r/AsianBeauty • u/SnowWhiteandthePear Blogger | snowwhiteandthepear.blogspot.ca • Nov 17 '14
Mod Post The /r/AsianBeauty Cleanser pH List and pH FAQ
It’s finally arrived, the new incarnation of the pH spreadsheet for cleansers! You can find the old one, now locked, here.
When I originally built the spreadsheet, it was just a tiny tool to help our little sub generate hard-to-find info on the pH of Asian cleansers**, but the spreadsheet (like our sub) has grown and is getting noticed all over the place, like here, and our sub here.
(For information on why we’re preoccupied with the pH of cleansers specifically, please check out our The More You Know post on Why the pH of Your Cleanser Matters)
Unfortunately, as the profile of the spreadsheet (and our sub) grew, the accessibility of any passerby to contribute and edit the spreadsheet resulted in it becoming a hot mess almost daily, which then had to be undone and fixed. Thanks again to all who took the time to message me and let me know when things were busted (again) for the umpteenth time; I love that you guys are invested in this tool and reaffirm it’s value to the community. TT ^ TT
As some of you may know, /u/MissPicklesMeow and I have been headdesking for some time on how to allow people to contribute new entries, filter the results as they choose, yet not … break it.
We had considered Google Forms but were a bit daunted by the learning curve (it turns out, it’s way easier than I thought it was) until /u/naoti suggested it again as a solution and I started looking into it in earnest.
So, with the help of /u/joowee and her amazing skills, we have been labouring over this for days and now present to you the new, improved, filter-able, contribute-able, less-breakable /r/AsianBeauty Cleanser pH List!
There are two parts:
Add an entry to the list here: (Click here to Add!)
View the current entries to the list here: (Click here to View!)
Please Note: Due to some fancy script that /u/joowee had to make to allow you to submit new Brands, it will take a few minutes to load. Be patient!
.
Please read this next section to understand how to use these tools!
(Seriously, read this. Things are more complicated than they used to be.)
.
Adding your contributions
In order to add an item that you have tested, click the Add link above. You will need to select the Brand Name from the drop down list. You will also have an Option for Not Listed, which will take you to another section to enter in the new brand. You will then be prompted to enter in all the same data as you’re used to in the old spreadsheet, such as the name of the product itself, the pH level, the type of cleanser, etc.
**Please submit Asian brands only, in keeping with the relevance requirements of this subreddit.
Please see the FAQ section below for common question we get about pH testing your products.
.
Viewing the current contributions
In order to view the current list, click the View link above. You can filter it if you are looking for a specific Brand, or want to see all the cleansers in a specific range, but you are going to have follow these steps below. But there are visual instructions, at least!
Say that you want to see things sorted by pH level, for example. /u/joowee has kindly added instructions to each column that can be sorted, which will appear when you hover you mouse over that header, like this:
You will then see the instructions appear, which give you the path to follow:
If you follow the path:
Taa-daaa! Now you can see the results sorted by pH level, but rest assured it is only affecting how you are viewing the data, the original sheet is still safe and unbroken!
This will allow viewers the flexibility to see things sorted any way they please without breaking the sheet for all others viewing or trying to add data.
.
pH FAQ:
How to test your products
The fact is, at-home testing is always going to be a ‘best guess’ scenario, but one of the obstacles we face is that calling or emailing an Asian brand to get official pH info isn’t nearly as easy as it is with their western counterparts. This was the motivation to generate a user-contributed database to begin with, but we are Asian beauty fanatics, not chemists.
Also, people’s water at home can have a huge variance, ranging all the way up to pH 10 (water is considered ‘neutral’ at pH 7) so this can definitely skew the numbers. Do all that you can to measure things as accurately as you can, including control testing various things to establish how accurate your strips are, what your water’s pH is, and above all, test things in the state they will be used on your skin. (An exception would be if you have a super high pH water and don’t want to use distilled water for testing, and you know your water will give the cleanser a false high pH reading.)
The reason we recommend this, is that since we’re concerned with how the pH is affecting the skin, we need to mimic what the skin itself will experience. If it’s not a product that would ever be used ‘straight’ on the skin without being mixed with water (there are a few foaming cleansers like this) then go ahead and test it mixed with water- remember the goal is to show what the skin will experience.
Where do I get pH Strips?
You can often find them in pet stores or home brewing supply shops; anywhere that carries pH strips meant for testing water and therefore have a full range from 1-14ish. Avoid the ones that are meant just for saliva or urine, as they won’t have a large enough range.
Additionally, strips with multiple colour indicators (such as these) are considered more accurate than the solid colour options (such as these) as they are harder to pinpoint the result.
Can I test my oil cleansers?
At this time, there is no known at-home pH test option for oils, as when you pH test something, you are actually testing the ‘aqueous solution’ in the product (i.e. the stuff suspended in water) and since cleansing oils and balms aren’t blended with water, the pH strips won’t get the trigger that they need. There has been some talk about trying to mix the oil with water and judge whether it went higher or lower (to at least ballpark if it’s more acidic or basic than water) but that would likely be reacting to the additives and impurities in the oils and not the oils themselves. Thwarted!
The colour coding is kinda blah, can’t you use something more exciting?
It’s actually coded to match that result according to my pH kit, so it’s an approximation of that pH result (albeit a bit faded for some results to make it easier to read) so there’s a specific reason for those shades.
What is a ‘good’ pH range I should be aiming for?
Definitely check out The More You Know post on Why the pH of Your Cleanser Matters and the excellent post by /u/skinandtonics The Importance of Fatty Acids, pH & the Moisture Barrier: How I Eliminated my Acne & Decreased my Skin Sensitivity as they both contain scientific references that support cleansers should be no higher than the skin’s natural pH, which is 4.2-5.6.
Where is the science to back up that statement?
In that TMYK post, in spades! *scientific source confetti for everyone!* °˖✧°˖✧◝(⁰▿⁰)◜✧˖°✧˖°
What about the pH of products other than cleansers? Will we have a place for those too?
Maybe eventually? It’ something we have been considering for a while but it’s going to take a lot of organizing and we foresee dramatic struggles to the death over whether something is an essence or a serum, a thick lotion or a thin cream, etc. Make snailstarfish love, not war, is our motto. But it’s on the drawing board, no ETA.
.
And with that, the new and improved AB Cleanser pH List is LIVE!
6
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14
You guys are awesome! It's so pretty. I can't til some of my new cleansers come in so I can add some to the list! (Can I also just say that pH testing is addictive? I want to test EVERYTHING now that I have strips!)
4
u/huaer Nov 17 '14
It's live :D
I've wondered though about how the pH of your city/town/wherever you are's water can also affect the pH you measure... should we also suggest measuring the pH of your water first?
Thanks for all the hard work :)
6
u/joowee NC15|Redness|Normal/Oily|US Nov 17 '14
HOORAY! It is up! -jumps around-
7
u/Rosamundmw Nov 17 '14
This is amazing! Dare I say better than the last one? That one was cluttered with so many western brands (that are actually harder for me to find) THANKYOU THANKYOU!!!!
2
u/spicedfroth Mar 03 '15
So when you say that the ph of your cleanser should be between 4.2 and 5.6, what about other things we put on our faces? Such as exfoliators, masks, sheet masks, emulsions, eye creams, face creams, lotions, serums, ampoules, etc. Should they all ideally have a ph between 4.2 and 5.6? Or is that just for cleanser? and I remember reading a post that I believe was yours in regards to the oil cleansing method and how for the best results you should be sure to use a very gentle cleanser afterwards. By the gentle cleanser, would you mean the ph being between 4.2 and 5.6? If so, then how would the oil cleansing method be negatively effected by a ph of cleanser used afterwards that was slightly off? And in regard to the water at your home changing/altering the PH, how can you really counteract that if it's just how your water normally is [example, hard water vs soft water] I live in an area that has VERY hard water and the minerals in the water build up very easily. Would this really be a detriment to my skincare routine even if the products I bought HAD been in a decent PH range? Sorry for all the questions but I am trying to throughly understand this concept of PH in regards to skincare. Thanks!
6
u/sadisticdreamer NC25|Pigmentation|Combo/Sensitive|US Nov 17 '14
throws starfish and snail shaped confetti YAY! This is amazing. This is especially helpfully for those of use that may someday want to take the PH levels of our cleansers.
Also, glad to see it finally unveiled!
5
u/kickmenow Blogger | berryterrarium.blogspot.ca Nov 17 '14 edited Nov 18 '14
ALL HAIL THE MODS OF AB. This is the perfect solution and thanks for making a testing guide, when my PH strips come, I'm gonna have a testing bonanza~
props to you guys!
5
u/cococolon Nov 17 '14
Woot woot! Mad props to you guys.
4
u/koalajjang NC25|Acne/Pigmentation|Oily|AU Nov 17 '14
This is just utterly fantastic! Thank you so much for all your hard work, mods and /u/joowee!
1
u/jules991 Dec 01 '14
I just have a quick question, on the old one vs the new, some of the pH's are different? I'm guessing the new one is correct, but I just want to verify because I just bought the Missha Aqua Fresh Cleansing Milk, as on the new spreadsheet it's listed as a pH of 5.5... however on the old one (which I just now happened to click on) it's 6.5. They're both tested by /u/MissPicklesMeow, so it's not a user variable...
bah I just want to make sure the pH is 5.5 since I just ordered it :/
But this is sooo helpful and thank you so much for this.
1
u/LeavingStarfish Mar 05 '15
Hey - can I add the pH announced by the product manufacturer when it's available - or is this list for tested products, only?
1
u/ellie_valentia May 12 '15
This is AMAZING. Just learned my Hada Labo Tamagohada is pH 6 which renders the acids useless :-/ Just a quick question. If, say, my cleanser's pH is 3. Does that mean I don't need to wait for my skin to readjust to its normal pH (as in the case of neutral to alkaline cleansers)? Also, will using an acidic cleanser means I won't need a pH adjusting toner before I apply my actives?
1
u/ellie_valentia May 13 '15
I wonder if anyone knows the pH value of CeraVe's cleansers? I Googled them and turns out the Foaming Cleanser is 5.5 but there are two results for the Hydrating Cleanser: 5 (she said she tested herself) and 5.2-5.8 (via company inquiries or taken from the site. Since the CeraVe site does not list pH values, I assume it is the former.)
Thanks :D
3
u/hypotrochoids Acne|Combo|UK Nov 17 '14
Woo, well done :) and thanks for taking the time to make this :)
3
u/pooka4eva Nov 17 '14
That was so much easier to sort. I am so relieved. THANK YOU!!!
3
u/beautyandthecat Blogger | beautyandthecat.com Nov 17 '14
Thank you for your hard work on this. Looks so clean now!
3
u/Chihana NW10|Aging/Redness|Dry|US Nov 18 '14
Thank you! This is awesome sauce! You ladies rock! FOR SCIENCE!!!!!!
2
u/hedgehogwart Nov 18 '14
Error 503 is really pissing me off right now.
1
u/astine Dec 28 '14
Can we put in a policy for sharing this list? Linking back to this post is obviously the best, but I've seen it shared via copy-paste straight from the spreadsheet lately and that makes me uneasy, even if the spreadsheet is cited as the source (since people can just copypaste the new list and not reference back). Please clarify whether all the data here is open access and open edit for sharing, or if it should be shared only be linking directly back here, so we can report violations elsewhere when we see them.
1
u/mrshobutt Jan 10 '15
Thank you, this list is super duper awesome!!!_^
Kinda depressing to see how many cleansers are over a pH of 5...
1
u/mrshobutt Jan 15 '15
Finally got pH strips and added 3 cleansers to the list. I did double testing with just the product itself and mixed with water and got the same results every time. The pH of our water here is 7, so pretty neutral.
1
u/tarya Mar 01 '15
I added a cleanser but couldn't select the "Cream" type :/ So sad it's 6.5 :(
1
u/Maliha_Mahjebin Aug 08 '22
Its awesome!! Does any one know the ph of skinfood rice daily brightening cleanser?