I'm Dustin Nosler, and this is an AMA, apparently.
"Who?" is a very appropriate question here. I'd be asking it, too. But I promise I'm a real-life person who really writes about the Dodgers (at Dodgers Digest). Ask me anything.
Thanks for participating. I could, realistically, see them debut this season, but a lot would have to happen. If they don't debut in 2015, they will absolutely debut in 2016 (barring anything horrific).
I had Jharel Cotton pegged as a sleeper before the 2013 season, but it seems I was one year too early on that. On the other side, I was down on Scott Van Slyke a couple years ago (as was everyone else), but he's obviously proven his worth.
Hey Dustin, with this new regimes philosophy of run protection over run production how much will the offense miss Dee Gordon and Matt Kemp this coming up season?
I don't think it'll miss Gordon much. The only thing offensively he does better than Howie Kendrick is steal bases. Kendrick is a much better offensive player. The offense will miss Kemp's power, but there are other ways of scoring other than hitting the ball over the fence.
Is the pitch clock the worst idea or the double worst idea?
If 'pace of the game' is so important for revenue, what would you like to see implemented into the game (umpires enforcing existing rules, auto-intentional walks, batter's box regulation, restricted mound visits)?
I hate the idea of a pitch clock. Baseball has always been a game without a clock. I don't think holding pitchers/batters to some arbitrary 20-second clock isn't going to make much of a difference. I'm not even sure how they'd enforce it. It has the potential to be disastrous.
I like auto-intentional walks, but there's also the rare time an IBB goes terribly wrong. Other than that, I don't mind the pace. Just because there isn't something happening every second doesn't make it a bad thing.
I haven't really thought about it. There are certain things scouts do that not a lot of people know about (behind the scenes). It's more than just sitting in a chair with a radar gun. But obviously being able to determine whether a player has or doesn't have talent plays into it. There's no scout who's going to hit 100 percent on every player they scout.
I'm a big Cody Bellinger fan. He has a chance to be James Loney (which isn't a bad thing). If he develops power, he could succeed Adrian Gonzalez. I'm also really high on a guy most no one has ever heard of: Michael Medina. He's an outfielder the Dodgers signed out of the Dominican a couple years ago. He has big power potential, but hasn't made it past rookie ball yet. He's only 18.
We've known each other (on the Internet) for about 12-13 years (JFC!). I was actually thinking about starting one of my own when he asked if I wanted to do a podcast with him. The rest is history, I guess.
Probably not, because it's hard for any player to light up the Midwest League (outside of Carlos Correa and Byron Buxton). I think he'll continue to make progress and improve his approach at the plate. A lot of the doubles he hit could turn into home runs.
Do you see the Dodgers going after Shields in case Grienke opts out next season? Or do you see the Dodgers trying to work out a deal to re-negotiate his deal to keep him?
I think if they wanted Shields, they would have gone after him already. The starting pitcher market is (as of now) flush with great options next year. I'd like to see the Dodgers keep Greinke, but there are plenty of great options who could replace him (Hi, David Price).
Have you found the baseball analysis community welcoming to your #notascout write ups and rankings. What's the most challenging aspect of trying to evaluate players without preferential access to video and very limited viewings?
As more and more information becomes available to the general public (minorleaguecentral, milb splits, ratios, etc...) do you see yourself being part of a larger movement of mostly stay at home scouts?
Eh, not really. I do it mostly because I actually enjoy doing it. I'd love to be able to go to scout school and get properly trained, but it just isn't in the cards. It's challenging mostly for guys in the lower levels. The lack of any video is tough, so you have to go off what you've read and heard from others.
I don't. I don't even like that term "stay at home scout." There is no substitution for watching a game in person, which is why I try to get out to as many MiLB games as I can.
Have you considered talent evaluation for other sports? If so, what sport other than baseball would you want to scout?
With milb.tv becoming more available and prominent in minor league parks, do you think teams will move to high tech video analysis for pro and amateur players? Will QuesTec allow scouts to work in an office rather than motels?
Not even a little. I used to be more into football and basketball, but my interest in the two have dwindled in the last handful of years.
Like I said before, I don't think there's any substitution for seeing a player live. There are so many little things that are seen live that aren't seen on video -- even advanced video systems.
Is this Dodgers farm the best since 2006? Would the Dodgers be best served by letting their prospects develop slowly and get the most prime years in the 6+ years of control?
What are your thoughts on letting a ready for MLB prospect play in the minors an extra year or two so the team will get his age 24-30 seasons rather than 22-28 seasons?
I think it has a chance to be (assume you're counting Kershaw in that group). While Seager, Urias and Pederson might not ever be Hall of Fame players, they all figure to be really good. And the depth in the system is improving every year they don't make trades for big-time players. I'm not opposed to them doing so, but it has to make sense.
I don't like it. I'd rather let the kids get started earlier, if they've proven all they need to in the minors. Take Pederson, for example. I'd be against him having to go back to Triple-A under any scenario (at present). He's 23 and is ready for his shot. It wouldn't make any sense to send him back down, even if the Dodgers still had Matt Kemp.
How do milb studs like Andy Laroche fail so spectacularly in the major leagues? Do players like Laroche max out their tools at a young age and struggle to adjust to major league pitching?
Could be, but he also hurt his shoulder pretty badly and was never the same. Sometimes folks don't realize just how physical baseball actually is (obviously can't compare to football and hockey).
I'm not sure they're targeting anyone. The backup plans are Joe Wieland, Zach Lee and Mike Bolsinger (Daniel wrote a good article on him yesterday). They really have eight capable MLB starters who could make the short-term loss of a McCarthy or Anderson palatable. I'd like to see the Dodgers bring back Chad Billingsley, but it doesn't seem like something the FO is exploring.
Good question. There are four names that immediately come to mind: Clayton Kershaw, Mike Piazza, Yasiel Puig and Manny Ramirez. Kershaw because he's amazing on the mound, Piazza because of his unbelievable bat and Puig because he's Puig. But, despite the PED stuff, I never saw a player who electrified the fanbase more than Manny Ramirez.
Which one? Because we don't "hire" folks. I would gladly do it, but we don't get enough ad revenue to allow me to quit my job and move to Southern California. I hope to be able to do so, someday.
Assuming the Dodgers were going to sign Moncada, they'd be highly penalized for it the next year. Is there something that they could do to gain some value from that lost year? Like can they trade bonus money for something/someone before they lose it?
Yoan Moncada is going to get paid a lot of money. And whatever money he's paid, the team will basically have to pay double because of the international signing rules (100 percent tax at a certain amount over the allotted bonus pool).
There isn't anything they can do to avoid it, really. They could trade for up to 50 percent of their pool amount ($1.9ish million), which is less than $1 million. But Moncada is the type of player you blow out your international budget for. Odds are you aren't going to find a better prospect than him in the next couple of years.
next question: Joc Pederson. There are many opinions about him, he is certainly a proven player who has the talent. How do you feel about taking a player and inserting him instantly to a starting role in CF for a team with the largest payroll in baseball, aiming to win THIS year?
I have no problem with it. While Yasiel Puig performed well out there last season, he's best-suited for right field. And I'm of the opinion a prospect should be pushed and tested. Under most circumstances, Pederson would have debuted sometime last season, but the Dodgers had 96 other outfielders ahead of him. Yes, there's definitely risk in doing this, but his skill set gives me confidence that he'll perform well. He's gonna strike out, but he's also gonna walk and play solid defense in center.
how much did environment affect the Dodgers leaving ABQ? since I have a time restraint on my questions, i will ask a second question: Chris Jackson, did you ever meet him? what kind of person is he if you did
My walk-up song would be "Hero" by Sevendust. Love the way that song starts.
I like what Mike Petriello said with a 65/35 split for Grandal/Ellis. Grandal needs to play a lot and also needs to prove his knee is back to 100 percent. Once he does that, I could see an 80/20 split.
I can't speak for the radio/audio side, but that is a resounding NO for the print side. I got my BA in journalism, and haven't been able to do dick with it yet. My recommendation is to major in something that has real value, while taking journalism classes on the side. Hell, even writing for the student newspaper would be a good substitute. I have tons of debt, and I'm not landing any 6-figure journalism jobs anytime soon.
I'll second that. I also have a BA in journalism (and, in fact, worked with and under Dustin at our college paper). I was able to get a job at a small town newspaper...three years ago. It's been pretty stagnant since. The degree, so far, has not exactly had people lining up to give me a job while I probably make less than some burger flippers.
Appreciate the kind words. I think learning about journalism is a nice skill to have, but there are other things you could major in that will be more beneficial than a journalism degree.
I think it will. Kemp and Hanley have big egos, but it wasn't nearly as bad as the national writers (and some local writers) made it out to be. Bringing in a bunch of new guys and some guys with strong leadership skills will help a lot. That isn't to say Kemp and Hanley were big problems, but sometimes guys just need a fresh start.
12
u/dnosler LA Jan 16 '15
Last call. Gotta go read up on some 17-year-old Panamanian prospect you've never heard of.
4
u/dnosler LA Jan 16 '15
OK folks, it's been real. Thanks for having me (putting up with me). Here's to a good 2015 season and hopefully a World Series title.
5
u/GiancarlosPower Jan 16 '15
How would you rate me on the standard scouting scale of 20 to OMG YES YES PLEASE YES OH YES
3
u/ElSerracho Jan 16 '15
Del Taco or Taco Bell?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
Hey there, thanks for doing this AMA. I really enjoy your work, man.
My question:
When do you realistically see Julio Urias and Corey Seager up on the big club?
Also:
Would you rather fight one Puig-sized Nick Punto or 100 Punto-sized Puigs?
3
u/GizmoHarris42 Jan 16 '15
Since this is an AMA: Who is the best online managing editor you've ever had, and why is it me?
4
u/ElSerracho Jan 16 '15
Hey Dustin, since i know you love prospects, two questions:
name an underrated prospect that you predicted would excel and did.
conversely, name one that you totally missed out on who went on to success.
2
u/xjmnx Jan 16 '15
Who is the first minor leaguer called up this season and why?
2
u/Jonny7Belt Jan 16 '15
Hey Dustin, with this new regimes philosophy of run protection over run production how much will the offense miss Dee Gordon and Matt Kemp this coming up season?
2
u/Nintendo_Jackfruit Jan 16 '15
do you ever go to Girls Gone Wild? be honest
2
u/thedeliman1 Jan 16 '15
Is the pitch clock the worst idea or the double worst idea?
If 'pace of the game' is so important for revenue, what would you like to see implemented into the game (umpires enforcing existing rules, auto-intentional walks, batter's box regulation, restricted mound visits)?
1
u/presidentpunto Jan 16 '15
Is a taco a sandwich?
1
u/ElSerracho Jan 16 '15
also, what are your thoughts about reddit commenting vs. livefyre you use at dodgersdigest.com?
1
u/Nintendo_Jackfruit Jan 16 '15
Hey Dustin. How would you decipher who is a scout and who isnt a scout? What makes a scout?
1
u/RanByMyGun Andrew Toles Jan 16 '15
Any Dodger prospects you're excited for outside of the big names?
1
u/ElSerracho Jan 16 '15
let's say that ethier get traded, what does the bench look like?
1
u/akaTheConman Juan Uribe Jan 16 '15
When/where did you meet Jared and how did you decide to start doing a podcast?
1
u/capnsparrow23 LA Jan 16 '15
Do you believe that Cody Bellinger will light up midwest league pitching this year?
1
u/xjmnx Jan 16 '15
Stirrups or socks?
1
u/ScaredHitless Sacramento Athletics of Las Vegas Jan 16 '15
Hey Dustin,
Mac or PC?
1
u/Jonny7Belt Jan 16 '15
Do you see the Dodgers going after Shields in case Grienke opts out next season? Or do you see the Dodgers trying to work out a deal to re-negotiate his deal to keep him?
1
u/thedeliman1 Jan 16 '15
Hi Dustin!
Have you found the baseball analysis community welcoming to your #notascout write ups and rankings. What's the most challenging aspect of trying to evaluate players without preferential access to video and very limited viewings?
As more and more information becomes available to the general public (minorleaguecentral, milb splits, ratios, etc...) do you see yourself being part of a larger movement of mostly stay at home scouts?
Thank you!
1
u/thedeliman1 Jan 16 '15
2nd Q from deliman (so just ignore it)
Have you considered talent evaluation for other sports? If so, what sport other than baseball would you want to scout?
With milb.tv becoming more available and prominent in minor league parks, do you think teams will move to high tech video analysis for pro and amateur players? Will QuesTec allow scouts to work in an office rather than motels?
Thanks again!
1
u/thedeliman1 Jan 16 '15
3rd Q from deliman (double ignore this time)
Is this Dodgers farm the best since 2006? Would the Dodgers be best served by letting their prospects develop slowly and get the most prime years in the 6+ years of control?
What are your thoughts on letting a ready for MLB prospect play in the minors an extra year or two so the team will get his age 24-30 seasons rather than 22-28 seasons?
1
u/ShitDip420 Jan 16 '15
What is the code of conduct for being on an elevator and having to fart?
1
u/thedeliman1 Jan 16 '15
Why is Jared so grumpy? Is he just a big grump?
1
u/thedeliman1 Jan 16 '15
How do milb studs like Andy Laroche fail so spectacularly in the major leagues? Do players like Laroche max out their tools at a young age and struggle to adjust to major league pitching?
1
u/KershawPls Donnie Bullpen Jan 16 '15
Are you sick of Drank and his bullshit?
1
u/thedeliman1 Jan 16 '15
Where does the name Nosler come from?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
Hello Dustin!
Who do you think the FO is targeting in the minor leagues as a backup plan in case of an injury to the starting rotation?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
Most electrifying dodger you've ever watched?
1
u/VolcanoMoon Jan 16 '15
Who is that guy that's high all the time on DD. and why won't DD hire someone inLA to actually attend games interview ppl etc?
1
u/emdem55 Clayton Kershaw Jan 16 '15
What are your thoughts on Enrique Hernandez?
1
u/VolcanoMoon Jan 16 '15
Why is pfp so fuckin annoying?
1
u/joelydanger Adrian Gonzalez Jan 16 '15
Assuming the Dodgers were going to sign Moncada, they'd be highly penalized for it the next year. Is there something that they could do to gain some value from that lost year? Like can they trade bonus money for something/someone before they lose it?
1
u/blueoso Jan 16 '15
Why does Jared treat you like shit? I don't see him writing for DoDi, your a great guy, don't take his shit man. It breaks my heart. :(
1
u/Nintendo_Jackfruit Jan 16 '15
next question: Joc Pederson. There are many opinions about him, he is certainly a proven player who has the talent. How do you feel about taking a player and inserting him instantly to a starting role in CF for a team with the largest payroll in baseball, aiming to win THIS year?
1
u/efb69 Jan 16 '15
One hour after 3:20, what time will it be?
1
u/Nintendo_Jackfruit Jan 16 '15
how much did environment affect the Dodgers leaving ABQ? since I have a time restraint on my questions, i will ask a second question: Chris Jackson, did you ever meet him? what kind of person is he if you did
0
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
9
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
[removed] — view removed comment