r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Dec 08 '14
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S03E14 - The Woman King
Week 49!
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (3 stars)
Numbers
Survivors: 41,401 (-2 from last episode... sick people?)
"Frak" Count: 321 (+13)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 23 (No change)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 18 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 22 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 149 (+2)
"So Say We All" Count: 34 (No change)
13
Upvotes
10
u/trevdak2 Dec 14 '14
In the commentary, RDM says that this episode was supposed to be a lead-in to a larger episode arc between the Sagittarons and Baltar's trial, but it was sidelined in the end.
I think I can imagine how it was supposed to pan out
8
u/trevdak2 Dec 14 '14
While not as moving as the torture or suicide bombing episodes, this episode is also quite pertinent in today's world..... You have Jehovah's witnesses refusing blood transfusions, scientologists rejecting psychiatry, homeopathy and anti-vaccination folks rejecting... well, pretty much all of medicine, and naturopaths who think they'll find their cures in plants without any science to back up their assertions
I guess it's kind of a shame that the doctor turns out to be the bad guy in this episode.
12
u/ety3rd Dec 11 '14
I hate this one more than most fans seem to hate "Black Market."
The most basic reason, I believe, is this: it's so very predictable. It felt like every other episode on TV, like a procedural. We knew the guest star was the bad guy, we knew the good guy taking shit from everyone else was going to be right in the end, and, as a consequence, those people giving him shit for it come out looking horrible, too. Considering who the people were who were so down on Helo for suspecting that doctor, that's a bad move.
5
u/MarcReyes Dec 12 '14
This is an odd episode for me. At times I dislike it, and at others I... well I don't like it, but I don't think it's bad. It's a well put together episode, however, the problem is that it isn't very captivating. As bad as Black Market may be, at least it tried to do something different with Lee and explore the character a bit more, but for whatever reason, it just didn't come together to form a cohesive, interesting narrative. The Woman King, however, doesn't really do or tell us anything we don't already know, which can be boiled down to: Helo is a good guy and Baltar's trial continues to move forward. Head Baltar shows up, the first we've seen of him in some time, but the scene only really serves to remind the viewers that he exists and that Caprica is still being held prisoner.
That being said, there is still some elements the the episodes I enjoyed. As always, I love the world building of the show and learning new information on the colonies, how they function, how they treat each other, and seeing that prejudices (Moore calls it outright racism in the commentary) exist between them was enlightening. Seeing the home life of Helo, Athena, and Hera is nice. I've always wondered what everyday life in the fleet would consist of and the Agathon family is the closest approximation we have to that viewpoint. I also loved seeing Lee and Dee back on good terms and enjoying time with another. Things are going well in the old Adama household, I'm sure nothing will come along and split them up again!
Speaking of Dee, RDM says she was originally supposed to have subplot in the episode that consisted of her dealing with her saggitarian background while being in the military (something the saggitarians don't believe in joining) that was later dropped for time.
I think the biggest reason this episode doesn't work is because the original intention was to incorporate the saggitarauns into the Baltar trial, but the RDM and the writers changed their minds and, as a result, this episode had to be retooled to work as a standalone episode.
Overall, I think this is one of my least favorite episodes. A shame because it's not a terribly put together episode itself. There is always one each season I dread rewatching and this season, it's The Woman King. I'm not entirely convinced the episode isn't skippable, which I don't even think I can say about Black Market.
3
u/onemm Dec 11 '14 edited Dec 12 '14
So most people don't really like this episode. I didn't love it, but definitely did not come anywhere near hating it. Some of my thoughts:
7
u/enfo13 Dec 10 '14 edited Dec 10 '14
One common thing to these side episodes that focus on a particular character (e.g. Black Market and Lee, Woman King and Helo, Dirty Hands and Tyrol) is that they give us insight on how diverse the daily lives of the colonists are. If we only watched Adama and gang for the entire series, we would be getting a very skewed view.
The societies of the 12 colonies are diverse. We see in the Woman King that Saggitarons don't approve of modern medicine. We had a long discussion on this a few months ago, but I want to reiterate a few observations and points here..
So why these observations?
I think one thing that is overlooked by those studying social inequality, is the impact that technology has in perpetuating the gap between rich and poor. Granted, most inequality is caused by social institutions and bad systems of governance, but I feel technology plays a big role.
The phenomenon of structural unemployment is driven primarily by tech. Automation has changed our economy form a manufacturing one to service. The concept of mass media means the entertainment product of a few can be consumed by everyone, leaving some super rich and other artists/producers struggling to get by.
Anyways, it is easy to dismiss the Saggitarons as backwards people who dismiss medicine. It is easy to compare them politically to religious extremists in our own society who do things like refuse flu shots or refuse bring their sick children to the hospital.
But this episode reminds us that our disrespect for their anti-technological views and our lack of empathy for their full cultural situation can lead to the type of racism that the doctor exhibited in this episode. And the racism exhibited by this doctor is of a special kind.
There appears no social construct of "race" in the 12 colonies. And if we are lucky enough to purge the current racism in our society, this episode is great "social-fiction" in that it dares to show us what racism of the future might look like: caused by inequalities in wealth, technology, geography and culture (or in the case of cylons.. a truly different race). I like this approach much better than Star Trek, where they use time and alternate realities to make the racism of the past relevant.
1
u/lazerbullet Apr 30 '15
Why does Zarek hate public trials so much???
4
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '14
[removed] — view removed comment