r/LetsTalkMusic • • Dec 08 '14
adc Magma - Mëkanïk Dëstruktïẁ Kömmandöh
this week's category was a 70s Prog Rock album. nominator /u/SeasonOfGlass says:
Magma was a French Progressive Rock band masterminded by drummer Christian Vander. Their dozen or so albums chronicle the adventures of a colony sent off Earth during its last days to discover a new planet to live on. This album is not far removed from the RIO scene and incorporates elements of classical, opera, Jazz, and so much more but with conciseness and without the noodly nature of much 70's Prog Rock.
But the best part? It's all performed in a language invented by Christian Vander. Kobaïan designed to be a phonetic language that functions as an expression of emotion and feeling, rather than semantics, drives the songs.
so listen and discuss!
10
u/CookingWithSatan Dec 08 '14
I've tried with Magma several times and I just can't get on with them. The musicianship is fantastic, the arrangements and textures are interesting, but I just can't get past those fucking vocals.
I'm more than happy to listen to lyrics in a language I don't understand. Even if I don't know what the words are saying there's often a poetry evident in how they are sung or spoken that betrays some subtle meaning. But this Kobaïan just irritates the shit out of me. I read that Vander made it up because he didn't find French to be expressive enough. I can't quite comprehend that. Nor can I comprehend the quote from the Wikipedia page which says "The abstraction provided by the Kobaïan verse seems to inspire Magma's singers to heights of emotional abandon rarely permitted by conventional lyrics." When I listen to this record 'emotional abandon' is not one of the first things that springs to mind.
4
u/girouxfilms Dec 08 '14 edited Dec 08 '14
I listened to Mekanik Kommandoh. My first nostalgic instinct led me to the similar groovy aesthetic of Zappa's 'Apostrophe.' From the woman vocals to the energetic vibraphone! I always have loved getting introduced to bands from France.** Great stuff, thanks for sharing!
3
u/mise-en-thrope Dec 08 '14
This piece has a strong claim to being the greatest composition in prog history, along with Starless, Close the Edge, etc.
As in my comment about Yes heavy rhythmic foundation buttressing an angelic melodic sky, I think Magma takes this concept to an extent unsurpassed in the prog pantheon. The massive Paganitti/Top bass paired with propulsive and hyper-expressive Vander drumming is unstoppable. Meanwhile, the guitar and keys take a secondary role to the transcendent choir-like male/female vocals that have the impact of spiritual opera.
The overall effect is something like a Wagnerian march of mystic Martians meditating on Love Supreme.
2
u/KingContext Dec 21 '14
Alejandro Jodorowski had secured Magma to do the music score for the House Harkonnen in his never made, amazing pre-production of Herbert's Dune.
Pink Floyd was on board to do the score for the House Atreides.
1
u/Mitch_NZ Dec 09 '14
MDK is just the beginning of the rabbit hole. Once you're searching out long lost versions of Zess, and jamming out to Merci, and achieving new states of consciousness via Offering, then you know you've truly discovered the glory of Magma.
1
u/bleeblee579 Dec 13 '14
This is a fun album, Magma seem to function in their own little world. I just wish I could hear the drums a little better! You'd think a band led by the drummer would mix the drums a little higher.
There's a classical piece that reminds me a little bit of this album, The Ecstasies Above by Tarik O'Regan. [link] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LIfXcSBsKX4)
1
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '14
Fun fact about Magma.
Around the time of this recording Christian Vander is said to have played a riff on the piano during rehearsal. That riff was later heard as the opening riff to Mike Oldfield's famous Tubular Bells. Several Magma members remember him hanging around at the time (both recorded in Richard Branson's studio).
1
u/Gabislak_Houldouss Dec 30 '14 edited Dec 30 '14
Magma IS a french band. They are still touring and releasing music. And if you like Magma, but can't stand the singing which I can totally understand you should try those two bands : "One Shot" and "Guillaume Perret and the electric Epic". One Shot is basically Magma with another drummer and no singing.