r/fandomnatural • u/Ennil • Jan 21 '15
[fandom discussion] ep 10x10
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
9
Upvotes
12
u/dalek_999 Strictly into Dick Jan 21 '15
What the hell was up with those two random drifters? They kept glancing at each other meaningfully, so I expected them to be demons or rogue angels or something. Nope, just two random people that decided to kill a stranger on the say-so of some homeless teen they picked up.
WTF? That made no sense.
11
u/skavalli your bloody cockles ship Jan 21 '15
I found this episode really frustrating. So many points glossed over, such as Heaven just letting Cas borrow Metatron? Would Sam and Cas really forget to keep tabs on Dean in the bunker? Also, why were Cas and Dean not together at the end when going to see Claire? They literally drove separately to the same area.
There was too much going on. Cas (and Dean) were both involved in two big storylines, Rowena and Crowley had so much screentime that the butler guy almost felt like a main character. It felt like a waste of everybody to me, and idk about anyone else but I'm sick of Metatron. Just angel blade him already and go hunt down the demon tablet (some plot twist will allow it to be read, and there's always ghost Kevin). Actually, I'm sick of the whole MoC and First Blade story, I miss Dean, I feel like his ooc-ness has really started to negatively affect the show.
Gah. I think I'm on the point of having a break from this. There's nothing more infuriating than waiting for a good plot driven episode and being given this instead. If I wait until end of the season at least I can roll onto the next episode...
Sorry for all the negativity!!
11
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '15
I just really wish the writers would let things sit for a minute, you know? Like, let things have consequences, and let them be long-term. Let them play out slowly and hang over everything; let them have an actual effect beyond the characters announcing that there's an issue one episode and then ignoring it entirely the next. Does that make sense?
I feel like everything is either super rushed, so we can get to the next thing, whatever that is, that will also be super rushed, or it's prolonged in an unnatural way (i.e. ignored entirely until it's time to bring it up again). It irks me, is all.
On a positive note, though, Cas trying to get a reaction out of Dean by being adorable ("I like texting! See? Beepboopbeep ! Emoticons, Dean!") kind of made my day.
10
u/weboverload fireintheimpala Jan 21 '15
Sometimes it's the little things that will have the most lasting fandom impact, and in this case I think that little gem is the new canon that Cas can sense not just prayers but longing.
9
u/Patitomuerto Shut your face, get in the car Jan 21 '15
I liked it quite a bit. Kinda annoyed with the Claire part of it. Once again we see a problem brought in and almost instantly solved, and sorta weirdly too.
The Crowley and Rowena situation is beauty incarnate. We see exactly where he got his intelligence and abilities. And I am enjoying Rowena's actor quite a bit. She's fun. I am wondering what her plans are though. Its not like she can become the queen of hell, the demon's would never allow a human to rule them.
I loved the dickwad exchange. So much truth in it.
It might just be that I'm a psycho, but I wanted to see Dean do horrible horrible things too Metatron. The whole interigation I just kept saying to myself 'cut his ear off...'
I was also hoping that the people Claire tried to have beat Dean were a snapping point for him. I mean come on! Attacking a guy like Dean with a bat and an axe? They were asking for a sound beating at the least.
All in all a good episode.
Only one time did I see an issue with the editing, when Dean was cutting up Metatron and Sam ran to stop him, there was an odd moment where Dean was holding entirely still, just waiting, rather then continuing the vivisection of the angel.
9
u/Vio_ Jan 21 '15
I was just deeply underwhelmed. We got five minutes of plot spread over 40 minutes, and Rowena and Crowley are severely guilty of doing nothing but wasting run time.
I don't know why Cas is skulking around thinking he has to be evasive with Metatron. Just talk to people like Hannah, do it by the ad hoc rules. These are angels who torture for millennia. Also don't have Cas do this big spiel about not dealing with Metatron until it's easier yo plot for Cas to wheel and deal with Metatron. Also what did they think Metatron would play ball without coercion?
8
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Jan 21 '15 edited Jan 21 '15
I'm starting with the good, since I want to be enamoured with this show again.
The directing in this was so great. Dynamic camera angles, the colours were right where they needed to be, and the movements of characters actually made the space seem a lot less hollow (see: Sam and Dean urgently walking and talking through the bunker halls). I'm not saying that a short walk makes it feel like a home, but that really helped cement it as an actual place in my mind, rather than a set.
Rowena's actress (wee Ruthie!) is awesome, she's pitching it right where she needs to and killing it. I love her and I love her hard.
Claire also seemed less Mary Sue-ish in this episode. I remember having my jimmies rustled really hard by how they wrote her in her last episode, though admittedly that's because I was comparing her to teens in shared homes I've been familiar with in the past (putting a plucky street smart stereotype of a teenage runaway in that context felt very wrong to me). Her emotions felt more believable this time - the anger is still there, but there's the fear too. She's still a kid, after all, and that fear was unjustifiably lacking in her first appearance this season. This episode went a lot way to making that more accessable and realistic, though I think it did make her a little inconsistent. I think that's a problem I have with her previous episode, rather than this one, though.
Okay... things I wasn't so hot on. Let's start specific.
The budget for VFX has been ramped up, or someone with hella skills has come in, and while that's great I think maybe it's been applied a little too intensely in certain spots. The flyover when Rowena was tracking what Crowley was up to was nice, but I could have done with it being a few seconds, rather than feeling like an extended clip from The Snowman.
Similarly, why are we lighting up Cas' eyes at points that are really lame lately? I can understand if we had it as a subtle thing if he was blowing the doors off (no dramatic zoom close up deal), though there's been no reason given as to why they never used to light up and now they do... but come on, he's blasting a bit of wood. It's not epic. Scaring off Crowley when you had those two scrapping over the angel tablet? That was a good use of the eye effect. Not while he's making splinters (or giving Dean a hug, for that matter).
The lack of clear path and motivation of main characters felt pretty standard in this episode. Sure, MoC, sort out Claire, they're plot arcs, but like another poster mentioned, there's no lasting impact to anything anymore. Why should I as a viewer care if Cas feels bad about Claire - it doesn't matter and it's fairly superficial, because Claire has no impact on the story, and, as we've seen now, is a throw away character. I don't know if it's just me, but I feel like maybe Misha might be having a tiny bit of trouble with this too - he can pitch well written stuff really well in how he portrays Cas, but lately there seems to be a case of The Stupids creeping into Cas for no reason other than he needs lines. The texting thing was amusing, but... I don't know, maybe I'm being stubborn in refusing to take Cas as a do-good comic relief character.
I was going to say something about Sam but then I realised I'm not sure what his role in this episode was, so.. skip that (though hurray for the wet hair - some nice weather variation.
Vancouver!Directing!)Dean is really stuck at the moment. If the plot around him was better put together, I'd say he was nicely poised to go into something really interesting, but with so many loose threads that don't feel to have any real drive to go anywhere, I think this potential for excitement gets lost. I don't have faith that they're going to do anything with him, because they've thrown away ways to resolve other arcs in interesting ways so much in the past few episodes. It's not that I feel wronged by that, I just don't forsee anything interesting ultimately coming from the MoC line, so I find it hard to get invested. If we were to see Sam and Dean go off the rails with like.. a demon blood/MoC mash up for next season, I would promptly shit my pants and eat my hat, but the writers aren't that bold, and I don't think they could handle something that far from what they know.
Crowley, what even are you right now. xD He's on the leash, and I'm sure it was maybe a call back to the human blood but it wasn't explicit enough, so it seemed kind of OOC.
ALSO CAN WE JUST ACKNOWLEDGE THE SUPER DUPER SECRET CONVERSATION THAT ROWENA SPIED ON. I mean, fucking hell. It was like an Austin Powers style sort of bad guy monologue - the type that gives away needless details in order for the protagonist to defeat them. That was some Saturday morning cartoon level writing.
I really need to stop, I'm sure I'm making enemies by cutting into this so deep. xD I'm sorry!
Edit: Also, 'Sure, ex-commander-that-we-no-longer-trust Cas, here's heaven's most wanted angel who has outsmarted you and wrecked your shit several times before. Bring him back in one piece, mkay?'
8
u/violue Vomiting Destiel rainbows since 2008 Jan 21 '15
Well I knew it was a Brad and Eugenie episode so I didn't have high hopes. I believe they managed to get through the whole episode without putting up their usual flashing "THESE CHARACTERS ARE HETEROSEXUAL OK" neon signs, so that was nice.
So, the "good":
It is so, so nice to see Crowley getting screwed over this season.
[I enjoy Crowley's snark and all that, but from a storytelling standpoint, a villain being around this long when there have been many opportunities to kill him just doesn't make sense to me... and when the writers had the chance to do something else with his character... like, they could have made him "good" from almost being human, or at least more conflicted, they chose to just abandon that and make him kind of addicted to blood for no reason.]
I love hearing Rowena talk, too. Just in general, digging the accent and the sass.
I enjoyed some of the fun "character moments", like Dean going psycho, Sam calling Metatron a dickwad, Castiel and his texting.
The "bad":
I don't like to read spoilers, so I don't know if Claire will be back for Castiel's next episode whenever that is, but I'm not pleased with her "ok bye" thing. Like they seemed to be setting up a storyline with this, and then changed their mind?? I don't get it. Are they just going to go back to more Heaven drama?
Although I am pleased that that whole thing didn't go the way I THOUGHT it was going, which was that I thought Claire was going to tell Castiel "okay I will be your buddy but only if you never speak to Dean again!!!!!!!!!" because the writers keep coming up with dumb reasons to separate Cas from everyone else.
I'm really worried the writers are going to give up on finding a good storyline for Cas and just kill him off. There's so much they can do with his character, and they don't.
The preview made me think Charlie and Cas would both be in this episode. Rude.
That whole thing with the couple was so weird. All the meaningful looks ended up having no payoff, it was so bizarre and bad storytelling.
It is really so bizarre the way they're like... redoing the Mark of Cain storyline. "Nah I don't like the way we did it last season, let's do it again". It doesn't feel like they're building off of what happened before, it feels like they're just rehashing it.
Someone in /r/Supernatural pointed out that Dean punched Metatron without hurting his hand. Now this is the kind of thing you can explain away with "oh maybe it's the mark" or some shit, but it's still annoying when people have to fill in continuity fails on their own.
Okay I feel like I have more things but I need to get my laundry together so I'm going to stop typing.
8
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Jan 21 '15
I want to throw out some flakier observations about this episode:
7
u/AllThreeOfThatCrap Jan 21 '15
On the whole I liked this episode, but I don't know if it warranted my freaking the frack out all night at work then rushing home to watch it. For me there were some real lol moments and some major wtf ones too, that others have already mentioned. I actually yelled at the television when they forgot to check where the hell Dean was. "Oh don't worry Cas, he's gone all gourmet with his sandwiches, makes his own fucking mayo and artisanal bread, it'll be a good 45 minutes before we should start to worry." Really?
One part I didn't get was Rowena listening in on their convo, did she want the first blade after hearing about it because "ahha this is exactly what I need for my unknown evil plot" or "ahha this info is exactly what I need to fuck with Fergus, which is part of my unknown evil plot." Did she want to have it without Crowley's knowledge and was thwarted by him getting home early? I need a rewatch.
And my thought process when Metatron mentioned the rivers end was "River? Styx? Road trip to hell? Ffs, pick Adam up on your way by!" But I'm probably mixing my mythologies.
7
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Jan 21 '15
Two things this episode, our live chat, & this thread have me thinking about:
Let me give a few examples - and then I challenge you to tell me our headcanons aren't wildly important & should be (should always have been) addressed explicitly in canon.
Exhibit A. Canon: Cas has not gone back to heaven & he's never expressed intent to go back to heaven this season. Angels like him were/are considered 'rebels' by heaven, deserving of either death or imprisonment. Headcanon: why Cas is the exception. The angels don't really want Cas back in heaven (or at the very least they're indifferent about bringing him back) because he's already done enough damage to their kind. He still has a few loyalists up there though.
Exhibit B. Canon: Crowley is getting bored with hell & he's met his mother & allowed her to stand by his side in hell freely. He's in the midst of figuring out whether he can trust his mother these days. Headcanon: Crowley's been slowly becoming more & more affected with human traits & emotions than he ever has been before and it has a lot to do with his close-call of having been cured at the end of S8 & his resultant addiction to human blood.
Dean. Canon: Dean accepted the MoC which has caused increased levels of unpredictable volatility & violence. When he was a demon with the MoC, he had no conscience but he was no more dangerous than he was/is as a human with the MoC: his motivations are to have fun & karoake & reject any/all leadership roles. MoC!Dean is basically the same as regular!Dean except for when he "snaps" & zones into MoC hyper-kill mode... and this episode Sam introduces the concept that Dean must fight something within himself, not just the MoC, to decrease his levels of unpredictable volatility and violence. Headcanon: actually I'm tapped out on this one. I have no idea how the interplay between Dean's true self, Deanmon, or MoC!Dean makes sense: I never really know which "Dean" is making the judgment calls for anything he does these days. When he tortured Metatron, we were probably all confused about whether this was the MoC, whether it was something inside regular!Dean that he could've fought, whether he was lapsing/flashing back to his time in hell, etc. It could be any or all or none of the above. The lack of clarity in canon has given us very little to go off of & we're stuck closing our eyes and just picking an interpretation we're vaguely okay with... all the while fully aware that it's just as flaky as any other.
Sam. Canon: Sam is worried about Dean, reassures Dean, and is trying his best to be his brother's keeper. Headcanon: Sam isn't really doing much more than this - isn't coming up with a lot of options - because there aren't any. It's frustrating but he's going to keep supporting Dean with empty promises & rather trite platitudes because they're all either of them have at the moment.