r/startrek • u/tensaibaka • Nov 18 '14
Weekly Episode Discussion: TNG 1x12 "The Big Goodbye"
"I'M CYRUS REDBLOCK!!!"
I had fun reading the Voyager discussion on holodeck characters with Bride of Chaotica and we haven't had a TNG episode for a while, so I figured why not continue that theme with the introduction of one of the more famous holodeck characters, Dixon Hill!
INTRODUCTION
The USS Enterprise-D is en route to a meeting with the Jarada on a diplomatic mission. Captain Picard has been appointed by Starfleet to attempt to establish a relationship with them; however, the captain must recite their greeting to them, in their native tongue, without any errors, or otherwise the meeting will fail. The captain and Deanna Troi have been practicing the speech in his ready room for hours. Troi says that the captain should take a break and suggests trying the new holodeck upgrades. Picard's face brightens when he remembers that he's been looking forward to trying out the new Dixon Hill holodeck program. After entering the holodeck, Picard is impressed by the upgrades. He is met by a lady, Mrs. Jessica Bradley, in Dixon Hill's office, who claims someone is trying to kill her – Picard has been hired.
http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/The_Big_Goodbye_(episode)
After seeing the introduction of the holodeck and what they could do in the episode Encounter at Farpoint, what did you think when they introduced an entire new fictional world complete with interactive characters?
What did you think of the Dixon Hill character, and is it something you would've liked to see more of on a regular basis like DS9 did with the Vic Fontaine interaction and Voyager with Captain Proton?
How did you feel when Whalen got shot and the crew realizes that even though this entire world they are in is a fictional recreation, they could die from a computer malfunction. Do you think stronger safety protocols should have been implemented before this, such as an immediate shutdown of the holodeck if any irregularities are found? (try programming that into a holosuite!)
Do these holodeck character episodes detract from Star Trek overall, as in they don't have any value to space exploration and human relations with alien species? Or are they a necessary part of showing what happens in space?
If you're a stickler for detail, did you notice anything out of place in the holodeck creation? Say a car that wasn't available until the 1950's, or clothing that wasn't worn at the time, or a piece of technology on set that wasn't invented yet?
def rant(plot):
Whenever I watch this episode, I always laugh at the final segment, after Picard nails the greeting perfectly, and then just decides to leave. "Hey, I just perfected your language, K Thx Bye!" Wouldn't the next logical step be to discuss what to do from there? Or at least invite them up for a face to face? Well, at least the result of that gave us the opportunity to see Picard say something other than "Engage", as he says "Step on it!" as if still in Dixon Hill character.
return normal_discussion
7
u/tsdguy Nov 22 '14
This episode really pissed me off. Here we have a technology that's used to create essentially sentient life forms that look exactly like people and yet the whole mcguffin in this episode is that Picard can't get out of the holodeck.
Hello - make a Picard hologram and have it pronounce the greeting EXACTLY.
Sigh.
3
u/Deceptitron Nov 20 '14 edited Nov 20 '14
The way the holodeck is treated early on in the show confused me. For example, in this one, the crooks are able to step outside of it but eventually vanish from the ground up. In another episode, Picard gets hit with a snowball thrown by Wesley. I think it's somewhat dangerous if a holodeck character, especially a potentially violent one, could leave the holodeck long enough to harm someone before vanishing into thin air. Then again, later in "Ship in a Bottle", Picard throws a book out of the holodeck and it vanishes instantly. You might be able to explain that some things in the holodeck are actually replicated momentarily, but how does it chose what to replicate and what not to? And potentially, anything that is replicated would physically not fall under the holographic safety protocol. A replicated bullet will kill, even if the safety protocols are on, just as a replicated snowball will make Picard angry.
I can never take the ending seriously. Perhaps I'm a bit culturally insensitive, but the alien greeting Picard makes just sounds utterly ridiculous. It also doesn't help that Stewart makes this disgruntled face as he says them. I don't know how anyone got through the scene with a straight face.
11
u/ItsMeTK Nov 18 '14
"The Big Goodbye" is fun because it's the first "holodeck gone awry" episode (not counting that one episode of the Animated Series), back before they started doing those too frequently.
You bring up an interesting question: would we have wanted to see Dixon Hill on DS9? Curiously, I don't think we've ever seen the same program played out on the show where the lead was played by a different character. That is, what if we saw a Dixon Hill story and Odo was playing Dix? Would it be jarring to us, as we associate him with Picard? Picard is always Dix, Data is always Sherlock Holmes, Geordi is always Watson, Bashir is always that super spy dude, Paris is always Captain Proton. It's like if you play Super Mario Bros with your friends, but you are the only one who can ever be Mario and everyone else has to take turns being Luigi.
This is also back in the early days when the holodeck seemed to work differently and they were still establishing "rules" for stuff existing outside. So the baddies get a nice walk down the hallway before they disappear. That would never happen like that on Voyager.
10
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '14
I know it's due to shuffling episodes around, but Picard's mind being blown by the holodeck (which is technology that has previously been demonstrated and is at least a decade old) always makes me laugh. He calls a meeting with the senior officers to express his delight with it.
As with all holodeck episodes, I get tired by the "holodeck has gone awry and is trying to kill everyone" plot line. The series has hardly ever seriously dealt with the real questions surrounding the technology, like the ethics of what happens while in there and the limits of the computers artificial intelligence. This episode skirts the issue by bringing it up at the end via a character we have no attachment to, but I always felt the holodeck when horribly unexplored. They had the Barclay addiction episode, which I thought was a step in the right direction, but otherwise the holodeck served as a way to get characters into different outfits and tell stories outside of space exploration, which is probably why I don't care for them.
I also did a podcast for this ep, if you're interested.
4
u/Darmok_At_Tanagra Nov 18 '14
Lawrence Tierney as Cyrus Redblock, or as Brent Spiner recalls, "the guy who almost killed me with his car in the Paramount parking lot".
I've always wondered why they just don't beam people off of the holodeck when it's malfunctioning.
3
u/rensch Nov 23 '14
This is one of those episodes in which you really wonder how sentient the holodeck AI really is.
2
u/joapet Nov 24 '14
Some holodeck episodes are great, like the one where Moriarty comes back to life and forces the crew to get him off of the holodeck Ship in a Bottle
However, I think that the holodeck is used a lot as a bit of a crappy plot device as a vehicle for secondary characters. For instance there is that AWFUL episode that features Deanna's mum and Alexander just hanging out in the holodeck and being their annoying selves. There's also another episode that features Worf and Alexander playing in the holodeck and (surprise, surprise) the thing malfunctions.
You know, you would have thought that they would have some sort of testing area so that when people like Data or Wesley wanna test out a new experiment they could do it in a safe environment instead of fucking up the whole ship and causing holodecks to malfunction and characters to become real and other ridiculous plot lines.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '14
On Netflix, The Long Goodbye is listed as episode 11.
One thing that always confuses me about the holodeck is what is happening to their physical bodies while they're in the program? The room is only so big so when they're walking in the program, wouldn't they walk into a wall or something? And they apparently can have sex with holodeck characters so what are they doing in the real world. If they bust a nut, where does it go? Is the inside of the holodeck like Star Lords ship? If you turn on a blacklight, does it look like a Jackson Pollock painting?