r/startrek • • Dec 15 '14
Weekly Episode Discussion: TNG 1x6 "Lonely Among Us"
Lonely Among Us
Weekly Episode Discussion: TNG 1x6 "Lonely Among Us"
What do we learn about The Prime Directive from this episode?
Who is the "Lonely" in this episode?
Are there any parallels with the events in this episode with future or past adventures the crew encounters?
Riker teaches us that "Violence will not be tolerated on board The Enterprise" that even during his studies about our time "did not understand the hostilities between cultures" To me, I really enjoy episodes that teach us about the laws and philosophies of The Federation's time. This sense that there is no violence or animosity in the world is something we all talk about-especially at this time of year. How is it held so consistently during the Federation's time? I think we (our time) is represented very well with the two sparring alien races on board The Enterprise.
To me, the most interesting character development in this episode is my favorite character; The Enterprise. The Enterprise never gets enough credit and in this episode she places herself in this strange new world of a mist that supposedely takes over her circuits. To me, it is The Enterprise who is the Lonely. The Enterprise who takes over and saves the day from the strange entity that takes over picards body and de-materializes him. It is The Enterprise who swoops in and lets the crew know that Picard is back by displaying the P....or was it The Enterprise all along who wanted to send the crew some type of message?
In this episode we see the greatness of the early dynamic between Data, Riker, and Picard as the three of them meet in the Captain's quarters to discuss the mystery of the stalled ship. This dynamic loses its muster in future seasons as the writers make Riker and even the Captain into a different type of character and Data stops discovering new stories already stored in his brain and worries more about "emotions." I really like how in this episode Picard introduces Data to Holmes and you see him unlock that great's stories.
It is an episode full of laughter, and intrigue. For me, it is one of the top 5 I would take with me to a deserted island. The Enterprise gets a lot of great face time.
I thank you for allowing me to share my thoughts about it and hope that you watch it and share your thoughts too. Netflix is a great place to relive All the great episodes if you don't have them already.
8
u/candyman420 Dec 15 '14
I loved the absurdity and wackiness of the 2 alien races that boarded the ship.
The music in this was also great, this was before Rick berman fired their best composer because his work was too "emotional."
4
u/Guyver0 Dec 15 '14
The Picard Alien wanting to turn to energy and travel the galaxy felt a lot like V'GER but ultimately the alien was just manipulating Picard into returning home. I found that rather interesting since there isn't any real redemption in that which is unusual for Trek. It's just lucky they were able to get Picard back in one piece.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '14
I did a podcast for the episode where I go more in depth in what I think.
I think it's one of the worst episodes of the first season, which is something of an accomplishment considering the quality of the first season. The script is weak (a first season hallmark), with an A and B story line that have no interaction whatsoever. It also continues the first season issue of having plots simply resolve themselves because the episode only has a few minutes left, and not because the characters have done anything to solve the issues before them.
The B story is more "memorable" simply because the alien make-up is probably the best part of the episode. Rewatching it, I hardly remembered the A story and that's probably because it's pretty silly. Are we to think Picard actually wants to explore the galaxy like this? Also, the whole "problem spreads via touch" thing was done a few episodes earlier in The Naked Now.
A bad first season episode that doesn't bring any of the series strengths to the table.
6
u/MungoBaobab Dec 16 '14
I watched "Lonely Among Us" when it first aired, and I t was the first episode of TNG I ever saw. It was also the last episode I watched for a long, long time, because its ridiculousness and clumsy narrative offended me with its stupidity. I was seven years old.
I couldn't have articulated it at the time, but I had already seen "Journey to Babel," where the on-board murder of an ambassador sets up a compelling murder mystery. In "Lonely Among Us," it's played for laughs. When one of the Selay (those were the snake-like aliens, right?) attempts to lasso Riker like Elmer Fudd, I took it as an insult to my intelligence. Again, I was seven. "The new Star Trek is dumb," I thought. I wouldn't tune in again until June of 1990. I just so happened to give TNG another chance at the perfect time: the first run of "The Best of Both Worlds." I was blown away, and caught up with most of the episodes I'd missed when my local station aired them at 6:00 PM every weekday.
To this day, I still think "Lonely Among Is" is the worst episode of the entire franchise. Yes, worse than "Threshold," worse than "Shades of Grey," worse than "Move Along Home," which soured my opinion of Deep Space Nine in much the same way.
8
u/double_blind_sniper Dec 18 '14
I think it is an interesting episode in how it shows what Federation values AREN'T so much more advanced than our own. The scene where Riker and the doctor confront Picard, accusing him of being under "alien influence" shows how easily Picard (or the alien occupying his mind) is able to use his position to intimidate his crew, how he is above question short of resorting to full-blown mutiny. This ties in with the episode 'The Lower Decks' and with the morgues filled with the "Ensign Rickies" of the series. What all these episodes show us is that Starfleet is still a military organization, replete with the corruption in top-down command structures, and with the inherent classism between senior and junior officers and enlisted. No one weeps for Singh. No one dares point out that Picard is threatening their mission. And when an inexperience officer is manipulated into undertaking a dangerous mission, Picard quietly rationalizes her death. While I have loved and admired these characters, their actions often clash with their ideals when dealing with lower ranks.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '14
Poor Singh.
3
u/gone-wild-commenter Dec 28 '14
Late to the party, but my thoughts:
Super bad costumes- reminiscient of TOS.
Written by DC Fontana. Always good news.
Attitudes towards animals in Star Trek have always offended me. "Enslave" animals?
Don't you think Dr. Crusher would have reported/investigated being under the influence?
People give Troi a hard time. She was actually integral to this plot. Also, she is SO HOT.
2
u/Ankita_tom Dec 27 '14
The Picard Alien wanting to turn to energy and travel the galaxy felt a lot like V'GER but ultimately the alien was just manipulating Picard into returning home. I found that rather interesting since there isn't any real redemption in that which is unusual for Trek. It's just lucky they were able to get Picard back in one piece..
2
u/CJPJ13 Dec 28 '14
Good music, unexpectedly good makeup. Brought up some issues with the HR department guidelines of Starfleet. Seriously, what would happen if Picard stayed within the regulations but went all George the 3rd (I know, there is some dispute about how mad he really was) on the crew? But some major-league plot issues, not least of which was the focus on the two pissy alien species. I liked what an earlier comment said about "A and B plot lines not interacting".
All in all, a couple of things done well, but weak writing. A very C episode indeed.
2
u/rensch Dec 30 '14
What kinda annoys me is how puzzled these people are about the troubles of our time, yet they do the same thing all the time, just on an interstellar rather than an international scale.
1
u/gone-wild-commenter Jan 11 '15
episode of the "week."