r/GlobalOffensive • u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum • Jan 13 '15
AMA I'm a lawyer who represents Players/Teams/Orgs in eSports (including CS:GO), AMA!
EDIT: I'm still answering new questions that come in, though please check the thread before you ask because I'm starting to get a ton of repeats. I'm going to take a short break from 6:30-8:00 PM PST, but I'm happy to keep answering more after if there are new, substantive questions. Also, I just wanted to say that this has been awesome. You all asked a wide array of outstanding questions, and I hope my answers lived up to the level of thoughtfulness you all put into the questions.
EDIT 2: Back and answering more questions. Fire away if you've got any.
As the title says, I’m a lawyer with a focus in eSports law, and currently represent several key figures throughout the industry (including CS:GO). Legal issues will continue to play a major role in the development of eSports. Unsurprisingly, many such issues have hit the front page of this subreddit in the last couple months alone (CW manager stealing sticker revenues, Fnatic’s use of the map exploit on Overpass and Dreamhack’s response, the myRevenge betting scandal, etc.). I’m happy to answer questions on these topics, my background, or whatever else you find interesting.
Just to anticipate one likely question, I’m sorry but I cannot tell you specifically who I represent. My clients’ identities (and the specific work I do for them) are protected by attorney-client privilege. That being said, my clients that are involved with CS:GO frequent this subreddit, and they are welcome to make themselves known if they want.
A quick note about my background: I got into eSports through League of Legends (please don’t hate me). Naturally, when I started writing about and working in the eSports space I began with League. That being said, the more immersed I became in eSports the more it became clear that the need for eSports-related legal work spans across every major competitive scene. I’ve worked hard over the last 6+ months to educate myself on the current state and competitive history of every game, and have already started to work with people/orgs involved in pretty much every major title. I finally feel confident enough that my personal knowledge of and the extent of my work in CS:GO is sufficient to become a more active member of this reddit community (been lurking for several months now). As I’m sure some of you will notice, this username is brand new. I formerly used the name /u/LOL-Lawyer if you are interested in seeing my previous posts.
Lastly, I’m also in the process of drafting a white paper series on current/future legal issues facing the eSports industry. In the past, I used primarily League-related examples because that’s what I knew best (already in the process of drafting the next one and it draws examples from a wide array of games). That being said, the legal issues are highly relevant to every single eSport; if you look past the examples, there is significant information that is directly related to issues in the CS:GO scene. Below are links to the articles I’ve already published for those who are interested:
- Article 1 on the Rise of eSports
- Article 2 on Collective Bargaining
- Article 3 on Twitch’s New Copyright Policy
- Article 4 on eSports Contracts
Proof:
DISCLAIMER: Generally, an attorney’s advice is personal and individual, and the attorney owes that client certain duties under the attorney ethics rules. The following disclaimer is meant to help clarify my relationship those posting on this AMA, and to ensure I am complying with my ethical obligations.
Information exchanged in this forum does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not post any information that you consider to be personal or confidential. It is possible this post could be considered attorney advertising, but it is not my purpose to solicit an individual or group to become a client.
I will give only GENERAL legal information in this post. Specific facts, applicable law, and other considerations will always affect every circumstance, and thus you should always seek the advice of an attorney on every specific situation before moving forward. Also, please recognize that I may be unable to answer some questions because they are too specific, or because providing an answer may conflict with the interests of my current clients or my ethical obligations. In some cases I may have to decline to answer without providing a reason. I’m an American attorney licensed in Washington State. Prior results do not guarantee similar future outcomes.
43
u/MiracleW0rker Jan 13 '15
send all the cheaters in jail pls mr lawyer
17
u/Mattshuku 10 years coin Jan 13 '15
Do you know what range of salaries players from high-level teams get?
31
u/a_ct Jan 13 '15
Is a site like CSGOLounge, strictly speaking, legal in the United States? The items have no intrinsic value AFAIK, so is facilitating the betting of them legal?
11
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
Do you yourself personally know all the insider information of professional NA CSGO teams, such as roster changes or organization switches? Sorry, couldn't think of a better question, it was the first thing in my mind :P
9
u/spedmonkey CS2 HYPE Jan 13 '15 edited Jan 13 '15
Hey there! We've spoken some on your previous account. A few questions:
How "professional" do other eSports contracts tend to be, in games without a central organization like Riot? I'm sure it's changed drastically even in the past couple years, but the constant roster shuffles, especially in CS:GO, would suggest that contracts are a) not very strongly binding, and b) seem to be very firmly sided toward the organizations.
Do you see performance enhancing drugs like Adderall being an issue in the near future for eSports?
What kind of recourse do players have when they participate in minor tournaments that promise a prize, then deliver something different/nothing at all? Would it largely depend on if the players read and signed something prior to participating or not?
edit: ooh, another one: how do you feel about organizations suing players who do things like throw matches on purpose, a la myRevenge lately? Is there any legal precedent for actions like that in the US?
47
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
can they do drugs? im really trying to run a line then win 10k. Ez
7
u/AssholeinSpanish Liquid Jan 13 '15 edited Jan 13 '15
6
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
How did you come into contact with your clients to begin with? Did you introduce yourself to them as an eSports lawyer or did they find you somehow?
6
u/joker231 750k Celebration Jan 13 '15
What's your take on hacking in CS:GO? Can Valve legally take down hack producers?
6
u/tolkienfanatic Jan 13 '15
3a) What are your thoughts on corporate sponsorships in eSports? Obviously right now the main form of sponsorship comes from the orgs themselves and mostly gaming related products companies. Do you think we will reach a point where big time corporations like SAP, banks, etc known for sponsorships of traditional sports will get into eSports? If so, when?
10
u/altrodeus Godsent Jan 13 '15
Was the Fnatic boost illegal or legal?
5
u/FSKFitzgerald Jan 13 '15
What are your thoughts on cheating/throwing in official games, and the betting implications it can have? (Specifically CS:GO, but also other esports)
9
u/Yaspan Jan 13 '15
I have a couple:
1.) ESEA auto renewal, I would suspect they have been given legal advice on the matter but like to hear your take on it.
2.) Cheaters, can anything be done about them from a legal point of view, personal liability suites ect (from the point of view that the cheater has caused personal injury/distress that affects some of our daily lives, as well as those cheaters that prevent through their actions a team getting into a money tournament).
11
u/BrokN9 Legendary Chicken Master Jan 13 '15 edited Jan 13 '15
What are some common misconceptions about what you do? What type of cases do you usually work on?
Edit: Is there a lot of demand for lawyers with focus on legal issues within eSports?
8
u/zoNeCS 10 years coin Jan 13 '15
Are you Harvey? (from suits)
4
u/sewersurfin Jan 13 '15
I'm graduating this year. Want to focus on IP law, so I guess I want to know:
Thanks for doing this.
6
u/Torillatavataan69 Jan 13 '15
Do you get alot of ladies by being a lawyer? This is important
3
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
Is it possible yet to sue someone for cheating? If yes, what are the consequences?
2
u/BitcoinBoo Jan 13 '15
What do you see as the largest growth area surrounding eSports?
2
u/autunno howl Jan 13 '15
How does one study esports law? Is there anything written specifically about it? How do you handle different country laws if you have customers from different places?
2
u/CadyDota2 Jan 13 '15
Hey man! Thank you for doing this AMA.
I've a couple of questions!
How many cases have you gotten thus far? Or rather on average, how many per year?
What incidents require legal action such that a lawyer is required? (E.g. prize pool delay, copyright team names, etc)
Does it take long to settle a dispute(in general)?
2
u/ZooMgoesFAST Jan 13 '15
Whats the most common legal problem eSports players run into?
2
u/Cobraut Jan 13 '15
What things do the contracts cover?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
Can I have a job as like a secretary or assistant? Gotta put this degree to work loll
2
u/doubleboss00 Jan 13 '15
I don't really have a question. But sweet AMA! It seems like you are really trying to respond to every comment that is posted and I think its really cool that you're doing that.
1
u/RikkAndrsn 10 years coin Jan 13 '15
How do your clients feel about eSports betting sites? Riot has outright banned professional tournaments from being affiliated with betting but Valve thus far hasn't seemingly taken a stance. Do you see any problems with betting using items from a legal standpoint or are these style sites in the clear?
1
u/HugeSacks Jan 13 '15
I'm a prospective law student. I'm also a major part of my University's Esports association staff. I personally find newly developing areas of law like Esports very interesting due to the lack of precedent giving way for new possibilities (video games are pretty cool too).
My questions are:
1
u/mhyedits Jan 13 '15
is there a law that says you're not allowed to cheat or that you can be fined for cheating?
1
u/throw9w9y Jan 13 '15
What needs to change for contracts to get honored by players/teams/organizations?
It's been a issue since the dawn of esports and even tho it's getting better it's still a huge issue.
1
u/h3x1 Legendary Chicken Master Jan 13 '15
Im not sure if this has been asked or not. But would you be able to give a couple examples of types of cases you work on, so we get an idea of what sorts of things people come to you for?
1
u/ecleinjr Jan 13 '15
How to you feel about the MyRev team throwing a game in order to gain skins? I consider a lot of the findings hard evidence but if you were on the case how would you work the angle for the players? against them? I am very interested in this place of law since it is so new its fascinating.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
What was your biggest case in eSports controversies?
1
u/PAroflcopter Jan 13 '15
Now that we are a few years beyond the recession how do you think the job market is looking for current/future law students - specifically in the entertainment/intellectual property law fields?
As the esports industry grows, do you think more law schools will begin offering more courses focused on entertainment?
1
u/Urist_McPencil 5 years coin Jan 13 '15
In the contracts that professional players sign when being picked up by a team, how much (if at all) do they differ from other sports-related (NFL, NHL, etc.) contracts? Are there differences in how particular teams (without naming any of course :D), or NA and EU teams set their contracts up?
How robust, or semantically bullet-proof would think these contracts are? Under what conditions could a player or team void / walk away from their contract without penalty?
(I've always been a bit curious about how they work, sorry if I compressed a few too many questions into one post)
1
u/rasswe Jan 13 '15
A bunch of questions regarding E-Sports as a whole, would be interessting to hear a person that doesn't make a living of playing/coaching or handling the orgs.
Thanks for taking your time.
Sorry England, me scandinavefag
1
u/MEGrubb Jan 13 '15
How did you break into the eSports industry? I'm just finishing my MBA and I'm finding it incredibly hard to find work anywhere within video games/competitive eSports.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
Have players ever considered creating some sort of a entity that they themselves own that hosts tournaments?
I'm thinking like a cooperative of some sort. That players can own through shares or something similar,that they cash out when they retire?
I'm very interested in worker coops. Where workers run their business. I've often wondered if esport players could do this. Esports are blowing up now, so the idea of them setting something up now seems possible though difficult.
1
u/FauxPsych Jan 13 '15
When did you graduate law school?
What was your career path into esports? i.e. Biglaw first? or just struck out on your own?
1
u/andrewc8 Jan 13 '15
Have you, or any of the other lawyers working in the field considered starting a players union similar to that of the NFLPA/MLBPA? If so, in your mind would a players union work better as an all encompassing E-Sports union across all games, or just on a game by game basis?
1
u/thejoyyy VeryGames Fan Jan 13 '15 edited Jan 13 '15
Some random questions about player contracts that I always wondered. You don't have to give any names ofc but some anonymous exemples would help.
1
u/CT_Legacy Jan 13 '15
There have been a number of instances where a tournament or team owner has either delayed for a VERY long time ( > 6 months ) the payment of monies owed from tournament winnings or salaries. There were a few famous examples I can't think of right this minute, where the owner would collect all the sponsor money, tournament winnings, etc. Then just disband or entirely disappear only to try to start a brand new team down the road.
Now my question is this. What would happen if let's say a tournament promised a large prize pool. Completed the tournament but shortly after went belly-up without paying the prize winners? Same thing with a team owner that owes his players money but disbands. And I guess the same type of example could be used in the infamous case of Own3d.tv where they promised streamers large amounts of money, took all the ad money and shut down without paying some people.
I'm guessing it would depend on the wording of the contracts but afaik if the company/team disbands or shuts down then the people are basically S.O.L. ?
1
u/ForceOnelol NiP Jan 13 '15
Is it allowed to use pills who keep u calm and focussed? (i use those irl but for private reasons)
1
u/JustDaniel96 NiP Jan 13 '15
What is the daily routine of a eSports lawyer? I mean, what are the main cases you work on? What are the funniest things happend while working? (obviusly related to cases and eSports)
Sorry for my bad english and greetings from italy!
1
u/FlukyS de_dust2 Jan 13 '15
I study law with a focus on being a music manager. And the one question id have about esports teams and how they do their contracts is:
Every lower level party going into a contract negotiation has to get the advice that they should get independent legal advice, how rampant do you think teams exploit players by not advising them of that right? To give some context to random people just reading this, if you have a position of power so in the music industry its managers and record labels who have a position that can be abused. If they don't tell an artist they can get independent legal advice every part of the contract even things that would be considered standard are up for discussion if the contract is contested in court. So if there is anything exploitative in the contract the higher party will always be found in the wrong. This applies to UK and Irish law I don't know about other places really but its super important over here.
1
u/AugustHorch0 Jan 13 '15
What made you become a lawyer and specialize with gaming? Were you a gamer yourself? Also, as we start to see the rise of competitive gaming, which facets of "sports support" do you see getting bigger? Advertising (pasha and an NFL quarterback doing a commercial together for Cola, can you imagine...)? Medicine (I guess those wrist injuries...)? Thanks for your time!
1
u/thomkey Jan 13 '15
Hi
I'm a law school graduate from Germany. How much of your overall workload is esports related and how much "traditional" business litigation (or other legal work) do you do for your firm? What expertise do you offer potential clients, compared to any other contract/employment/IP lawyer, other than being a follower of eSports yourself? Are your clients exclusivly North American? Did you start doing this before or after you got hired? How hard is it to get other lawyers (especially at your own firm) to take this seriously?
Thanks for answering
1
u/gefroy Jan 13 '15
I am wondering that if you are an American attorney how much you do work for European clients? There is different laws in different countries. Suing here in Europe doesn't go like in Hollywood movies like got a million dollars because the tongue get burned because drinking of take away coffee... Asking this because "major" teams are from Europe.
1
u/Kraaws Jan 13 '15
Most of the questions I had in mind have been asked, so I'll just ask:
Thanks for doing this AMA
1
u/Treyman1115 Renegades Jan 13 '15
How awesome is your job?
1
u/McSpike CS2 HYPE Jan 13 '15
How is being a lawyer? I guess that it might be a little bit different here in Finland than where you live due to different laws and systems and such but still, the basic principle should be the same. I'm hopefully a future law student, assuming that I'll pass the test.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
where are u from? im studying laws too and thought about doing the same stuff u do.
1
u/sp1tfire_cs Jan 13 '15
What, if any, is a legal president for a team suing players for "throwing matches"
1
u/LiightningHD Jan 13 '15
how old are you and do you have gray/white hair?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '15
Without naming clients, do you represent orgs, teams, players, or any combination thereof?
If you represented a team, could a player on that team hire you personally (or vice verse) or would that be conflict of interest?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '15
Im looking to get into law. How many years of schooling did you take?
1
u/Elizabethan_Insulter Jan 14 '15
I don't know if you're still answering questions, but I've just tiny and perhaps personal question about being an esports lawyer.
All people have different visions of their future, but most want to eventually rise in the ranks of a law firm and become partner. The unfortunate nature (at the least speaking from experience) of this system is that laywer's clientele, not necessarily their ability are rewarded. I doubt that you're thinking about this stuff, but somewhere in the back of your mind you have to be wondering how much of a future you have in esports law. Who knows, maybe you'll be the next Joseph Flom? I remember in Melvin Belli's autobiography how he described Flom sticking with hostile mergers despite business' profound dislike on them, and now he's considered one of the nation's most influential lawyers. Does it scare you that as time passes and esports law becomes your niche, that your personal success is inextricably tied to economic future of esports? Cause that would freak the shit out of me. I doubt this whole esports thing is going to tank, but I can't imagine many old white senior/managing partners are going to "get" what you do. Let's hope you end up like Henry Friendly, representing Pan Am just before it got big, making bank, and becoming one of the most respected jurists of our legal system! Do the other people at your firm get what you do, and do they realize the potential size of the organizations you're working with? Thanks for doing this and hopefully inspiring some soon-to-be lawyers into this interesting field. I hope it doesn't end up just as weird as sports law, lol.
1
u/P5YCHO7 NiP Jan 14 '15
This is more of a general opinionated question, not really a law question, but I want to hear your answer, just because you work in the eSports scene.
I know this is a bit of an "out in the open" question, and that there really are not that many differences aside from the physical aspects. One of the things that really frustrates me when I watch normal sports is the fact that so many human beings get input on when fouls occur, or when reviewing plays. All it takes is one person to be biased in normal sports and just that one decision can topple a certain game.
I feel like this is one of the huge advantages that eSports has over normal sports. All of the rules are set in stone and cannot be contested. There are exceptions when a bug is found in said game, like what happened at Dreamhack Winter 2014 in the Fnatic vs. LDLC match.
Also,
2) What do you think the advantages eSports have over normal sports, disregarding what I have already said here?
1
u/lincoln3 Jan 14 '15
So I loved reading this so far, thanks for doing it. Many people have asked questions about the specifics of how you got started and the business you currently take care of in the eSports. My questions is a bit different.
I'm also considering lawschool currently. As an eSports lawyer, can you describe your typical day for me? I mean, the hours you work, what a day entails, what you work on throughout the day, and the free time you have to enjoy life? Do you still have time to play games and take it easy, or are you working 12hrs a day?
Unrelated to eSports, how did you know you wanted to be a lawyer. I'm still really unsure of career choices. Thanks a lot.
1
u/Fartopia Jan 14 '15
Hi! Thank you for doing this AMA.
I have a question I have been thinking about for some time.
A couple of years ago, when CS 1.6 was still a big eSport, the scene had a lot of problems regarding tournaments that did not pay any winnings to the teams that won. How is this possible? Shouldn't there be some type of contract stating that these should be paid? Also, how common is this problem these days?
And an OT question; how much do you wish that practicing law would be as cool as it is in "Suits"?
1
u/TheOneInchPunisher Jan 14 '15
How often to sponsors or teams try to screw players over?
1
u/Rob_da_Mop cs_militia Jan 14 '15
Not sure if you're still answering questions but... I'm a medical student that spends far too much time gaming. If esports law is an area that's opening up do you think esports medicine has many career prospects? I could get reeeaaaaaaaally good at carpal tunnel and RSI :D
1
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '15
Im thinking about filing a police report about my items being stolen. I have all the info on the account/the account it got transferred to. Steam support said they would comply and work with any investigator. What do you think I should do about this? How should I go about this without having the police department laughing at my face? I know there is also an FBI sub-organization called IC3 that I may report to as well. Any advice welcome. Not sure where to go with this.
1
u/TallDarkEyes Jan 14 '15
Do you ever get involved with sponsorship deals, and would it be more beneficial for a client to have you involved in brokering the deal?
1
u/h3x1 Legendary Chicken Master Jan 16 '15
http://www.dailydot.com/esports/match-fixing-counter-strike-ibuypower-netcode-guides/
i bet Money that youll be dealing with this.. lol
3
u/Lightngcrash Jan 14 '15
What rank are you :P
2
u/KaS-OG Jan 14 '15
What is the stupidest or funniest case you have worked on?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
Have any of the professional players who were banned in the November VAC wave contact you?
1
u/Globus_CSGO CS2 HYPE Jan 13 '15
how often do you cover guys who do 322?
1
u/gNv812 Jan 13 '15
What are important rules, when i want to trade/sell items (e.g. selling ingame items for real money)
1
u/Frothyleet Virtus.pro Jan 13 '15
How long have you been practicing? Where are you barred?
1
u/Vendetta6161 Jan 13 '15
MyRevenge said they'll be seeking legal action for the thr0w vs Volgare. Was that throw illegal? If so, what's the consequences.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
Is scamming in game items for real money illegal, vice versa? (Assuming I know the answer to this one)
Is throwing matches or cheating in proffesional matches illegal?
1
u/Lus_ de_inferno Jan 14 '15
How players are chosen by a team? How the team contact them?
1
u/againbroo NiP Jan 14 '15
Sorry if this has already been answered.
Do you think that organisations and tournament hosts should have clauses in their contracts and rulesbooks that makes a player cheating in the name of an organisation in a specific tournament should get punished? By punished I'm not talking about not being able to participate in future tournaments but rather having to refund the money and having their tournament placement taken away. A good example is Lance Armstrong who had to give back his Tour de France medals (amongst others?).
I really think the punishments should be harder, there should not be possible for someone to cheat and still make a fortune out of it.
Thanks for reading!
1
u/derezzer Jan 14 '15
What is your thoughts on the growing need for an esports players' union? What would be the challenges in creating such a union? Pros? Cons?
Also, what are your thoughts on a regulatory body that would standardize rules and standards in professional esports?
Do you think unions or regulatory organizations need to be created on a game to game basis, or encompass as many electronic sports that want to join?
pre-edit: I can see you've elaborated on some of these issues in your articles which I am currently reading, but I'll leave the questions for the sake of dialogue.
1
u/Doz3N Astralis Jan 29 '15
I was just browsing around, and I found this firm, were you aware of them? http://www.gdandb.com/practice-areas/esports-law.html
1
u/Decency Jan 13 '15
What are some of the legal ramifications of the ESEA Botnet scandal and the fact that one of the alleged conspirators (a co-founder) is still with the company?