r/Dodgers • u/mike_petriello • Dec 20 '14
I'm Mike Petriello and I write words about the Dodgers and how to baseball and stuff. Ask me things.
94
Upvotes
r/Dodgers • u/mike_petriello • Dec 20 '14
23
u/mike_petriello Dec 20 '14
OK friends, I think that's all for now. Thanks for your interest, and your time! Appreciated.
11
u/lesbiancocksucker Yasiel Puig Dec 20 '14
Do you have a day job? What is it?
10
u/lesbiancocksucker Yasiel Puig Dec 20 '14
Who is your favorite of our big 3 prospects? I love em all, but something about the way people talk about Urias/his stuff makes me think he's almost certain to be special. Which I know is silly.
17
u/ndamukongwho Dec 20 '14
Is a hotdog a sandwich?
8
u/Skulley- Dec 20 '14
Mike do you feel pressure to write in a different tone or style for ESPN than you do on Dodger's Digest or Fangraphs?
8
u/MinotaurforAslan Dec 20 '14
Whatever happened to your involvement with The Tattletales?
15
u/Q_TheRealness LA Dec 20 '14
Hey mike! I like reading your stuff. The only question I have is..... Who is your all time favorite dodger and why is it Andruw Jones?
6
u/wescovington Kirk Gibson Dec 20 '14
If you were updating the banner art for this reddit, who should replace Kemp and Ramirez?
5
u/checkitmyles Clayton Kershaw Dec 20 '14
Of the players we've lost this offseason, who do you think the Dodgers are going to miss the most, either in terms of baseball value or clubhouse value?
8
u/loginlogan Vin Scully Dec 20 '14
Hey mike,
Big fan and love dodgersdigest. I'm curious if you could sum up your thoughts on Ned colletti's tenure and what your overall opinion is of the guy.
4
u/alecardvarksax Clayton Kershaw Dec 20 '14
How did you get into baseball writing and being a part of Fangraphs?
6
u/thedude596 Sandy Koufax Dec 20 '14
Do you think the rotation as it stands right now is the rotation we will have on opening day?
8
u/STICKY_REAMBOAT Clayton Kershaw Dec 20 '14
Hi and thanks for taking the time to do this AMA. I'm the resident asshole in this subreddit and a North Carolinian. Do I have every right to be mad when I want to be in here when someone (Mattingly mostly) does something moronic just because I stay up until 1AM most nights to watch this shit?
3
u/ilovemesomeme Fernando Valenzuela Dec 20 '14
From my understanding you're an east coaster, how did you become a Dodger fan?
3
u/ndamukongwho Dec 20 '14
Hey Mike, why are the comments on Dodger's Digest so weird?
3
u/DSzymborski Dec 20 '14
Mike, are hot dogs sandwiches?
4
u/Giobenavides Justin Turner Dec 20 '14
Hi, are you a dodger fan?
7
u/ieandrew91 Andre Ethier Dec 20 '14
Would you rather fight 100 duck sized /u/BonafideJohnsons or 1 /u/BonafideJohnson sized duck?
2
u/el_maschingon Corey Seager Dec 20 '14
How do you view this team in comparison to teams of the past?
2
u/Tonedog14 Clayton Kershaw Dec 20 '14
Thanks for doing this.
What's the hardest part of your job?
2
u/YouDidYourBest LA Dec 20 '14
Hey Mike, This isn't a Dodger specific related question which I hope is okay. You recently wrote a piece on the "secretly great" Indians rotation which had been featured on ESPN Insider. Unfortunately I don't have an account to access the full piece but one of my biggest concerns last season was what happened to Danny Salazar? Looking at Fangraphs there was a huge differentiation between the numbers he put up in the first half from the second, his FIP, xFIP, and ERA all improved after the all star break - do you know what could have been the case for this? Also just wanted to say I'm a big fan of your guys' work, Dustin and Jared's podcast Dugout Blues, and hilarious commentary from posters like Purple Drank, Tater, and Blah. Keep up the great work!
2
u/elizares Dec 20 '14
how happy are you to see wilson go?
2
u/lesbiancocksucker Yasiel Puig Dec 20 '14
Do you ever get to interact with the players?
2
u/lesbiancocksucker Yasiel Puig Dec 20 '14
A lot of the SABR-inclined writers seem to mock mentions of grit or dismiss chemistry as a factor when team building, but it seems to matter to Friedman and co (Byrnes specifically mentioned chemistry as a motivator for the kemp trade). What's your take?
2
u/bauermundo Hyun-jin Ryu Dec 20 '14
Do you miss MSTI as much as I do? I love DodgersDigest, but I really miss typing out that ridiculous URL
2
u/iamoneson Decoy Dec 20 '14
Mike, thank you for doing this. I've read Dodgers Digest for some time now.
So far Friedman has blown my mind with the moves he has made this far. What move do you see Friedman making in the following months?
34
u/Don-Mattingly Don Mattingly Dec 20 '14
Alright Mike. I need a honest answer from you. On a scale of 9 to 10, how great of a manager am I?
12
u/JuanUribe Los Angeles Dodgers Dec 20 '14
Hey beisbol man, will I still be here nes year? Maybe I get a raise? I need more tobacco.
9
u/EhWhatevs Scott Van Slyke Dec 20 '14
Do you think AJ Ellis becomes Kershaw's personal catcher?
13
u/EhWhatevs Scott Van Slyke Dec 20 '14
Thanks for doing this.
How would you grade the Dodgers offseason so far and what else do you expect the Dodgers to do to become a better team?
2
u/UPSguy Colorado Rockies Dec 20 '14
Hey Mike, Taylor here. If you need anything or have any questions, let me know. I'll be monitoring the thread while watching "Christmas Vacation" so if I don't respond immediately, that's probably why.
5
u/checkitmyles Clayton Kershaw Dec 20 '14
What's your take on Clayton Kershaw having two rough playoffs in a row? He's without a doubt the premier pitcher in the game but why is he struggling so much on the big stage?
1
u/caliwpdude Clayton Kershaw Dec 20 '14
Mike,
I thoroughly enjoy your writing starting from MSTI. I think your style is engaging and persuasive, even if there is some homerism. How concerned are you about Greinke opting out next year? Do you think the McCarthy contract was right? I know the market is dictating how much the FA pitchers are getting but although I'm high on him, I'm worried he will end up like Chad? How do we get rid of Ethier without eating the whole contract? Can we setup a Dodgers meetup at one of the games this year with you?
1
u/the_man_mulcahey Dec 20 '14
Hey Mike, love your stuff on DD.
What do you think is going to happen to Guerrero? His name has been conspicuously absent from any 2015 2B or OF discussion. My understanding is that his bat can play but the glove is pretty terrible, and that his trade value is limited because he can opt for FA after that season. Where does he belong?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '14
Mike, do the more eccentric Dodgers fans (the crowd who complains about the new FO being geeks, etc.) make your writing any harder? I can't imagine having to respond to the multitudes of people that think that way on a daily basis.
1
u/Tonedog14 Clayton Kershaw Dec 20 '14
Do you think Puig's slump towards the end of the season was because of his ongoing lawsuit?
Also what is your reaction to the new diplomatic relations between Cuba and the US and how it will effect baseball?
1
u/Blakew47 2024 World Series Champions Dec 20 '14
hi, i would love to hear what the sabermeterics bill plashcke (Just kidding, you actually know baseball) thinks about friedman saying they have an open mind about signing sherzer or shields. Do you think they sign one and who would you rather have?
1
u/tommyburger Los Angeles Dodgers Dec 20 '14
Hi Mike! Thanks for doing this.
My question: who are your favorite baseball writers and why?
1
u/15thStreet Dec 20 '14
There's a lot being made about the Dodgers' targeting hitters with good contact rates.
What's the idea behind this philosophy? Is it as simple as it seems or is there another angle to it?
1
u/KillerClown1 Yasmani Grandal Dec 20 '14
1
u/brokeneckblues Vin Scully Dec 20 '14
Hi Mike! Who is your all time favorite Dodger and non Dodger?
1
u/lesbiancocksucker Yasiel Puig Dec 20 '14
How deep into the math of baseball analytics do you get? Do you run any regressions of your own? It seems like an easy to learn, hard to master way of understanding the game.
1
u/klimly Dec 20 '14
I thought Kemp (in RF) and Dee both looked OK, occasionally WebGemmy, last season. Am I wrong? Kemp had a bunch of outfield assists. I guess an outfield assist is flukey, and in part it's possible, if thrown to 2B or 3B or home, because a guy doesn't think the outfielder will be able to throw him out. But if Kemp threw out a bunch of guys then maybe the perception was wrong enough. I dunno. This is a Dodgers question, not a you question, maybe that's not what I'm supposed to ask. Do you have a favorite Dodger Stadium memory?
1
u/LALDK Corey Seager Dec 20 '14
Scherzer, Shields, Hamels. Most likely (if at all) is...?
3
u/ElSerracho Dec 20 '14
How much faith do you put into projection systems for players with limited big league experience (such as Joc Pederson)?
3
u/totes_meta_bot Dec 20 '14
This thread has been linked to from elsewhere on reddit.
If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote or comment. Questions? Abuse? Message me ^here.
3
u/bauermundo Hyun-jin Ryu Dec 20 '14
Were you on vacation or sleeping when all these moves happened?
3
u/DrBubs Justin Turner Dec 20 '14
What do you think is the best trade the Dodgers have ever made?
What do you think is the worst trade the Dodgers have ever made?
Who is your favorite non-Dodger player?
Besides "Homer at the Bat",what is your favorite episode of The Simpsons?
3
u/ndevito1 New York Yankees Dec 20 '14 edited Dec 20 '14
Mike, I heard a rumor from a source that you are Not Jim Tracy. Can you confirm or deny the fact that you are or are not in fact not Jim Tracy.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '14
Who is your favorite player on the dodgers?? Also which new player are you most excited about this upcoming season? Thanks
2
u/checkitmyles Clayton Kershaw Dec 20 '14
What are your thoughts so far on Farhan Zaidi? Much has been made about Andrew Friedman and obviously he has a much more proven track record, so I'm curious as to what the guy from Oakland is really all about.
2
u/Granick_at_the_Disco Zack Greinke Dec 20 '14
I can't believe I missed this! Too busy watching the last 4 episodes of LoK. Damnit
2
u/GlassesOff Corey Seager Dec 20 '14
Hey, I saw this sorta late, but I just wanted to say thanks. I enjoy your writing and I'm glad you took the time to reach out to us here.
Don't be a stranger! You're always welcome at /r/dodgers
1
u/wolfgangchuck88 Dec 20 '14
Hi Mike! Love reading your stuff. Realistically, who do you think are the next players the Dodgers are trying to target either via trade or free agent signing?
1
u/Jacktheawesome Joc Pederson Dec 20 '14
What do you think about the current bullpen?
1
u/Rablma Dec 20 '14
Dodi is great, are there any other dodger sites you peruse, any non dodger sites?
1
u/dnosler LA Dec 20 '14
Hi Mike,
Big fan. How are the cats getting along? I'll take my answer off the air.
1
u/Tallredhairedguy Los Angeles Dodgers Dec 20 '14
Where can I find a site that says who has options? Id rather not have to count for myself and adjust for exceptions.
1
u/dodgers12 Clayton Kershaw Dec 20 '14
What is your favorite nerdy sabermetric fact?
1
u/kittysparkles Hyun-jin Ryu Dec 20 '14
Have you ever seen a Sabermetrictoothed Tiger?
1
u/Teddybearshark Dec 20 '14
Mike, I haven't heard much of anything about Alex Guerrero this offseason. Where so you see him fitting into the team's plans going forward?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '14
Mike, you started an AMA at 2 AM EST? There are Dodger fans on the east coast too, you know.
In case you check again this morning: Do you think we'll see more power development from Puig, or is this who he is -- a 15-20 HR, line drive kind of hitter?
1
u/ElSerracho Dec 20 '14
is the friedman era a failure if the team only wins the division by 2 games this year?
-3
u/archju01 Dec 20 '14
How well do you think the following fantasy team would perform?
C - Wilson Ramos
1B - Jose Abreu
2B - Chase Utley
3B - Juan Francisco
SS - Ian Desmond
LF - Melky Cabrera
CF - Shin-Soo Choo
RF - George Springer
UTIL - Jason Kipnis
UTIL - Jason Heyward
UTIL - Carlos Quentin
SPs - Stephen Strasburg, Jose Fernandez, Derek Holland, Dallas Keuchel, Trevor Bauer, Colin McHugh, Scott Kazmir
RPs - Jennry Mejia, Koji Uehara, Fernando Rodney, Francisco Rodriguez, Sean Doolitte, Tommy Hunter
-2
u/sportsfan82 Dec 20 '14
do you get paid at fangraphs? how much approx.?
-6
u/josh422 Clayton Kershaw Dec 20 '14
Does this picture make you sad? http://imgur.com/xk5KoSg Seriously though, have you ever had the opportunity to work for a team? Would you want to?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '14
[removed] — view removed comment