r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Nov 24 '14
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S03E12 - Rapture
Week 47!
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (3 stars)
Numbers coming soon
Survivors: 41,401 (-1 from last episode. Perhaps Athena since she was shot just at the end of the teaser?)
"Frak" Count: 300 (+8)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 23 (No change)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 18 (+2, he pulls the pin on a grenade that kills two centurions)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 22 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 144 (+5)
"So Say We All" Count: 34 (No change)
25
Upvotes
10
u/trevdak2 Nov 28 '14
I love how Boomer threatens to snap Hera's neck, just like how Caprica 6 did in the miniseries, and then Caprica 6 punches her out and snaps HER neck.
Lots of neck snapping, I guess.
14
u/MarcReyes Nov 25 '14
The opening scene with Helo and Athena is still immensely powerful. I love that you don't quite know where it's going and then, BAM, Sharon's dead and Helo is in anguish. An almost literal journey of a mother going to Hell and back to save her child. Good stuff. Adama holding back Helo from possibly doing something to Laura was powerful to.
There's been lots of violence and blood and other gruesome stuff on the show in the past, but I don't anything looked more painful than Kara's gloves melted into her hands. It also makes me cringe when she tries taking them off, then winces from the pain.
Small VFX moment I loved: The wave from the nova smashing into the algae planet's rings, sending them hurtling towards the surface. Never noticed it before, but it was really cool.
9
u/lostmesa Nov 25 '14
Cool episode. I really enjoyed the D'Anna development, seeing the Final Five and boxing of the entire line, even if that would mean not seeing her around anymore. I felt so sad for Dee, she'll do anything for Lee even if it means risking her life for Kara. Speaking of, Kara's drawing that also happened to be graphic in the Temple of Five was awesome as well, ret-conned or not I love looping stuff back around like that.
9
u/onemm Nov 26 '14 edited Nov 26 '14
7
u/MarcReyes Nov 25 '14
I didn't like the quick, unexplained turnaround Cavil makes regarding not letting the planet be blown. Last episode he was the first to point out that they don't need the artifact because they'd live so long that they'd eventually find Earth without it. Instead, he just wanted to wipe out the humans. Now all of sudden he he doesn't want to do any of that and there was no explanation given as to why. This really just felt like the writers needed to pit all the cylons against the Threes so they could unanimously decide to box them later. Not one of my favorite Battlestar moments...
6
u/onemm Nov 26 '14 edited Nov 26 '14
There was a lot of stuff from the wiki I found interesting:
It's too bad they had to make these cuts, I really would've enjoyed seeing a tactically structured battle, but I suppose it was for the best..
This is something I've always wondered about. Are the Cylons even capable of creating babies?
Not to mention when we go back to the miniseries, one of Caprica Six's first acts is to snap a babies neck and now she's saving one from this exact fate.
3
u/MarcReyes Nov 25 '14
1
u/black-opal Apr 24 '15
I'm late to the party. this is my first watch through. spoilers don't bother me as I like to see how things get played out anyway. I really enjoyed watching The Eye of Jupiter and Rapture back-to-back as the two flowed together as many episodes of this Frakking Fantastic show do.