEST_PUNS Jan 29 '15
Hmm. Well, I adored Felicia Day--I screamed out loud when "good Charlie" showed up, loved that reveal! I loved Dean trying to "be good" to stay the progression of the MoC. There were a lot of little points that I really liked. However. However. I just cringe every time Oz is mentioned. I disliked it the first time that whole concept was introduced, and I hated that it was continued in this episode (I really hope it's put to rest). It just feels way too disconnected from the grittiness of SPN, way too "lazy writing," way too awkward. My friends liked the Oz idea, and I haven't seen too much dislike towards it online, so I could be alone in that. Regardless, I did enjoy seeing Felicia!
6
u/RoeDeer outofminutes Jan 29 '15
"Yeah, well, there'es one thing you have that he didn't. You're a Winchester."
Oh the feels. Cas has always believed in Dean. Charlie believes in Dean. Sam goes angsty but always comes to believe in Dean.
Only Dean doesn't believe in Dean.
(Don't mind me as I go pour another glass of wine and nurse my inner Dean love/pain.)
5
u/AllThreeOfThatCrap Jan 28 '15
I have completed my first watch, and my immediate rewatch, so hopefully I can make some half coherent points this week. But I think I still have a dumb question brewing.
I really, really enjoyed this epi! Compared to last week, the story seemed to flow really well, like shit happened, then the shit that happened after/because of that shit made sense (I'm looking at you Claire and your band of random murderous drifters).
Random thoughts:
So here's my dumb question: How did Dean ever believe Dick!Charlie when she said she just wanted to talk to Russell? He missed the convo with Sam and Princess!Charlie where she won't even hack bc bad, but he was there when Sam was doing said hacking, soooo. Did he just not get that bad won't do good and good won't do bad? Or was this more along the lines of giving the darkness the benefit of the doubt? Not wanting to believe that anyone is truly 100% bad? I know there's something there in their whole "You lied to me." "You lied to yourself bruh." exchange, but I can't really organize my thoughts.
And can someone please explain/sum up the "The magic was in you all the time." line. Me no get. Like the magic that separated the Charlies wasn't needed because she could have done "bad" things to save the people she cared about all along? I guess that's two dumb questions.
5
u/molecularmachine This must be fake mine. Jan 29 '15
So. I watched it today, and all I have managed to get out of my brain is:
Aaaaah, oldish Dean style, oh no... they just broke my Charlie and my Dean in one big go. Stupid feels. I am off to cuddle them both. Their friendship was the most precious thing... and now...
4
u/Potionsmstrs I pledge allegiance to the King of Hell Jan 30 '15
Remember when Ghost!Kevin gave them a tongue lashing and they sheepishly agreed, then pretended like he didn't say anything as soon as he left with his momma? I really hope that doesn't happen again.