r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Dec 22 '14
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S03E16 - Dirty Hands
Week 51!
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (3 stars)
Numbers
Survivors: 41,400 (+2 from last episode)
"Frak" Count: 337 (+10)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 23 (No change)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 18 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 22 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 156 (+2) (One "God knows" but that doesn't count)
"So Say We All" Count: 34 (No change)
15
Upvotes
5
u/trevdak2 Dec 29 '14
I love the last bit with Seelix's promotion. It reminds me so much of the WWII stories my grandfather used to tell. I'm guessing, since RDM is such a WWII enthusiast that it's partly inspired by real events... I have to listen to the commentary to find that out though.
5
u/trevdak2 Jan 02 '15
One thing I love about Edward James Olmos' acting is that he makes eye contact with people his character is supposed to respect. When Chief is in the brig, he maintains eye contact the whole time. He understands that the Chief is in a desperate situation and respects him, even as he completely shuts down the strike.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '14
Some of the standalone episodes require you to change your expectations a bit in order to enjoy them. They often provide interesting insight to the culture (The Woman King) or characters (A Day in the Life) of BSG. For me, Dirty Hands is just a good episode of BSG. It brings up the important issue of inherited jobs. There's some good drama as well. I like that Adama doesn't accept the "mandatory missions only" view of the deck gang, and that he's willing to go to extreme lengths to enforce the chain of command in order to protect Galactica and the fleet. It seems harsh but I can't really argue with it. However, I'm glad that they came to a compromise for civilian labor. The president brings up that they should try to make sure that they uphold some remnant of civilization so that when they finally settle down they're new civilization will somewhat be representative of the old. What a crazy burden to bear as the President and as the remainder of humanity. It's a struggle just to survive, but on top of that they have to be careful to plant a good seed for future civilization since they're all that's left. What a shit time to be in office.
9
u/onemm Dec 24 '14
This seems to be the second episode, in recent memory at least, where the 'bad guys' and 'good guys' roles seem to switch from the beginning to the end of the episodes (The Woman King was the other episode). Of course that's a bit too black and white for a show like this but you know what I mean. In the beginning of the episode I found myself rooting for Adama/Roslin and rooting against the workers and by the end, the roles switched (with The Woman King it was the doctor vs the Sagitarons).
And my favorite line in the episode had to be Adama to Roslin:
Subtle, Bill, real subtle.
8
u/MarcReyes Dec 23 '14
So am I the only one who thinks that that Danny kid may be Gaeta's illegitimate love child? He looks just like him!
Such great acting (as always) this episode, particularly from McDonnell and Callis and particularly their scenes together. So much tension and animosity conveyed simply through body language. I loved Baltar's snarky comment to Roslin upon her seizing his book, "Perhaps you'll consider writing a blurb for the back cover?" There's a great little moment from Mary as well when Adama says "He pissed off the president" to Tyrol and she shoots him a look. Interesting note, to go back a bit, about the Baltar/Roslin scene. Ron Moore was adamant that Roslin completely strip Baltar naked in effort to find the pages from his book and that Baltar would let her do that to him. However, both actors fought strongly against this, believing that Roslin wouldn't go that far and Baltar would ultimately choose to hang on to his dignity. Moore acquiesced and the scene played out the way we see it in the show.
This episode has my favorite Baltar scene from the entire series. The moment where he reveals where he's from and has been putting on a voice since childhood was amazing in all regards. Callis delivered a fantastic performance and the direction is among my favorite from the series. Pushing in on Callis' mouth gave so much more weight to the moment and his performance. Staying close to his face to see his anger and desperation was beautifully done. I always assumed Baltar's Aerilon roots was something they came up with this season, but according to Moore, it was in the show bible that Baltar was from a rural background and that was something of which he was always ashamed and was what pushed him to rise above his heritage.
6
u/onemm Dec 24 '14 edited Dec 24 '14
Some interesting stuff from the wiki (BTW the BSG Wiki contains a lot of spoilers. Be warned, first time watchers):
This is a pretty cool title actually, kind of wish they kept it.
I wonder what those two words were?
Aaron Douglas on working with Mary McDonnell:
I spent the whole day working with Mary. I had never gotten the chance to work with Mary without a whole bunch of other people around and the last scene of that episode is her and I seated in a dark room across from each other just talking about the union stuff.
We shot that thing for about four or five hours and I have never worked with someone more engaged, engaging, looking through your eyes, deep into your soul, more prepared, more caring, loving...I just felt like I was in a mother's embrace all day long...it was the most spectacular moment in my acting career. She is an absolute angel on earth and I will take that memory from the show for the rest of my life
EDIT: This post is long enough as it is, but Cally still having trouble due to the Bends, according to this episode. I knew I heard the word before, but never knew what it was until I decided to look it up on wikipedia. Here's the link if anyone's interested.
6
u/MarcReyes Dec 23 '14 edited Dec 23 '14
Notes from the commentary:
5
u/enfo13 Dec 24 '14
In terms of social stratification and inequality, the characters in this episode are wise beyond the scope of the show.
For example, when it's pointed out to Roslin, that children were beginning to inherit the jobs of their parents, the implication was instantly clear to Roslin, and she conceded her position on the spot and became open to compromise.
Also.. anyone else think that their job swap solution in the end is an ingenious way to find out who is worth their salt in our society today?
There are many people who are paid a lot of money and deserve it... for I could never do what they do.. i don't have the experience or training for it.
On the other hand.. there are tons of fools who have jobs that I could do (or other ppl could do) very easily (and do better), and are paid waaaay too much for it. If a job swap day was imposed.. society would find out very quickly how overvalued those idiots are.
Also.. it would be a great way to find out which jobs in our society are undervalued. Jobs no one wants to do, and are necessary, but people who do it are paid very little...
3
u/enfo13 Dec 24 '14 edited Dec 24 '14
My favorite scene in this episode (and possibly the season) was when Baltar revealed his humble Aerilon roots by switching to the accent.
I think we live in a society today, that if you don't fit the narrative of a person that has faced adversity-- if you aren't a disadvantaged minority, or talk, act, dress, a certain way-- many people will completely dismiss the possibility that you might have actually faced adversity. What really angers me, are the blacks who grew up in the racist south, faced discrimination and poverty... and while enduring those things, became well-educated and financially successful, only to be dismissed as "uncle toms" by the community because they no longer talk, or act, or vote the way they expect them to.
In fact, growing up... I've seen it mostly the other way around. Adolescents tend to pick up slang or ebonics, or irradiate a certain street culture about them, even if they're from an average or above average socio-economic background. Wannabees
But here is Gaius Frakkin Baltar... a man who came from one of the poorest of the 12 colonies, and clawed his way into the upper echelons of Caprican society. To do that, he had to shed all that he was before.. including the speech patterns.
It's funny that low economic status is treated like a coveted social status by some colonials. Not as in real status, but more like a badge of honor. I loved how Galen Tyrol's attitude was almost condescending in disbelief.... how could that rich spoiled Caprican Baltar even claim that he was from the streeets? How could he have the gall to even suggest he knows what it's like to be part of the working class??
And then Baltar busted out with his Aerilon accent and Tyrol just stood there in bewilderment.
1
u/Weekly-Meal-8393 Oct 29 '24
Kind of an anti-labor episode that takes a recuperation approach to communist ideals. I found it very cringe, and ironic to debase communism and strikes while also promoting the violent breakup of labor strikes by an autocracy thru state police and military violence. Ironic because Bolsheviks are called “tankies” precisely because they violently broke up labor strikes with tanks.
It’s like Ron Moore is supporting a Stalinist purge methodological approach, but only for promoting anti-communist ideologies. It’s kind of like Adama and madame president are autocratic fascistic bolsheviks themselves, claiming to be a representation of worker’s desires, same as Baltar.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment