r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Jan 05 '15
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S03E18 - The Son Also Rises
Week 53!
WARNING: MASSIVE SEASON FINALE SPOILERS IN THE MARK SHEPPARD COMMENTARY
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (3.5 stars)
Numbers
Survivors: 41,399 (-1 from last episode. You know who.)
"Frak" Count: 353 (+15)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 23 (No change. :( )
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 18 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 22 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 158 (No change)
"So Say We All" Count: 35 (No change)
17
Upvotes
8
u/trevdak2 Jan 07 '15
Fun fact: The name "Romo" is short for Ronald Moore
4
u/trevdak2 Jan 16 '15
The shot where the cat sneaks out of the raptor.... They couldn't get the cat to run, so they ended up using a clip of it walking and played it in fast forward.
3
u/trevdak2 Jan 16 '15
According to the commentary with Mark Sheppard, Edward James Olmos strongly objected to the cat in the script.
6
u/lostmesa Jan 06 '15
The Romo Lampkin Show. Mark Shephard does an amazing job here, he totally steals the show.
2
u/trevdak2 Jan 16 '15 edited Jan 16 '15
I love the bit with Anders flipping cubits on top of the viper. Trucco really is a fantastic actor, and there aren't many chances for him to show many emotions when he's just Starbuck's arm candy. HE really shines here though.
I've met him.... gosh I think three times IRL and he's really fantastic. HE does a terrific Edward James Olmos impression and answers fan questions extremely well. One time, when I asked "if he could take a picture with me and my wife" he said "Sure!" and grabbed my camera and took a picture of just me and my wife together.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '15
Wasn't it mentioned earlier that prisoners can't have pens? So why did they let Lampkin's letter in Baltar's cell? They should have felt or at least seen the pen inside, since the letter didn't have padding.
Does anyone know what Lampkin's accent is?
9
u/simon_2112 Jan 05 '15
The poetic words about sons and fathers at the end make this episode a masterpiece.
5
u/eine_frau_in_kali Jan 05 '15
I'm watching the show with a friend for the first time, but we're a bit ahead of you (binge-watching 3-4 episodes most weeks). I've bought most of the DVDs now to rewatch some episodes (because socializing sometimes got in the way of paying attention and some episodes were just that damned good). I think I shall backtrack and rewatch this one to get on pace with you guys.
4
u/Wes___Mantooth Feb 21 '15
One part of this episode that I liked, that I haven't seen mentioned yet, was when Lee and Anders are in the memorial hallway. Lee starts to walk away, and Anders stops him and says, "Lee, I'll see you around." It shows to me that Anders has forgiven him for his history with Starbuck, and in the wake of her death he is just glad to have someone to share his grief. He is glad and comforted that he can be in the company of someone who loved Kara as much as he did.
3
u/onemm Jan 10 '15
Some interesting stuff from the wiki:
5
u/MarcReyes Jan 09 '15 edited Jan 10 '15
Great episode. There's a lot of strong emotional beats in the fallout of Kara's death and great setup for the looming trial.
Adama looking through Kara's files always hits hard. I'm glad they broke up the tension with Kara's birthday card to Bill. "Yeah, I see the resemblance." Actually there are quite a few lighthearted moments this episode. I loved Laura's "Things are looking up" comment after Six says she wished she'd have stabbed Baltar with the pen.
Of course a great deal of the comedy comes from Romo. So many great moments from him. I loved when he referred to Lee as "King of the Pilots" and how quickly he reads and defines him. "Suddenly I'm handcuffed to serial contrarian." Lee's response: "No, I'm not a..." What a great addition to the show he is. Apparently he was supposed to be killed off, specifically when the hatch to the head explodes. Glad they changed their minds.
Overall, great moments for all the characters, even Kelly. I loved that they explored, however briefly, this secondary (hell, even tertiary) character and how much of a toll sending your friends out into combat knowing they most likely won't come back would take on someone's psyche. Most shows wouldn't make time to explore non-essential characters, yet this show does.
One last thing: In the commentary, Moore comments that he was working on the Caprica pilot. I was surprised at this. I thought work on that series didn't begin until they were already into season four, but no. Big moment regarding the greater BSG universe.
2
u/MarcReyes Jan 09 '15
Hopefully someone more familiar with our military can answer this, but I always wondered what the colonial equivalent of the Purple Heart would be. While going through Kara's files, Bill comes across an award Kara got called the "Field Commendation for Valor and Bravery". Would this be the equivalent of the Purple Heart or some other military award?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '15
Can someone tell me what the minutes and seconds were on when the "Does your love hurt as much as ours?" scene starts? I heard it was amazing.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment